Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU She/Her

258 replies

beewritesx · 09/09/2021 11:19

My sister is a big advocate of trans rights and says that pronouns in bio is a way of showing inclusion and support of the trans community.

I was quite surprised to receive a professional email from my ex boss with She/Her listed next to her email address (as I know this person and their gender).

I believe people should have the right to identify as they choose. If somebody asked me to call them X, I will as it's respectful. I also believe that if somebody is aged over 18 and decides to transition or change their gender identity they should do so with no persecution whatsoever.

However, pronouns in bio is just something I don't understand and cannot get on board with. If I'm ever in a professional position it's not something I would want to consider. I can't explain why. I just don't.

AIBU or too "traditional" (like my younger sister would probably argue) or does anyone feel the same? I can't give a rational explanation as to why I wouldn't, I just don't want to.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mustlovegin · 10/09/2021 15:03

Nobody should be forced to do something that makes them feel uncomfortable OP. You don't have to justify yourself (although lots of useful suggestions were provided on this thread). Also politics/ideology should be kept out of the workplace IMO.

wednesdayweather · 10/09/2021 14:25

@Blibbyblobby

A better comparison is if your colleague’s name was Catherine and they preferred to be called Cat. Might be a bit annoying for you to get used to but surely you wouldn’t mind?

That's not a valid comparison. A closer comparison is if someone decides to use my job title on emails instead of their own because they just feel my job title suits them better.

And then pushes to have some pretty major parts of the job removed from the job description because they will never be able to do them and that makes them uncomfortable in the new title (but they are still sure it is the right title, it's the job that's wrongly defined).

But those bits of the job still need to be done so I end up doing them anyway, I just don't get training or support any more because it's not in my job description.

When I complain about that change I am lambasted for not supporting the newcomer in their role, despite the fact they never passed any assessment for the job, are incapable of some key elements and have no experience doing it other than they just decided to appropriate the title.

After a while the new definition of my job becomes the common one. I feel uncomfortable putting my own, original job title in my email because it doesn't represent my job any more.

I'd look for another one, but it seems my job now has no name so how do I even find the vacancy I should apply for?

This is an absolutely brilliant analogy!
1stWorldProblems · 10/09/2021 14:14

I think the fact that my autosig (which I manually add to people who don't know me - as I hate them cluttering up emails from people I interact with all the time), has 1stWorldProblems (Mrs). That should be enough.

LaikO · 10/09/2021 14:10

My workplace wants everyone to include pronouns in our email signatures, I don't and barely anyone else does.

GrolliffetheDragon · 10/09/2021 14:00

^‘Oh yeah, Lucinda’s a woman, isn’t she? I'd completely forgotten until she actively reminded me via her specifying her pronouns in an email. Take her off the Anderson account and get her to make some cupcakes instead’.

Happens every day.^

Yeah, if it's correct I don't think it would happen quite like that. A lot of this stuff isn't the result of a conscious decision.

dolorsit · 10/09/2021 13:57

Also, when did get it so embarrassing to wrongly refer to someone's sex in writing?

I'm of the generation of women who could screen their junk mail and sales calls by being addressed as Mr or Sir. It was annoying the assumption that I was male but no more.

My forename is not "read" as feminine to foreigners so I've been referred to as "he" on a number of occasions. I often didn't bother correcting especially after experiencing a change in attitude once someone realised I am female.

dolorsit · 10/09/2021 13:51

I think putting pronouns in signatures to be inclusive is counterproductive.

If everyone starts doing it and then the vast majority use masculine and feminine pronouns which match male and female names your brain will start filling in the details.

Because you are so used to them matching you are far less likely to catch someone who uses them differently to what you expect.

Blibbyblobby · 10/09/2021 13:02

‘Oh yeah, Lucinda’s a woman, isn’t she? I'd completely forgotten until she actively reminded me via her specifying her pronouns in an email. Take her off the Anderson account and get her to make some cupcakes instead’.

Happens every day.

It sounds daft, doesn't it?

Yet studies show the the rational reasons why people believe they do things are retro-fitted by our brains to cover up the reality that it's usually our instincts, subconscious and yes, prejudices that are really making decisions, especially the "behind the scenes" decisions like what impressions you form of people.

So the fact that you can rationally see it's daft doesn't mean it doesn't happen.

As a thought experiment, imagine you have a colleague from Manchester with a strong accent (if you are from Manchester then imagine they are from Hull). Where they come from doesn't matter at all to the job but as you've spoken to them it's there as a background fact.

Now imagine every time they send an email or introduce themselves in a group, they add "I'm from Manchester". You are going to start thinking of their Manchester association much more strongly than you had before, aren't you?

godmum56 · 10/09/2021 11:59

so can nobody explain what "performing my gender" is please?

godmum56 · 10/09/2021 11:54

@thegcatsmother

Blibbyblobby You nailed it, thank you. That's exactly how I feel.
yup great post @Blibbyblobby
WomanStanleyWoman · 10/09/2021 11:31

@GrolliffetheDragon

As for people saying, "look how differently female employees are treated by clients when they know what sex they are" that's shit but a different issue. It's pretty fucking obvious I'm female - or will be assumed to be female - if my name's Lucinda or Jane, and the vast majority of people have names associated with a particular gender.

