Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to ask if anyone cares? (Passports)

232 replies

Revertion · 10/09/2021 10:34

I'm posting here rather than in the CV board because I don't think this is actually about the virus anymore.

We all saw it coming, some earlier than others, but it's coming on the 1st of October.

https://www.google.co.uk/amp/s/news.sky.com/story/amp/covid-19-vaccine-passports-required-in-scotland-for-entry-to-large-venues-from-1-october-12403321

https://www.gov.scot/publications/coronavirus-covid-19-mandatory-vaccine-certification/

Honestly I could weep. And I can say that as someone who this plan, in it's current iteration at least, is not going to affect in any way.

But this is setting a precedent. An unprecedented change to our way of life and it has happened without being mentioned on any manifesto, without public consultation, and without clear plans, scopes, limitations and exemptions having been finalised.

It’s saying that in this country, we can limit your daily life based on your perceived health status and we can measure that perceived health status any way we choose to and we don’t need to provide any scientific reasoning, justification, or evidence that there is a need for it or benefits to it.

That is without getting into details about human rights, valid exemptions, and the blinding issue of an end date being based on ministers (not medics or experts) consideration on preventing spread of CV, when the very same plan says, regarding negative testing as an alternative, that it is not considered appropriate because it would undermine one of the main aims which is to encourage vaccination.

So the scope of the plan is not even aligned with the aim.

That is the precedent we are setting here and it is coming from a government who are attempting to make emergency powers permanent (subject to public consultation - for which there is already a CLEAR PRECEDENT of this government entirely disregarding on other issues).

Yes, yes, slippery slopes are a fallacy and all that. But can we call it that when the top of the slope isn't ethically or morally 'correct' and you don't have to make too many logical distinctions or conclusions before you get to the bottom?

AIBU to think this has the potential to be dangerous?

And, specifically if you are in Scotland or follow Scottish politics, AIBU to think the current government really have no line when it comes to their reach into personal lives and freedoms?

(This is coming straight off the back off their attempts to make emergency powers permanent, the 4 year olds can change gender, the thoughts can be a hate crime, etc. Where does it end?).

I'm really having a 'final nail in the coffin' moment this morning. Feel utterly powerless.Sad BUT prepared to be told I'm unreasonable because I'm apparently also a masochist.... Grin

OP posts:
Revertion · 11/09/2021 00:28

Do people still not get this? Vaccinated people are far less likely to become ill, this who do are far less likely to be hospitalised. When they are, they are far less likely to need an ICU bed, and will stay for a day or two rather than a week or two. That’s the point of the passports.

You're not considering that perhaps people still aren't getting this because it's the exact opposite logic to how we've dealt with other restrictions during the pandemic.

A couple living separately alone, mid twenties, no health or weight issues, always worked from home, not allowed to see each other.

Couple are far less likely to become ill, if they do they are far less likely to be hospitalised, if they are then far less likely to need ICU and will stay for a day or two etc.

We haven't given a rat's arse about likelihoods throughout.

If we did, we wouldn't have been in a situation where bingo halls were open to pensioners long before children were allowed to set foot in schools.

But apparently it's all about the likelihoods now and anyone who hasn't noticed is a dummy. But we're only allowed to use one thing to calculate said risk?

100% vaccination rate for 60+
Admissions this week 76 per 100k

35% vaccination rate for u30s
Admissions this week 14.9 per 100k

Why are we only allowed to use vaccination status to calculate illness > hospitalisations > ICU when the above shows age is far more significant?

Because it's about stopping the spread?

If it was about stopping the spread they could use testing. (They've admitted it's not about stopping the spread though).

If it was about keeping hospitalisations down, the stats above categorically show that restrictions based on actual passports would be far more effective than restrictions based on vaccine passports.

But that would be making sweeping judgements and restricting people's lives based on the perceived risk of a demographic, which sounds massively unjustifiable imo........

OP posts:
XenoBitch · 10/09/2021 21:21

YANBU
Night clubs have been open for ages. Now all of a sudden, they have to turn people away if they are not jabbed and have the app. The passports are a way to coerce people into getting the vaccine. If it was about health or protecting the vulnerable (who I doubt are lining up to go to clubs anyway) then they would be insisting on tests for everyone.

Have seen it mentioned so... comparing vaccine passports to yellow fever certificates does not work. You only have to prove your yellow fever vaccine status on entry to the country requiring them. You don't have to show it again to access anything else.

YouMeandtheSpew · 10/09/2021 20:56

Do people still not get this? Vaccinated people are far less likely to become ill, this who do are far less likely to be hospitalised. When they are, they are far less likely to need an ICU bed, and will stay for a day or two rather than a week or two. That’s the point of the passports.

Just like seatbelts are there to prevent serious or fatal injuries in a crash, not to stop the car crashing in the first place. Do people really not understand this, or is it something they keep telling themselves to justify their decision not to vaccinate?

I totally understand the benefit of the vaccines. I love vaccines. I just don’t understand the point of the passports, when overall take-up of the vaccines among the eligible population and, in particular, among the vulnerable groups has been so high.

If only, say, 50% of adults had accepted it then I would understand it a lot more. But we don’t appear to have a major problem with vaccine hesistancy in the U.K., given nearly 90% of adults have accepted at least their first dose (and I think another poster upthread said it’s slightly more than 90% in Scotland). Are we saying we need 100% of adults to be vaccinated?

PeriWrinkles · 10/09/2021 20:27

Get jabbed guys and for fuck's sake don't vote for the blond twat again.

Geamhradh · 10/09/2021 20:23

[quote PeriWrinkles]@Geamhradh whereas the UK is a shining beacon of hope and enlightenment for the rest of Europe 😂😂😂😂😂. It's a shithole run by corrupt incompetent liars.[/quote]
True dat.

PeriWrinkles · 10/09/2021 20:16

@Geamhradh whereas the UK is a shining beacon of hope and enlightenment for the rest of Europe 😂😂😂😂😂. It's a shithole run by corrupt incompetent liars.

Geamhradh · 10/09/2021 20:04

@forinborin

I don’t believe any country in the world tests for HIV at point of entry. Given that the vast majority of PLHIV in the U.K. are on effective meds and no risk to anyone it’s not really relevant to the thread. Not at the point of entry. Poland will not allow HIV positive visits over 90 days. Hungary will deport HIV positive people who are not complying with their treatment.
In fairness, (and being more than happy to be living in a "police state" Confused) I don't think we should be holding either Poland or Hungary up as shining examples in how citizens are treated.
forinborin · 10/09/2021 20:00

I don’t believe any country in the world tests for HIV at point of entry. Given that the vast majority of PLHIV in the U.K. are on effective meds and no risk to anyone it’s not really relevant to the thread.
Not at the point of entry. Poland will not allow HIV positive visits over 90 days. Hungary will deport HIV positive people who are not complying with their treatment.

PeriWrinkles · 10/09/2021 19:54

In Italy it's been a police state since 1 September. You get the jabs or get excluded from normal life and also from many occupations. I've done what they demanded while internally raising the middle finger.

I had the jab, my teens have had the jab, on my paediatrician's advice my 10yo will be getting the jab as soon as it comes out for kids, probably in the next 6 months or so. My kids and their friends need their lives back and that's that.

The mental health toll of all these restrictions far outweighs any risk or my indignation at creeping state control.

I was reluctant to have it. Now I've had it, I don't care any more.

I'll concentrate my efforts on learning how to vote, instead.

Geamhradh · 10/09/2021 19:43

[quote YouMeandtheSpew]@Geamhradh

Yes I think those figures are for the population as a whole and the figures I gave are for the adult population (higher in the very vulnerable groups) as per the figures @tigger1001 shared.[/quote]
Ok, thanks.
It was interesting to see how high Portugal is now. When I was preening over getting my first Vax my Portuguese friend was saying she had no idea when it would be offered to non CV people.

Carriemac · 10/09/2021 19:39

I think it’s an excellent idea. People aren’t wearing masks and are walking around as though no pandemic. This needs to happen! I don’t want another bloody lockdown
It's working well in France and Ireland

Cantfindausernamethatsnottaken · 10/09/2021 19:36

YANBU

ripples101 · 10/09/2021 19:25

OP,

What exactly is your solution?

All I see from people like you is moaning about actions that have been taken. Never do people like you provide solutions.

I am sick of this crap. We are in and have been in a pandemic for 18 months now. It has been shit for all. And worse for many others who have lost husbands, wives, parents, children, uncles, aunties, and friends. Etc etc etc

And you equate this to a hit on your civil liberties?

Tumbleweed101 · 10/09/2021 19:16

I'm against this in principle. The 'good reasons for it being put in place (protecting vulnerable) will very quickly be overtaken by those who want to exert control on a population and it has the potential to slip into other areas of our life unless closely regulated.

I don't think anyone should be coersed into taking this or any other vaccine or medical treatment. I am very concerned at the potential consequences of it going ahead.

To add - I have had my covid jabs. This decision won't affect me directly right now but I dislike the direction things are going in.

SlipperyDippery · 10/09/2021 19:14

@BoredZelda

And all the double vaccinated clubbers could get sick as dogs too. And then - off work, pressure on NHS etc. So what was the point of the passports..?

Do people still not get this? Vaccinated people are far less likely to become ill, this who do are far less likely to be hospitalised. When they are, they are far less likely to need an ICU bed, and will stay for a day or two rather than a week or two. That’s the point of the passports.

Just like seatbelts are there to prevent serious or fatal injuries in a crash, not to stop the car crashing in the first place. Do people really not understand this, or is it something they keep telling themselves to justify their decision not to vaccinate?

I agree with this.

I would add that although I agree needing a vaccine passport is a concerning erosion into people’s autonomy to choose, it’s a tiny infringement of people’s rights compared to a national lockdown, or other restrictions on day to day life, which we might be facing if hospitalisations continue to rise.

tigger1001 · 10/09/2021 19:07

@BoredZelda

Scientists are saying that delta in particular is more likely to spread through vaccinated people. And that people with the delta variant carry as much virus in their nose as an unvaccinated person.

