Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

School shoes haven't lasted a week

168 replies

Smartphonetoomuchoo · 10/09/2021 16:21

£20 in sainsburies which i thought looked quite sturdy. Well they lasted a grand total of 5 days. How can this be? The sole is ripped up after a week. I don't have the receipts because I am a moron.
I can't afford £45 each on clarkes shoes. I have looked in all the charity shops but school shoes are never sent in. Are they all just shit?
Considering just sending them in converse because at least they last and look alright even when they are tattered and old. and converse are easy enough to find on second hand market places.
Am I the only one? I thought 20 quid was a lot, I usually go for the 12 pound ones but thought I'd go more expensive thinking they would last better. Ha!
Also, I am worried about spending more money and still getting the same results.
I never have this problem with home shoes, mostly they last until we outgrow.

OP posts:
Tangledtresses · 10/09/2021 20:27

@womaninatightspot

I always recommend Geox for school trainers. Definitely outgrown and we've had a few pairs. Somertimes get lucky on amazon for a cheap pair.
Same here! I give them to my friend after a year and they are still going strong with another child
SloopB · 10/09/2021 20:11

My son kills Geox in a matter of weeks. Lovely shoes and he likes the feel but they don't last.

Rach000 · 10/09/2021 20:10

Take them back, you will be able to get a gift card with the money on. I bought my daughter that make from sainsburys last year and they only lasted a few weeks and the sole came away. I also thought they looked good quality. I dont think I had the receipt but got my money back. I would have prob tried another pair if they had her size in but they didn't.

Just buy some asda ones instead, think you have just been unlucky. I think the cheaper supermarket ones are fine. Don't worry about not been able to afford clarks!!

piefacedClique · 10/09/2021 20:07

I usually buy Clark’s but I’ve bought deichmans recently. Can’t tell the difference and they have a buy one get one half price offer

EmotionalSupportBear · 10/09/2021 19:55

i find shoezones are good for the girls, dd just went into a size 4 (adult size) and the cheap ladies comfort sole ones are great.

DS goes through shoes like water, he wrecks them that quickly i prefer to buy the cheaper £12/15 a pair ones every 6-8 weeks for him, expensive ones didn't last longer and just cost me more/made me more annoyed when he invariably ruined them (he's disabled/dyspraxic so its to do with his gait)

Anonymous48 · 10/09/2021 19:53

Do they have to have special shoes just for school? What do they wear when they're not at school?

user7012893145776 · 10/09/2021 19:46

I've only found 2 pairs that have lasted a full school year. One pair from Asda and another pair from sports direct (Adidas black trainers) everything else fell apart.

Clarks, pogs, kickers, etc never lasted more than 6 weeks.

livingthegoodlife · 10/09/2021 19:39

Our Clarks shoes lasted exactly one day. The buckle has come clean off. They must be faulty. Taking them back tomorrow.

Faulty shoes aren't the preserve of supermarket shoes! Take the Sainsbury's ones back. I bet they exchange them.

winewolfhowls · 10/09/2021 19:12

@Gilmoregale

Can't afford Clarks new either and have often had to opt for cheaper brands (it's the Discworld Sam Grimes law of economics/boots, which wealthier people don't get often). We live nearish the Clarks shopping village in Street which sometimes has bargains; plus the online Clarks website is worth a look and I know they used to deliver shoes free to upir local Clarks shop; however ebay BNIB (brand new in box) has often been our friend for shoes! I hate clothes shopping with a passion and often go poking about on Ebay when new items are required, or alternatively he clearance sections of websites.

Agree they shouldn't have fallen apart so quickly though - what surfaces have your kids been walking on?!

I came here to post the vimes quote too, so true!
Matilda82 · 10/09/2021 19:09

Treads shoes. They lasted the whole of last year. Just bought a new pair half price for £23. Sadly they won't last as DS is 13 so growing like you won't believe , but the shoes are indestructible.

Thidwick · 10/09/2021 19:09

What @SoundBar said - barely used Clark’s on eBay. My youngest is in a pair that cost 4.99 plus postage.

