Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Racism on room advertisements

213 replies

Suetully · 09/09/2021 22:28

I was going through spareroom tonight and some of the ads real 'Asians preferred.' I have some recollection of reading similar ads years ago saying 'Asians only.'

AIBU to think if ads like that read 'whites only' there would be outrage?

OP posts:
ManifestDestinee · 10/09/2021 10:02

Being correct is not a clever argument? And reveals...what exactly?

Calling women a minority was very silly of you, as was assuming everyone here is in the UK. Don't compound your embarrassment by lashing out.

toconclude · 10/09/2021 09:52

@ManifestDestinee
I'm sure you think that's a clever argument. It's not. It is, however pretty revealing.

Peanutsandchilli · 10/09/2021 09:51

Do they mean Asians preferred or Muslims preferred? I can see, for example, a white Muslim fitting in better with a group of Asian Muslims, and an Asian Christian fitting in better with white Christians. Just saying Asians preferred is a very broad request, but I don't think there's anything wrong with it. I wouldn't necessarily be comfortable living with a group of people from an entirely different culture/religion to me. People are within their rights to feel comfortable in their home.

ManifestDestinee · 10/09/2021 09:50

You didn't mention the UK. And women are not a minority in the UK, so.....

toconclude · 10/09/2021 09:46

@Manifesdestinee
Asians are a minority in the UK as you very well know.

toconclude · 10/09/2021 09:42

@SukonthaM
Of course they wouldn't be arrested, don't be bloody silly. How is it that racists ( and yes, your and OPs comments are racist) always come up with this overegged nonsense?

ManifestDestinee · 10/09/2021 09:37

@FortunesFave

YABU. It's similar to a gym deciding to run a women's only session. That's not sexist because women are a minority who have suffered due to male behaviour.

Asians are a minority who have suffered racism. If they want only Asians there are good, cultural reasons for that.

Neither women nor Asians are a minority. Both, in fact, are the majority.
Comedycook · 10/09/2021 09:24

@mustlovegin

Was I deeply offended and hurt? No

What if it was the only nursery close to you and you had to travel 30 miles for a place because you were rejected there? Would you still have found it acceptable?

It's not acceptable. I'm not saying it was but it didn't hurt me or deeply upset me.
mustlovegin · 10/09/2021 09:22

Was I deeply offended and hurt? No

What if it was the only nursery close to you and you had to travel 30 miles for a place because you were rejected there? Would you still have found it acceptable?

Comedycook · 10/09/2021 09:17

An interesting debate and reminds me of something which happened years ago to me.

I was looking for a nursery for my ds...I'm white but my ds is mixed race. We live in a very diverse area. All the nurseries I viewed had a mix of white, mixed, black, Asian children and the same for the staff...very diverse. One nursery I went to I noticed that every single child was black as was every member of staff. Not a single mixed race child, Asian child or white child. Now, a fully white nursery in my area would have also been very unusual and surprised me. Anyway, the woman was a bit short with me whilst I was looking round and when I asked her if she had space, she said no...now i had asked her previously if there was space when I had phoned her to arrange a visit and she had said she wasn't sure and had been a bit vague. It certainly seemed to me like there was an agenda there. Just as I'd be suspicious there was an agenda if I saw a nursery with an entire white group of children and staff in the area. And before anyone jumps on me, I have zero issue with my child being in a nursery with only black children. It just seemed like it had been engineered as all other nurseries in the area had a very mixed intake. As it stood he went to a different nursery with black, white, Asian, mixed children and the staff were a mix of ethnicities too. It was much more representative of the area we lived in.

Do i believe she denied my child a place based on his ethnicity? Probably
Is that right? No
Was I deeply offended and hurt? No because within the society I live in I experience white privilege so the incident was not set under the backdrop of me already experiencing prejudice and discrimination.

Thehardtruth · 10/09/2021 09:15

I posted some links earlier but they aren't showing. Must have done it wrong. Let's try again.

"Racism is not just a white problem – it’s time we Asians confronted our own prejudices"
www.google.com/amp/s/inews.co.uk/news/long-reads/racism-south-asian-prejudices-black-lives-matter-753885/amp

"China has an irrational fear of a “black invasion” bringing drugs, crime, and interracial marriage"
qz.com/945053/china-has-an-irrational-fear-of-a-black-invasion-bringing-drugs-crime-and-interracial-marriage/amp/
"The ad featured a Asianwoman stuffing a black man into a washing machine to turn him into a pale-skinned Asian man..."

"South Asian anti-black racism: 'We don't marry black people'"
www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/newsbeat-53395935

Mulletsaremisunderstood · 10/09/2021 09:08

mrschocolate

For example women’s refuges can ask for applicants to be women for pretty obvious reasons.

