Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To myself and impatient? Weight loss,exercise related

107 replies

MintyGreenDream · 09/09/2021 08:32

Took up a gym membership 3 weeks ago.Ive been doing cardio and weights 3 times a week plus 1200 calories a day and ive lost fuck all weight,not even a pound.
It can't be muscle weight because I've only just started.
I'm 41, 5ft 10 and weigh 12st 5 the heaviest I've been in years.Im a big 12 in clothes edging to a 14.HELP

OP posts:
MintyGreenDream · 09/09/2021 13:56

@blobby10 I'mglad I'm not alone in this,I'm sure we'll see results soon

OP posts:
blobby10 · 09/09/2021 11:49

@MintyGreenDream

Thanks everyone.Im going to try eating less carbs.Ive definitely not been getting my calories wrong.Its trial and error like most things so I'll keep on with it.
Minty I'm in the same boat - it takes 3 weeks(ish) for any change in diet/exercise to register on the scales for me. However this time I have noticed that whilst I'm going to the gym every morning and burning 6-700 calories according to HRM, I do eff all after work which is a desk job anyway! Last time I lost weight effectively I was not coming home exhausted and slumping in front of the TV- I was taking kids to judo and going for a walk whilst it was on, playing touch rugby, coaching rugby, taking dogs for a walk etc etc. I KNOW that if I can just get out for a half hour walk after work it will make a difference but right now my emotional self won't let me do it.

Plus I keep sabotaging my 'good' food all week then overeating at the weekend 'because I've cycled 30 miles'

I'm over 13 stones which I haven't been since pregnant with DC3 21 years ago and my clothes don't fit. I can't afford to buy bigger ones so have to do something and quickly but at 52 it aint going to come off quickly is it? Sad

Latinorapida · 09/09/2021 11:39

My husband lost loads of weight on the keto diet. I would do it if I didn’t have such a sweet tooth. You only eat fat and protein. You can’t even have fruit (apart from some berries and even then it’s just a handful). No oats or grains so typical day would be omelette for breakfast, tuna salad and eggs for lunch and salmon/steak, creamy saucy and green veg for dinner.

Basically you can have as much fat and protein as you want. My husband lost 20 kilos and he wasn’t particularly overweight to begin with. Hope that helps x

Bluntness100 · 09/09/2021 11:19

@a8mint

I think you will have built loads of muscle doing weights 3 x a week for three weeks especially in the first 3 weeks.
No she won’t, do you know how hard it is for a woman to build muscle?
WreckTangled · 09/09/2021 11:17

'If you want to lose stored fat, the only way to do this is to eat a diet designed to keep insulin low.'

Rubbish. Insulin converts food to energy for your body to lose. It all comes down to a calorie deficit. You also need/produce insulin for protein, albeit at a slower rate.

WreckTangled · 09/09/2021 11:12

@Bluntness100

Honestly some nonsense being posted on here, she’s not holding on to half a stone of water weight as she exercises three times a week, what a ridiculous idea.
Agreed.
ColorMagicBarbie · 09/09/2021 10:57

If you want to lose stored fat, the only way to do this is to eat a diet designed to keep insulin low.

If you're in a calorie deficit you will generally lose. Personally, I can't do exercises like squats and deadlift etc with any intensity if I'm too carb depleted. The body just doesn't convert fat/protein to useable energy fast enough.

But it depends on one's goals. I think some resistance training is important as most people want to be toned rather than just be skinny fat so to speak.

MintyGreenDream · 09/09/2021 10:43

Thanks everyone.Im going to try eating less carbs.Ive definitely not been getting my calories wrong.Its trial and error like most things so I'll keep on with it.

OP posts:
TheSquashyHatOfMrGnosspelius · 09/09/2021 10:09

Exercise will not lose you weight, it will make you gain weight as you gain muscle.

If you want to lose stored fat, the only way to do this is to eat a diet designed to keep insulin low. The job of insulin is to store fat from the carbs you take in. Stop taking in carbs and insulin stays low.. You start to access your stores Low carb, moderate protein (as high protein also spikes insulin) high fat (no carbs in fat and it's full of vitamins and minerals) and you start to go into ketosis and use the stored food instead.
Your breath will reek, you will have a touch of 'keto flu' and you will have to get used to hunger but you have to go through this phase to get to the ongoing day and night fat burning that a low carb diet creates. Once in ketosis you feel brilliant though.
Exercise will burn off the stored fat faster, bulk up your muscles and make you feel better in yourself but unless you cut carbs, exercise without modifying your diet will barely register for fat loss.

a8mint · 09/09/2021 10:04

I think you will have built loads of muscle doing weights 3 x a week for three weeks especially in the first 3 weeks.

lljkk · 09/09/2021 10:03

3x/week isn't a lot of exercise imho.

Post here all the items that passed your lips in last 7 days.

