Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU She/Her

258 replies

beewritesx · 09/09/2021 11:19

My sister is a big advocate of trans rights and says that pronouns in bio is a way of showing inclusion and support of the trans community.

I was quite surprised to receive a professional email from my ex boss with She/Her listed next to her email address (as I know this person and their gender).

I believe people should have the right to identify as they choose. If somebody asked me to call them X, I will as it's respectful. I also believe that if somebody is aged over 18 and decides to transition or change their gender identity they should do so with no persecution whatsoever.

However, pronouns in bio is just something I don't understand and cannot get on board with. If I'm ever in a professional position it's not something I would want to consider. I can't explain why. I just don't.

AIBU or too "traditional" (like my younger sister would probably argue) or does anyone feel the same? I can't give a rational explanation as to why I wouldn't, I just don't want to.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 18:42

Bold of you to complain of others ‘obsessively interrogating’ when you asked me the same question about a fake scenario for several posts.

I was trying to work out what the frig you were actually saying, because it continued to make no sense even after I attempted to clarify. Anna is a she and doesn't want to be a he, so how will I know she's a she. Absolutely nonsensical. I actually wondered if you were on a wind up!

NigellaSeed · 09/09/2021 18:30

I'm on the fence. I don't see the need to know people's identity in an email so it wouldn't come naturally to me to do it, but it doesn't bother me when people do it. If I later learn that people who are non binory etc would prefer I did it, then I would not hesitate. But I can't tell if they are actually asking for it or if it's a CIS concocted idea.

(Sorry if CIS offends - I mean no harm to anyone)

SeaShoreGalore · 09/09/2021 18:26

The way I see it, it costs me nothing to put my pronouns in an email

It costs you the respect of many people around you. Most of whom wouldn't dream of saying anything to you face.

RichPetunia · 09/09/2021 18:18

I work in an office where it’s gaining popularity to put she/her and he/him on emails. Luckily it’s voluntary. I won’t be doing it, namely because the whole thing is a load of bollocks.

TheRebelle · 09/09/2021 18:16

Either someone is male/female and uses a name appropriate to their gender so you get it “right” because it’s bleedin’ obvious or they make efforts to appear as the opposite gender by using an opposite gendered name, clothing, hairstyle and whatever else and you can take an educated guess they’d like to be referred to as opposite gender pronouns and ask them or they make no effort at all therefore deserve no such courtesy.

Blibbyblobby · 09/09/2021 18:12

A better comparison is if your colleague’s name was Catherine and they preferred to be called Cat. Might be a bit annoying for you to get used to but surely you wouldn’t mind?

That's not a valid comparison. A closer comparison is if someone decides to use my job title on emails instead of their own because they just feel my job title suits them better.

And then pushes to have some pretty major parts of the job removed from the job description because they will never be able to do them and that makes them uncomfortable in the new title (but they are still sure it is the right title, it's the job that's wrongly defined).

But those bits of the job still need to be done so I end up doing them anyway, I just don't get training or support any more because it's not in my job description.

When I complain about that change I am lambasted for not supporting the newcomer in their role, despite the fact they never passed any assessment for the job, are incapable of some key elements and have no experience doing it other than they just decided to appropriate the title.

After a while the new definition of my job becomes the common one. I feel uncomfortable putting my own, original job title in my email because it doesn't represent my job any more.

I'd look for another one, but it seems my job now has no name so how do I even find the vacancy I should apply for?

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 18:11

@DrSbaitso

And then the same goes for people who think they’re so important, but only for certain people.

Well at least those people seem to be owning it. They're not obsessively interrogating people to see if they agree and then claiming it isn't a big deal.

Bold of you to complain of others ‘obsessively interrogating’ when you asked me the same question about a fake scenario for several posts.
DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 18:02

And then the same goes for people who think they’re so important, but only for certain people.

Well at least those people seem to be owning it. They're not obsessively interrogating people to see if they agree and then claiming it isn't a big deal.

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 17:57

@DrSbaitso

Ok, I see it. Cross post.

Well, if you think pronouns make so little difference to how we communicate, I can't see why you feel the need to obsessively question people on here about whether they use them in the you want them to.

And then the same goes for people who think they’re so important, but only for certain people.
DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 17:54

Ok, I see it. Cross post.

Well, if you think pronouns make so little difference to how we communicate, I can't see why you feel the need to obsessively question people on here about whether they use them in the you want them to.

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 17:51

@DrSbaitso

So you’ll use a female name for a male-bodied person, and you’ll use their preferred pronouns but don’t want them on emails?