Pumpkinseedpesto · 10/09/2021 19:06

@RedHelenB

Buy Clarks, they last the year.
I bought clarks. They lasted her 2 and a half days.
DanceAllDay · 10/09/2021 19:06

Whilst we buy clarks shows in general, I really don’t rate them for school shoes. They didn’t last a term for us and at that price I’d expect them to last a year, particularly because we only bought the reinforced ones.

The last three years we’ve bought these from M&S and they last. They’re leather and good quality.

www.marksandspencer.com/kids-leather-riptape-school-shoes-8-small-1-5-large-/p/clp60256842?color=BLACK

Newmumatlast · 10/09/2021 19:03

@Gilmoregale

Can't afford Clarks new either and have often had to opt for cheaper brands (it's the Discworld Sam Grimes law of economics/boots, which wealthier people don't get often). We live nearish the Clarks shopping village in Street which sometimes has bargains; plus the online Clarks website is worth a look and I know they used to deliver shoes free to upir local Clarks shop; however ebay BNIB (brand new in box) has often been our friend for shoes! I hate clothes shopping with a passion and often go poking about on Ebay when new items are required, or alternatively he clearance sections of websites.

Agree they shouldn't have fallen apart so quickly though - what surfaces have your kids been walking on?!

Exactly this re economics point. Its another way poorer people get hit where it hurts. They would get a cheaper deal if they could buy something laster longing but don't have access to the capital to do it, or sometimes enough spare to save or the time to save as its a need now item. Whereas I took benefit of startrite sale and bought my toddler shoes in the next few sizes at £12 a pop, as I would've paid full price otherwise, alot of people can't afford to. I need to save the ££s less but have the capital to do so. It sucks
cookingisoverrated · 10/09/2021 19:01

Take them back. They're not fit for purpose and you can make that clear at customer service.

drpet49 · 10/09/2021 19:00

Clarks have always lasted a school year. I buy on the Clarks outlet website

Gilmoregale · 10/09/2021 18:59

Can't afford Clarks new either and have often had to opt for cheaper brands (it's the Discworld Sam Grimes law of economics/boots, which wealthier people don't get often). We live nearish the Clarks shopping village in Street which sometimes has bargains; plus the online Clarks website is worth a look and I know they used to deliver shoes free to upir local Clarks shop; however ebay BNIB (brand new in box) has often been our friend for shoes! I hate clothes shopping with a passion and often go poking about on Ebay when new items are required, or alternatively he clearance sections of websites.

Agree they shouldn't have fallen apart so quickly though - what surfaces have your kids been walking on?!

GertrudeKerfuffle · 10/09/2021 18:59

Have a look at Treads www.treads-shoes.com

They cost the same as Clark's full price, but currently have a sale and often have offers if you sign up to emails. Delivery is free too. We're on our third pair over three years, we only ever need new ones when they get too small.

AttaGirrrrl · 10/09/2021 18:53

Are they allowed plain black trainers? Mine have plain black Nikes from sports direct for £25 and they last well.

Newmumatlast · 10/09/2021 18:51

@ImFree2doasiwant

I know you said you can't afford Clarks, but by the time you've bought a second d pair of cheap shoes (and 3rd...) you've paid for the clarks.

Ds2 has a not quick black pair that were £12 last week. Ds1 has black which I bought last year and still fit him.

The problem is if you're on that tight a budget you don't always have the money at the time to pay the double and can't wait to save it as theyre needed there and then. Ideally you would save a quid a week or something but then if something comes up emergency wise, rather than get in debt you fight the fire presently in front of you and have to start again
CottonSock · 10/09/2021 18:43

Agree on the Geox. I paid £50 but saw them in shoe zone yesterday for £30.

Welshmaenad · 10/09/2021 18:40

Geox are the only shoes my DS cannot kill. Have a look on brandalley for discounted ones.

MrsWhites · 10/09/2021 18:39

Definitely take them back, I bet they’ll be happy to replace them. I bought my dd kickers once and they were destroyed within a week, took them back to schuh and they changed them with no problems at all. School shoes should be sturdy enough to withstand at least a half term.

I find M&S shoes excellent, my sons for this year were £30 so not as expensive as Clarks.

MrsMiddleMother · 10/09/2021 18:33

Take them back to sainsburys firstly, you don't need a receipt. Imo clarks are shit anyway. You'll get a free replacement from Sainsburys but if not, Asda fair way better.