Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Racism on room advertisements

213 replies

Suetully · 09/09/2021 22:28

I was going through spareroom tonight and some of the ads real 'Asians preferred.' I have some recollection of reading similar ads years ago saying 'Asians only.'

AIBU to think if ads like that read 'whites only' there would be outrage?

OP posts:
AlfonsoTheMango · 10/09/2021 08:17

@mustlovegin

YANBU OP

It's double standards to deem this request acceptable for some groups but not others, surely?

Because there's a double standard.
Mantlemoose · 10/09/2021 08:15

Yes but I think this is where we're told to check our white privilege?

FortunesFave · 10/09/2021 08:09

@mustlovegin

It's similar to a gym deciding to run a women's only session. That's not sexist because women are a minority who have suffered due to male behaviour

I don't understand this logic. So, if your group has been discriminated against you are allowed to express a preference as to who you will share your home with, otherwise, you can't? Standards should be the same for everyone

No they shouldn't. Of course they shouldn't. It's called redressing the imbalance.
takehomepay · 10/09/2021 08:08

@Rubyupbeat

'Asians prefered' is odd in itself, there are different asian cultures, who dislike each other greatly, in fact my friend gets more 'racism' from another asian group than she ever did from white English.
A bit of a generalisation. Most Asian people do not dislike other Asian cultures greatly.
mustlovegin · 10/09/2021 08:06

It's similar to a gym deciding to run a women's only session. That's not sexist because women are a minority who have suffered due to male behaviour

I don't understand this logic. So, if your group has been discriminated against you are allowed to express a preference as to who you will share your home with, otherwise, you can't? Standards should be the same for everyone

Ozanj · 10/09/2021 08:06

with my name. But I managed to get viewings when I pretended to have an english name

Ozanj · 10/09/2021 08:05

White racism is often institutional and hidden. When Estate agents get asked for ‘white people only’ on viewings for high end 1m+ properties in some areas they make it happen by often delaying or ignoring requests from ppl with foreign names (or pretending an offer has already been made). I remember trying to view a house in a swanky white area and I couldn’t even get through the door.

Rubyupbeat · 10/09/2021 08:03

'Asians prefered' is odd in itself, there are different asian cultures, who dislike each other greatly, in fact my friend gets more 'racism' from another asian group than she ever did from white English.

KittenKong · 10/09/2021 07:58

@CaMePlaitPas

Another example of white people desperately wanting to be oppressed.
Asians - so this excludes black, and white people too, also indigenous Americans, Canadians, Australians, etc.

It’s such a wide range too - it’s impossible to tell if they want to share with someone from India, or a Muslim (Sikh, Hindu, Zoroastrian...), or a (religious) vegetarian/halal diet.

If one of my family rocked up and they said ‘nah, wrong Asian’ - would they be ‘allowed’ to be offended?

mrschocolatte · 10/09/2021 07:55

@SerendipityJane

What if a job ad said "Asians prefered" ?
But it wouldn’t though. There is specific legislation that covers recruitment in the UK that legislates against this. There are only exceptional circumstances when you can specify a specific characteristic when recruiting. For example women’s refuges can ask for applicants to be women for pretty obvious reasons. Otherwise what you propose would be against the law.
burnoutbabe · 10/09/2021 07:54

Job adverts are different and can't say that, unless it's required for the role (ie an actor maybe or working in a particular restaurant)

You would be allowed to advertise for female only for a personal career role.

An advert for white tenants only is allowable but of course no one would do that as it invites criticism, they would just interview people and pick someone suitable.

THisbackwithavengeance · 10/09/2021 07:53

YANBU.

Posters desperately trying to argue that it's acceptable for "Asians" to not want to live with "White" people but it would be racist the other way.

All that bollox about curry smells. I love a good curry personally, should they make an exception for me (a non-Asian)???

SerendipityJane · 10/09/2021 07:47

What if a job ad said "Asians prefered" ?

CaMePlaitPas · 10/09/2021 07:44

Another example of white people desperately wanting to be oppressed.

Xtraincome · 10/09/2021 07:36

But 'whites only' is distinctly problematic. We know this.

Say I was in Paris and looking for a room mate I could say 'English speakers preferred though not essential' would open it up to people of all ethnic backgrounds.

'Asians Only' in a house share is not an issue. If it was for a house sale from an estate agent it would be a problem. Context is everything.

mrschocolatte · 10/09/2021 07:33

[quote Lollipop40]@mrschocolatte

For me personally colour wouldn’t be an issue. The important thing would be cultural compatibility.