Isn't the issue, as I seem to recall reading, that reminding people you're female increases the risk of discrimination. So an objection is that having She/Her in you email or introducing yourself as having those pronouns is actively reminding everyone around you that you are a woman, so they view you more as a woman and less as just a person.

‘Oh yeah, Lucinda’s a woman, isn’t she? I'd completely forgotten until she actively reminded me via her specifying her pronouns in an email. Take her off the Anderson account and get her to make some cupcakes instead’.

Happens every day.

thegcatsmother · 10/09/2021 11:12

Blibbyblobby You nailed it, thank you. That's exactly how I feel.

GrolliffetheDragon · 10/09/2021 08:57

As for people saying, "look how differently female employees are treated by clients when they know what sex they are" that's shit but a different issue. It's pretty fucking obvious I'm female - or will be assumed to be female - if my name's Lucinda or Jane, and the vast majority of people have names associated with a particular gender.

Isn't the issue, as I seem to recall reading, that reminding people you're female increases the risk of discrimination. So an objection is that having She/Her in you email or introducing yourself as having those pronouns is actively reminding everyone around you that you are a woman, so they view you more as a woman and less as just a person.

whatthejiggeries · 10/09/2021 06:59

I wouldn't do it but it's an individual choice

Blibbyblobby · 09/09/2021 22:34

@DeborahAnnabel

By the way I’ve decided that if ever my firm forces the use of pronouns in emails, I am categorically going to write he/him. I’d have liked to have been born a, dare I say it, white, neuro-normal, heterosexual male. After all, in terms of privilege, that’s livin’ the dream, innit.
Absolutely.

It's one thing to use pronouns that simply refer to your sex. It's quite another to actively choose ones that come laden with all the cultural baggage of womanhood.

So if we are moving from sex-based to free choice, I'll have the ones with the privilege thank you.

DeborahAnnabel · 09/09/2021 22:28

By the way I’ve decided that if ever my firm forces the use of pronouns in emails, I am categorically going to write he/him. I’d have liked to have been born a, dare I say it, white, neuro-normal, heterosexual male. After all, in terms of privilege, that’s livin’ the dream, innit.

DeborahAnnabel · 09/09/2021 22:23

One of my friends has added her pronouns on LinkedIn. Her husband has done the same. And they met at Harvard. They’re both highly intelligent people.
Not quite sure what critical thinking has gone into that at all.
I’ve lost a bit of respect for her, actually.

Blibbyblobby · 09/09/2021 20:49

Like you op I can't really describe why but I would feel uncomfortable having this info highlighted.

I feel uncomfortable because the she/her that is meant in the context of preferred pronouns is not the same she/her that I use. My she/her means "I have a female body". Preferred she/her says "I have a womanly essence". Very different thing and not something I feel comfortable or indeed even truthful saying. For that reason, despite being female I cannot say my "preferred" pronouns are she/her.

badg3r · 09/09/2021 20:30

I have seen it on LinkedIn quite a lot recently. I don't like the way they use it there because it is shown right next to people's names wherever they appear and gets in the way of other more useful info like how you are connected or titles. I find it distracting. And also having experienced sexism in the workplace it's not something I want paraded across the top of my professional profile. It is so much more of a loaded statement for women than men. I'm not happy that I feel this way but I have been shaped by my environment I guess. Like you op I can't really describe why but I would feel uncomfortable having this info highlighted.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 09/09/2021 19:47

Maybe what we should be doing is adopting gender neutral emails, gender neutral "professional" names such as Sam and tell everyone our preferred pronouns are he/his

Maybe then we might actually get taken seriously

Ionlydomassiveones · 09/09/2021 19:38

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Eilatan2018 · 09/09/2021 19:33

I find it annoying and attention seeking. Why a big deal needs to be made I don’t know! It draws unnecessary attention to something that shouldn’t be an issue. I feel the same about gay pride. Sorry if I offend anyone but it’s my opinion! I have no issue with anyones sex or gender or sexual preferences btw just find some things a bit OTT.

underneaththeash · 09/09/2021 19:29

@wednesdayweather

This is important though. Many of us objecting take issue with the very idea of "performing our gender". I am not performing female. I am a female, due to biology, which is immutable. Everything else is personality. Or regressive stereotypes. Which I won't be supporting

This!

I agree WTF
Shuffalo · 09/09/2021 19:19

It’s unbelievably performative and encourages stereotyping, like so much of the pro-trans agenda

dannydyerismydad · 09/09/2021 19:19

It can be really helpful working in international companies where you correspond with people you rarely see.

Some names a British person wouldn't recognise as male or female. Some names we recognise as female are male in other cultures and vice versa (e.g. Nicola is a man's name in Italy).

It can save a lot of embarrassment. "I emailed Nicola last week and she confirmed..."