Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What do you think this father should do? Remain or relocate?

194 replies

Thenavyblue · 10/09/2021 19:57

If a separated father can't afford a sufficient property in his children's home city which allows him to provide good enough shared care, which of these scenarios do you think is in the children's best interests?

  1. The father stays in the city and rents a room in a flat share or at a push a small self contained studio flat, has the children over for tea during the week and the odd sleep over during which the children have to sleep on a blow up bed in the common area.

  2. He relocates to a cheaper part of the UK where he can afford a house and give them their own bedroom(s) and space, is able to have them for extended periods over the holidays and provide a much better environment for them. The caveat being he sees them slightly less, so for example, staying over EOW as opposed to just going for tea at his place every week.

Additional information: father is a low earner, currently living in an expensive city where property prices are sky high.

OP posts:
Daleksatemyshed · 11/09/2021 08:54

It's not really a case of what should happen, the hard facts are what matter. You are now seperated, he doesn't have a high paying job so can't afford CM and a two bedroom flat on his own. I know you're angry but it's no good saying everything must be as the DC want /need if it's not possible.
I'm sorry he cheated, and I don't have sympathy for him, but you need to live in the real world now

astoundedgoat · 11/09/2021 08:51

It doesn’t sound like your family could ever afford to live in London.

You cannot, and never could afford to be a SAHM.

I think it’s much better for your ex to live nearby. When you go back to work you will be very glad of having him there to share the load with school runs, sick days etc.

He has to increase his earnings though. He has been coasting for too long.

RAFHercules · 11/09/2021 08:42

Option 119
My friend actually did this for donkeys years and it worked for her DC.
You move out EOW and let him see them at your house. She used to stay with family and eventually new partners place.
The kids Dad slept on a sofa bed in the sitting room.

Underamour · 11/09/2021 08:39

I would say 2) BUT how much of an issue would travel be? Could he maintain this long term?

Surelyunsure21 · 11/09/2021 08:31

I think if you were both on the tenancy originally than he should have a 1 bedroom flat, he could even move out of London and rent a property further out but on the days where he has the children, they should all be able to stay in the house and you go stay in the flat! Regardless of what he did.. the children shouldn’t suffer. The HA property was originally given to you both and a bit like a mortgage you were both jointly named so he shouldn’t have had to give up.

Also I think you should get a job too and maybe contemplate all of you moving out of London if you cannot afford the lifestyle. You are a SAHM so you cannot afford London lifestyle and neither can the children’s father so you are making life difficult for the children regardless of their living circumstances.

It does very much sound like you are punishing him and that’s not fair and it’s not really teaching your children the best life lessons!

hartwood · 11/09/2021 07:42

The bedsit. I actually don't think young kids need their own room really, they'll love the novelty of sleeping on a blow up bed and having a sleepover with their dad. Then when they're older they can come and go as they please and can stay nearby their friends at the weekend.

messybun101 · 11/09/2021 02:03

@Changechangychange

Honestly OP, the more you type the more it sounds like this objection to him having them over for tea is really just an excuse to push him to move to Swansea, or Newcastle, or wherever it is in the UK that you think you can rent a multi-bedroom house for less than £500pcm.

You just want him to move away. It is fair enough to not want to see him ever again yourself if he’s cheated on you, but stop trying to make out it’s better for the children to see him once or twice a year in a shitty house in Bradford instead of a couple of times a week in a shitty flat in Lewisham.

This
KhoshkaKatya · 11/09/2021 01:14

As a child, this is how these options played out for me in real life.

Option one. First couple of years after my parents split. Have some very happy memories of this. No overnights, but over couple of nights a wel and one weekend day. He also came over to mum’s sometimes to look after me when she was out, was able to pick me up from school sometimes if she was late, could see him at short notice, that kind of thing.

Option 2. Collapsed pretty quickly. Out of sight, out of my life. Our life’s were in separate places and we detached. He was lonely in a new place and he started actively seeking a new relationship/family setting.

Very quickly option 2 became option 3. Dad moves in with new girlfriend and her kids. New girlfriend quickly insists dad has no time just with me it has to be as a new “family” so she and her kids don’t miss out on his free time. Cue bitter custody battle, even though it’s pretty obvious new girlfriend doesn’t want me to be resident with her.

Then it became option 4. Dad disappears from my life.

If he’s keen to be involved in his kid’s lives and the accommodation challenges are genuine, you will find a way to make it work if you both don’t get caught up in rules and entitlements and responsibilities. If you push him away to the middle of nowhere where he is lonely you are just increasing the chances he finds a new family to fill up that space and that loneliness.

