Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Racism on room advertisements

213 replies

Suetully · 09/09/2021 22:28

I was going through spareroom tonight and some of the ads real 'Asians preferred.' I have some recollection of reading similar ads years ago saying 'Asians only.'

AIBU to think if ads like that read 'whites only' there would be outrage?

OP posts:
FleetwoodRaincoat · 10/09/2021 19:24

Sorry but your post reminded me of this classic

Suetully · 10/09/2021 19:18

*They’ve probably experienced lodgers expressing how they struggle with the strong smell of their food, insert other microagression here. Everyone needs to be comfortable in their home. For some, this includes living with someone from the same culture. I don’t see the issue .

What would the white person’s reason for wanting to live with ‘whites only’ be*

I am sure you could think of similar reasons why one would only want to live with white people only or exclude Asians from an advert on the idea that many wouldn't drink booze because of Religion etc. Eitherway that wouldn't fly.

OP posts:
ManifestDestinee · 10/09/2021 18:13

I can see what you mean but at the same time it wouldn't bother me they are looking for someone from the same culture as them presumably. I think in some ways if they are only going to choose an Asian person than it saves non Asians wasting their time! But I don't think you can compare it to white only - you could compare it to more a culture thing like only other Americans can apply. I am speculating that is most likely linked to food and I am guessing if someone advertised for other vegans only that would be OK?

You're doing that thing white people do when you think all Asians have one culture. What do you think a lad from Iran has in common with a young woman from Japan, for example? What food, religion, cultural values do you think they share? Or someone from Pakistan with someone from Thailand? Etc etc.
"Asians" are the majority of people on earth and are many many different and very varied cultures.
Asian only doesn't even really mean anything, its that vast.

georgarina · 10/09/2021 18:11

Doesn't seem like racism to me, it's not a job or anything, it's just people wanting to houseshare with someone from the same culture, maybe who speak the same language, etc.

If it's the case of just wanting to be around them for race reasons then yeah I would think it's racist - hence the difference between 'whites preferred' and 'Canadians/Australians/Polish people preferred'

mustlovegin · 10/09/2021 18:02

It is the same with sexism where positive discrimination for women is not "sexism."

This is difficult. Where's the limit? If there is sufficient positive discrimination, at some point it could become negative discrimination against previously non-discriminated groups?

Also, in an employment context, employers would need to be careful, otherwise it could be challenged in Court under the Equality Act

LaetitiaASD · 10/09/2021 17:48

[quote Lollipop40]@LaetitiaASD

Yes I agree with everything you say, I would be the same and would also want someone who was culturally a “good fit” for me. I wouldn’t care what colour they were but would care that we would both feel comfortable to live our lives the way we chose without being judged by the other.

I suppose I disagree that wanting to share with someone from your own culture is racist. I think it’s understandable for many of the reasons already mentioned.[/quote]
I think that it is perfectly fine to want a good cultural fit, and to believe that the good cultural fit is likely to involve someone from the same culture... but I think that assuming that everyone who is not from your culture will not be a good cultural fit is racist.

Also, sorry, but when I went to view a flat in my student days and the door had "honkeys get out" sprayed on it - that was racist (and us three white students didn't take the flat!!!) I appreciate that structural and societal racism is much worse than individual cases against members of a white majority, but minorities can be racist against their oppressors.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 10/09/2021 17:09

There is a hella lot of hate between minorities. Pps have very good points there. Racism is not just something white people can do. My ME friends could sometimes give EDL good competition... Ao yes, it can very well be aimed at others than "just white people". And whoof at some of the stuff certain EE community sometimes pops out (and these are people who apparently emigrated due to racism...).

It can also very simply be a case of looking for similarly minded and same in culture housemage, with prevalence of locals, I can see why the ad would say that. If I put up advert I will end up (based on demographics) with absolute majority of white British. Nothing wrong with them, but sometimes it's just preferable to have your own group members at home. IYSWIM

womaninatightspot · 10/09/2021 16:53

I think it's fine. Sharing with other people is hard enough when you all have the same expectations. My sharing years have gone by but it's easier if people are upfront about the flatmate they want. Vegan/ female/male/ gay/teetotal/ easygoing/ asian whatever saves wasting time.

Obviously it doesn't always work but I always went for house shares with people who I'd expect to have similar values and expectations to me.

TheChiefJo · 10/09/2021 16:49

I don't see a problem with looking for a housemate who is same/similar background to the current residents, in fact it makes some good sense. That said, the ads specifying 'Asian' are not being specific enough to justify it that way. As one or two other pp have suggested, it looks like anti black racism.

Plumtree391 · 10/09/2021 16:49

@ittakes2

I can see what you mean but at the same time it wouldn't bother me they are looking for someone from the same culture as them presumably. I think in some ways if they are only going to choose an Asian person than it saves non Asians wasting their time! But I don't think you can compare it to white only - you could compare it to more a culture thing like only other Americans can apply. I am speculating that is most likely linked to food and I am guessing if someone advertised for other vegans only that would be OK?
Those are good points, ittakes2.
Lollipop40 · 10/09/2021 16:37

@LaetitiaASD

Yes I agree with everything you say, I would be the same and would also want someone who was culturally a “good fit” for me. I wouldn’t care what colour they were but would care that we would both feel comfortable to live our lives the way we chose without being judged by the other.

I suppose I disagree that wanting to share with someone from your own culture is racist. I think it’s understandable for many of the reasons already mentioned.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 10/09/2021 16:36

Racism" is about institutions and structures of power. It doesn't work that way around because the structures do not favour them. It is the same with sexism where positive discrimination for women is not "sexism."

