Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should parents contribute?

88 replies

shoppingismydownfall · 10/09/2021 20:44

I'm aware this may be a contraversial topic. I work in social care and see children brought into the care system from all backgrounds, from the extremely wealthy to extremely poor. I'm not debating the rights and wrongs of social workers here.

My Aibu is, if it costs the local authority on average £3,000 per week to look after that child, should parents be financially assessed to contribute towards their care?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Blindingpeaky · 14/09/2021 21:00

A Child could be in care due to emotional abuse from the parent. I would be concerned about the hold that a parent might continue to have over a child due to their financial contributions. For example suggesting that the child still owes them, or they aren't wanted by the foster carer and are only there because the parent pays them.
I would also be concerned about what control parents would expect to have over foster placements if they financially contributed, for example refusing a placement for their child based on ethnicity.

I really cant see how it would work.

Milkshake54 · 14/09/2021 20:43

There is very limited foster care provisions within local authorities - they are the cheaper provision. Therefore it is outsourced to private agencies - whether foster care or residential home for both SEN and non-SEN children. As someone mentioned above, this is for profit and the prices are eye watering.

I think also a child having respite or placement due to SEN is different as the parents are still likely to be heavily involved and contributing financially to clothes, presents, days out etc.

It the parents who abandon / demand their children are taken into care and then don’t bother that should be means tested.

LA’s don’t often put the ability to do this into practice as it isn’t equal, as it means a wealthy parents is paying where as a parent in poverty isn’t…

Sunndown · 11/09/2021 17:34

Fair enough. But 5 times the cost of a top boarding school? And at 18 they're supposed to cope without support?

Spikeyball · 11/09/2021 16:47

Disability aside think about the type of background that a child is likely to have for it to be necessary for a child to come into the care system. They are going to need a lot of specialist support.

Sunndown · 11/09/2021 16:34

But presumably £3k is an average, and many children won't have special needs?

Spikeyball · 11/09/2021 16:09

Ds's respite costs £500 a night. Specialist residential settings are expensive.

GingerAndTheBiscuits · 11/09/2021 16:07

From the recent Case for Change review of social care

“Across both fostering and residential care it is impossible to ignore the increasing role of private provision. 78% of children’s homes are provided by private providers and 41% approved fostering places are provided by independent fostering agencies (Ofsted, 2021a, p. 20). The average reported price per child for a place in an independent children’s home in England in 2018/19 was around £4,000 per week (more than £200,000 annualised), representing an increase of 40% on prices in 2012/13 (Rome, 2020b). Across the largest twenty providers this amounts to a profit estimated at £265 million or a profit margin of 17.2% (Rome, 2020a). Supply is not meeting demand, the overall number of looked-after children at 31 March increased by over 24% between 2009/10 and 2019/20, but the number of children’s home places grew by just 8% in the years 2011/12-2019/20 (Department for Education, 2021e).25
The review is concerned about the cost, profit, and financial health of providers and the impact of the current system on children. We want a pragmatic re-think given the urgent problems, the complexity of the issues and the fragility of the current system. We are pleased the CMA are undertaking a market study in this area and are working closely together, within the bounds of the CMA’s legal powers and obligations and respecting the independence of both pieces of work. There is an active debate in the sector about whether incremental improvement of commissioning or radical rethinking of the care marketplace is needed to ensure that children receive the care that they need. This review will consider all options. We have also asked the What Works Centre for Children’s Social Care to work with the Government Outcomes Lab at Oxford University to look at effective models of commissioning that could be applied to children’s social care.”

GingerAndTheBiscuits · 11/09/2021 16:03

Placements in the thousands per week are usually in private and/or therapeutic settings so higher staff ratios but also run for profit. The Competitions and Markets Authority is currently investigating the issue.

x2boys · 11/09/2021 16:00

@Jux

If it costs that much to keep a child half-way decently, why do CMS only require absent parents to pay so little?
Two different issues, there will be many complex reasons why children go into care, and in some cases the cost of keeping them in care will cost ££££, s depending on the needs of the child.
Simonjt · 11/09/2021 15:59

@Jux

If it costs that much to keep a child half-way decently, why do CMS only require absent parents to pay so little?
Do you think social workers etc work for £0?
Jux · 11/09/2021 15:53

If it costs that much to keep a child half-way decently, why do CMS only require absent parents to pay so little?

FlumpsAreShit · 11/09/2021 13:59

@shoppingismydownfall

Just for example, I was raised in care and my parents were very comfortable finacially. Why shouldn't they contribute?
Presumably they did through taxation? And if they didn't, that's one area that needs reform!

I imagine statistically these cases are so unusual it'd not be worth the administration to make the law, agree how it'd work and enforce it.

DontBeAHaterDear · 11/09/2021 13:47

Oh I know that @x2boys I have a child with disabilities and have reached out for help myself in the past, albeit not residential care.