Tell that to the Edinburgh Rape Crisis centre!

Mulletsaremisunderstood · 10/09/2021 09:04

@Doomscrolling

It’s about who you want to share your house with, so it’s totally different from job applications etc.

You can request women only, men only, Aussies and Kiwis preferred, non-smokers only, cat lovers, Muslims only, knitters preferred etc etc.

I agree, surely it’s a bit like dating, people should be allowed to have preferences. If you’re sharing your home with someone you should be able to be picky, just don’t be a dick about it.

When I was looking for accommodation in Canada, many of the ads we’re like dating websites - ‘looking for an open minded, attractive woman’ etc. it was ridiculous!

Thehardtruth · 10/09/2021 08:59

@NoNoThankYou

I have mixed opinions on this but posters saying, "it's not saying 'no blacks, no Irish' so it's not that bad" are making me laugh.

Two groups that are very much being actively excluded by this advert, (with the slight exception of any Irish citizens with Asian heritage)!

Have any of you ever thought that this advert may not be designed to exclude white people at all, but actively aimed at the existing tenants making sure that they don't get a black housemate without having to say "no blacks" out loud, which they know would be unacceptable? How would you feel about that?

Can't believe I posted then saw your post! Just what I said too.

Funny how arguments only come from one side. When you've also faced countless racism from other ethnic minorities in western countries (not even to mention Asian and Eastern European countries), you can also read between the lines and can see things from more than one pov.

mustlovegin · 10/09/2021 08:54

it's about being more vulnerable

But how would you assess vulnerability in the OP's scenario? Those posting the ad could be two 6 foot strong women, very confident, outspoken and bossy. The applicant could be a petite, shy girl with difficulties to assert herself, from a different ethnicity. Would you still consider the former more vulnerable?

Thehardtruth · 10/09/2021 08:54

@Kokeshi123

Some really dippy Pollyannas on this thread. Anyone who thinks that Asian people are incapable of racism is laughably naive. Racism happens everywhere. I LIVE in Asia, and there is plenty of racism here too. Asian-Black tension is also common in a lot of western societies where both are minority groups.
Well good someone said it! People are arguing from a white person's pov, thinking it must only mean "White people stay out" but they could also mean "Black people stay out". What then? Would you still think they're trying to protect themselves?

I know this is rarely talked about openly and is often swept under the rug but there's a lot of racism in Asia, particularly anti-black or anti-dark skin racism and colourism. Mainly in India, China, South Korea, Pakistan, etc. I know a lot about this from both first-hand lived experience and second-hand experience.

Not saying everyone in these countries are racist towards Black people or anyone with dark skin even from their own country (of course not!), but it's a general issue.

www.google.com/amp/s/inews.co.uk/news/long-reads/racism-south-asian-prejudices-black-lives-matter-753885/amp

qz.com/945053/china-has-an-irrational-fear-of-a-black-invasion-bringing-drugs-crime-and-interracial-marriage/amp/
"The ad featured a Asian woman stuffing a black man into a washing machine to turn him into a pale-skinned Asian man...

www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/newsbeat-53395935

Buttons294749 · 10/09/2021 08:50

@Brieeeeeeeeeeee

Because it is reasonable for people from ethnic minorities, who are looking for a houseshare in a country where they will almost definitely have experienced overt racism, to try and protect themselves from further racism.
This
BoredZelda · 10/09/2021 08:49

as a Brit my first thought is “Indian”

Whereas my initial thought is Chinese or Japanese. Not sure the assumption is based on being British, more of your own experiences.

Tal45 · 10/09/2021 08:46

To me it's not about being a minority it's about being more vulnerable. That's why you can have 'women only' because women are more vulnerable, not because they're a minority - it's just that minorities tend to be more vulnerable ie to racist or homophobic abuse.

CatsArePeople · 10/09/2021 08:39

I don't think its racist. But category is way too broad. Asians as in Indian? or Japanese?
Same with whites. White-British or White-Russian?

DarlingFell · 10/09/2021 08:29

It’s not racism 🤷🏻‍♀️

mustlovegin · 10/09/2021 08:26

It's called redressing the imbalance

The Equality Act in the UK applies to everyone. If one group can be selective (and I'm not suggesting I would post an ad like this), so can others

KittenKong · 10/09/2021 08:22

But ‘Asian’ covers such a wide church though doesn’t it?

Doomscrolling · 10/09/2021 08:21

It’s about who you want to share your house with, so it’s totally different from job applications etc.

You can request women only, men only, Aussies and Kiwis preferred, non-smokers only, cat lovers, Muslims only, knitters preferred etc etc.

takehomepay · 10/09/2021 08:20

A lot of the people I know in London have a vetting process in the form of interviews for houseshares. I’d be surprised if there wasn’t an element of racism in that vetting process.