Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Racism on room advertisements

213 replies

Suetully · 09/09/2021 22:28

I was going through spareroom tonight and some of the ads real 'Asians preferred.' I have some recollection of reading similar ads years ago saying 'Asians only.'

AIBU to think if ads like that read 'whites only' there would be outrage?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
IslingtonGreen · 04/10/2021 08:39

The link at roomlets.rentals says "It’s always illegal to discriminate on the grounds of race. There is no exception".

The small premises exemptions can apply to other aspects of the Equality Act, but not race.

AlfonsoTheMango · 13/09/2021 14:47

I like your style, @Masterbeth, and wish you all the best.

MasterBeth · 13/09/2021 12:14

@AlfonsoTheMango

Nope. *@MasterBeth*, the link you provide states the following:

"Do the Equality Act Rules Always Apply?

The Act exempts many room rentals and flatshares from the rules. These are known as ‘small premises exceptions‘ and apply where each of the following is true:

  1. The advertiser, or a close member of their family (such as a spouse, partner, parent, grandparent, child, grandchild or sibling) lives in the same property.
  2. They share facilities such as a kitchen, bathroom or living room with the tenant.
  3. In addition to the advertiser and their household, the property cannot accommodate more than two other households, or six individual tenants or lodgers."

So, yes. It is legal and non-discriminatory to state a preference.

The Equality Act applies to landlords, not to people taking in lodgers. Lodgers do not have the same rights as tenants.

You’re right.
ManifestDestinee · 13/09/2021 11:35

There is a difference between discriminating and discriminatory.

BreadPita · 13/09/2021 11:15

@TurnTowardsTheSun
Using your own logic, most men have not been convicted of a violent crime, so you're discriminating based oon a minority of the group.
By definition, the perpetrator of a racist crime is much more likely to be of a different race to you.

Keroppi · 13/09/2021 08:31

Typo galore!

Keroppi · 13/09/2021 08:25

@AlfonsoTheMango

m.spareroom.co.uk/content/default/discrimination/

Since OP was specifically talling about lodger situation/spare room adverts etc.

I also skimmes through here too but not proeprly, so didnt quote, but is relevant

assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/376789/Code_of_Practice_for_Landlords__web_.pdf

Bumblenums1234 · 13/09/2021 07:34

No issue with people from ethic minorities doing this and wanting to live with others who have a shared experience. Just like I would only respond to an advert for a female only house.

AlfonsoTheMango · 13/09/2021 07:15

@Keroppi

"What if I live in the property?

If you live in the property you’re advertising a room in then the law is slightly more flexible. You’re allowed to have a preference, but still not when it comes to race.

In practice this applies to current flatmates and homeowners renting out a room to a lodger. If you’re advertising your room because you’re moving out you can’t discriminate, as you won’t be living there any more. If your flatmates have a preference they’ll need to post the ad themselves.

It’s always illegal to discriminate based on race when you’re letting a room or property, regardless of whether you live there or not. "

As an aside I hate how the UK has decided Asian means just south asian pakistani muslims. So vague.

Where does this quote come from, please?
GreyhoundG1rl · 13/09/2021 01:59

Yes, it does. And far from "you have NO control over who you offer a room in your home to, to discriminate on the basis of your personal preference is illegal".

Keroppi · 13/09/2021 01:56

"SpareRoom’s policy

It’s not just a case of what is and isn’t legal – it’s about treating people as you’d want them to treat you. We’d always prefer you stated the race, gender, sexual orientation (and so on) of the people living in the property, rather than be specific about who you’re looking for.

If you are expressing a preference in your ad, please give an explanation. If, for example, your ad says ‘No men’ or ‘Muslims only’ we’ll remove that bit of the ad. If it says ‘We prefer a female flatmate as all the other flatmates are female’ or ‘This is a Halal household so we’d prefer a Muslim’ that’s fine as you’ve offered an explanation for your preference.

We’d always prefer it if you take people on the basis of who they are, rather than which ‘boxes’ they tick. "

Seems reasonable.

Keroppi · 13/09/2021 01:54

"What if I live in the property?

If you live in the property you’re advertising a room in then the law is slightly more flexible. You’re allowed to have a preference, but still not when it comes to race.

In practice this applies to current flatmates and homeowners renting out a room to a lodger. If you’re advertising your room because you’re moving out you can’t discriminate, as you won’t be living there any more. If your flatmates have a preference they’ll need to post the ad themselves.