This.

mrschocolatte · 10/09/2021 16:29

[quote Lollipop40]@mrschocolatte

“that’s a poor example. Eating bacon is not about cultural compatibility - some people (and this includes white British people too!) don’t eat it because they hate it or their religion forbids it.”

Surely that would still be an example of incompatibility for religious reasons though? Does that class as cultural? If I hate fish I wouldn’t mind someone else I live with eating or cooking it for themselves. It’s when people try and dictate how others live based on their own lifestyle/religion etc that could cause tensions I imagine in a shared house. Hence why I mentioned cultural compatibility.[/quote]
You are confusing religion and culture. These are two different things.

My sister in law is a vegetarian and wouldn’t live with a meat eater if you paid her. That has nothing to do with religion or culture - just her personal beliefs and values. I lived in flatshares in London for over 15 years. I lived with a lot of people with different beliefs to me but I just learnt to accept and get on with it. They lived there lives free from judgment from me and vice versa. But when I used to go looking for flat shares you could see the disappointment in their eyes when they saw me. I even had one person say to me - “but you sounded so English on the phone” Er, just because I’m brown don’t mean I’m not English! Personally I don’t agree with adverts that specify but I do get why people might do it to stop wasting other people’s time. But of all the things to be pissed off with in life - this isn’t one of them.

LaetitiaASD · 10/09/2021 16:28

@Lollipop40

Why would that make them racist though *@LaetitiaASD* ?
Surely the entire definition of racism is making decision based on race, when race should be irrelevant?

I do get it's difficult. If I were in a house share again I would certainly want people who were a good fit culturally... I'd guess that my likely housemate would be white... they'd also probably be a bit arty and a bit left wing, and if they were working class they'd be aspirational working class, not defiantly working class. But my guess that they would be white is simply a guess - it is perfectly possible that a black person would be my kinda person and be the perfect housemate - and it would be racist of me to advertise for a white housemate or assume someone is not a good fit because they're not white.

I'd also want someone sensible and rational and not superstitious... which rules out anyone who believes in god in my view, but advertising for atheists isn't acceptable either.

OneTC · 10/09/2021 16:26

It doesn't bother me at all, in the area I live you see it alot on adverts. I'm surprised some people think it's universally innocuous though. Some people just don't want to integrate and whilst I, again, don't really have a problem with it and think it's up to them if they want to or not, I don't think it's the way to a successful multicultural society. I know people who've lived here for decades and barely speak English

Adverts I see containing this are often dual language, so say Tamil and English, I guess the point of putting it in English is they're not being totally exclusive,

Lollipop40 · 10/09/2021 16:17

Why would that make them racist though @LaetitiaASD ?

ittakes2 · 10/09/2021 15:04

I can see what you mean but at the same time it wouldn't bother me they are looking for someone from the same culture as them presumably. I think in some ways if they are only going to choose an Asian person than it saves non Asians wasting their time! But I don't think you can compare it to white only - you could compare it to more a culture thing like only other Americans can apply.
I am speculating that is most likely linked to food and I am guessing if someone advertised for other vegans only that would be OK?

LaetitiaASD · 10/09/2021 14:43

@UndecidedPoster

They’ve probably experienced lodgers expressing how they struggle with the strong smell of their food, insert other microagression here. Everyone needs to be comfortable in their home. For some, this includes living with someone from the same culture. I don’t see the issue .

What would the white person’s reason for wanting to live with ‘whites only’ be?

They were a racist who only wanted to live with "someone from their own culture"?
Ajl46 · 10/09/2021 14:35

[quote Lollipop40]@Ajl46

Not sure how a women only gym class will address that though?!

Surely it’s more to do with feeling less self conscious on exercising or not having men possibly leering at them?[/quote]
Absolutely! The aim of women only classes is presumably so that women feel empowered to attend when they otherwise would not. Men's sport is still sadly far more embedded at grass roots levels but that is changing... gradually....

KittenKong · 10/09/2021 14:30

Well. Having most of my family from/living in the ME I would never have known that. We are talking about people living in the U.K. here are we not.

So apologies if I reacted to a part of what you said that’s was quoted that sounded rather like a generalisation of Asian women being one particular way. But calling me racist?

Doubledoorsontogarden · 10/09/2021 14:26

I’ve house shared and would have no issue with these ad’s. Saves a lot of time wasting, imagine you visit a property, love it but they don’t want you.

Years ago it was Saffers only

LaBellina · 10/09/2021 14:25

But ofcourse you’re going to deny that.
Fine. It’s clear to me what your agenda is and I won’t engage in any further discussion with you. It’s utterly pointless.

LaBellina · 10/09/2021 14:23

Let’s start with what I said @KittenKong.
I said there are cultures in this world, including SOME in Asia where men / women relationships are different and it’s inappropriate to have men staying over (that would include boyfriends or partners from flatmates). If these women feel uncomfortable about that, does that automatically mean that they’re chaste little petals? I didn’t say that, those are your words. Which sound very disrespectful towards women that hold these values.

Also you say ANY Asian woman.
You do realize that Asia is a huge continent and that the culture and values hugely differ per country? That let’s say, Bangladesh is very different from Japan in terms of culture?

You sound very racist.
But

KittenKong · 10/09/2021 14:15

Not being goady - how else could it be interpreted?

tryrantosaurus · 10/09/2021 14:03

I'd understand if it was "Muslim preferred" for a lodger In their home (they want someone familiar/who shares their culture), but just putting "Asian" makes me feel uncomfortable.

Not all Asians are the same, so it's not a cultural reason, in that case.