For example I wouldn’t want to be made to feel bad if I cooked bacon (which I do regularly) and certainly wouldn’t expect people to think it was a micro aggressive behaviour as someone further up alluded to.[/quote]
I’m British Asian and I LOVE bacon! Nothing better than a bacon sarnie in the morning!
Seriously though I think that’s a poor example. Eating bacon is not about cultural compatibility - some people (and this includes white British people too!) don’t eat it because they hate it or their religion forbids it.

RedHelenB · 10/09/2021 07:27

@SukonthaM

Yanbu op. As you can see from the previous posts there are all sorts of reasons why someone would prefer a person of their own ethnicity. And that includes white people. If someone advertised a room for whites only though they’d probably be arrested
They really wouldn't be arrested.
KittenKong · 10/09/2021 07:25

In our house there’s always the ‘which bloody box to I tick?’ when you get one of the ‘what’s your ethnicity’ questions.

‘Asian’ covers a huuuuuuge range of countries, ethnicities, religions and cultures. Ask ten people ‘quick - name one Asian off the top of up your head’ and you will get ten people with nothing in common that would imply that they would make comfortable flat mates.

And as for ‘smell’ - the worst cooking smell I ever lived next to wasn’t Asian. And I’m sure my neighbours love me cooking fish (and I love a food curry - but am not Asian).

takehomepay · 10/09/2021 07:22

@MrMucker

There's a bit of an assumption so far that the ad was placed by somebody Asian because they seek like minded people. In fact we have no idea who posted the ad. I'd say if you stated "Asian preferred" then you are less likely to be Asian yourself, because I don't actually know any Asian person who is happy enough to use the term "Asian" as sufficient to denote someone they'd like to live with. Almost 60% of the world's population is "Asian". It's a blanket term encompassing multiple cultures, climates, religions, languages. It's pretty ignorant therefore to talk of "smells of Asian food" or "Asian thinking" or "Asian lifestyle". But no Asian people do this all the time. So the ad to me looks creepy and superficial, like the tabloid phrase " busty Asian beauty". I would not respond to the ad as an Asian for that reason. And I would absolutely not conclude it had been placed by someone "Asian."
This is a good point. ‘Asian’ is too broad.
Namenic · 10/09/2021 07:17

I’m east Asian. I think it’s racist. People from different ethnic groups can be racist too.

I agree that there may be some vegan or religious or cultural rules (eg shoes off inside, no partners staying over) that people would be following in the house and it would be fine to say that the flatmates would prefer someone who agrees to follow these practices.

MrMucker · 10/09/2021 07:10

Ooops, Non Asian not "no Asian"!

MrMucker · 10/09/2021 07:09

There's a bit of an assumption so far that the ad was placed by somebody Asian because they seek like minded people.
In fact we have no idea who posted the ad. I'd say if you stated "Asian preferred" then you are less likely to be Asian yourself, because I don't actually know any Asian person who is happy enough to use the term "Asian" as sufficient to denote someone they'd like to live with.
Almost 60% of the world's population is "Asian". It's a blanket term encompassing multiple cultures, climates, religions, languages.
It's pretty ignorant therefore to talk of "smells of Asian food" or "Asian thinking" or "Asian lifestyle".
But no Asian people do this all the time.
So the ad to me looks creepy and superficial, like the tabloid phrase " busty Asian beauty".
I would not respond to the ad as an Asian for that reason.
And I would absolutely not conclude it had been placed by someone "Asian."

Lollipop40 · 10/09/2021 07:07

@Ytrigging

I think it’s quite common if you’re moving into a shared house. I’ve seen Spareroom ads for Australian / New Zealand houses. I’ve also seen room ads in another language which is presumably to limit the applicants to speakers of that language. We’re talking about trying to make a peaceful, homely arrangement with strangers so I think it makes sense to looks for shared culture.
I agree with you completely.

How would you word the advert if you were British/English/white though without people calling you out as racist/xenophobic?

People seem to understand it one way but not the other

takehomepay · 10/09/2021 07:05

I think it’s fine. Similarly strict vegetarians (for religious reasons) may wish to live only with other strict vegetarians do they don’t have to smell meat etc. Jewish or Muslim people may prefer to share with Jewish/Muslim people do they don’t have to have pork in the house.

These things are nuanced!

Lollipop40 · 10/09/2021 07:03

@mrschocolatte

For me personally colour wouldn’t be an issue. The important thing would be cultural compatibility.

For example I wouldn’t want to be made to feel bad if I cooked bacon (which I do regularly) and certainly wouldn’t expect people to think it was a micro aggressive behaviour as someone further up alluded to.