Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if anyone cares? (Passports)

232 replies

Revertion · 10/09/2021 10:34

I'm posting here rather than in the CV board because I don't think this is actually about the virus anymore.

We all saw it coming, some earlier than others, but it's coming on the 1st of October.

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/news.sky.com/story/amp/covid-19-vaccine-passports-required-in-scotland-for-entry-to-large-venues-from-1-october-12403321

https://www.gov.scot/publications/coronavirus-covid-19-mandatory-vaccine-certification/

Honestly I could weep. And I can say that as someone who this plan, in it's current iteration at least, is not going to affect in any way.

But this is setting a precedent. An unprecedented change to our way of life and it has happened without being mentioned on any manifesto, without public consultation, and without clear plans, scopes, limitations and exemptions having been finalised.

It’s saying that in this country, we can limit your daily life based on your perceived health status and we can measure that perceived health status any way we choose to and we don’t need to provide any scientific reasoning, justification, or evidence that there is a need for it or benefits to it.

That is without getting into details about human rights, valid exemptions, and the blinding issue of an end date being based on ministers (not medics or experts) consideration on preventing spread of CV, when the very same plan says, regarding negative testing as an alternative, that it is not considered appropriate because it would undermine one of the main aims which is to encourage vaccination.

So the scope of the plan is not even aligned with the aim.

That is the precedent we are setting here and it is coming from a government who are attempting to make emergency powers permanent (subject to public consultation - for which there is already a CLEAR PRECEDENT of this government entirely disregarding on other issues).

Yes, yes, slippery slopes are a fallacy and all that. But can we call it that when the top of the slope isn't ethically or morally 'correct' and you don't have to make too many logical distinctions or conclusions before you get to the bottom?

AIBU to think this has the potential to be dangerous?

And, specifically if you are in Scotland or follow Scottish politics, AIBU to think the current government really have no line when it comes to their reach into personal lives and freedoms?

(This is coming straight off the back off their attempts to make emergency powers permanent, the 4 year olds can change gender, the thoughts can be a hate crime, etc. Where does it end?).

I'm really having a 'final nail in the coffin' moment this morning. Feel utterly powerless.Sad BUT prepared to be told I'm unreasonable because I'm apparently also a masochist.... Grin

OP posts:
Beautiful3 · 10/09/2021 12:06

I strongly disagree with vaccine passports, they take away human rights. So controlling.

lemmein · 10/09/2021 12:04

I 100% agree with everything you've said OP. I am increasingly feeling quite depressed at the way this country is heading and feel powerless to do anything about it. It's alarming how quickly people have accepted these restrictions, and how any voices which disagree are silenced in the media (I mostly listen to LBC - anyone who isn't 100% pro vaccine/passport is immediately reprimanded, labelled a conspiracy theorist and cut off!)

Coercive control is supposed to be against the law - yet here we are, coercing people to have medical procedures they don't want and having to 'show their papers', it really is quite unbelievable. More shocking, the amount of people who support it.

I'm double jabbed and not a conspiracy theorist, I just don't like the way this is going. If someone told me 3 short years ago this would be happening I wouldn't have believed them.

Even more depressing that if there was an election tomorrow nothing would change Sad

(Also, my periods have definitely changed since I had the vaccine!)

Pikamoo · 10/09/2021 12:03

I do see your point and I think that a negative test should be accepted as an alternative to vaccination status. Between the two alternatives though I'd rather have a passport that only looks at vaccination status rather than no passport at all.

Revertion · 10/09/2021 11:57

How do people on the thread feel about the requirement to lodge medical conditions with the DVLA to drive then?

This is also perceived risk...

Yes, it's a perceived risk of X illness or condition causing X harm.

The person has to actually have the illness or condition.

We can't say... well, over X age are much more likely to have dementia, and those with dementia are much more likely to cause X so we should ban them from driving.

It's not democratic's chance of having dementia multiplied by dementia risk of causing harm to others.

It's dementia risk of causing harm to others.

So surely to make the comparison to DVLA then it would be infected risk of causing harm to others.

Not wilfully unvaccinated chance of having infection multiplied by infection risk of causing harm to others.

They're not the same.

OP posts:
wheresmymojo · 10/09/2021 11:54

I also think it's incredibly rude and arrogant to say that those that don't agree with you haven't thought it through Hmm

Of course I've thought it through I've just reached an entirely different conclusion to you.

Pikamoo · 10/09/2021 11:51

@Justcallmebebes

Totally agree with you OP. It's not about the virus and it has very sinister implications which all those disagreeing with you haven't really thought through. Covid passports today, what will it be tomorrow?

