Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU She/Her

258 replies

beewritesx · 09/09/2021 11:19

My sister is a big advocate of trans rights and says that pronouns in bio is a way of showing inclusion and support of the trans community.

I was quite surprised to receive a professional email from my ex boss with She/Her listed next to her email address (as I know this person and their gender).

I believe people should have the right to identify as they choose. If somebody asked me to call them X, I will as it's respectful. I also believe that if somebody is aged over 18 and decides to transition or change their gender identity they should do so with no persecution whatsoever.

However, pronouns in bio is just something I don't understand and cannot get on board with. If I'm ever in a professional position it's not something I would want to consider. I can't explain why. I just don't.

AIBU or too "traditional" (like my younger sister would probably argue) or does anyone feel the same? I can't give a rational explanation as to why I wouldn't, I just don't want to.

OP posts:
FourteenSixteenTwentyTwo · 09/09/2021 13:34

I saw an interesting video from Blaire White before who strongly disagrees with gender identity. Her view is that why would she go through all that time and money and then need to keep telling people she’s a ‘she’. As a trans woman she wants to be recognised as a ‘woman’ at first glance and would find it humiliating is she was constantly mistaken and asked.

The only people this serves are those who don’t fully ‘present’ as their identity.

Bumblenums1234 · 09/09/2021 13:33

I don't use pronouns professionally. People can use my name and unused theirs. It makes no difference to my work what my gender identity is.

Beowulfa · 09/09/2021 13:29

[quote timeisnotaline]**@Beowulfa* I only ever look at email signatures for contact details (I regularly have to get items couriered and it's surprisingly hard to find full, correct postal addresses listed).*
Well then it can hardly bother you can it if you don’t even read it?[/quote]
The point of an email signature is for concise, useful information in a professional context. Pronouns but no full contact details marks someone out as not a deep thinker; I have already classed two new colleagues as such.

IsadoraQuagmire · 09/09/2021 13:25

@Nancydrawn

People used to do it all the time with email signatures that said Ms. Evelyn Smith or Mr. Evelyn Smith. Does that make you uncomfortable?
That's different. If you're writing a formal email or letter, you'd want to know how to address the recipient. You don't address anyone by their pronouns.
Coldilox · 09/09/2021 13:25

If you don’t want to put your pronouns in your signature, don’t.

Why does it bother you if other people do?

timeisnotaline · 09/09/2021 13:23

@Beowulfa I only ever look at email signatures for contact details (I regularly have to get items couriered and it's surprisingly hard to find full, correct postal addresses listed).
Well then it can hardly bother you can it if you don’t even read it?

Beowulfa · 09/09/2021 13:22

Aside from the ideology issues, it's just unecessary in professional communication. We already have a method in the English language of referring to a person when their sex is unknown or irrelevant.

When addressing a person your options are name or the pronoun "you". "Dear Dr Singh, please could I check whether HR have sent you your new employment contract?"

When referring to a person in their absence the use of "they/their" is polite and correct in English. "There seems to be a delay with Dr Singh's new contract; please could you check their status in the HR system?"

I only ever look at email signatures for contact details (I regularly have to get items couriered and it's surprisingly hard to find full, correct postal addresses listed).

timeisnotaline · 09/09/2021 13:22

@Breakfastofmilk

Presumably you also know your boss's surname, phone number and postal address but I doubt you would come on here complaining that she'd sent you an email with a standard automatic signature including that information.

It's information. Since you don't need the information you can ignore it. If she sends an email to someone who doesn't know her in person they now know what pronouns she prefers. And as your sister has explained to you, if she sends that email to someone who is trans and wondering who in the office might be supportive of them if they were to find out, now they know that too.

Why do you have a problem with her giving simple information?

