Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if anyone cares? (Passports)

232 replies

Revertion · 10/09/2021 10:34

I'm posting here rather than in the CV board because I don't think this is actually about the virus anymore.

We all saw it coming, some earlier than others, but it's coming on the 1st of October.

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/news.sky.com/story/amp/covid-19-vaccine-passports-required-in-scotland-for-entry-to-large-venues-from-1-october-12403321

https://www.gov.scot/publications/coronavirus-covid-19-mandatory-vaccine-certification/

Honestly I could weep. And I can say that as someone who this plan, in it's current iteration at least, is not going to affect in any way.

But this is setting a precedent. An unprecedented change to our way of life and it has happened without being mentioned on any manifesto, without public consultation, and without clear plans, scopes, limitations and exemptions having been finalised.

It’s saying that in this country, we can limit your daily life based on your perceived health status and we can measure that perceived health status any way we choose to and we don’t need to provide any scientific reasoning, justification, or evidence that there is a need for it or benefits to it.

That is without getting into details about human rights, valid exemptions, and the blinding issue of an end date being based on ministers (not medics or experts) consideration on preventing spread of CV, when the very same plan says, regarding negative testing as an alternative, that it is not considered appropriate because it would undermine one of the main aims which is to encourage vaccination.

So the scope of the plan is not even aligned with the aim.

That is the precedent we are setting here and it is coming from a government who are attempting to make emergency powers permanent (subject to public consultation - for which there is already a CLEAR PRECEDENT of this government entirely disregarding on other issues).

Yes, yes, slippery slopes are a fallacy and all that. But can we call it that when the top of the slope isn't ethically or morally 'correct' and you don't have to make too many logical distinctions or conclusions before you get to the bottom?

AIBU to think this has the potential to be dangerous?

And, specifically if you are in Scotland or follow Scottish politics, AIBU to think the current government really have no line when it comes to their reach into personal lives and freedoms?

(This is coming straight off the back off their attempts to make emergency powers permanent, the 4 year olds can change gender, the thoughts can be a hate crime, etc. Where does it end?).

I'm really having a 'final nail in the coffin' moment this morning. Feel utterly powerless.Sad BUT prepared to be told I'm unreasonable because I'm apparently also a masochist.... Grin

OP posts:
LuaDipa · 10/09/2021 11:34

In principle I am in full agreement that those who can be vaccinated should in order to protect the vulnerable. But it’s clear that this sort of thing only serves to encourage the vaccine skeptics to dig their heels in.

I think it would be far more effective to make a negative pcr test mandatory for entry to a large event. I have recently had a number of fully vaccinated friends who have tested positive for Covid, some with no symptoms at all. I think the risks if the virus spreading are greater now than ever as we are all far more complacent now that we feel we are ‘safe’.

I am far from a vaccine skeptic and am fully vaccinated myself but it’s clear that the vaccine does not prevent Covid-19 infection in all cases, although I certainly agree that it does mitigate the effects and prevent hospitalisations.

I think if the aim is to actually stop the spread then pcr testing is the only way to ensure an event is as ‘Covid secure’ as possible. With the added bonus that it puts everyone on a level playing field and the Covid deniers can either put up or shut up and stop complaining that the government is trying to inject them with 5G or whatever the latest argument is.

tigger1001 · 10/09/2021 11:33

@Ponoka7

My main worry is the lack of research on periods and reproductive health. Women's health is always the bottom of the pile and this has been shown again. So for that reason, I'm not sure.
And I agree with this!

So many women experienced issues with their periods. Not sure that's something we should be overlooking.

tigger1001 · 10/09/2021 11:31

@Aquilegiagazer

I care OP, so much. I am actually devastated that people can't see where this is leading.

Not too long ago, on here, most MNetters were very wary about vaccines for children and Covid passports were a silly conspiracy theory that wouldn't happen...well look what happened.

Vaccinations are now on the way for 12-16 year olds and I am happy with that being a choice parents and children can make but what if the next step is vaccine passports for children? To attend large events to start with.. But then restaurants and pubs, soft play, supermarkets. And when the vaccine for 2-11 year olds is rolled out? The choice for parents and their children isn't so black and white then is it?

Where does it end?

This is a real worry for me.

It's nightclubs today (was a definition agreed on what constitutes a nightclub?) but what about when vaccines are offered to 12-16 year olds? What will a covid passport look like then?

TinaYouFatLard · 10/09/2021 11:31

I care OP. I’m utterly horrified by the direction we’re heading it. I’m too exhausted by it all to expand any further today. Some days it feels too much.

