Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to ask how we fix the care system?

131 replies

TheABC · 09/09/2021 10:27

The furore over the NI tax rise has obscured the fact that little will change on the ground for anyone giving or receiving care. AFAIK, there are no changes or help for the unpaid family carers and no extra cash, training, or appreciation available for the staff in care homes.

The number of over-80's is forecast to double in the next 10 years (ONS), so the demand for care is only going to rise. AIBU to say we need a National Care Framework, in the same spirit as Scotland's?

||www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/populationestimates/articles/overviewoftheukpopulation/august2019||

OP posts:
Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 09/09/2021 16:51

@CovidCorvid

Do we need a National Care Service rather than for profit, private companies providing it and making money out the system?
I definitely think we do. I work in public sector and It is a fallacy that contracting out is cheaper. You still need commissioning team to manage them. Training still needs to be done to make up for the lack of training. Money goes out of the system instead of staying in the system eg, a great carer may be a great manager so you have upskilled that person and invested in them and then benefit from their skills & experience. Ditch the private companies I say.
MatildaIThink · 09/09/2021 16:49

@Mercurial123

I think it's all very well quoting systems like Sweden but they only have a population of 12 million and the make up of their population is different too. It's like the comparison of the UK to NZ in pandemic, it's not a good comparision

The OP mentioned Scotland. Sweden has double the population. Sweden has some workable ideas if we had a government that actually cared about its elderly, people living with disabilities etc.

The problem is not really the government, we get what people vote for, it is the electorate.

The electorate in Sweden are happy with taxes that are considerably higher than in the UK, until the UK electorate we willing to pay more, and to get to Swedish levels it would be a lot more for most, then we will not get anything like Swedish levels of public services.

Stircraazy · 09/09/2021 16:48

Have a look at the profits made by care homes it does not cost what they charge, it is about making money out of people with no other options

How can this be the case?
If there was money to be made the care homes would be competing for clients, building luxury places to attract more clients. They aren't making lots of money, except maybe in the south east where people have more money, remember clients put there by councils pay a low rate subsidised by a wealthier few paying ones. They arent making a lot.
Duncan Bannatyne made his fortune in Care Homes but I think it was when Maggie's Gov first made the Councils pay -anyway for some reason it was lucrative then.

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2021 16:48

@DoubleShotEspresso

I'm so shocked so many support assisted dying. Devastatingly so... Religious beliefs aside I find it horrifying though I can read some value into the reasons some give here. God I'm depressed at this.
Why? Nobody’s suggesting it should be obligatory. Why shouldn’t someone with capacity choose the time of their death?
Mercurial123 · 09/09/2021 16:47

I think it's all very well quoting systems like Sweden but they only have a population of 12 million and the make up of their population is different too. It's like the comparison of the UK to NZ in pandemic, it's not a good comparision

The OP mentioned Scotland. Sweden has double the population. Sweden has some workable ideas if we had a government that actually cared about its elderly, people living with disabilities etc.

DoubleShotEspresso · 09/09/2021 16:45

I'm so shocked so many support assisted dying.
Devastatingly so...
Religious beliefs aside I find it horrifying though I can read some value into the reasons some give here.
God I'm depressed at this.

GingerAndTheBiscuits · 09/09/2021 16:43

@Cocomarine absolutely, there are criteria the council needs to satisfy (did the person have a reasonable expectation of needing care when they disposed of the asset, did they know they’d need to pay for care and was the asset disposed of with the intention of avoiding paying for care). But too often people here suggest “signing your house over” as a solution to paying care fees and it’s misleading, that’s all

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2021 16:42

@Cocomarine

Any actuaries around?

How much would you have to pay as a private insurance premium for a care home payout?

What impact would voluntary care home insurance have? People pay for life insurance, critical illness cover, medical cover, income protection…

Didn’t Dilnot look at that and found no insurance company would touch it because there would be too few premium payers to spread the risk?
Cocomarine · 09/09/2021 16:39

Any actuaries around?

How much would you have to pay as a private insurance premium for a care home payout?

What impact would voluntary care home insurance have? People pay for life insurance, critical illness cover, medical cover, income protection…

Pazuzu · 09/09/2021 16:38

It's not just assisted dying it's taking a far more real world on what is provided during end of life care.

We now seem obsessed with keeping people alive for the sake of it regardless of quality of life.

I fully appreciate the oath doctors take but is it right to keep someone going just because you can?

As for assisted dying, if we did extend it's provision we very much have to ensure that sufficient deterrent exists for those who will abuse the system.

Cocomarine · 09/09/2021 16:37

@GingerAndTheBiscuits

It bears mentioning there is no “deprivation of assets timescale”. Councils can look back as far as they want when deciding if there has been intentional deprivation of assets. It’s a common myth with comes up here a lot.
That’s true, and I mentioned extending the time period for deprivation of assets myself.

But if an 80yo sold her house at 60 (fully well) to fund a purchase for an adult child, I think currently a council would have a hard time pursuing that.

I’m saying that even at 60, you should know that you can’t give away assets beyond a set sum, or it WILL be clawed back. Not might. Obviously not retrospectively! We need to plan for potential care home fees, and for many that will be knowing their equity is the answer.

I say 60 - I’m not trying to put an actual age on it here, just picking a 20 year period that I think a council would struggle to justify today!