As an aside, I'm job hunting at the moment and a couple of jobs have specified only double vaccinated candidates will be considered. I am double jabbed so no agenda from me there

How rude of you to think that those of us who disagree with the OP "haven't really thought it through". Do you feel like that about everyone who disagrees with you? That they're just a bit thick..
janj2301 · 10/09/2021 11:51

My husband who is CEV had a very bad reaction to his first vaccine, now on blood thinners. He still had the second as if he gets Covid he IS DEAD, blood thinners for life or die sooner from Covid, no brainer.

wheresmymojo · 10/09/2021 11:50

[quote Thunderpunt]@wheresmymojo passports and ID cards are for identifiable purposes, not health related reasons.
And I thought you self declared in most cases for the DVLA with regard to medical issues[/quote]

Self-declare, yes. But to not self-declare is punishable by a £1000 fine and criminal prosecution if you're involved in an accident and haven't self-declared so it's hardly 'voluntary'

SoupDragon · 10/09/2021 11:49

and it has very sinister implications which all those disagreeing with you haven't really thought through.

Alternatively, maybe they have thought it through and disagree 🙄 So rude.

SoupDragon · 10/09/2021 11:48

@thegcatsmother

Wheresmymojo One of the things I loved when we moved back to the UK, was being able to leave the house without needing to ensure I had my ID card and €5 on me. If I wanted to change my address at the bank, ID card needed; if I wanted to buy paracetamol, ID Card needed; outpatients and the GP, ID card needed. It was never ending.
DS has just had to activate an English Covid passport for a festival. It's on his phone. Most people never leave home without their phone.
Justcallmebebes · 10/09/2021 11:47

Totally agree with you OP. It's not about the virus and it has very sinister implications which all those disagreeing with you haven't really thought through. Covid passports today, what will it be tomorrow?

As an aside, I'm job hunting at the moment and a couple of jobs have specified only double vaccinated candidates will be considered. I am double jabbed so no agenda from me there

wheresmymojo · 10/09/2021 11:47

@BubbleCoffee

I don't want this to happen. This is supposed to be a free country with the minimum of state control. Freedom of speech and thought, freedom to move around without surveillance, freedom of artistic expression, freedom to disagree etc. and our rights to privacy of personal and medical information are shrinking ever more rapidly.

This is an odd way to look at our country.

We have all kinds of limitations over what we can and can't do.

You can't drive without a driving licence
You can't leave the UK without a passport (other than to Ireland)
There are many professions you can't do without a qualification
You can't drive above a certain speed, park in certain places
You can't be served alcohol under a certain age or if you look drunk already
You can't divorce unless you meet certain criteria (seperated two years etc)
You have to give the Govt a proportion of any income you make
Your children have to be educated
Every single criminal law is a limit on freedom
Every single regulation and piece of legislation is a limit on freedom

And complete freedom of speech doesn't exist either - you can't libel or defame people, you can't do anything that would offend 'public decency', there are certain viewpoints that you cannot express (rightly IMO but let's not pretend that it isn't a limit on freedom of speech).

Obviously there's no point listing the literally millions of ways our freedom is limited...but there are millions!

It's part of living in a society.

RuggerHug · 10/09/2021 11:46

Do you think you should be allowed pay cash for a plane ticket and walk on without going through security? No passport, no checks? If so then you have a point but if you agree with passports and safety and security checks then you really have nothing to complain about.

mynameiscalypso · 10/09/2021 11:45

@EileenGC

Where I live Covid passports have been compulsory since March - at the beginning it included shopping centres, hairdressers, restaurants and events on top. Now the first two don’t require them anymore.

It’s fine. I can’t get worked up about showing a QR code on my phone every time I go somewhere, it takes seconds. I also need to show them for work, as I move between different venues and some of them are external to our company.

BUT a certificate of recovery, or a negative test are accepted on top of the vaccination pass. I became fully vaccinated in July and until then, I’d just test myself every day or two (negative test only valid for use 24h), it was still fine although a bit time-consuming.

They’re saying tests will stop being compulsory next month for those eligible for the vaccine. Those who are medically exempt will get a free ‘testing prescription’. Vaccine exemptions here are certified by a medical professional, same as mask exemptions.

This was our experience in France last month too. I was surprised at 1) how everyone where we were just complied with good grace; and 2) how well the process worked.
lljkk · 10/09/2021 11:45

I'm with you, OP.
Bad precedent.
Not sure precedents will stand long, is some consolation. I mean, it's not like UK govt is going to keep abandoning all fiscal discipline forever.