Pikamoo · 10/09/2021 11:30

But we do limit what people can do based on their perceived health. Like if someone appears intoxicated they shouldn't be served alcohol, many venues will refuse entry. This is presumably to protect the rest of society from the direct and indirect harms that come from excessive drinking. On what basis would diabetics and overweight people be treated this way? Theres no clear direct impact of the harms of obesity. Yes it's bad for society but in a different way imo.

tigger1001 · 10/09/2021 11:29

@YouMeandtheSpew

The thing I don’t really understand (and I’m potentially being very slow) is why is it necessary? I’m not in Scotland but I understand that in England nearly 90% of adults have had their first jab, which presumably means in a few weeks 90% of adults will be fully vaccinated, and the proportion is even higher among vulnerable groups (sorry I don’t know what the level is in Scotland but I assume it’s similar). That level of take-up seems really high to me, far higher than initially estimated. So does it matter if 1 in 10 people can’t have it or don’t want it?
Yes a similar level of uptake here. Just over 90% of the over 16 population have had one dose.
emuloc · 10/09/2021 11:29

@Thunderpunt

Any time a population has to 'present papers' at the behest of a government - it never ends well. This is shocking and people who support it should looks closely at recent history to see how this could pan out.
This.
wheresmymojo · 10/09/2021 11:29

@Thunderpunt

Any time a population has to 'present papers' at the behest of a government - it never ends well. This is shocking and people who support it should looks closely at recent history to see how this could pan out.

I find this a bit dramatic frankly.

Europeans have had ID cards for a long time and there's no issue.

We have actual passports that we have to present 'at the behest of a Govt' and that's fine.

I have to present my driving licence at certain times at 'the behest of a Govt' and it is limited by certain medical conditions as I have to update the DVLA every year about my condition.

TBH I don't see this as much different to the driving licence / medical condition scenario.

With the driving licence I have to prove that I am medically fit to do an activity I want to do without the risk of endangering others as a result of my medical condition.

tigger1001 · 10/09/2021 11:26

I am completely against it.

Over 90% of the over 16 population in Scotland have had at least one dose of the vaccine. There doesn't seem to be a big part of the population not vaccinating.

But given that the current thinking is vaccinated people can and do still get covid and pass it on it seems pointless. And the fact that boosters are being talked about. And also that vaccine protection wains over time.

I despair of the Scottish government I really do.

LizzieMacQueen · 10/09/2021 11:25

I agree OP. The fact that they want these emergency powers to be permanent ( not necessary! ) and also soon it'll be illegal to demonstrate outside Holyrood.

Nicola Sturgeon's 'shame on you' comment was my nail in coffin moment. >>> follow that discussion on the feminism board

Revertion · 10/09/2021 11:22

I think they're selfish fuckers, frankly.

I'm not going to agree or disagree because I think it's honestly more nuanced than that.

But for the sake of argument lets say they are indeed selfish fuckers.

And lets forget it's subjective and say everyone is in agreement on what constitutes selfish fuckery.

Does that not apply to many more behaviours?

We don't limit their daily lives unless they've been proven in a court of law or by panel of experts to have committed a crime (dangerous driving) or to be incapable of doing the part of their daily lives we are limiting (removal of children).

If this is about the jeopardisation of health then why is a negative test not acceptable?

And arguably by creating medical exemptions all you are doing is putting one person's health (the exempt) above the other's (the vaccinated vulnerable).

There would be a lot more logic to argue with if being vaccinated meant there was no way you could carry or spread the virus. This is not true.

As I said in my op, this is (in my knowledge) unprecedented because it is limiting daily life in your own country based on your perceived health status. Not your actual health status (i.e diseased / not diseased) or your ability to infect others.

If we implement this, then the argument of 'we can limit the lives of those with type 2 diabetes, or the morbidly obese, or the alcoholics until they change their behaviours' - which I completely disagree with - begins to have more logical validity.

Previously this could be argued against quite easily with 'none of those can be spread to others' and shut down.

But we are not basing this decision on ability to spread or endanger the lives of others because if we were, the most logical and effective way to do that would be to require a negative test. And the second most logical would be to require an antibody test.

So this is arguably more about punishing those who are making poor health choices and limiting their lives until they comply. They have said in their proposals this is the main aim.

Which is a valid slippery slope because A) we can limit the current targets lives further since the clear aim is to change behaviour and B) we can extend the target to anything and anyone since the clear aim is to change behaviour.

