Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to ask how we fix the care system?

131 replies

TheABC · 09/09/2021 10:27

The furore over the NI tax rise has obscured the fact that little will change on the ground for anyone giving or receiving care. AFAIK, there are no changes or help for the unpaid family carers and no extra cash, training, or appreciation available for the staff in care homes.

The number of over-80's is forecast to double in the next 10 years (ONS), so the demand for care is only going to rise. AIBU to say we need a National Care Framework, in the same spirit as Scotland's?

||www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/populationandmigration/populationestimates/articles/overviewoftheukpopulation/august2019||

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Candleabra · 11/09/2021 19:33

She's 70 @GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER

Diagnosed 6 years ago. So started off from a very high level of health and fitness.
She is terribly physically frail now now, especially now she can't walk, but it's all caused by the dementia, no other co existing health problems.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 11/09/2021 19:22

How old is your Mother, @Candleabra? I ask because once my mother was past 90, with pretty advanced dementia, we agreed with the care home that active life- prolonging treatment would not be in her best interests - palliative care only would be best.

We were at least partly influenced by the fact that she’d been an intensely private person who would have been horrified at what she’d become, and would certainly have said, ‘For God’s sake just let me go.’
In the event the question never arose - she went on to 97 and then went downhill very quickly.

TBH I’d have thought you were perfectly entitled to have a similar conversation with staff.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 11/09/2021 19:02

There is a great difference between assisted dying, and abstaining from striving to keep alive. Especially IMO when dementia beyond the early stages is involved. Why would anyone strive to keep alive someone who is doubly incontinent, who no longer recognises any of their own family, and/or, like a poor lady of 80 odd in my DM’s care home, who was in an almost constant state of tearful distress, either because she had to get home for ‘the baby’, or, depending on which particular obsession was distressing her that day, her mother wouldn’t know where she was and would be so worried. And no amount of comfort or reassurance from the very kind staff could help her.

There surely comes a time when Nature should be allowed to take its course, and to strive to keep alive is verging on cruelty.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 11/09/2021 18:31

A chosen death - consensual euthanasia - does not take into account whether one's children claim your quality of life is poor or excellent, because it is not up to them to decide.

Of course.

I'm uncomfortable with the emphasis being placed on money instead of dignity.

legoriakelne · 11/09/2021 18:23

@ChardonnaysPetDragon

Nothing to do with my own moral compass, more a sad truth that SOME people will be quicker to say their parent has poor quality of life if there's ££ at stake

So? Why are you making it about money when people's dignity is destroyed? Why should they be denied an exit on their own term just because there are some chancers out there?

Build in safeguards in the systems, and let people take their own decisions.

A chosen death - consensual euthanasia - does not take into account whether one's children claim your quality of life is poor or excellent, because it is not up to them to decide.
legoriakelne · 11/09/2021 18:17

[quote notanothertakeaway]Coincidentally, here's a thread giving reasons why people terminated a pregnancy. Some of the reasons do not meet the high tests in abortion legislation, which again illustrates my point that legal safeguards can be watered down over time

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4346471-to-think-no-woman-aborts-a-baby-lightly-is-untrue-and-unhelpful[/quote]
You're still conflating two different things.

This is the equivalent of some people saying there are only specified reasons why someone may consensually choose to end their life - of you imposing on others your value judgement on what constitutes poor quality of life rather than allowing individuals to determine what is an intolerable quality of life for themselves. It will after all be different for every person.

Women being granted abortions within the legal time limits is not an erosion of safeguards.

Your strawman argument is that people will be murdered. The thread you are linking still lends no credence to that notion.

There is no evidence from countries that have legalised chosen dying of it devolving into murder instead. You are scaremongering based on zero evidence.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 11/09/2021 17:50

Nothing to do with my own moral compass, more a sad truth that SOME people will be quicker to say their parent has poor quality of life if there's ££ at stake

So? Why are you making it about money when people's dignity is destroyed? Why should they be denied an exit on their own term just because there are some chancers out there?

