Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What do you think this father should do? Remain or relocate?

194 replies

Thenavyblue · 10/09/2021 19:57

If a separated father can't afford a sufficient property in his children's home city which allows him to provide good enough shared care, which of these scenarios do you think is in the children's best interests?

  1. The father stays in the city and rents a room in a flat share or at a push a small self contained studio flat, has the children over for tea during the week and the odd sleep over during which the children have to sleep on a blow up bed in the common area.

  2. He relocates to a cheaper part of the UK where he can afford a house and give them their own bedroom(s) and space, is able to have them for extended periods over the holidays and provide a much better environment for them. The caveat being he sees them slightly less, so for example, staying over EOW as opposed to just going for tea at his place every week.

Additional information: father is a low earner, currently living in an expensive city where property prices are sky high.

OP posts:
Thenavyblue · 10/09/2021 20:36

If there was a split shouldn't the home be sold and each get half to find suitable new homes that the children can access?

Wasn't married and neither are home owners.

OP posts:
Thenavyblue · 10/09/2021 20:35

Would not he be entitled to social housing if he has underage children?

In an ideal world yes, however he forfeited his part in the H.A lifetime tenancy therefore fell under the 'intentionally homeless' bracket and had to source his own accommodation. The only affordable private housing he could secure is inadequate for the DC.

Now the current lack of space is cited as the reason for sparse contact, sparse being "tea at dad's" on a weekly basis and few and far between overnight stays.

OP posts:
NoSquirrels · 10/09/2021 20:33

That’s really tricky. If he had 50-50 care of the DC, then would he be entitled to HA or similar?

Somehow the moving away doesn’t sit right as I think it has as many downsides as advantages but I see you think differently and perceive staying close as the easy option so I’m guessing history of putting himself first.

It’s not simple.

fuzzymoomin · 10/09/2021 20:31

I think that option 2, while might sound better, would eventually lead to reduced contact with the children, particularly as they reach teenage years and want to spend time with friends during weekends/school holidays instead.
Option 1 might be the better short-term solution, but with the children sleeping in the father's bedroom and the father sleeping in the communal space.
This is a really difficult situation. I'm presuming you are the mother with the children resident and you obviously haven't given details of the split but I'm wondering how the father came to be so significantly disadvantaged financially compared to the mother. If there was a split shouldn't the home be sold and each get half to find suitable new homes that the children can access?

TomBradysLeftKneecap · 10/09/2021 20:30

My friends do what @UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme suggested and it works great. The parents do get on brilliantly for exes though.

SunnyDayOut · 10/09/2021 20:29

I guess my point is that I think I would have been massively overstepping to tell him to move to a cheaper area to get a bigger house and there is no way I could have got him to do that.

forinborin · 10/09/2021 20:28

@Thenavyblue

He's currently in London yes.

His average monthly take home is around 1,200 - 1,300 IIRC.

No chance of obtaining a flat or house with an extra bedroom locally for anything under around about the same amount of money per month so would be his entire pay check if not more.

Would not he be entitled to social housing if he has underage children?
SunnyDayOut · 10/09/2021 20:27

Unfortunately you cannot make a non-resident parent move away from their children (or do anything) regardless of whether you consider it in the best interests of the DC or not.
The other point is that this is about the children, not what suits the parents. It might be better for the DC as they grow up to know that dad is just around the corner or within walking distance than far away. Realistically how far out of London does one have to move to get the space he needs?

My DD’s dad has a small house and two children from his second marriage. She stays over on a blow up bed in a room with her two half-sisters. I just made sure she didn’t go when she was about to do exams as she invariably came home tired. She came and went to his as she pleased and the lack of space did not bother her.

Thenavyblue · 10/09/2021 20:27

@NoSquirrels

Other parents living situation is perfectly adequate for the children. What I meant was, has a divorce been finalised or have assets been divided up fairly? It’s hard to tell without knowing the whole circumstances.
Sorry i misunderstood.

No divorce nessecary as wasn't married. No real assets.

Primary residence is H.A with a lifetime tenancy, so whilst not owned outright it is secure.

Father moved out of said property post split and is now in a 1 bed you couldn't swing a cat in.

OP posts:
Rainbowqueeen · 10/09/2021 20:26

I think option 2 would work better with younger kids and option 1 would work better with teens. And I agree with option 1 it should be dad sleeping on the blow up mattress

RandomMess · 10/09/2021 20:25

All you can do is putting in writing regularly what the DC want and ask them to tell them what they want. Perhaps instigate sleepovers every weekend?

NoSquirrels · 10/09/2021 20:25

Other parents living situation is perfectly adequate for the children.
What I meant was, has a divorce been finalised or have assets been divided up fairly? It’s hard to tell without knowing the whole circumstances.

Thenavyblue · 10/09/2021 20:24

@Bucanarab

Have you asked the children what they want?
More and better quality time with him and their own sleeping space when they're there.
OP posts:
Brollypackedforscottishholiday · 10/09/2021 20:23

I moved 30 miles away and did all travel.
Then dc moved here ft..

BananaMilkshakeWithCream · 10/09/2021 20:23

Option 2. DH did this when he split with his ex. Even though we live quite far away, we worked out that he is only missing out on about 6 contact hours per fortnight. Plus the contact times were happening in a shared house and in car parks, miserable. Now we have our home which we own and there is plenty of space for the step kids.

Thenavyblue · 10/09/2021 20:23

He's currently in London yes.

His average monthly take home is around 1,200 - 1,300 IIRC.

No chance of obtaining a flat or house with an extra bedroom locally for anything under around about the same amount of money per month so would be his entire pay check if not more.

OP posts:
alwayswrighty · 10/09/2021 20:22

In reality it is up to the Dad. I mean if it were me I'd be choosing option 2 but I'm only seeing a snapshot of the situation, not the finer details.

Willyoujustbequiet · 10/09/2021 20:22

Option 2 but he should do all the travelling and bear the costs.

Bucanarab · 10/09/2021 20:22

Have you asked the children what they want?

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 10/09/2021 20:20

If the parents are amicable "nesting" would be the best option - the house is the children's nest, there's a studio flat for the parent not in primary parenting role for the children at any given time. Ideally the parent who lives there most (or each parent if 50/50) has a lockable bedroom or space, even if its a wardrobe. Whichever parent is caring for the children lives in the house while parenting and whichever is not in charge of the children is in the studio flat (where each also has lockable storage.

However that won't work if there's any animosity, nor if there are new partners, let alone blended families...

Otherwise option 2 but as near as possible in terms of hours of travel time. If it's too far the children may well only want to visit in the holidays.

forinborin · 10/09/2021 20:19

No idea as to where or how far is nessecary for option 2 as that's his job to research.
It would be then difficult to answer the question. If you are in London and he can afford only a croft in a small fishing village in the north of Scotland it is a very different scenario compared to say South London vs Kent seaside towns.

Thenavyblue · 10/09/2021 20:17

@RandomMess

What is the father's objection to option 2?
Not wanting to be away from the DC, ironically.

Lip service and excuses to enable him to do as little as possible if you ask me but hey I'm biased.

OP posts:
Thenavyblue · 10/09/2021 20:17

No idea as to where or how far is nessecary for option 2 as that's his job to research.

Other parents living situation is perfectly adequate for the children.

Father staying with other family members to have overnight contact isn't an option, they are disinterested and uninvolved with regards to anything to do with the DC.

OP posts:
RandomMess · 10/09/2021 20:14

What is the father's objection to option 2?

OrangeTortoise · 10/09/2021 20:13

Option 2, but at the end of the day it's his decision.

Swipe left for the next trending thread