If he’s genuinely not keen on time with his kids and the unsuitable accommodation thing is just an excuse, it’s not going to be 50/50 custody or fair share of parenting anyway. Atleast if he’s local your kids might bump into him or know they can go see him if they need to. As such he might not function as a parent, but as some kind of supportive/involved adult in their lives. More like an uncle or an older brother or a cousin. A lot better than nothing.

BeenThruMoreThanALilBit · 11/09/2021 01:09

So you want your DC to have a parent living in London, a parent living elsewhere on a salary that doesn’t afford a decent standard of living for anyone anywhere commutable to London let alone with two kids, for you not to move, for you not to work, AND for your D.C. to see their father “slightly less”?

Yes he’s a shit for cheating. Fact.

You are coming across as entitled, living in cloud cuckoo land, seething, and impractical.

Life has no guarantees. Shit happens to everyone all the time. We have no entitlement to a smooth or easy life. We all make the best of things when shit happens. You trying to get your kids’ dad to move so far away that travel costs mean he’ll barely see them in two or three months, isn’t that. The children need a loving relationship. Not their own bedrooms.

Cocomarine · 11/09/2021 01:04

Local is better.
The system is fucked up if you have such cheap rent and you don’t need to work when your kids are that old. Sitting pretty compared to him!
And yeah, cheating sucks. But my XH cheated too and I still put kids first 🤷🏻‍♀️

Tealightsandd · 11/09/2021 01:02

This wasn't in London but still relevant. A friend of DP's had to move in with his parents after splitting with his ex. The children didn't often stay overnight as it was a small house but he saw them regularly whilst living there.

ottermadness · 11/09/2021 00:58

My parents were divorced and long travelling between was awful, option 1.

UndertheCedartree · 11/09/2021 00:49

I personally prefer my DC's father to live close by even though he can't have them for overnights. It means he's much more flexible and a much more hands on parent. DC don't need another house - they already have a home - they need a hands on dad.

Tealightsandd · 11/09/2021 00:48

@TractorAndHeadphones

Also i wanna bet that this thread will be removed for being outing Grin
Grin
Tealightsandd · 11/09/2021 00:47

Bear in mind also that OP's idea of rental costs will be distorted by being in genuinely affordable housing (social housing).

TractorAndHeadphones · 11/09/2021 00:46

Also i wanna bet that this thread will be removed for being outing Grin

Tealightsandd · 11/09/2021 00:45

HTH

Not really, since I already knew that
Hence the word 'misapprehension' (reading comprehension...Smile)

TractorAndHeadphones · 11/09/2021 00:42

@Tealightsandd

Maybe it's this that gets my goat. OP as a Londoner thinks that the rest of a UK is a deserted wasteland where everything's as cheap as chips

Cos one person represents 9 million people... Talking of false stereotypes, I expect lots of people are stunned by OP's predicament...because they think everyone in London is rolling in it and has twenty second homes...

It's hardly surprising OP has her misapprehension.There's been thread after thread on here over the years with an OP and family on low salaries, unable to afford a home in London (because of the 'investment London gets') when their landlord has given notice. Every single time they're told to move out of London because 'it's much cheaper'. A lot of people realise it's still expensive in many areas,but it's not surprising when people like the OP get the wrong idea.

As for OP's dilemma. It's more than likely the decision will be taken out of the dad's hands - unless he's got a magic private landlord who will never ask him to leave. I'm actually very surprised he was able to find a landlord willing to let to him on his salary. Even if he's in the outer suburbs he's looking at very minimum £900 pcm for a 1 bed (perhaps slightly less if a one room studio). He'll seriously struggle to find even a flatshare on his salary but definitely if/when he has to leave his current 1 bed that's all he'll be able to get.

In fact OP that might be why he's so reluctant to move. He's found a landlord willing to take him. He wants to cling on in there because he probably knows we live in a society that's happy to see people homeless.

Nobody said that every Londoner thinks that (reading comprehension darling!). Just that OP as a Londoner thinks that everywhere else is cheaper. It's correct to a certain extent. 30K, the national average is 'low' in London but would allow a comfortable life with a partner earning at least 15K. Two people earning slightly below the national average would be alright, but screwed in London.

The OP however wants someone who is not only the sole earner - but a VERY LOW sole earner at that to rent an entire house with multiple bedrooms. If he was unable to earn that much in the capital city where salaries are higher he's probably going to earn even less elsewhere.