Build in safeguards in the systems, and let people take their own decisions.

GU24Mum · 11/09/2021 16:59

Having watched a relative spend months (fortunately not years) in a care home with dementia - and having walked round the corridors and seen many of the other patients, that isn't living in any way most/many of us would want to think of it. I suspect most of those dementia patients would have been horrified to look forward and see how they would end up.

Before watching a second person die of/with dementia, I lost the naivety that dementia means that you are in your own world but happy in it - so many of them, when they express any emotion, were angry, upset or sad. It's an appalling disease.

It's also, from my admittedly limited experience, over-medicated. My relative had a fall and ended up in hospital with sepsis about 9 months before she died. Another relative was treated for a minor heart attack and had another 2.5 years of a miserable existence. Should they have been treated? In my opinion, no.

Relatives can often be part of the issue - I was on a FB group for a while and quite a few would understandably say that they weren't ready for their relative to die - but really that relative was most likely more than ready.

notanothertakeaway · 11/09/2021 16:37

Coincidentally, here's a thread giving reasons why people terminated a pregnancy. Some of the reasons do not meet the high tests in abortion legislation, which again illustrates my point that legal safeguards can be watered down over time

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4346471-to-think-no-woman-aborts-a-baby-lightly-is-untrue-and-unhelpful

notanothertakeaway · 11/09/2021 16:26

@legoriakelne

When I'm frail and elderly, I don't want to risk being "assisted to die" if I make a few comments about being fed up I can't walk, and everyone rushes to say "oh dear, no quality of life for her, time to let her go"

You stated that a chosen death is equivalent to abortion in terms of legislation and safeguards, then made this outrageous statement.

Bringing your imagined scenario back to your original comparison of the position on abortion: if a pregnant woman makes a few comments about struggling with the pregnancy, nobody rushes her off for a forced abortion.

Feeling too young / old to have a child, or knowing that a foetus has certain health conditions would now be considered a valid reason to terminate a pregnancy. This may or may not be a good thing, but illustrates my point that legal safeguards may be weakened over time
notanothertakeaway · 11/09/2021 16:21

@ChardonnaysPetDragon

And the risk of abuse eg a greedy child has their eye on an inheritance and doesn't want care home fees to get in the way....

Ah, we all see this according to our own moral compass, so talk about yourself…

Nothing to do with my own moral compass, more a sad truth that SOME people will be quicker to say their parent has poor quality of life if there's ££ at stake
notanothertakeaway · 11/09/2021 16:19

@Stircraazy

When I'm frail and elderly, I don't want to risk being "assisted to die" if I make a few comments about being fed up I can't walk, and everyone rushes to say "oh dear, no quality of life for her, time to let her go"

I don't think you've known someone existing with severe dementia - they certainly won't be capable of making a few comments about feeling fed up. They will probably not be able to make any comments at all - just babbling or crying.

Frail and elderly isn't the same as having dementia
Charley50 · 11/09/2021 16:15

I also don't see why it isn't 'fair' to have to sell your house to pay for care. It's unfortunate and unlucky, but lots of things are. It's a reflection on our over-inflated house prices that we worry so much about passing on our inheritance to our children. If property was more affordable, it wouldn't be such an enormous deal.

Charley50 · 11/09/2021 16:10

I don't think suggesting assisted dying is so shocking. I witnessed my mum's decline and her last few months were so, so awful and lacking in any autonomy. I do not want that for myself. It's about my wants.
I've written a living will (different term but can't remember what it is). Downloaded it from Dignity in Dying website and have asked for no treatment e.g. antibiotics, if I'm in a state like dementia. This isn't euthanasia, it's declining life-prolonging treatment.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 11/09/2021 16:07

Never mind the carpet, the bloody dogs are always lurking on the stairs.

bebanjo · 11/09/2021 15:51

As a carer, I have started to think about how I would end my own life should I need to. We would not make dogs live the way some old people are existing. 4 visits a day to Chang an inconvenience pad, 5 mins chat if that and then left. But let’s keep them alive. It’s cruel the way the elderly are kept.
I believe there will be more conversations about assisted dying as more people see how those they love are made to carry on with no quality of life.
Modern medicine has made people live far longer than they would have done.

