Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Vera is the worst crime drama of our age?

216 replies

MorrisZapp · 10/09/2021 10:50

I love a cosy ITV procedural, and happily go along with the expositional dialogue and hoary old stereotyped characters but fuck my old boots this is unwatchable stuff.

Tinkly 'suspense' music, mugging to camera, and her grating voice drove me over to Grand Designs by the second ad break. I believe it's on season 11, so clearly it's a much loved show in some quarters.

YABU - how dare you, I love watching detectives two decades past retirement age turn up and call a corpse 'pet'

YANBU - it used to be finely nuanced, edgy stuff but I feel it's lost it's way somewhat

OP posts:
MissMarpleRocks · 10/09/2021 16:19

Love Vera, Morse, Father Brown & Midsomer. If you have not read the Caroline Graham books I’d recommend. Loved them. It’s perfect comfort tv & don’t have to concentrate too much!

KilledByWitches · 10/09/2021 16:18

I used to love Witless Silence as well, and then Tom whatsisface went and Emilia Clarke got more annoying. Clarissa was the only thing worth watching and she’s gone as well.

Shakespeare and Hathaway is brilliant. Proper little guilty pleasure that one. I especially love Lou’s red boots and covet them more with each passing episode.

Interesting to note I’ve just returned from a break in Oxford and all reference to Laurence Fox seems to have been removed from places of interest. Now only listing Morse and Lewis and actors from A Discovery of Witches on one pub sign Grin

theliverpoolone · 10/09/2021 16:14

YANBU - I can't even bear the trailers, so based on that I've avoided all episodes.

VickyEadieofThigh · 10/09/2021 16:09

I know all the police procedurals have pathologists doing stuff they don't do in real life, but I used to know one in real life and he said it made him feel stabby that they showed the one in Silent Witness behaving like a police officer.

pigsDOfly · 10/09/2021 16:08

Silent Witness has been risible for years.

Oh god yes.

I used to really enjoy Silent Witness but at some point a new series started with, I think, a new actor is in the lead part.

I watched part of the first episode and gave up as it seemed to be less about the 'silent witness' of the title and more about the emotional agony and angst of the lead character.

Never watched it since.

Velveteena · 10/09/2021 16:03

@Etinox

I haven’t watched so haven’t voted. I love police procedural. What I’m still reeling from is the utterly appalling Silent Witness I watched for the first time this week. It’s been on for ever and has a good cast, but oh my! Is Vera as bad as Silent Witness?!
Silent Witness used to be quite good. About 20 series ago.

NO idea why they insist on keeping its rotting corpse going Confused

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/09/2021 16:00

Yes, I've often thought that about the interviews, but by that stage I don't really care. Grin

Velveteena · 10/09/2021 15:58

Grantchester I used to enjoy when the delightful James Norton was in it. But they've replaced him with a geography teacher. It's like getting Joe Pasquale to play Rhett Butler. It will not do.

Velveteena · 10/09/2021 15:55

I voted YABU because as long as Midsomer Murders exists nothing else can claim to be the worst crime drama. I do find Vera annoying though with that weird high pitched voice.

I love the cinematic quality of Endeavour. You can tell a lot of work goes into each episode.

VickyEadieofThigh · 10/09/2021 15:48

@Etinox

I haven’t watched so haven’t voted. I love police procedural. What I’m still reeling from is the utterly appalling Silent Witness I watched for the first time this week. It’s been on for ever and has a good cast, but oh my! Is Vera as bad as Silent Witness?!
Absolutely not! Silent Witness has been risible for years.

My criticisms of the 2 most recent episodes of Vera:

  1. Brenda Blethyn is 75. She'd have taken her pension about 20 years ago.
  2. In both the 2 recent episodes, Vera got a confession from each perp but not under caution, etc. In both cases, they shipped the perp off to the station and Vera and sidekick went off home. Any fule kno that they'd have had to do a proper interview, under PACE, with the perp cautioned, offered a solicitor, recorded on tape, etc.
pigsDOfly · 10/09/2021 15:47

Shakespeare and Hathaway, another brilliant one.