In short run the only protest I plan is simply not to go places that require covid passes. My own little private pointless economic boycott. Restaurants etc. won't miss me, I'm sure, but it's the only way I can think to make my protest that isn't a giant headache in my life. I'd still accept rules to visit my family an airplane flight away, for instance. I'm not absolutely willing to forgo that.

My social media & some relatives are shouting that people who don't get vaccinated (against covid, since nothing else matters) should be denied medical treatment. I am speechless at their infectious insanity.

Am very glad I am not living in America with their new coercive employment policies.

GrandTheftWalrus · 10/09/2021 11:45

How are they going to prove the person showing them the qr code is actually them? Are we all going to need to carry id as well at all times now?

What about people who have had both jags but have changed their name since. Will the doctors update their vaccine record etc?

Nappyvalley15 · 10/09/2021 11:44

I care.
I don't like the direction this is heading in at all. Feels like boiling a frog.

One of the cleverest thing that happened at the start of this was to the highlighting of the absolute crazy of conspiracy theories. No-one wants to be like them for good reason. But it also means that any questioning of the direction we are headed in risks you being put in that category. So people dismiss their fears and concerns and find ways to justify extreme government overreach.

EileenGC · 10/09/2021 11:43

They’re saying tests will stop being compulsory next month for those eligible for the vaccine.

Sorry - tests will stop being free. Edit button please MN!

MLMbotsno · 10/09/2021 11:43

@Josette77

This is about protecting the vulnerable and I support it.
This.

That trumps the right to enter a large venue.

Thunderpunt · 10/09/2021 11:42

@wheresmymojo passports and ID cards are for identifiable purposes, not health related reasons.
And I thought you self declared in most cases for the DVLA with regard to medical issues

EileenGC · 10/09/2021 11:41

Where I live Covid passports have been compulsory since March - at the beginning it included shopping centres, hairdressers, restaurants and events on top. Now the first two don’t require them anymore.

It’s fine. I can’t get worked up about showing a QR code on my phone every time I go somewhere, it takes seconds. I also need to show them for work, as I move between different venues and some of them are external to our company.

BUT a certificate of recovery, or a negative test are accepted on top of the vaccination pass. I became fully vaccinated in July and until then, I’d just test myself every day or two (negative test only valid for use 24h), it was still fine although a bit time-consuming.

They’re saying tests will stop being compulsory next month for those eligible for the vaccine. Those who are medically exempt will get a free ‘testing prescription’. Vaccine exemptions here are certified by a medical professional, same as mask exemptions.

Revertion · 10/09/2021 11:41

Except for those who can't be vaccinated because they're too young or too ill and those that have been vaccinated but their immune systems are unable to mount a response.

Firstly, I do have sincere sympathy for the people who fall into these categories and I understand how difficult their lives must be right now.

But the people who fall into this category (and would fall into similar categories) have lived among since long before covid happened and I don't think they have ever been "held up as an example" to such an extent on any other matter.

You could make the same logical argument for banning allergens in all public places to protect those who are vulnerable. We have never done this (or called for this). Instead the onus is - rightly or wrongly - on those affected to be mindful and take precautions. Sure you could hold up nuts on planes, but airlines give no guarantees and can't prevent it.

And again, the point about vaccine passports being less effective for keeping vulnerable people safe than negative screening or antibody passports stands for this too.

OP posts:
wheresmymojo · 10/09/2021 11:38

@thegcatsmother

Wheresmymojo One of the things I loved when we moved back to the UK, was being able to leave the house without needing to ensure I had my ID card and €5 on me. If I wanted to change my address at the bank, ID card needed; if I wanted to buy paracetamol, ID Card needed; outpatients and the GP, ID card needed. It was never ending.

So, a minor inconvenience. I can't get worked up about that. I have to remember to take my phone everywhere (as my debit card is on it) and I manage that.

thegcatsmother · 10/09/2021 11:36

Wheresmymojo One of the things I loved when we moved back to the UK, was being able to leave the house without needing to ensure I had my ID card and €5 on me. If I wanted to change my address at the bank, ID card needed; if I wanted to buy paracetamol, ID Card needed; outpatients and the GP, ID card needed. It was never ending.

wheresmymojo · 10/09/2021 11:36

How do people on the thread feel about the requirement to lodge medical conditions with the DVLA to drive then?

This is also perceived risk...

For example everyone who has a mental health condition is supposed to notify the DVLA and then; like me be on an annual or three year review of whether or not you can continue to drive.

My mental health condition and the medication I take for it have absolutely no impact on my driving.

My driving licence is much more important than being able to access a nightclub as my ability to earn a living depends on it.