Stircraazy · 11/09/2021 15:50

ChardonnaysPetDragon

And the risk of abuse eg a greedy child has their eye on an inheritance and doesn't want care home fees to get in the way....

Well obviously the best plan is to keep the old person in their home and allow them to have an accident/ wander off into the night.

Watch you don't trip on that stair carpet Chardonnay Grin Grin

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 11/09/2021 15:47

Living not loving, thought I suppose there ain’t much loving there either.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 11/09/2021 15:44

You say the system is underfunded, abs while that is true, millions are spent on keeping people existing, not even loving, often against their wishes.

Is that fair?

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 11/09/2021 15:41

You might see it that way, I think it’s unfair to assume everyone has ulterior motives.

guinnessguzzler · 11/09/2021 15:30

@ChardonnaysPetDragon

And the risk of abuse eg a greedy child has their eye on an inheritance and doesn't want care home fees to get in the way....

Ah, we all see this according to our own moral compass, so talk about yourself…

I think that comment is unfair. Having a good understanding of human nature and being able to anticipate how any system might be abused is not the same as being willing or keen to undertake that abuse yourself.

Personally, I do have experience of the horror of dementia and I certainly don't think anyone should be forced to live who doesn't want to. However, the ease with which so many here seem to think the solution to a really poor, wasteful, not-at-all designed and inadequately funded system is to reduce demand through assisted dying really does make me reconsider whether the 'slippery slope' objection may have some weight after all.

legoriakelne · 11/09/2021 15:13

When I'm frail and elderly, I don't want to risk being "assisted to die" if I make a few comments about being fed up I can't walk, and everyone rushes to say "oh dear, no quality of life for her, time to let her go"

You stated that a chosen death is equivalent to abortion in terms of legislation and safeguards, then made this outrageous statement.

Bringing your imagined scenario back to your original comparison of the position on abortion: if a pregnant woman makes a few comments about struggling with the pregnancy, nobody rushes her off for a forced abortion.

Otherpeoplesteens · 11/09/2021 14:51

Fucking hell, I cannot believe how many people are genuinely suggesting assisted dying as the solution to the social care crisis. That's a large part of the problem, right there. Assisted dying should be a completely separate issue.

No, no, no, no. It's not a completely separate issue at all; there are no easy choices and everything is a messy compromise one way or another, just that many people can make decisions without caring about the externalities - the consequences which fall to others. If the supply and demand curves don't reach equilibrium at a price people are willing to pay, you need to alter the shape of the curves if you want a functioning market. You can try tinkering on the supply side, or you could try altering demand.

Assisted dying is a perfectly rational way of reducing demand in the care system, and there are many, many people who would make that choice very rationally if they were only bloody allowed to.

I posted on here a couple of years ago that my stepmother watched her own mother resuscitated during a cardiac arrest at the age of 89 at the plea of one of the grandchildren. She then stroked out. This elderly woman 'recovered' enough to spend ten years in inco pads in a care home not recognising a single member of her family after about the first three days, and burned through nearly a million quid during that time. Those ten years were torturous for everyone apart from the eastern European care workers the family's nine hundred and something thousand pounds provided employment for. None of them ever, ever want to repeat it, even if someone else picked up the bill.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 11/09/2021 14:31

And the risk of abuse eg a greedy child has their eye on an inheritance and doesn't want care home fees to get in the way....

Ah, we all see this according to our own moral compass, so talk about yourself…

Jourdain11 · 11/09/2021 14:30

[quote Mercurial123]Swedish care for the elderly looks pretty good.

sweden.se/life/society/elderly-care-in-sweden[/quote]
Sweden has amazing social care generally, but also high taxes to pay for it.

Unfortunately I fear that's the only realistic way to do it Confused You can't have super low taxes and super high state expenditure, the books just don't balance.