Bluntness100 · 09/09/2021 09:59

Honestly some nonsense being posted on here, she’s not holding on to half a stone of water weight as she exercises three times a week, what a ridiculous idea.

RonObvious · 09/09/2021 09:55

@MegBusset

It's probably the exercise making you hold on to water weight, if you didn't exercise much before. This should even out over a few weeks as your body gets used to exercise.
I second this. Plus, stop measuring success by weight! You've maintained a workout regime for 3 weeks, as well as a low calorie diet. That's a real achievement! You are fitter and healthier than you were 3 weeks ago. Personally, I find that the more muscle I have in my body, the easier I find it to maintain my weight. Actually, the easier I find everything, so definitely don't get discouraged, and keep it up!
mum11970 · 09/09/2021 09:54

Is the exercise giving you aching muscles? When you are new to exercise your body will retain water to protect your muscles whilst they repair. This may last a couple of weeks and then your body should flush it out. Muscle is built by tearing slightly when you exercise and rebuilding stronger. Your body will hold water around the muscle whilst it repairs itself.

MajorNeville · 09/09/2021 09:54

Drink more water, I lose weight very slowly but the more I drink the quicker it gets, I have at least 2.5l a day but usually hit around 3-3.5l a day. I started at 2l and built up so my body got used to it, if you get a headache have an oxo cube in water to replace lost electrolytes.

Your body needs water to help it burn fat, drink to shrink.

EatYourVegetables · 09/09/2021 09:50

Low carb / keto / IF.

LBirch02 · 09/09/2021 09:46

I struggle to lose weight sometimes at 1200 calls so when I was doing my weight loss thing went down to 800 cals a lot of the time!
Also don’t eat back exercise cals!!

WreckTangled · 09/09/2021 09:32

You don't need to lower your carbs (and I say that as someone who eats low carb because I'm diabetic). Bluntness is right, your calorie counting is off, or because you're over restricting you're then over eating at other times. Any decent coach would say the following:

1600cals a day as a starting point (averaged over the week)
100g protein a day
10000 steps a day
Minimum 3 resistance training sessions a week

Scale weight is a good indicator of trends over a few weeks but not the be all and end all, take measurements and photos and don't expect to see much difference for a good month.

Cardio is fine if you enjoy it but not of much benefit for weight loss as a) people tend to think they've burnt way more than they have and then 'eat back' calories and b) tend to make you hungry.

Also you're not trying to lose weight, you're trying to lost body fat which is really hard to measure, hence why scale weight should only be looked at as an overall trend over time.

Really recommend ESG fitness on Instagram.

ColorMagicBarbie · 09/09/2021 09:31

Some gyms do a bodyfat measurement where they put a very mild current through your body. This can be useful to know. I'd also be wary of going too low carb if you're lifting weights. Will be hard to maintain energy for compound lifts etc and will make it much more mentally challenging.

starmoonsun · 09/09/2021 09:25

I find that if I exercise a lot weight loss is slower but get fitter and toned ( so lots like you've lost weight). If your not bothered about the number on the scales but want clothes to fit better and look slimmer id say keep doing what you are. If your bothered about the number then either reduce the exercise or you'll need to be more patient as it'll take longer.

MegBusset · 09/09/2021 09:22

It's probably the exercise making you hold on to water weight, if you didn't exercise much before. This should even out over a few weeks as your body gets used to exercise.

Excelthetube · 09/09/2021 09:22

I can do 1200 with carbs and not really lose weight
Or 1200 low carbs and lose 2lb week on average
I am also 40s

Bluntness100 · 09/09/2021 09:19

@Snorkello

Muscle weighs more than fat, so weight change might not be a good indicator. Measure your waist etc. Instead.

Also, you won’t see a change for at least 6 weeks. Keep going and try some regular long walks. This will help shift the weight too. Stay focused, it will easily drop off as you don’t have much weight to lose.

Re diet, don’t worry about calories, but avoid bread and alcohol. Eat tons of veg (soup/salad) and drink lots of water. Cut back sugar. Don’t snack or cut out meals. Eat breakfast. This will help boost you short term.

Um what? She’s not built up enough muscle in three weeks on that regime.

Op then irs your portion sizes. You’re getting your calories wrong, no wat round it.

MintyGreenDream · 09/09/2021 09:13

I'm definitely weighing and using MFP I've lost weight quicker before doing naff all exercise just low calories Maybe it is my age!

OP posts:
Snorkello · 09/09/2021 08:48

Muscle weighs more than fat, so weight change might not be a good indicator. Measure your waist etc. Instead.

Also, you won’t see a change for at least 6 weeks. Keep going and try some regular long walks. This will help shift the weight too. Stay focused, it will easily drop off as you don’t have much weight to lose.

Re diet, don’t worry about calories, but avoid bread and alcohol. Eat tons of veg (soup/salad) and drink lots of water. Cut back sugar. Don’t snack or cut out meals. Eat breakfast. This will help boost you short term.