Like I said before, I don't object to pronouns on emails per se, but I find the dominant branch of trans rights activism to be more anti-woman than pro-trans, and in that wider context it feels like forced complicity. I also haven't seen anyone doing it who wasn't she/her and whom I know to have been born female, so I'm wondering why this is a thing and who benefits. I also think it could pressure trans people who aren't ready to come out yet.

I've repeated myself. Your turn.

My turn what?

It’s perfectly possible to have this conversation without being snide, could we give that a go?

I have a vague memory of someone with Dr in their username having a go at me being called Pumper on a similar topic, would that be you?

DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 17:50

So you’ll use a female name for a male-bodied person, and you’ll use their preferred pronouns but don’t want them on emails?

Like I said before, I don't object to pronouns on emails per se, but I find the dominant branch of trans rights activism to be more anti-woman than pro-trans, and in that wider context it feels like forced complicity. I also haven't seen anyone doing it who wasn't she/her and whom I know to have been born female, so I'm wondering why this is a thing and who benefits. I also think it could pressure trans people who aren't ready to come out yet.

I've repeated myself. Your turn.

VerveClique · 09/09/2021 17:50

It's ridiculous.

Do we think people should also put things like:

Wheelchair user / can't attend meetings upstairs if there's no lift
Jehova's witness / please don't sent me a birthday card
Over 60 / no bus pass jokes please
Not pregnant / happy to be invited out for drinks

As well?

Surely anyone who was in any of the above situations would have to advocate for themselves with others if these things were important to them? They certainly wouldn't be including all of this on their email signatures at work FGS.

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 17:43

@DrSbaitso

Do you use people’s preferred pronouns?

Yes, since before it became fashionable. But I don't actually think male people are female.

So, your views on sex based rights?

So you’ll use a female name for a male-bodied person, and you’ll use their preferred pronouns but don’t want them on emails?

See above.

DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 17:42

Do you use people’s preferred pronouns?

Yes, since before it became fashionable. But I don't actually think male people are female.

So, your views on sex based rights?

FireworkParrot · 09/09/2021 17:40

I roll my eyes when I see it on email signatures or Zoom names (because I think it's performative) but carry on with my day. I won't be doing it though because I see gender ideology as exactly that.....a belief system. There are two biological sexes and if a biological male chooses to believe they are a woman and identify as that then they shouldn't be discriminated against but I see it as no different to someone's belief in Allah and identifying as Muslim. Which I also wouldn't expect to see on an email signature.

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 17:39

@Pumperthepumper

Sorry, I missed my own point - I think by making a big deal out of the little things (to me, pronouns) it’s hard to be taken seriously when we talk about bigger issues.
And further clarification here.
Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 17:38

I see it as the opposite, actually.

Like it or not, trans people exist and we will eventually have to find a common ground. As I said above, I consider myself to be gender critical - I don’t believe trans women should be in a female prison, for example. But I do think pronouns make little difference to how we communicate, so why not?

I’d love to hear where other people draw their line.

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 17:38

@DrSbaitso

I will.

Go on then.

Do you use people’s preferred pronouns?
DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 17:37

I will.

Go on then.

Whatsnewpussyhat · 09/09/2021 17:37

It's compelled speech and virtue signalling.

It is absolutely absurd that we should have to pander to such a tiny % of the population who share the religious beliefs of gender ideology and expect to put their wants before our own needs.

Why should I have to make other adults feel 'comfortable' by going along with beliefs that makes ME feel uncomfortable?
I don't believe in God either yet don't have to pretend I do to be civil or respectful of those who do.

I have never once had to declare my sexual orientation on an email signature to show solidarity to gay colleagues.

It has nothing to do with being 'inclusive' and everything to do with control.

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 17:36

@DrSbaitso

I’ve already said upthread where I stand on retaining sex-based rights.

I can't find it, sorry. Can you repeat?

I will.

Do you use people’s preferred pronouns?

DrSbaitso · 09/09/2021 17:34

I’ve already said upthread where I stand on retaining sex-based rights.

I can't find it, sorry. Can you repeat?

ElliottSmithsfingers · 09/09/2021 17:34

@DrSbaitso

So where’s your line re including trans people?

That they should be able to live, work and love authentically to themselves without persecution. And that spaces and services that are female-only for a reason (safety, athletic integrity etc) should not be open to anyone with an intact male body who merely says they feel female, since actually being female is not a feeling.

This! I strongly believe that TW are men, think it's madness not to. I also think they should be able to do what they want, when they want, where they want, other than to the extent it affects women e.g. sports, female spaces, confusion of medical terminology that will impact people having the correct advice and care for their sex. Is it so hard to comprehend?
Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 17:32

@boreda09

Whilst it strikes me as the use of pronouns in email signatures strikes me as tokenism and gesture, if someone chooses to do this I will respect their choice. And respect the option not to do so.
Yes, I think this is how most people feel.