Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Racism on room advertisements

213 replies

Suetully · 09/09/2021 22:28

I was going through spareroom tonight and some of the ads real 'Asians preferred.' I have some recollection of reading similar ads years ago saying 'Asians only.'

AIBU to think if ads like that read 'whites only' there would be outrage?

OP posts:
HettySunshine · 10/09/2021 07:01

@FortunesFave

YABU. It's similar to a gym deciding to run a women's only session. That's not sexist because women are a minority who have suffered due to male behaviour.

Asians are a minority who have suffered racism. If they want only Asians there are good, cultural reasons for that.

Women are not a minority. They make up 50% of the world's population.
Ytrigging · 10/09/2021 06:59

I think it’s quite common if you’re moving into a shared house. I’ve seen Spareroom ads for Australian / New Zealand houses. I’ve also seen room ads in another language which is presumably to limit the applicants to speakers of that language. We’re talking about trying to make a peaceful, homely arrangement with strangers so I think it makes sense to looks for shared culture.

romdowa · 10/09/2021 06:54

I've never understood why people bother to put any specifications in ads like that. Surely you would just filter through the applications and pick according to what ever criteria you have. I know a girl I went to college with wanted a female only room mate , stated this in her add and she had so many men apply out of pure spite. Some even used fake names 🤣

mrschocolatte · 10/09/2021 06:46

@LegendaryReady

I understand people wanting to live with someone culturally similar, but what if your "culture" is white British? I think it could be uncomfortable to live with people from a very different background, regardless of whether you're a minority.
I’m fascinated by your comment. I’m British and consider myself with British values. But I’m not white. What are White British Values?
garlictwist · 10/09/2021 06:44

My neighbour rents a flat and she says she won't rent to Chinese people because they always move everything around for feng shui reasons. She doesn't state that in the advert though. I think there's all sorts of racial undercurrents when it comes to flatmates and house shares, they are just not usually so overt.

BeenAroundTheWorldAndIII · 10/09/2021 06:38

@Proudboomer

Asia covers a pretty wide area with lots of different religions and cultures so it is a pretty meaningless preference to state Asians preferred.
Yes, a huge area of different beliefs and cultures. Asians are also classed as a lot of Middle Eastern consider themselves Asian too, not always referring to themselves, or being considered Arabs by British nationals
BeenAroundTheWorldAndIII · 10/09/2021 06:33

@UndecidedPoster

They’ve probably experienced lodgers expressing how they struggle with the strong smell of their food, insert other microagression here. Everyone needs to be comfortable in their home. For some, this includes living with someone from the same culture. I don’t see the issue .

What would the white person’s reason for wanting to live with ‘whites only’ be?

Well. You've just completely contradicted yourself 🤦‍♀️🤷🏼‍♀️ so Asians can ask for Asians to share cultural interests (I'm actually confused about the term Asian anyway cos that's inclusive of a huge variety of people from different countries that have numerous cultures and religions, but anyway, that aside), but white people cannot expect to request to share a home with other white people who have a similar culture and/or religion to them? (Or maybe it should read British only so as not to exclude British nationals of colour). Why? So because I am white, so I do not offend, I should share a space, with say, a Muslim who has completely different practices and beliefs to me, but the other way around it's understandable that a Muslim may not want to share a space with me!??? I would have to adapt the way I live significantly to share a space with a Muslim (food considerations, being quiet during prayer time etc). Just for the record I don't want to share a house with anyone, white or otherwise, I'm speaking as an example only! I do get why it's 'deemed' acceptable to advertise this way, but yes, the other way around and there would be uproar.
Sometimeswinning · 10/09/2021 06:10

Have any of you ever thought that this advert may not be designed to exclude white people at all, but actively aimed at the existing tenants making sure that they don't get a black housemate without having to say "no blacks" out loud, which they know would be unacceptable? How would you feel about that?
This is exactly what jumped out at me! People were so desperate to excuse it thinking it only excluded white people.

LegendaryReady · 10/09/2021 06:07

I understand people wanting to live with someone culturally similar, but what if your "culture" is white British? I think it could be uncomfortable to live with people from a very different background, regardless of whether you're a minority.

Islamorada · 10/09/2021 06:06

I had a nightmare with smelly food coming from a neighbour house a few years ago. I moved because it was unbearable but never said anything. Apparently, we are expected to put up with this every time otherwise we are racists.

NoNoThankYou · 10/09/2021 05:40

I have mixed opinions on this but posters saying, "it's not saying 'no blacks, no Irish' so it's not that bad" are making me laugh.

Two groups that are very much being actively excluded by this advert, (with the slight exception of any Irish citizens with Asian heritage)!