Akire · 09/09/2021 16:36

@ZoBo123

A National Care Service would be a good start. Have a look at the profits made by care homes it does not cost what they charge, it is about making money out of people with no other options
This is start. Donkeys years ago council had home helps who paid well and a offered good service. Then it started being charged then went private and out to lowest bidder. Make vast majority state control And no profit with option like now for private care above NhS level.
Cocomarine · 09/09/2021 16:32

I don’t have time to Google for it now, but I read an interesting piece in the press not long ago.

It was about the US system for end of life care, and insurance. Not elderly, any condition. There was some issue that you basically only got one chance to pick a pathway - end of life palliative only, or medical intervention. So they did a study with agreement of insurers that people ours switch between. More went for palliative care. There wasn’t much difference in remaining life, and quality of life was judged far higher by those on palliative.

It quoted a huge percentage of overall medical costs (not care) falling in the last 6 months. For an individual to get some extra weeks? Hard to say that’s a bad thing. But on a population level… it’s certainly an interesting ethical debate.

GingerAndTheBiscuits · 09/09/2021 16:29

It bears mentioning there is no “deprivation of assets timescale”. Councils can look back as far as they want when deciding if there has been intentional deprivation of assets. It’s a common myth with comes up here a lot.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 09/09/2021 16:26

the 60-year-old with her own health problems caring for her 80-year-old parents who are even more frail

Why is a 60 year old frail? I’m 57, Dh is 62. We are both absolutely not frail! You have to work until 67. We can’t have health problems!

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2021 16:25

So sorry @JockTamsonsBairns, I’m not surprised you’re upset. My mum’s carers were absolute saints. They cried when she died and several of them took time off work to go to her funeral. It’s absolutely shocking that people have such an appalling misconception of carers.

ZoBo123 · 09/09/2021 16:25

A National Care Service would be a good start. Have a look at the profits made by care homes it does not cost what they charge, it is about making money out of people with no other options

Artus · 09/09/2021 16:24

To the poster advocating the Logans Run solution - what age do you suggest. I'm 63. How long will you give me?

My parents are both 86. Still drive. Still in their own home. No carers. Do their own shopping. But getting frailer. Guess they should be off soon then.

Candleabra · 09/09/2021 16:23

@Candleabra, could your mother have consented? Would she had given you the power to do so when she was well? The percentage of the budget taken up by people in your Mum's position is tiny. I'm not prepared to sacrifice people who are disabled, but healthy and living their lives quite happily to save it.

I don't know if she would have consented years ago when she was well. Perhaps not. Noone thinks they'll end up in such a position. I only know that she would hate what has happened now. And having seen it first hand I would consent to my daughters having the power to end my life at an appropriate time. To spare them the pain and stress of what I've been through. Leave them with happy memories.
I know that could be hugely exploited. I don't know what the answer is on a population basis. I only know that those are my wishes.

(And I would have thought that dementia patients near the end of life makes up a huge proportion of care and NHS costs. I'm obviously not suggesting that people with good quality of life would be subject to euthanasia).

JockTamsonsBairns · 09/09/2021 16:20

Very few people want to live out their days sitting in a soggy incontinence pad with the TV blaring out Naked Attraction whilst being looked after by a bored yob who's been forced by the jobcentre to work in a smelly care home.

Wow. I'm a carer, and this has really upset me. I've got 24 years' worth of experience, and my skills and compassion have meant that I've been extremely well regarded by everyone I've looked after in their final stage of life.
Reading that is like a kick in the stomach, particularly in light of what carers have been through over the past 18 months.
Plenty pp saying that carers should be more valued and respected, yet perceptions like this go unchallenged. Awful.

Akire · 09/09/2021 16:19

Don’t forget 1/3 users are under 65 and half the cost goes toward that age group. Mainly for children and young adults with disabilities and complex needs. None of this just sell your house will work for most of this age group. We need vastly improve what care is giving above and beyond the washed dressed fed. That’s no way live a whole life and just stay home rest of the time watching Tv

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/09/2021 16:17

[quote Ponoka7]@Candleabra, could your mother have consented? Would she had given you the power to do so when she was well? The percentage of the budget taken up by people in your Mum's position is tiny. I'm not prepared to sacrifice people who are disabled, but healthy and living their lives quite happily to save it.

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz, what do you mean by euthanasia?[/quote]
Sorry probably wrong word - Dignitas, basically.

Cocomarine · 09/09/2021 16:16

@Samcro

Stop shouting. Nobody is assuming that.
If we can cut the bill for elderly residential care (like my suggestion that people actually do have to sell their house, tough cheese) then we have more money left for disability care earlier in life.

Though I don’t have the statistics, I’m willing to bet that the huge increases (percentage and actual people) predicted for elderly care requirements far outstrip projected increase in disability care for younger people.

Ponoka7 · 09/09/2021 16:15

@Candleabra, could your mother have consented? Would she had given you the power to do so when she was well? The percentage of the budget taken up by people in your Mum's position is tiny. I'm not prepared to sacrifice people who are disabled, but healthy and living their lives quite happily to save it.

@BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz, what do you mean by euthanasia?

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 09/09/2021 16:12

ffs when will people realise NOT ALL PEOPLE LIVING IN CARE HOMES ARE OLD, OR AT END OF LIFE.
DISABLED PEOPLE LIVE IN CARE HIMES TOO

No ones saying that us the case. Stop shouting.

Of course care homes facilitate a broad range of ages and abilities. The suggestions dont have to cover every single type of resident.