This. My boss knows my name and my office address, same as his, and my phone number. I don’t edit it out of my signature every time I’m emailing him. You must know this so all this ‘I know their gender’ is a bit manufactured isn’t it? I don’t put pronouns into mine but I’m hardly going to get upset if someone else does.
wednesdayweather · 09/09/2021 13:17

This is important though. Many of us objecting take issue with the very idea of "performing our gender". I am not performing female. I am a female, due to biology, which is immutable. Everything else is personality. Or regressive stereotypes. Which I won't be supporting

This!

ElliottSmithsfingers · 09/09/2021 13:17

I think it's virtue signalling bollocks, either from people who have drunk the trans kool-aid or from those who have not thought through the full insidiousness of the trans agenda, particularly for women. In either case, it makes it easier to identify people that are best avoided.

MatildaIThink · 09/09/2021 13:17

I think the whole pronouns thing is a load of rubbish. My first name is Matilda, it often gets shortened to Matt (my dad did not like it spelled as Mat as he said that is something you wipe your feet on), I also have a PhD so I am often Dr Matt X. People make a mistake sometimes, presume I will be a man etc. but it is obvious when meeting me in person or hearing me speak I am a woman, however I have never been offended when someone has thought I would be a man.

VerveClique · 09/09/2021 13:15

There's actually been a socially-acceptable solution to this for years.

If someone wants to ensure people are aware of their sex (or gender identity? IDK - for something so fluid how can is possibly be captured in a couple of words... but I digress...

It's:

Alex Smith (Mr); or
Alex Smith (Ms)

I can't be doing with this at all. 'They' is just ridiculous. I know it's pedantic but I feel that it's someone wanting to identify as a team. So I always picture Sam Smith for example as a team of tiny Sam Smiths every time they are mentioned on the radio.

In any case, I'm sure it doesn't really address any real marginalisation or discrimination that is out there. It just ties people in up in knots.

Okbye · 09/09/2021 13:15

I've had the same experience - received an email (in a professional sense) with she/her in the signature.

To be honest, I couldn't have cared less if the person was a man, woman or a bloody giraffe as long as they do their job! It's a bit 'bandwagony' and unnecessary in my opinion 🤷‍♀️

wednesdayweather · 09/09/2021 13:15

@BrimfulOfBaba

I believe people should have the right to identify as they choose. If somebody asked me to call them X, I will as it's respectful.

The pronouns in the bio are both a way of letting people know what they prefer to be called, and also a show of solidarity from people who aren't trans, to make it feel more normal IMO. Otherwise putting your pronouns only if you were trans would be a massive "Hey, I'm trans!" signal which some may not always want to announce.

Yes, but women may not want to shout ' Hey I'm a woman!' . In nearly all professional contexts being a woman is irrelevant. It shouldn't be need to be announced, and there is evidence that drawing attention to yourself as a woman can disadvantage women.

I don't really see how it is an act of solidarity. If someone is trans and they have chosen a male or female name, everyone will read that in the email and use the appropriate pronoun for that sex.

If they have chosen a name which does not indicate sex then they may wish to say what sex they want to be referred to, but tbh, in all the years I have worked with people with names used by both sexes they have never felt the need to do this. If you get it wrong they may say, actually I'm a man/woman, and you say, 'oh ok' and that's all that happened.

As for not wanting to come out as trans, well if you 'pass' you don't need to. If you don't, you can use a name for the sex you wish to live as (for emails) and people will use that pronoun, or in real life if you don't pass, telling people your pronouns won't stop you being identified as trans.

I don't think this really is about making it easier for trans people. No-one has to declare they are not dyslexic/ have ASD etc to make it easier for people who are to declare. Its really about enforcing submission to this particular, and controversial, social trend.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 09/09/2021 13:14

@Whatwouldscullydo

Adding pronouns should be a personal choice, not a fad

I think tbh it blurs the boundaries. I dobt get this " bring your whole self to work thing" work is work. You are there to work. You have friends and family and free time for the rest. Private lives should not get in the way of work. Work colleagues don't exist to validate identities or pick our your wedding invitations or listen to your domestic problems etc

I agree. Years ago when doing diversity training for a new job, we were told that it was important that gay and lesbian people could talk about their weekends and same sex partners.