Have any of you ever thought that this advert may not be designed to exclude white people at all, but actively aimed at the existing tenants making sure that they don't get a black housemate without having to say "no blacks" out loud, which they know would be unacceptable? How would you feel about that?

Plumtree391 · 10/09/2021 04:31

@Brieeeeeeeeeeee

Because it is reasonable for people from ethnic minorities, who are looking for a houseshare in a country where they will almost definitely have experienced overt racism, to try and protect themselves from further racism.
I certainly understand and have some sympathy with that. However a white person would not be allowed to say, "Whites preferred", in an advert for housing.

Honestly, I don't know what the solution is.

If you are letting a flat, it hardly matters who lives there as long as they have good references and can pay the rent. If, however, you are letting rooms in your house where you live, you could tell any prospective viewers that a few people are coming to look and you intend to let to the first person who likes the place providing they can pay; they can come along at xxx time, and afterwards you'll let them know.

That would apply to weeding out people with whom you don't fancy sharing, regardless of race.

It is difficult though.

FortunesFave · 10/09/2021 04:24

YABU. It's similar to a gym deciding to run a women's only session. That's not sexist because women are a minority who have suffered due to male behaviour.

Asians are a minority who have suffered racism. If they want only Asians there are good, cultural reasons for that.

Kokeshi123 · 10/09/2021 04:23

Some really dippy Pollyannas on this thread. Anyone who thinks that Asian people are incapable of racism is laughably naive. Racism happens everywhere. I LIVE in Asia, and there is plenty of racism here too. Asian-Black tension is also common in a lot of western societies where both are minority groups.

Mummyoflittledragon · 10/09/2021 03:30

This is due to the past as it was common to advertise rooms and include no blacks, no dogs, no Irish.

NiceGerbil · 10/09/2021 02:57

A few years ago there was an investigation into letting agencies.

There were loads who did not consider people who weren't white as possibilities.

Often on instruction from landlord.

They got hidden camera recordings etc.

So there you go.

If there's an issue with racism I don't think that it's a huge issue for white people.

Links to ads please?

When they can just not take whoever if they don't want to then in the ad seems unusual. I've never seen one like that.

MrsTerryPratchett · 10/09/2021 02:28

I think the Venn diagram of people who think reverse racism is a thing and people I wouldn't want to share with were I Asian is close to a circle so no harm done.

@VladmirsPoutine this is for you!

FlowerArranger · 10/09/2021 02:20

I own a flat that I rent out to sharers. If someone leaves they have to find a replacement. Having to share your living accommodation with a stranger isn't easy. I believe they have every right to look for someone who they are likely to get along with. So their adverts may specify their gender/sexual preference and specific interests/hobbies. I have no problem with that.

Siameasy · 10/09/2021 02:10

I too find Asian such a broad term - in the US it implies SE Asia but to me as a Brit my first thought is “Indian”

simitra · 10/09/2021 01:53

If you are (for example) Moslem then it may well be convenient to have others with the same cultural beliefs. That would include not drinking alcohol and celebrating certain festivals.

Hardybloodyhar · 10/09/2021 01:50

@UndecidedPoster

They’ve probably experienced lodgers expressing how they struggle with the strong smell of their food, insert other microagression here. Everyone needs to be comfortable in their home. For some, this includes living with someone from the same culture. I don’t see the issue .

What would the white person’s reason for wanting to live with ‘whites only’ be?

Maybe they don't want flatmates micro-aggressing their greasy bacon sandwiches, backpacking and camping holidays, folksy indy pop music, yoga classes, and general stuff other cultures associated with white people. (I've actually seen items in these list described as microaggressions that white people inflict on other cultures to exclude or belittle them). Whites are not a majority in every city either.
Siepie · 10/09/2021 01:17

@Kitchendrama1

Yes it’s bad and it should be worded in a way … Such as, we practice Islam traditions in our house, so we would prefer you were a practicing Muslim or willing to follow the religious rules in our house.

Please note we feel more comfortable in just a female only household.

If they can say they feel more comfortable in a female only household (i.e. they prefer females), why is it 'bad' to say they prefer Asians?
Lookingoutside · 10/09/2021 00:59

Are you joking?

Kitchendrama1 · 10/09/2021 00:55

@Proudboomer

Asia covers a pretty wide area with lots of different religions and cultures so it is a pretty meaningless preference to state Asians preferred.
In the U.K. we know Asians mean south Asians.
Kitchendrama1 · 10/09/2021 00:53

Yes it’s bad and it should be worded in a way …
Such as, we practice Islam traditions in our house, so we would prefer you were a practicing Muslim or willing to follow the religious rules in our house.

Please note we feel more comfortable in just a female only household.