MyPatronusIsACat · 10/09/2021 15:45

@MorrisZapp YANBU, it's shit. And I HATE her accent. Big fan of Brenda, but OMG I detest her bloody awful Geordie accent in VERA. The accent is one of my faves in the world, and to hear it done so shockingly bad (IMO) makes my soul weep. Sad

eddiemairswife · 10/09/2021 15:43

Lawrence Fox's antics have ruined my love for Hathaway. Perhaps he's going through a male menopause and he's hormonal!

MeanderingGently · 10/09/2021 15:41

Oh don't knock Vera, I absolutely love it! I was delighted now they've just started series 11.

I watch all the usual...Midsomer Murders (it got better after John Nettles retired from the cast but is still a bit silly and unbelievable), Silent Witness has become pretty gruesome....
Vera is perfect. It's northern, gritty and down to earth, but obviously a crime drama. Much better now 'Vera' has softened a bit....and even better that it focusses on the drama in the main, and doesn't get caught up with the main character falling for a prime suspect or whatever (as in many of these dramas these days).
As for Brenda Blethyn, I luffs her character.....

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 10/09/2021 15:41

I enjoyed Unforgotten! Clearly I have abysmal taste in crime shows.

Haven't watched Midsomer Murders in years. I didn't take to the new Barnaby. Never took to Morse either, so haven't watched Lewis or Endeavour. I did watch a lot of re-runs of The Sweeney during lockdown. That's the stuff to watch if you want a reminder of neanderthal attitudes amongst TV cops.

DynamoKev · 10/09/2021 15:31

YABU Unforgotten is much much worse

Tinkerbellatrix · 10/09/2021 15:28

@hippychick10

The dreadful accent she puts on is utterly horrendous and it's for this reason alone I cannot watch it!
Exactly this. I can't bear it.
WomanStanleyWoman · 10/09/2021 15:20

@Chikapu

Brenda Blethyn is awful in it but it's not the worst crime drama ever, surely Rosemary and Thyme takes that honour!
Have you seen the French and Saunders spoof, ‘Sausages and Mash’? It’s genius Grin
WomanStanleyWoman · 10/09/2021 15:17

Newsflash but she's just within retirement age, but who doesn't love a bit of ageism before lunch. Or because she's female and old, should she not be on television or in work?

As usual, someone manages to enjoy all the indignation without grasping any of the point.

The OP didn’t say she had any issues with watching an older actress. Neither did anyone else. There are brilliant older actresses out there. It’s about realism. Police officers typically retire in their early fifties. Do you really think there is a hidden swarm of 75 year-old serving DCIs out there? Newsflash - there isn’t.

pigsDOfly · 10/09/2021 15:17

Somebody upthread mentioned McDonald & Dobbs; brilliant stuff, loved it.

Likewise Professor T. Really quirky, with a very dark edge.

pigsDOfly · 10/09/2021 15:15

I've been watching the latest offerings of Vera but tbh if you've watched one you've watched them all.

It all feels a bit old and tired and frankly a bit depressing. It's not a programme that I'll rewatch episodes of.

Midsomer murders though, I'll happily sit through every episode several times.

It's light and silly and not to be taken at all seriously. It always feels like the cast act it with their tongues firmly in their cheeks.

Perfect for a lazing evening's viewing.

Droite · 10/09/2021 15:15

Talking of cosy detective stuff, my secret pleasure is Shakespeare and Hathaway. Totally non-challenging, but entertaining, and I love Sebastian.

MorrisZapp · 10/09/2021 15:13

@HarebrightCedarmoon

I can't stand Morse, it's so dated now and Morse himself is actually quite horrible to women all the time. Endeavour is ok, before he turned into a nasty sexist old git Wink
The books are worse. I read half of one once, Morse visited a strip club on his lunch hour. All the posh bits were put in for the telly. So fond of the late John Thaw though, he reminds me of my dad.
OP posts:
Droite · 10/09/2021 15:12

YABU, definitely.

Talking of Peter Wimsey, they did a good version a few years ago with Edward Petherbridge. They could do with being re-shown.

MorrisZapp · 10/09/2021 15:11

@NapoleonOzmolysis

Father Brown and Grantchester are the same thing except one is CofE and one RC. That's it. It's exactly the same otherwise. Scenery ✅ housekeeper ✅ sidekick ✅ useless policeman ✅
James Norton (and Robson thingy for us old birds)

Um... Father Brown?

OP posts: