Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if anyone cares? (Passports)

232 replies

Revertion · 10/09/2021 10:34

I'm posting here rather than in the CV board because I don't think this is actually about the virus anymore.

We all saw it coming, some earlier than others, but it's coming on the 1st of October.

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/news.sky.com/story/amp/covid-19-vaccine-passports-required-in-scotland-for-entry-to-large-venues-from-1-october-12403321

https://www.gov.scot/publications/coronavirus-covid-19-mandatory-vaccine-certification/

Honestly I could weep. And I can say that as someone who this plan, in it's current iteration at least, is not going to affect in any way.

But this is setting a precedent. An unprecedented change to our way of life and it has happened without being mentioned on any manifesto, without public consultation, and without clear plans, scopes, limitations and exemptions having been finalised.

It’s saying that in this country, we can limit your daily life based on your perceived health status and we can measure that perceived health status any way we choose to and we don’t need to provide any scientific reasoning, justification, or evidence that there is a need for it or benefits to it.

That is without getting into details about human rights, valid exemptions, and the blinding issue of an end date being based on ministers (not medics or experts) consideration on preventing spread of CV, when the very same plan says, regarding negative testing as an alternative, that it is not considered appropriate because it would undermine one of the main aims which is to encourage vaccination.

So the scope of the plan is not even aligned with the aim.

That is the precedent we are setting here and it is coming from a government who are attempting to make emergency powers permanent (subject to public consultation - for which there is already a CLEAR PRECEDENT of this government entirely disregarding on other issues).

Yes, yes, slippery slopes are a fallacy and all that. But can we call it that when the top of the slope isn't ethically or morally 'correct' and you don't have to make too many logical distinctions or conclusions before you get to the bottom?

AIBU to think this has the potential to be dangerous?

And, specifically if you are in Scotland or follow Scottish politics, AIBU to think the current government really have no line when it comes to their reach into personal lives and freedoms?

(This is coming straight off the back off their attempts to make emergency powers permanent, the 4 year olds can change gender, the thoughts can be a hate crime, etc. Where does it end?).

I'm really having a 'final nail in the coffin' moment this morning. Feel utterly powerless.Sad BUT prepared to be told I'm unreasonable because I'm apparently also a masochist.... Grin

OP posts:
RuggerHug · 10/09/2021 14:52

@EileenGC

LFTs are not very efficient. PCRs are a bit better but they cost £40 each. Ok, let’s bring down the cost to £20. If you take one of these every 48 hours (you should do one every 24h tbh to be even more ‘safe’), that’s £300 per person per month. Granted, not everyone will need them every 48 hours, but it’s still a huge amount of money on testing the general population all the time. Who pays for this? It’s not like the government has extra money lying around for this.
This is why I've thought if you want to refuse a vaccine and go with testing to go to work or wherever, fine. But you pay for them yourself. Also, if it was someone working for me you need the result in time to start work at the time you're meant to. You don't walk in at 9, take a test and wait for the results before you start work. You have it done and ready beforehand.
MistressoftheDarkSide · 10/09/2021 14:51

The government appears to have plenty of money to pay for PR campaigns, contracts with biometric firms looking at vaccine passports and the like.....just saying.

EileenGC · 10/09/2021 14:48

LFTs are not very efficient. PCRs are a bit better but they cost £40 each. Ok, let’s bring down the cost to £20. If you take one of these every 48 hours (you should do one every 24h tbh to be even more ‘safe’), that’s £300 per person per month. Granted, not everyone will need them every 48 hours, but it’s still a huge amount of money on testing the general population all the time. Who pays for this? It’s not like the government has extra money lying around for this.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 10/09/2021 14:35

Yes, I said up thread that more efficient tests should be worked on..... but we have to work with what we've got I suppose.....