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 10/09/2021 11:21

My main worry is the lack of research on periods and reproductive health. Women's health is always the bottom of the pile and this has been shown again. So for that reason, I'm not sure.

Sushirolls · 10/09/2021 11:21

Totally agree with you, OP.

This is no longer about the virus, and all about control.

Ponoka7 · 10/09/2021 11:19

@Revertion, as soon as it is made law, then people can get an exemption certificate. I know this because my DD is a manager of residential houses for different categories of people. She has already been in touch with the GPs.
Exemptions will include phobias, MH, consent (under some circumstances) etc as well as physical reasons.

I have mixed feelings. The level of stupidity out there is high. The anti Vax movement is strong, without any science reasoning. The deaths that have happened in the US, of heavily pregnant women and their babies, because they've been sucked in, are tragic. We need carrots and sticks to get through this pandemic.

Aquilegiagazer · 10/09/2021 11:18

I care OP, so much. I am actually devastated that people can't see where this is leading.

Not too long ago, on here, most MNetters were very wary about vaccines for children and Covid passports were a silly conspiracy theory that wouldn't happen...well look what happened.

Vaccinations are now on the way for 12-16 year olds and I am happy with that being a choice parents and children can make but what if the next step is vaccine passports for children? To attend large events to start with.. But then restaurants and pubs, soft play, supermarkets. And when the vaccine for 2-11 year olds is rolled out? The choice for parents and their children isn't so black and white then is it?

Where does it end?

YouMeandtheSpew · 10/09/2021 11:17

The thing I don’t really understand (and I’m potentially being very slow) is why is it necessary? I’m not in Scotland but I understand that in England nearly 90% of adults have had their first jab, which presumably means in a few weeks 90% of adults will be fully vaccinated, and the proportion is even higher among vulnerable groups (sorry I don’t know what the level is in Scotland but I assume it’s similar). That level of take-up seems really high to me, far higher than initially estimated. So does it matter if 1 in 10 people can’t have it or don’t want it?

littlebilliie · 10/09/2021 11:16

@LakieLady

Doesn't bother me in the slightest, and if it encourages people who wouldn't otherwise get vaccinated, I think it's a positive thing.

People who can get vaccinated but won't are jeopardising the health of those who can't be vaccinated. I think they're selfish fuckers, frankly.

Totally agree, also while I'm at it I welcome the surveillance that is appearing in towns and cities as it protects everyone
Chardlettuce · 10/09/2021 11:14

I completely agree with everything you've said OP. I disagree with vaccine passports on so many levels. And I speak as someone who is fully vaccinated.

PinkiOcelot · 10/09/2021 11:11

Totally agree OP.

Mary1Mary · 10/09/2021 11:08

I agree with you op.

EatYourVegetables · 10/09/2021 11:08

I am all for it. I would like to get my life back please. If it’s anyone’s right to not be vaccinated, then it’s my right to not be surrounded by them.

BubbleCoffee · 10/09/2021 11:05

I don't want this to happen. This is supposed to be a free country with the minimum of state control. Freedom of speech and thought, freedom to move around without surveillance, freedom of artistic expression, freedom to disagree etc. and our rights to privacy of personal and medical information are shrinking ever more rapidly.

Pikamoo · 10/09/2021 11:02

@Revertion

They very clearly state that there will be exemptions for those unable to be vaccinated.

But, as far as I'm aware (and prepared to be corrected) there is currently no means of getting an exemption and even if there were, they haven't actually defined what a valid reason for exemption would be?

Contraindications?

Phobias?

Mental health issues?

This is 20 days away from being implemented. Have GPs been consulted? Are they all agreed on what a valid medical exemption looks like?

So your problem is less with the vaccine passport itself and more how you think the implementation is going to be shoddy/mismanaged? I can get on board with that. I don't think it's a reason not to do it though, just a reason to scrutinise it.
PastMyBestBeforeDate · 10/09/2021 11:02

The vulnerable are protected by their own vaccination status.
Except for those who can't be vaccinated because they're too young or too ill and those that have been vaccinated but their immune systems are unable to mount a response.

Revertion · 10/09/2021 10:59

They very clearly state that there will be exemptions for those unable to be vaccinated.

But, as far as I'm aware (and prepared to be corrected) there is currently no means of getting an exemption and even if there were, they haven't actually defined what a valid reason for exemption would be?

Contraindications?

Phobias?

Mental health issues?

This is 20 days away from being implemented. Have GPs been consulted? Are they all agreed on what a valid medical exemption looks like?

OP posts: