Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Childminder - is this normal practice?

138 replies

JackGrealishsHair · 10/09/2021 10:32

Just started looking round at childminders locally and it's the first time I've done this. A genuine AIBU to be surprised / shocked by these practices?

For context children are aged from 12 months up to 5 years.

  • children sleep on a plastic crashmat on the floor all piled in together. No blankets, no cots for tiny ones, no curtains in the room. This room is also used for soft play. Is this normal practice?
  • meals are always dahl and bread. Always vegetarian and lentil based, some variation on the dahl recipe. This is because so many children have different dietary requirements, so its easier. If parents wish child to eat something else eg chicken or vegetables they have to provide those already prepared.
  • there are no high chairs available for very young children at meals. They eat in the floor or if they can manage sitting in a small chair.
  • nap time is the same for every child regardless of age or routine at home.
  • childminder says she will often tell children that they love them and this is healthy because of how close she is with the children.

AIBU to be surprised by these or is it normal?

OP posts:
Helenluvsrob · 10/09/2021 13:17

Missed the lead the kids in prayer twice a day. A bit bonkers but hey they went to a c of e school so it’s the same 😂. They had a “ k
Let us pray “ reflex where they sit and close their eyes😂😂

Helenluvsrob · 10/09/2021 13:15

Sounds fine for me. Dahl and bread is not unhealthy , it’s a basic cheap eat and beat chicken nuggets or ham sandwiches every day.

Napping together like a pile of puppies in an area that is easy to monitor abs supervise. Fine. You can’t have a cot and 3 child beds in their own rooms etc. Blanket if cold maybe.

Expression of love and hugs. Yes. Why not. My CM and daughter share a real loving bond. Daughter goes out for afternoon tea with auntie - nowt to do with me - she’s 22 now 😂. Wouldn’t have it any other way.

RedMarauder · 10/09/2021 13:07

She also said she led all children in prayer twice a day.

Shock
takealettermsjones · 10/09/2021 13:03

I understand others may disagree but the telling them she loves them thing is so far over the line for me I'd be taking my kid out of there straight away.

Why? I really don't understand this. Odd to begin with, but as they get to know each other?

Because for me, the childminder is just that, a childminder. They're there to provide short term childcare. My child is only in childcare a couple of days a week to start, and we intend it to end after two years. It's not a lifelong bond kind of a situation. I don't want her to get overly attached and then perceive that the person who was supposed to love her abandoned her. Which is why I chose a nursery setting rather than a small-group CM.

They're the objective reasons. Subjectively? It just doesn't sit right with me.

BarbaraofSeville · 10/09/2021 12:58

@INeedNewShoes

This sounds like a cultural difference.

I don't translate any of your points to the childminder not being caring or good at what they do (although the lack of variety in diet isn't great at least the one meal on offer is a good one).

I agree. In some cultures dhal is obviously very common and a standard food for everyone including infants. Variety will be provided by by adding different vegetables and using different types of lentils. Just like you would think a sandwich every day is fine, so is this.

Eating on the floor on a mat is also standard. I don't know about sleeping, but I don't see anything wrong with it as long as the child isn't cold.

Antinerak · 10/09/2021 12:57

A 1 year old can definitely sleep on a mat. In most nurseries you'll find they sleep on mats when they're past the baby age.

I understand they should have a secure bond and close relationship with the kids but saying they love them seems a bit off to me. If they specified that it suggests a parent has had a problem with it before so they're warning other parents it will happen.

The food may contain plenty of veg and good ingredients but what child would want to eat that every day, especially if they're there for long hours.

It sounds like laziness due to accepting more children than they can care for. Whether it's in ratio or not it doesn't sound well managed.

Drinkingallthewine · 10/09/2021 12:53

Some of it is fine, other parts not so much. The mat is fine, but a blanket should be provided. Vegetarian food, ok, but again, variation for nutritional purposes is expected.

Go with your gut. I viewed one place and while it ticked all the boxes, something felt off - they had pictures on the wall of some kids baking and doing other activities but the expressions on their faces were like they were startled to be shoehorned into an apron and handed a bowl for a photo. They didn't look happy, that was for sure. There was also no toys at baby level in the baby room and the few they did have were old and tired looking.