HTH.

Changechangychange · 11/09/2021 00:39

Honestly OP, the more you type the more it sounds like this objection to him having them over for tea is really just an excuse to push him to move to Swansea, or Newcastle, or wherever it is in the UK that you think you can rent a multi-bedroom house for less than £500pcm.

You just want him to move away. It is fair enough to not want to see him ever again yourself if he’s cheated on you, but stop trying to make out it’s better for the children to see him once or twice a year in a shitty house in Bradford instead of a couple of times a week in a shitty flat in Lewisham.

TractorAndHeadphones · 11/09/2021 00:34

Also to add - I don't normally react with emotions but you are clearly putting your desire for revenge above the needs of your children. Cheating is cowardly and selfish but that doesn't excuse your weaponizing them.

Tealightsandd · 11/09/2021 00:32

Maybe it's this that gets my goat. OP as a Londoner thinks that the rest of a UK is a deserted wasteland where everything's as cheap as chips

Cos one person represents 9 million people... Talking of false stereotypes, I expect lots of people are stunned by OP's predicament...because they think everyone in London is rolling in it and has twenty second homes...

It's hardly surprising OP has her misapprehension.There's been thread after thread on here over the years with an OP and family on low salaries, unable to afford a home in London (because of the 'investment London gets') when their landlord has given notice. Every single time they're told to move out of London because 'it's much cheaper'. A lot of people realise it's still expensive in many areas,but it's not surprising when people like the OP get the wrong idea.

As for OP's dilemma. It's more than likely the decision will be taken out of the dad's hands - unless he's got a magic private landlord who will never ask him to leave. I'm actually very surprised he was able to find a landlord willing to let to him on his salary. Even if he's in the outer suburbs he's looking at very minimum £900 pcm for a 1 bed (perhaps slightly less if a one room studio). He'll seriously struggle to find even a flatshare on his salary but definitely if/when he has to leave his current 1 bed that's all he'll be able to get.

In fact OP that might be why he's so reluctant to move. He's found a landlord willing to take him. He wants to cling on in there because he probably knows we live in a society that's happy to see people homeless.

TractorAndHeadphones · 11/09/2021 00:31

@Kneesaregood

Op you're right, he can't live somewhere he can't afford. Ergo he has to live in a houseshare. He can't afford his own property anywhere, not in London, not outside of London.
THIS. You don't even have a proper AIBU - and both your options are unreasonable. Despite every single poster telling you that what you want is unaffordable you're still harping on getting him the hell out of London. This isn't about your kids living arrangements at all is it? it's about making life as miserable as possible for him because he cheated.

It was a good decision to not tolerate his crap and kick him out but that is what has resulted in his financial situation. Your DC have a low earning father who has only managed to provide for them + a long-term SAHM BECAUSE of the HA property. If you didn't have that all 4 of you would have been screwed anyway.

It's really in your kids interests to have no nights with him (because what bonding are they going to do at night)? You have to do the lion's share not because you're the mother. But because you're the one with the asset that you got out of luck, which made your family life possible in such an expensive city. That's all. You'll probably come along and say that one or other of you have SEN, disabilities etc etc which is all well and good. But that doesn't change the hard financial facts.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 11/09/2021 00:26

You can't afford to live where you live either - the only reason you're there is that it's social housing and presumably you are claiming benefit if you aren't working.

Whatever he has done, as long as it isn't abusing the children, it seems more like you're looking for reasons to stop him seeing the children. Usually, Mums are more upset when their exes do move away because it means the kids never get to see them. But you appear to want to reduce contact - he's clearly not able to get a better paying job, so he'd be highly unlikely to be able to get a new job in areas of higher unemployment - or pay the costs inherent in moving across the country or travelling to come back to see them, assuming he is able to not just get a job, but doesn't have to work weekends and can afford to travel several hundred miles from the nearest affordable 2 bedroomed places.

He may well have been an utter shit to you, but you trying to force him to leave your children as well as you is likely to hurt them more than sleeping on a blow up bed every week and a visit for tea every Wednesday.

Kneesaregood · 11/09/2021 00:14

Op you're right, he can't live somewhere he can't afford. Ergo he has to live in a houseshare. He can't afford his own property anywhere, not in London, not outside of London.

Thenavyblue · 11/09/2021 00:03

What a fucked up system. Mother should be working.

Why? Are we judging SAHM's now?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread