Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU She/Her

258 replies

beewritesx · 09/09/2021 11:19

My sister is a big advocate of trans rights and says that pronouns in bio is a way of showing inclusion and support of the trans community.

I was quite surprised to receive a professional email from my ex boss with She/Her listed next to her email address (as I know this person and their gender).

I believe people should have the right to identify as they choose. If somebody asked me to call them X, I will as it's respectful. I also believe that if somebody is aged over 18 and decides to transition or change their gender identity they should do so with no persecution whatsoever.

However, pronouns in bio is just something I don't understand and cannot get on board with. If I'm ever in a professional position it's not something I would want to consider. I can't explain why. I just don't.

AIBU or too "traditional" (like my younger sister would probably argue) or does anyone feel the same? I can't give a rational explanation as to why I wouldn't, I just don't want to.

OP posts:
Libraryghost · 09/09/2021 16:40

I just won’t play this game. The one that gets me is they/them. It’s ridiculous. I am just ignoring it.

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 16:39

@Whatwouldscullydo

Again what do you mean?

I am not obligated to validate anyones identity. If it doesn't work of no ne else pays attention or goes along with it then that's not people not including people that's just the nature if what you want validating. Something you can't define or visibly see. I will be civil and polite as I would with anyone but tahts as far as anyones obligation goes

And if they asked to be called ‘he’ as a biological female?
HipTightOnions · 09/09/2021 16:38

“Preferred pronouns” are such a mealy-mouthed proxy.

If Mary (a woman, female, for the sake of clarity) signs off with “she/her” she is saying “I believe in gender identity and I’m not trans”.

If Alex (male) signs off with “she/her” he is telling us “I believe in gender identity, I’m trans and I expect you to treat me as a woman, at least in your speech, and probably in other ways as yet unspecified”.

Mary would presumably be fine with this but not everyone will be.

Whatwouldscullydo · 09/09/2021 16:36

Again what do you mean?

I am not obligated to validate anyones identity. If it doesn't work of no ne else pays attention or goes along with it then that's not people not including people that's just the nature if what you want validating. Something you can't define or visibly see. I will be civil and polite as I would with anyone but tahts as far as anyones obligation goes

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 16:35

@DrSbaitso

That I can’t know if Anna wants to be called something different.

But in your example, she doesn't want to be called something different. She isn't ready to be called "he". I wondered at first if you'd mistyped, but you confirmed it as "your point" when I said "she still wants to be called "she", so there's nothing for you to know".

So if Anna intends to remain she, at least for the time being...what information are you missing?

I’m not missing any. I still don’t know what you’re getting at? There is nothing for me to know if she doesn’t do anything towards being ‘he’, I can’t know anything different. I don’t understand why you’re labouring this point?

Where’s your line?

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 16:33

@Whatwouldscullydo

I dont understand what you mean?

Compelled speech is not anyones right trans or otherwise.

There are 8 other protected characteristics which have to be given equal consideration.

I mean; where will you allow trans women to be recognised as trans women? If not their pronouns?
DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 16:33

That I can’t know if Anna wants to be called something different.

But in your example, she doesn't want to be called something different. She isn't ready to be called "he". I wondered at first if you'd mistyped, but you confirmed it as "your point" when I said "she still wants to be called "she", so there's nothing for you to know".

So if Anna intends to remain she, at least for the time being...what information are you missing?

Whatwouldscullydo · 09/09/2021 16:32

I dont understand what you mean?

Compelled speech is not anyones right trans or otherwise.

There are 8 other protected characteristics which have to be given equal consideration.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 09/09/2021 16:30

@DoubleEx

Just put your pronouns down as male and then wait for the pay rise…
Grin
Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 16:30

@Whatwouldscullydo

Define trans inclusion?

I mean they should be employed and treated like everyone else surely? You can't be fired for being trans.

Where are you happy with trans women being included with women, or trans men with men, if not pronouns?
Cuddlypinkcat · 09/09/2021 16:29

I think using pronouns in emails makes inclusive people feel all virtuous.
Can't see how it helps anyone otherwise.

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 16:29

@DrSbaitso

I don’t understand - I can’t know if Anna wants to be called ‘he’ unless she tells me, was my point. And she might not feel comfortable to tell me face to face.

Ok, this started off because you said: "But that’s exactly my point - if Anna isn’t ready to be called ‘he’ and says nothing, I can’t know."

I asked: if Anna isn't ready to be called "he", and is therefore still "she", what is it that you need to know?

Your response has been "that's my point", several times.

What exactly is this point?

That I can’t know if Anna wants to be called something different. So therefore I’d assume she was ‘she’ unless she said otherwise.

Where’s your line with regard to trans inclusion?

Whatwouldscullydo · 09/09/2021 16:23

Define trans inclusion?

I mean they should be employed and treated like everyone else surely? You can't be fired for being trans.

DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 16:23

I don’t understand - I can’t know if Anna wants to be called ‘he’ unless she tells me, was my point. And she might not feel comfortable to tell me face to face.

Ok, this started off because you said: "But that’s exactly my point - if Anna isn’t ready to be called ‘he’ and says nothing, I can’t know."

I asked: if Anna isn't ready to be called "he", and is therefore still "she", what is it that you need to know?

Your response has been "that's my point", several times.

What exactly is this point?

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 16:18

@DrSbaitso

Yes, that’s my point.

What point? If she's still going by female pronouns, there's nothing to communicate. What do you need to know if Anna is still a she?

And changing your name is a bigger step than still being Anna, but asking to be called he or they. It’s more obvious.

Really? I'd have thought announcing a name change was quite a lot easier and more diplomatic than having to actually come out and say "I am still Anna but now call me "he"." Also less chance of people missing it because they don't scrutinise your email sig to see if the person called Anna is now He-Ann.

I don’t understand - I can’t know if Anna wants to be called ‘he’ unless she tells me, was my point. And she might not feel comfortable to tell me face to face. And she might not feel ready to change her name. She might feel able to ask to be called ‘he’ or ‘they’, she might not.

But all of this is very what-if, and it’s becoming a bit circular. If you’re not happy with pronouns, what are you happy with in regards to trans inclusion?

BrendaBubbles · 09/09/2021 16:15

My personal pronouns are I/me and myself, as are everyone’s.

Whatwouldscullydo · 09/09/2021 16:11

Probably showing some ignorance here - how common is it for someone with a name associated with a specific gender to have the opposite pronoun?

Look up pip/Philip bunce. You'd have to check.emails daily to know which one they are that day

DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 16:09

Yes, that’s my point.

What point? If she's still going by female pronouns, there's nothing to communicate. What do you need to know if Anna is still a she?

And changing your name is a bigger step than still being Anna, but asking to be called he or they. It’s more obvious.

Really? I'd have thought announcing a name change was quite a lot easier and more diplomatic than having to actually come out and say "I am still Anna but now call me "he"." Also less chance of people missing it because they don't scrutinise your email sig to see if the person called Anna is now He-Ann.

CiaoForNiao · 09/09/2021 15:48

@QueenFreesia2021

Surely that depends on the work place ? It can be very relevant in care work for example. Or working in a DV shelter

This is even trickier again - so a trans women could secure a job working in the care sector caring for women? Or in a DV refuge for example.

Look up the CEO of the Edinburgh rape crisis Centre.
QueenFreesia2021 · 09/09/2021 15:45

Probably showing some ignorance here - how common is it for someone with a name associated with a specific gender to have the opposite pronoun?

So if someone was called Sophie - how likely are they want to be called “he”?

QueenFreesia2021 · 09/09/2021 15:42

Surely that depends on the work place ? It can be very relevant in care work for example. Or working in a DV shelter

This is even trickier again - so a trans women could secure a job working in the care sector caring for women? Or in a DV refuge for example.

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 15:41

@DrSbaitso

But that’s exactly my point - if Anna isn’t ready to be called ‘he’ and says nothing, I can’t know.

At that point, she still wants to be called "she", so there's nothing for you to know.

But if she’s ready and changes her pronouns on her email signature then she doesn’t have to tell anyone face to face. It’s an easy first step.

How is it any easier, and less obtrusive, than merely changing her name in her email to Adam? Do you read to the end of every email sig to see if someone has announced a change of pronoun?

At that point, she still wants to be called "she", so there's nothing for you to know.

Yes, that’s my point.

And changing your name is a bigger step than still being Anna, but asking to be called he or they. It’s more obvious.

DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 15:28

But that’s exactly my point - if Anna isn’t ready to be called ‘he’ and says nothing, I can’t know.

At that point, she still wants to be called "she", so there's nothing for you to know.

But if she’s ready and changes her pronouns on her email signature then she doesn’t have to tell anyone face to face. It’s an easy first step.

How is it any easier, and less obtrusive, than merely changing her name in her email to Adam? Do you read to the end of every email sig to see if someone has announced a change of pronoun?

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 15:25

@DrSbaitso

But ‘you’ is a pronoun. And you’d also say, in front of them ‘oh bill! I’m just saying to Anna about the document and she’s sent it!’ If Anna was in front of you.

Yes but as before, "you" isn't gendered in English, which is why it doesn't matter.

But what if Anna preferred to be "he" and wasn't ready to tell you that? If she is still using the name Anna, is it unfair to assume she's female gendered?

When she comes in one day and introduces herself as Adam, surely you could take the hint?

But that’s exactly my point - if Anna isn’t ready to be called ‘he’ and says nothing, I can’t know. But if she’s ready and changes her pronouns on her email signature then she doesn’t have to tell anyone face to face. It’s an easy first step.
DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 15:16

But ‘you’ is a pronoun. And you’d also say, in front of them ‘oh bill! I’m just saying to Anna about the document and she’s sent it!’ If Anna was in front of you.

Yes but as before, "you" isn't gendered in English, which is why it doesn't matter.

But what if Anna preferred to be "he" and wasn't ready to tell you that? If she is still using the name Anna, is it unfair to assume she's female gendered?

When she comes in one day and introduces herself as Adam, surely you could take the hint?