Anyway, went to view a dearer nursery. Offered a tour on the spot, and was able to see how they interacted with the children on the spur of the moment. In the baby room, it was bright, spotless and loads of toys on the play-floor, with all the babies absorbed in their activities and the vibe was just one of contentment. One of the workers came over with a little one snuggled into her sucking his thumb. While she was telling me about the room she was absent-mindedly stroking his temple and he was loving it. The gesture was so unthinkingly affectionate that immediately I thought "yep, I would be happy to leave PFB in their care." They had a varied menu, cooked by a qualified cook and all freshly prepared every day.
They showed me the inspection report, and showed the changes they had made in line with it's recommendations.
I'm so glad I picked that one, it was a great one. The manager was a take-no-shit from parents person and I loved her for it.

Maryann1975 · 10/09/2021 12:51

Just started looking round at childminders locally and it's the first time I've done this. A genuine AIBU to be surprised / shocked by these practices?

For context children are aged from 12 months up to 5 years.

  • children sleep on a plastic crashmat on the floor all piled in together. No blankets, no cots for tiny ones, no curtains in the room. This room is also used for soft play. Is this normal practice?
  • meals are always dahl and bread. Always vegetarian and lentil based, some variation on the dahl recipe. This is because so many children have different dietary requirements, so its easier. If parents wish child to eat something else eg chicken or vegetables they have to provide those already prepared.
  • there are no high chairs available for very young children at meals. They eat in the floor or if they can manage sitting in a small chair.
  • nap time is the same for every child regardless of age or routine at home.
  • childminder says she will often tell children that they love them and this is healthy because of how close she is with the children.

AIBU to be surprised by these or is it normal?

How many childminders have you been to see? I’d be very surprised that they were all the same, following this kind of setting As it sounds unusual?

It is a nightmare trying to please very one food wise. At the moment, I’ve got one who refuses any kind of fruit or veg and it’s a battle to get her to eat any kind of protein as all she wants is crisps and biscuits and a bottle of fizzy pop and another who at home is fed really lovely dinners, with a completely lovely variety of what I consider unusual fruit and veg. If she has found something everyone eats and the parents are happy, that’s fine (although ideally there should be A lot more variety).

Napping on mats, again, it’s not for me, but if parents are happy and the children are napping If they want to, that’s the most important thing. I try to get all my children to nap at the same time if possible. We go out in the morning, so it fits for everyone to have a nap after lunch. Is it a cultural thing that the children sit on the floor to eat? Again it’s unusual but if it works for them?

I’ve had children who tell me they love me every day. I respond that I love them too. It’s never really crossed my mind to tell parents that I say it back, but it’s kind of hurtful if you tell someone you love them and they don’t say it back. I don’t initiate that though, it comes from the child. And some never tell me, which is fine, they still get hugs and cuddles when they want them.

Please go and see some other childminders in your area and hopefully one of them will be a better fit with how you want to raise your dc.

Nomorepies · 10/09/2021 12:46

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ on the poster's request

Cruiser123 · 10/09/2021 12:44

Why wouldn't you want your child to feel securely attached and loved if it spends 8 to 9 hours a day with a person?

Eastie77Returns · 10/09/2021 12:34

Well none of it sounds abnormal as such, it's all about your personal preference?

We visited a childminder who sounded great on paper and even had her own website showcasing activities etc. She lived in a large house in a leafy part of town and the house sounded ideal. Upon arrival we discovered similar things such as the children sleeping on mats in a tiny room and strange menu choices. She had a very unfriendly looking/hostile DH who worked from home and she mentioned she would leave napping mindees with him whilst she picked up her own DC from school. She also said she led all children in prayer twice a day. None of this worked for us. She was able to provide references from happy parents including a local doctor and solicitor so I guess it's all horses for courses.

We've been with our current CM for 8 years now. I don't know if she's ever told the DC she loves them but they certainly love her.

NoSquirrels · 10/09/2021 12:31

If you don’t like it you don’t like it, but none of it is especially odd - just cultural differences, I’d say.

I’d be happy with the food (because you can supplement it if you like, and because some childminders do no food at all & you have to send in, so some hot food on offer sounds great. Dahl is delicious and very nutritious) and OK with the sleep arrangements as long as the CM had contingency plans for children that didn’t settle. I assume there’s only 3 DC there in the daytime max so seems fine to me.

The expressing love thing - your comfort level dictates this but I was always really grateful my CM loved my kids and told them so. It was what I wanted in a CM setting - an extra special person to look after them.

YukoandHiro · 10/09/2021 12:26

Floor mat stuff is normal across settings - when in the baby room my DD did have a sleeping bag though, and they had separate mats, not all on top of each other

Food is lazy. Meeting dietary requirements while offering a varied meal plan is part of the job.

crazyguineapiglady · 10/09/2021 12:25

@Patapouf

The last one is fine, children can't be loved by too many people and a good bond is imperative for a happy and successful childcare placement.

The rest is weird, daal is a pretty lazy meal for all meals tbh. I'd also personally want a little more variance for different developmental stages.

What kind of variance? The OP doesn't mention any developmental stuff does it?

I'm not sure why variations on dahl is lazier than variations on sandwiches which is what a lot of parents and childcarers do every day.

audweb · 10/09/2021 12:23

My childminder told my daughter she loved her. Because she did/does. She helped raise her! She was in her life from 10 months old and stopped being her childminder at 7, but we still see her. I have no issue with childminders expressing affection and love.

The food thing sounds a bit odd, my childminder was fantastic though and just cooked extra family meals to have the next day with the kids.

The routine - normal especially if they have school runs to fit in, it is a group setting after all

The sleeping thing - not so sure, my childminder has another room for them to sleep in but my child was known to fall asleep in the play room on the sofa 😂

Patapouf · 10/09/2021 12:21

The last one is fine, children can't be loved by too many people and a good bond is imperative for a happy and successful childcare placement.

The rest is weird, daal is a pretty lazy meal for all meals tbh. I'd also personally want a little more variance for different developmental stages.

TheWeatherWitch · 10/09/2021 12:18

Sounds like a lazy childminder. I’m sure your child deserves better care.

Blendabrethin · 10/09/2021 12:18

Sounds nuts. Mats on the floor for sleeping (with a blanket) is normal for toddlers but definitely not babies!

Nothing else about this is normal practice.

Comedycook · 10/09/2021 12:11

dhal may seem an odd choice

It's not an odd choice but I wouldn't want my dc eating the same thing, whatever it was, every day

MrsGrif1992 · 10/09/2021 12:07

My childminder tells my kids she loves them, BUT she has been in their life from DS being 9months (he’s now 5) and DD (now 3) from birth. They love her too and I see it as a sign we’ve picked the absolute best person we could’ve
When they were very small they slept in the bouncer chair things but now on the rare occasion any of the kids nap they just go on her sofa (all children in the setting are 2.5years and above so not baby babies and most are transitioning out of afternoon naps, mine certainly have)
Food wise, it’s basic, but it’s what we’d cook at home, spag bol, bangers and mash, chicken curry etc. If a child doesn’t like/want what is offered they’ll be offered a snack, crackers or an apple or whatever but there’s no other meal made and the parent just gets told they’ve had no tea, or that they didn’t have lunch but they’ve had tea or whatever.
Personally I’m happy with that, at home I don’t make 3 different meals and wouldn’t expect anyone else to (especially when I know that my kids DO like it, but kids are ratbags at times)

We dropped on so lucky with ours, she’s the only one in the area rated outstanding by ofsted and we just “clicked” straight away but definitely keep looking until you find one you and your child are happy with

TheWayTheLightFalls · 10/09/2021 12:06

I'd happily eat dhal every day, sounds like the CM for me Grin. Though in all honestly my lone child gets the same home breakfast and pack-up lunch for nursery each day and so do many of her friends, dhal may seem an odd choice but the repetitive menu is less of an issue imo.

The other stuff... it clearly doesn't work for you, that's the important thing, so this isn't the setting for you.

On routine though - you want (I think) a CM who gets out and about with the kids, and that means that any naps do need to happen at the same time for all/most of them, except the ones who are napping on the go.

Iwantamarshmallowman · 10/09/2021 11:56

I saw some really terrible stuff while looking for a childminder how the hell these people get an through offstead ill never know. We visited loads untill we found a really good one. You just have to keep looking.
The I love you thing wouldn't bother me, i heard my kid say i love you to her teacher and the teacher said i love you too. It made me cry and i was happy my daughter felt secure with her.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 10/09/2021 11:55

I wouldn’t expect them to be in cots to as old as 2, but something like 12 -18 months

nomoneytreehere · 10/09/2021 11:50

Awful. My son is 14 months and that would be a no for me. Watch out for the ones that spend all days at soft play with their mates too.

The best childminder I ever had was a young grandma who kept an immaculately tidy house with different stuff out every day on rotation and fed them traditional nursery food. She was amazing.

Comedycook · 10/09/2021 11:48

@Berkeys

Mmm, this has made me want some dahl now, love the stuff! Lentils are fab!
Yes but I imagine it becomes pretty tiresome to eat it every day!
Swipe left for the next trending thread