tigger1001 · 10/09/2021 14:32

@MistressoftheDarkSide

The people who work in these venues have the right to have potential exposure to the virus minimised, and a negative test would be of more value than simply being able to state that you're vaccinated. Because both vaccinated and unvaccinated can catch and transmit the virus, and the passports are a danger in that some may believe their sniffle can't possibly be Covid because it's so mild......but they're vaccinated so they can't be a risk.
Totally agree!
lockdownmadnessdotcom · 10/09/2021 14:32

If the true goal is to prevent spread, then negative tests are the most logical path

but then you need a test that actually works - and quickly. Not tests that only work about 5-10 days after you've been infected.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 10/09/2021 14:31

@RuggerHug

1958-1977 was the major smallpox vaccine roll-out, one poster saying it's irrelevant to this discussion is a century out in their argument.

Also this 'yes but this is the UK' groups. What is it that is so special about the UK and it's people that they don't think they should do what other developed nations are doing to help stop this worldwide issue? What makes them so special?

Vaccine scepticism is lower in the UK than other countries so maybe we don't need this coercion - not that I agree with it anywhere.

Plus the fact the vaccine is not 100% effective so what is the point of coercing people to have it?

People have died after having this vaccine. That is a fact. Therefore people should have the choice as to whether to have it. Personally I thought the risk of the illness as greater, but that was MY choice.

Get the vaccine yourself and stop worrying about other people. Their health choices are no business of yours.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 10/09/2021 14:31

If the true goal is to prevent spread, then negative tests are the most logical path. My DIL works in a big chain and is vaccinated, but also has to do LFTs every three days or so provided by her employers. She caught Covid at work at Christmas, before she was vaccinated. None of us were at that point. She had probably been infectious for a considerable period before her positive test came back, so we'd been in relatively close contact. None of us caught it then. When I and my double vaxxed DP caught it from our double vaxxed friend we'd spent four hours in our big well ventilated kitchen with her. It's a lottery to be honest but if measures are in place I'd like them to be somewhat logic and science driven, not just lip service giving the smug a stick to beat others with.

RuggerHug · 10/09/2021 14:30

@MistressoftheDarkSide

So many responses here are based on moral judgement over science and logic.....is it not true that a significant number of the vulnerable are protected by vaccination? This vaccine is designed primarily to reduce symptoms, illness and hospitalisation in the most vulnerable, via their own vaccinated status.

I can't get my head round people being written off as pariahs having led perfectly responsible and benevolent lives because they have declined a medical treatment as is their right.

Vulnerable people (however you want to define it) have the same rights to work,social and be in public as anyone else. Someone choosing not to protect themselves or vulnerable people is of course able to make that choice but it comes with consequences. If you've opted out you accept you don't have everything you want. Rights,responsibilities,actions,consequences, it's not all about you. Stuff primary school children learn.
tigger1001 · 10/09/2021 14:29

@forinborin

But we are debating about the uk here. Sure, and all points you make further are also all valid. I am not sure how efficient this measure will be either. I was just pointing out that it is not exceptionally unusual, and not necessarily a slippery slope to a dictatorship as some posters seem to imply.
I'm just not so sure I trust this government not to make it a slippery slope. There is very little this government have done recently that I can get on board with and it makes me worry about long term future. To be honest the covid passport is just another nail in the coffin.

Rules are far more likely to be followed if they are clear and have a valid purpose. These rules appear to be neither clear or have valid purpose.

I do wonder how long it will be before the first legal case challenges this rule. After all it won't be the first legal challenge the Scottish government has faced over covid rules.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 10/09/2021 14:29

@Josette77

This is about protecting the vulnerable and I support it.
It isn't. It is a ridiculous overreach of government powers, aimed at forcing people to have the vaccine - if the vaccine were 100% safe and effective that would be fine, but it's neither, so it should always be a choice. And where does it end? Flu vaccine next?

And when will this finish? I read yesterday that vaccine passports are being considered for the Commonwealth Games. That's August!

Pinkcrispy · 10/09/2021 14:27

If the government were genuinely so concerned for our health, why were nightclubs reopened at all without the requirement of vaccination?

