Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It's a work one

35 replies

leopardprintandzebras · 10/09/2021 15:49

This is a mixture of are we being unreasonable and hr question.

Basically (I've name changed as this can be linked to a few of my other threads) I work in the care sector. Domiciliary care.

We have to log in and out of calls using one of those scan things qr code of something. We work every day of the year. All through pandemic etc.

During the pandemic we didn't have to sign in and out. Recently we have had a lot of staff leave like 15-20%. It's caused us to be very busy and our calls are back to back with 5 minutes travel time even if the journey normally takes 15!

We finish at 10 pm. When it's late and we have to people to bed they don't want us hanging around in the house (perfectly understandable) so we don't log out and it lets us play catch up a bit on time. If we didn't do this I think we would be home about 10:45-11 and we don't get paid travel. We are paid by the minute.

Anyway the manager has now said if we don't log out we will only be paid 15 mins of the call.

Can they legally do this? Only about 10% of our clients are private rest is adult social care. They will still charge the client for the entire call.
There has obviously been uproar within the staff and we have said give us more travel but they can't at the moment as we don't have enough staff to care for all clients.

Please can anyone advise on this??

Do you think wabu?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
leopardprintandzebras · 12/09/2021 20:01

Thank you

Few answer to questions:

We would never leave the client if the call isn't finished. We can go over but again not paid for it. We only ever leave once the client is in bed and everything is done. Please remember some of our client are literally medication only which takes 5 minutes. Some won't talk to you or want anything else.

We have argued the no travel but we are told there's nothing they can do for now

The client ALWAYS gets charged full even if we clock out at 45.

OP posts:
yellowglass · 12/09/2021 10:30

Can I offer my opinion from the business point of view .

The LA manage these systems and if you don't log in and log out it appears that work hasn't been done and your company is not going to be paid for that time .

It's a shit system and it isn't working but no one is listening , the LA is reaping the rewards as they are not paying their invoices but the care companies still need to pay the staff as they know it's been done but it is showing on the system that it is not .

I expect the threat of only paying for 15 mins is because your company need you to do what is asked of you and scan in and out correctly . It's out of their hands.

This does not take away from the fact who does does your Rota's are not very good at it , travel time need to be reflective of reality . That's a complaint you need to take higher .

Alternatively, leave , experience Dom carers can walk out of one company into any other without issue especially if your DBS is on the update system . But just be aware that most LA's will now have version of this scan in system so it might be the same again . It saves them LOTS of money !

Care companies are being screwed over quietly and no one gives a toss

Myotherusernameisshy · 12/09/2021 10:11

Nobody seems to be considering the clients' perspective. They are paying for an hour and getting significantly less. If the job takes 45 minutes you should be logging that and they should be paying for 45 minutes. You can't use 'their' time to make your employer effectively pay your travelling time, which is what you are doing at the moment. If you want to be paid for travelling time then ask your employer. You sound like you're in a strong position to negotiate a better contract.

GCITC · 12/09/2021 09:32

Union now. You are most likely earning under NMW which is illegal. I speak from experience.

skipperjonce · 12/09/2021 09:17

Just leave. They sound terrible. Failing that, take a picture of the QR code on a tablet or some other device, then just scan the picture later when you're home at the max time.

They screw you, you screw them. Seems fair to me.

Dotty1219 · 12/09/2021 08:55

If you're in a union speak to them, or acas.
If you don't get travel time, im assuming you don't have time for breaks? What are your shift patterns like?

MoiraNotRuby · 12/09/2021 08:42

P.S. you do a really important job - even if your employer doesn't value you, I certainly do, thank you (I realise that doesn't pay the bills though)

MoiraNotRuby · 12/09/2021 08:40

As a temporary work around... Can you leave the client, start driving home, then at the time you should be leaving, pull over and clock out?

Twylar · 12/09/2021 08:25

I think care staff are treated appallingly by all sectors.
The issue here is that your employer is not giving you sufficient travel time and they always do this as a way to make more profit.
Is there any scope for you to take on private work yourself as self employed ir if not I would move to somewhere with a shift pattern e g nursing home, set start and finish times

mummydinosaurRawr · 11/09/2021 23:42

What happens if you don’t ‘log out’, but you leave and then something happens to the client? I understand wanting to claw back time / money in crappy employment arrangements, but I think potentially you are leaving yourselves vulnerable to accusations of negligence if a client falls etc while the paperwork says your there, but in reality you’re not. While I’m sure there is a money-grabbing element to your employer’s new rules, I do wonder if it is also designed to discourage staff from falsifying records.

Sadly this is an industry where exploitation of staff, and an utter lack of appreciation, seems to be rife. I’m not sure what the answer is, I suppose your options are either to put up, change to a different career, or try to fight to change the whole industry. It is disgraceful that care staff are subjected to contracts like this.