I remember thinking at the time that I wasn't interested in other people having more exciting weekends than I was, regardless of what sex they were sleeping with, churlish person that I am.

WomanStanleyWoman · 09/09/2021 13:12

Done. To. DEATH.

RealBecca · 09/09/2021 13:11

And by "qualify" i mean im still working out my feelings. I think i am but im confused.

Wrongsideofhistorymyarse · 09/09/2021 13:10

Many of us objecting take issue with the very idea of "performing our gender". I am not performing female. I am a female, due to biology, which is immutable. Everything else is personality. Or regressive stereotypes. Which I won't be supporting.

RealBecca · 09/09/2021 13:10

I dont know how I feel about it. I worry that if everyone did it then it could push someone into deciding what they want to use before they are ready.

As an alternative example, im not sure if i qualify as bisexual so i would hate to have to decide whether to use the term publicly. But if other people declared themselves id feel unnecessary stress, particularly if all allies were using "heterosexual".

So i guess i support it but worry about whether it makes all trans people feel included or actually stresses some out.

BingoLingFucker · 09/09/2021 13:09

I’m sure I’ve read several accounts of women being taken far more seriously in email communication when their sex is unknown (eg using initials rather than their name, in one case a woman used a male colleague’s email address then continued because she was taken seriously when the recipient assumed she was male).
Apart from the obvious compelled speech arguments, there’s also the issue that men and women in the workplace tend to be treated differently, and this will surely exacerbate it.

Cuddlyrottweiler · 09/09/2021 13:09

I don't think it should be forced, some people haven't yet decided/realised? Who they are and it forces people who aren't ready to made a declaration.

But if someone wants to do it then I don't care and will follow their requests. I don't feel the need, but I also don't care if people call me anything, people regularly get my name wrong never mind he/she, it's just not something I personally care about. I don't really consider my gender as part of my identity.

BreatheAndFocus · 09/09/2021 13:06

The way I see it, it costs me nothing to put my pronouns in an email, and it helps a vulnerable group in society to be accepted

I don’t think it helps trans people be accepted. It’s facile to think it would IMO, any more than putting your skin colour would stop racism. I know two trans people and neither of them feel the need to put their pronouns on letters. The older one finds it embarrassing, and, I think a reminder of things they’d rather forget, and the younger one just laughs at it. The only time I’ve seen pronouns are from people who are not trans.

If those people want to do it, they can, of course, but I think the idea that you must, or that doing so is automatically helping trans people, is wrong, and frankly quite patronising.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 09/09/2021 13:06

If you want to refer to them when communicating to a third party it might be relevant

to whom? I don't know if people are talking about me behind my back, although I would assume in most cases they would still use my name.

If I’m emailing an Alex or a Chris is makes no difference to me at all whether they’re a man or a woman. Why would I care

I don't, but it's obvious that people still, unfortunately, treat men differently to women, so a female Alex might actually not mind being taken for a man, as she may get more respect and her instructions may be followed more expeditiously than if people know she is female. Sad but still true.

Alconleigh · 09/09/2021 13:02

@HerrenaHarridan

So don’t then add your pronouns to your email Rabbit. It’s not even hard to not do something you already aren’t doing.

Continue performing your gender in more physical ways so people can guess it without asking

In the mean time as the rest of the world is starting to find it useful (for example in international companies which has sod all to do with the mn anti trans rhetoric) so people are going to continue doing it and you’ll just have to work it through like all the homophobes had to do about gay marriage.

This is important though. Many of us objecting take issue with the very idea of "performing our gender". I am not performing female. I am a female, due to biology, which is immutable. Everything else is personality. Or regressive stereotypes. Which I won't be supporting.
Wrongsideofhistorymyarse · 09/09/2021 13:02

We should be normalising getting on with work.

Oh yes to this! I don't want to bring my whole self to work. I'm an adult and professional and enjoy what I do.