I actually think passports could make the situation worse. Too many people will be utterly complacent; "we've been vaxxed, we're safe", spreading the virus around far more than this time last year. A vaccination pass to get you in anywhere but no testing? Absolutely bonkers!

RuggerHug · 10/09/2021 14:27

1958-1977 was the major smallpox vaccine roll-out, one poster saying it's irrelevant to this discussion is a century out in their argument.

Also this 'yes but this is the UK' groups. What is it that is so special about the UK and it's people that they don't think they should do what other developed nations are doing to help stop this worldwide issue? What makes them so special?

SusieBob · 10/09/2021 14:27

@FuckPilledLatteplus

How long before you need to show your passport to enter a hospital, dentist or supermarket?
Never. Obviously.
SusieBob · 10/09/2021 14:26

I have sympathy for people with actual medical reasons not to have the vaccine over this, but beyond that - nope.

Going to large events is not a right and if you CBA to have the vaccine or think you know better than medical science then you don't get to go. Oh well.

Revertion · 10/09/2021 14:24

The people who work in these venues have the right to have potential exposure to the virus minimised

Which would be a valid reason to make entrance based on negative test result?

I'm also not sure how someone who works in a nightclub has any more right than someone who works in a pub?

OP posts:
MistressoftheDarkSide · 10/09/2021 14:24

So many responses here are based on moral judgement over science and logic.....is it not true that a significant number of the vulnerable are protected by vaccination? This vaccine is designed primarily to reduce symptoms, illness and hospitalisation in the most vulnerable, via their own vaccinated status.

I can't get my head round people being written off as pariahs having led perfectly responsible and benevolent lives because they have declined a medical treatment as is their right.

lljkk · 10/09/2021 14:19

The people who work in these venues have the right to have potential exposure to the virus minimised

Most likely, The people who work in these venues have the right to work there & yet be not vaccinated themselves.

Hopeisnotastrategy · 10/09/2021 14:17

@Josette77

This is about protecting the vulnerable and I support it.
Yes.
nunamenuyear · 10/09/2021 14:16

I support it, but I also don't have a problem with everyone carrying ID cards. I think people who could get vaccinated but choose not to are selfish idiots.

MistressoftheDarkSide · 10/09/2021 14:15

The people who work in these venues have the right to have potential exposure to the virus minimised, and a negative test would be of more value than simply being able to state that you're vaccinated. Because both vaccinated and unvaccinated can catch and transmit the virus, and the passports are a danger in that some may believe their sniffle can't possibly be Covid because it's so mild......but they're vaccinated so they can't be a risk.

Pinkcrispy · 10/09/2021 14:15

"Vaccine passports are nothing to do with risks though, because the vaccinated can still pass the virus on just as the unvaccinated can. As an unvaccinated person I'm happy to do tests to prove I am not unwell. Accepting vaccinated people who have not tested into crowded venues because passport says so is nothing to do with actual public health."

" People who can't be vaccinated for medical reasons will be treated as vaccinated. People who have chosen not to be vaccinated for their own reasons are outcast but it's still two unvaccinated people so there should be no differences."

Agree with both of these.

It doesn't make sense.

didyouseeit · 10/09/2021 14:10

don't the people who work in these venues have rights then?

Do they have to accept people who won't be vaccinated putting their lives and livelihoods at risk?

People can survive not going to venues, therefore they don't need a passport or a vaccine. they still have a choice.

KatieB55 · 10/09/2021 14:05

I'm totally against it.

Nightclubs & large events have been running for months - what do the Govm think is going to change on a particular date?

Vaccinated and unvaccinated can catch and transmit Covid so what exactly is the point?

forinborin · 10/09/2021 13:53

But we are debating about the uk here.
Sure, and all points you make further are also all valid. I am not sure how efficient this measure will be either. I was just pointing out that it is not exceptionally unusual, and not necessarily a slippery slope to a dictatorship as some posters seem to imply.