It’s always illegal to discriminate based on race when you’re letting a room or property, regardless of whether you live there or not. "

As an aside I hate how the UK has decided Asian means just south asian pakistani muslims. So vague.

TurnTowardsTheSun · 13/09/2021 01:46

@Kitchendrama1

Yes it’s bad and it should be worded in a way … Such as, we practice Islam traditions in our house, so we would prefer you were a practicing Muslim or willing to follow the religious rules in our house.

Please note we feel more comfortable in just a female only household.

Also discriminatory!
TurnTowardsTheSun · 13/09/2021 01:43

@ElvisPresleyHadABaby

Posters saying YANBU, how would you feel if I said an advert saying "female preferred" or "female only" was unfair? Think what your response would be, why you might prefer female company and then answer. Sex segregated facilities etc.
That's a safety issue, are you saying different races of people are more or less dangerous? We know 97% of violent crime is commited by men so it's fact driven that a woman wouldn't like to live with a strange man. Is there any evidence of an Asian/ White/ Black/ any other ethnicity household member (of any sex, so we can isolate the two factors) being more dangerous to live with as a housemate?

If so, please share the studies.

GreyhoundG1rl · 13/09/2021 01:40

It's not illegal when it's a room in your own home. I thought we'd established that.

NiceGerbil · 13/09/2021 01:40

'Hmmmmmph

Would an advertisement for a spare room ‘Men only’ be sexist?'

House share? Useful info. If not given they will just not give room to a woman. If she did get it then I can't imagine it will be much fun for her!

Men who only want to share with men is a pretty important piece of info.

Illegal to say it out loud.

The issue with racism is way more an issue for black people>>> see previous posts.

TurnTowardsTheSun · 13/09/2021 01:38

@Slippy78

The advert doesn't say 'Asians only' though does it. It says 'Asians preferred'. Nothing wrong with that at all.
Except that it's illegal...
TurnTowardsTheSun · 13/09/2021 01:38

@Antinerak

Asians preferred likely means someone is looking to avoid racism

It is not equal to whites preferred as white people don't need to avoid racism unless its their own.

Lol, you don't avoid racism by being a racist. Confused
TurnTowardsTheSun · 13/09/2021 01:35

@BrendaBubbles

"Racism" is about institutions and structures of power. It doesn't work that way around because the structures do not favour them. It is the same with sexism where positive discrimination for women is not "sexism."
Not sure what you are quoting but the UK law relevant here is The Equality Act (2010). Race and sex are among the protected characteristics and they are protected for all people. Women suffer far more sexism but yes, men can be subject to sexist discrimination and the law protects them from that also, as it should. Ethnic minorities suffer more racism but the protected characteristic in law is "race" so discrimination against anyone based on their race - minority or not - is also illegal.
TurnTowardsTheSun · 13/09/2021 01:32

@Hmmmmmph

Would an advertisement for a spare room ‘Men only’ be sexist?
Yes
TurnTowardsTheSun · 13/09/2021 01:32

@Comedycook

Is it even legal?
No
TheQueenOfDreams · 12/09/2021 20:27

There would be no uproar if someone advertised as ‘Scot preferred’ or ‘German/Aussie/Irish/Liverpudlian preferred’
Technically, they’re not saying White only, but could do it that way.
And it would be totally understandable.

PumpkinsGalore · 12/09/2021 19:55

@MissyMooKins

Yabu that's not racist. I'm neither asain or white and wouldn't be offended by that. I actually understand that. They want someone from their culture theres nothing wrong with that.
But there would be something very wrong if a white person only wanted someone from their own culture?!? Of course! There would be absolute UPROAR
ManifestDestinee · 12/09/2021 11:45

Yes....www.roomlets.rentals/info/avoiding-discrimination-letting-room

Didn't read your own link there, did you?

Empressofthemundane · 12/09/2021 11:25

I would agree that people in flat shares /renting a room out of their own home should have some control over what is in effect their personal lives.

And this should extend to everyone. No special cases, no special pleading.

If we want to live in a harmonious, free society, rules and responsibilities need to be universal and reciprocal.

Otherwise, we will spend all our time arguing over who is more deserving, vulnerable, special, etc. As groups vie against each other for advantage.

Enlightenment thinkers figured this out hundreds of years ago.