Bargebill19 · 11/09/2021 23:25

But who decides how long it takes for travel? Google? (Often wrong) the employer? The employee? The bit I posted doesn’t clarify that.

Hankunamatata · 11/09/2021 23:07

You said you have to log in and out, you cant just choose not to log out. What's wrong is not being paid for travel!

Bargebill19 · 11/09/2021 22:45

Not unlawful to not pay travelling time.
But would depend on your pay rate.

But I suspect that there will be an argument regarding the travel time - eg the employer says a to b is 5 mins, but the carer actually takes 20mins to travel.

It's a work one
Sophielt90 · 11/09/2021 20:07

So there's a couple of things here, if they don't pay travel time and also don't pay mileage, the way they have set up puts the risk there that you end up being paid less than minimum wage which is an issue. You would therefore have right to challenge. If they are contracted with the authority then it is worth raising with them as they are likely in breach of contract if the contracts in place are robust enough to cover this... most are. ACAS would be the best option but do review your contract. If this is a new change and contracts haven't been reissued and you havent been through some form consultation due to change of T&Cs you also have cause to challenge

Alpinechalet · 11/09/2021 19:32

I’m out of date so contact ACAS but I think the Working Time Regulations require travel time between appointments to be treated as working time, this overrides a contract. This time is then used to calculate hours worked for NMW.

I think they can require you to log in and out but this would help you by showing true travel time.

I agree also contact your TU.

I think their may be a shift in power in the care industry over the next few years with good employers attracting staff and poor ones struggling/failing to achieve minimum staffing levels. Poor employers may find they have to change or go out of business.

Bargebill19 · 11/09/2021 18:53

@CorrBlimeyGG

In this case they are claiming for hours not worked. That’s fraud. The consequences are that they only get paid for 15 mins if they don’t clock out when they leave. Travel time isn’t paid and is irrelevant.
Minimum wage doesn’t enter into it. If the staff don’t like the conditions of the contract, then they need to vote with their feet.

@Bluntness100 puts it better than perhaps I have.

Bluntness100 · 11/09/2021 18:36

Sorry that should say working five hours out of six, you basically travel for an hour and fifteen throughout that

Bluntness100 · 11/09/2021 18:35

The reason we don't clock out is we get paid approx 4.75 hours when we are working 4-10pm

Is this including travel time? This seems the disconnect. You see it as working (and I agree but it’s irrelevant) they don’t and that’s what your contract will say. So you are paid 4.75 hours becayse that’s what you technically worked. You basically work five hours out of ten becayse of travel time.

Bluntness100 · 11/09/2021 18:33

I think it’s right op. You don’t get paid travel and only paid foe the mins you work, as such, if you don’t log out and claim to be working fifteen mins more it’s claiming for work you didn’t do.

I get the issues round travel time. You count them as working hours, and They don’t. If you signed a contract saying you agree they are not working hours then the hours you work are the hours you are with the clients,

CorrBlimeyGG · 11/09/2021 18:12

Join a union!

15 or 30 mins docked wouldn’t take you under minimum wage.

Many care workers earn NMW. Any deduction would take them under.

leopardprintandzebras · 11/09/2021 18:02

Thank you for all the replies so far

OP posts:
leopardprintandzebras · 11/09/2021 18:01

Sorry let me be clear. We are paid by the minute. Hence logging in and out. However we are very short staff so have no travel time (we don't get paid for the travel either)

We are supposed to finish at 10 but the rounds take us past 11! This is why once the client is in bed we then go. We then can catch up on time. We are in the call for 45 mins but work want to pay us 15 if we don't clock out.

The reason we don't clock out is we get paid approx 4.75 hours when we are working 4-10pm!! (Or the morning etc) so if we were to work until 11 we would only get an extra 45-1 hour pay. So we work for less than we should already

OP posts:
Bargebill19 · 11/09/2021 16:15

15 or 30 mins docked wouldn’t take you under minimum wage. It is legal because you are getting what you’ve worked. And you stated that via the clocking in and out. All the agencies I’ve worked with have operated this system - some are multinational and employ thousands. Even the unions agree it’s legal. Not nice, but it is legal.
Those that can’t abide by the rules get docked and lose money.

Niconacotaco · 11/09/2021 15:57

@Bargebill19 that isn't legal if it takes you under minimum wage for the hours you work, no matter what is in your contract.

Bargebill19 · 11/09/2021 15:51

Its legal if it’s in your contract - eg my contract states I clock in and out at certain times. If I clock in a minute late or a minute early, I get docked 15 mins. So I could lose 30 mins per shift.
But it states that in my contract. People either accept it or don’t stay.