Source?

www.nature.com/articles/d41586-021-02187-1

To be honest it was widely discussed in the news in recent weeks.

bcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyza · 10/09/2021 19:02

I personally don't mind if we have to get one.

I am in Scotland and got the copy through NHS Scotland covid website as prove as I thought this was coming.

To me when travelling abroad I feel the covid jag will be added to the list of required jags like all the others already.

BoredZelda · 10/09/2021 19:01

Scientists are saying that delta in particular is more likely to spread through vaccinated people. And that people with the delta variant carry as much virus in their nose as an unvaccinated person.

Source?

User135644 · 10/09/2021 19:01

@BoredZelda

And all the double vaccinated clubbers could get sick as dogs too. And then - off work, pressure on NHS etc. So what was the point of the passports..?

Do people still not get this? Vaccinated people are far less likely to become ill, this who do are far less likely to be hospitalised. When they are, they are far less likely to need an ICU bed, and will stay for a day or two rather than a week or two. That’s the point of the passports.

Just like seatbelts are there to prevent serious or fatal injuries in a crash, not to stop the car crashing in the first place. Do people really not understand this, or is it something they keep telling themselves to justify their decision not to vaccinate?

Unvaccinated people are still going to socialise though or generally be reckless because they don't give a shit about Covid (assuming they can have a vaccine).

It's not going to make them sit at home shielding. It's a small minority of the adult population that are unvaccinated.

Unvaccinated kids spread it like wildfire in schools, but they aren't going to nightclubs.

Coogee · 10/09/2021 19:00

Covid passports are already a thing where I am. To get in any venue/shop with a capacity of more than ten, you need to show it at the door.

And wear a mask.

BoredZelda · 10/09/2021 19:00

We currently have no idea how they'll handle exceptions and little sign of any action that they give a fuck.

I had a look, medical and age exemptions are in place. Apparently the number of people currently medically unable to be vaccinated is 1 in 1000. So your average night club will have less than one person who is exempt.

HIVpos · 10/09/2021 19:00

@forinborin

As a third party national from many countries around the world, to get into the UK you have to pass a TB scan before you are allowed to cross the border. I still remember waiting for my scan a decade ago at the airport, feeling incredibly anxious. Other countries demand to be HIV clear before you are admitted in. Yes, even in the EU. It is not like it is a new thing.
These are the only countries that have a total entry bar on people diagnosed with HIV. None are in the EU and consist of those that also punish homosexuality and discriminate against women.

Brunei
Equatorial Guinea
Iran
Iraq
Jordan
Russia
Solomon Islands
United Arab Emirates (UAE)
Yemen

I don’t believe any country in the world tests for HIV at point of entry. Given that the vast majority of PLHIV in the U.K. are on effective meds and no risk to anyone it’s not really relevant to the thread.

I had to have a scan for TB many years ago when spending several months in Switzerland. I had no issue with that as if by any chance I had it, it’s something that can be passed on very easily to others.

Hope that gives some perspective.

BoredZelda · 10/09/2021 18:57

And all the double vaccinated clubbers could get sick as dogs too. And then - off work, pressure on NHS etc. So what was the point of the passports..?

Do people still not get this? Vaccinated people are far less likely to become ill, this who do are far less likely to be hospitalised. When they are, they are far less likely to need an ICU bed, and will stay for a day or two rather than a week or two. That’s the point of the passports.

Just like seatbelts are there to prevent serious or fatal injuries in a crash, not to stop the car crashing in the first place. Do people really not understand this, or is it something they keep telling themselves to justify their decision not to vaccinate?

BiBabbles · 10/09/2021 18:39

ID cards have been in place on the continent now for a long time...what sinister scheme has it ended in? Nothing.

I support better universally accepted state ID in the UK, though another posters has pointed out one of the risks of them being compulsory. For a British example, Biometric Residency Permits in the UK have caused a number of issues for immigrants who already had indefinite leave to remain when they came into force and then had to prove sometimes decades of residency or lose their rights to work or access services or rent. Family carers have been particularly vulnerable.

I don't think it's a 'sinister scheme', I think people tend to forget the people who get fucked over by these changes when it's not them and that assholes will use any tool available to them to exert power over others. These changes always have benefits for some people and risks that hurt others.

I've no strong opinion on vaccine passports, even less if we're talking international borders rather than domestic movement, but I can acknowledge it has it's risks in isolating vulnerable members of the population. We currently have no idea how they'll handle exceptions and little sign of any action that they give a fuck. Not everyone has a smart phone for the app. Not everyone who has a smart phone has one that will use these apps. We've already been told the paper given at vaccination is not enough. Some are going to get fucked over, and generally, it feels like a distraction to fit an image - much like BRP is for immigration and CCTV for crime prevention - than anything that solves the issues COVID has brought up or grown.

Jangle33 · 10/09/2021 18:30

I think it’s an excellent idea. People aren’t wearing masks and are walking around as though no pandemic. This needs to happen! I don’t want another bloody lockdown