But I would have thought that wealthy parents (actually wealthy, not all who have a higher than average income) would have more options for appropriate housing and care before it came to a point of having to relinquish care completely. But I also know it’s not as simple as that.

x2boys · 11/09/2021 12:02

@DontBeAHaterDear

I understand that children from all sorts of backgrounds enter the care system for all sorts of reasons but really, how many children of wealthy parents do? Not because wealthy parents equal better parents but because I’m just surprised it happens enough that you are starting a debate whether the parents should contribute.

As it goes, I’m not sure that they should. Only because it’s something that could easily be exploited. Like others have said, some parents have to give up care of their children through no fault of their own, sometimes for good but sometimes on a temporary basis. They shouldn’t be penalised for doing the right thing in those circumstances and charging them for the care could make it harder for them to regain custody of their children if that is the end goal as it would deplete their funds a lot.

More money needs to be pumped into social care but shaking down already vulnerable people for the cash isn’t the answer.

Parents from all kinds of socio economic backgrounds can have disabled children, sometimes residential placements are the only place that can meet the childs needs In these cases it can be a huge fight for the parents to get a suitable placement and not a decision thats taken lightly
Sunndown · 11/09/2021 11:55

The figures are nonetheless surprising.

Simonjt · 11/09/2021 10:35

@PinkiOcelot

I’m really surprised at the £3k per week. When I looked into fostering, my LA paid £160 per week.
Do you think all the staff associated with looking after LAC children, working with their families etc are paid £0 per week? Then we have the buildings needed for those people to work in, for contact to happen in.
PinkiOcelot · 11/09/2021 10:11

I’m really surprised at the £3k per week. When I looked into fostering, my LA paid £160 per week.

Sunndown · 11/09/2021 10:06

I can imagine the Tories doing this, in the knowledge that it would cost more to administer than the money it would bring in. Because of their strong beliefs that the poor should be milked of every bit of money they have, rather than be supported by the taxpayer.

AgentJohnson · 11/09/2021 07:46

And how would this work exactly? In the end it would cost more in administration that it would generate and that’s not taking into account, how it would bring an unnecessary element into an already complex situation.

I’d hope someone in Social Care could have come to their own conclusions as to why it isn’t done or are you secretly working for a right wing think tank.

Spikeyball · 11/09/2021 07:40

"There is a means test. It just never applies because only poor people have their DC's removed."

Being in care doesn't always been they have been removed. Section 20 placements for disabled children in residential schools for example. Children can have these placements without a section 20 but the section 20 offers the child greater protection because it means social workers have to be very actively involved with the placement so is often preferred. Most parents in these situations still make large contributions in terms of time and things that cost money towards their child.

00100001 · 11/09/2021 07:24

@StoneofDestiny

I must be naive - why are people who are wealthy have children removed?

Because sexual and physical abuse, neglect, emotional and physical deprivation isn't something found only in homes with economic problems. There are a lot of screwed up well off people who screw up their children's lives too.

Quite.

I know an incredibly wealthy couple who actively encouraged their 14yo daughter to be in a sexual relationship with a nearly 50yo, because he was a friend and would know how to treat her properly... 🤢
(And yes, i did report it)

StoneofDestiny · 11/09/2021 00:26

I must be naive - why are people who are wealthy have children removed?

Because sexual and physical abuse, neglect, emotional and physical deprivation isn't something found only in homes with economic problems. There are a lot of screwed up well off people who screw up their children's lives too.

StoneofDestiny · 11/09/2021 00:23

Maybe get prisoners to pay for their stay in prison? I believe it costs £25,000 per annum.

Whatever next?

felulageller · 10/09/2021 23:42

There is a means test. It just never applies because only poor people have their DC's removed. (They aren't the only ones who abuse their DC's bit that's another issue!)

Phphion · 10/09/2021 23:17

There is statutory provision to do this, but usually it is not applied because realistically, once you exempt all the parents who would be entitled to it for free, e.g. benefits recipients, plus all the children who would be entitled through other funding, e.g. children receiving disability support, children on probation, children receiving time-limited emergency care, plus all the people who would receive discretionary exemptions, e.g., where it would create financial hardship for other children remaining in the parental home, then you are left with only a small group who would need to contribute.

You then have to decide what it would be reasonable for parents to be charged for, so it wouldn't be the full £3,000 but only a proportion of that for things like bed and board.

Then you means test your small group of eligible, but not usually all that well-off, parents and charge them a proportion of the smaller figure. Meaning that it doesn't generate much actual money.

Then you set against this the cost of enforcement, plus the opportunity costs for both the child and their families related to missing the opportunity for earlier intervention amongst those who don't engage and for providing other support to families who face financial hardship as a result of having to pay.

As a result of all this, it largely comes down to a moral decision, with on one side the case that parents should pay to support their children if they are able to, and on the other side the case that the welfare of the child should come first and that there should not be a financial element to decision-making around the welfare of a child. A worst case scenario would be a situation where one child was being looked after but an equally if not more vulnerable child was not, because the first child's parents would contribute to the costs, but the second child's parents wouldn't.