Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To myself and impatient? Weight loss,exercise related

107 replies

MintyGreenDream · 09/09/2021 08:32

Took up a gym membership 3 weeks ago.Ive been doing cardio and weights 3 times a week plus 1200 calories a day and ive lost fuck all weight,not even a pound.
It can't be muscle weight because I've only just started.
I'm 41, 5ft 10 and weigh 12st 5 the heaviest I've been in years.Im a big 12 in clothes edging to a 14.HELP

OP posts:
Thebig3 · 11/09/2021 10:08

Oh my god the misinformation on this thread is absolutely shocking and shows exactly why there is an obesity crisis in the country with all the crap people are spouting on here!

OP you need to speak to a personal trainer who can advise you properly, someone who is trained in this kind of thing. I would also recommend looking at the likes of the fitness chef, James Smith Pt and similar on Instagram. Do not do keto and crap like that there is no need, carbs are not the enemy!

midgemagneto · 11/09/2021 09:30

Muscle weighs more than fat? Muscle is denser.

Actually means 2 people of the same weight then the one with more muscles will look smaller

Hormones and water retention would be my guess

Mercurial123 · 11/09/2021 09:19

Exactly because MUSCLE WEIGHS MORE THAN FAT

Can you prove that from a reliable source?Otherwise you are just "blathering on". And stop shouting it's rude.

BrisbaneandGone · 11/09/2021 07:01

@a8mint

taken from a medical website so you don't agree with what they are "blathering" about. Someone who lifts weights will look very different from someone with the same height and body weight than someone who doesn't lift weights. Exactly because MUSCLE WEIGHS MORE THAN FAT
No it doesn't, a pound of muscle weighs exactly the same as a pound of fat...a pound. Visually there'll be more muscle in a pound of muscle than fat in a pound of fat, but they both weigh the same. Imagine a pound of marshmallows, there'll be loads of them, now imagine a pound of chicken breasts and there won't be very much at all. Both still weigh a pound though
Invasionofthegutsnatchers · 11/09/2021 07:00

Are you drinking alcohol OP?

Dixiechickonhols · 11/09/2021 06:57

Can you pay for a trainer some are online to get you started. Do a tdee calculator 1200 is very low for height and activity. I’m 5 ft 8 moderately active and need around 1700 to lose.

a8mint · 11/09/2021 06:50

taken from a medical website so you don't agree with what they are "blathering" about. Someone who lifts weights will look very different from someone with the same height and body weight than someone who doesn't lift weights.
Exactly because MUSCLE WEIGHS MORE THAN FAT

Mercurial123 · 10/09/2021 10:43

@a8mint

Muscle weighs more than fat. "In simple terms, a pound of muscle weighs the same as a pound of fat," Heimburger tells WebMD. "The difference is that muscle is much more dense than body fat. Therefore, a pound of muscle will take up much less room in your body than a pound of fat What on earth are you blathering on about? Saying fat takes up more space than muscle, is the same thing as saying muscle weighs more than fat. And yes when someone girst starts weight training they build up muscle noticeably very quickly. Having little musculature could tell the difference in how my biceps and calf muscles felt after one session let alone 9!
It's taken from a medical website so you don't agree with what they are "blathering" about. Someone who lifts weights will look very different from someone with the same height and body weight than someone who doesn't lift weights.
a8mint · 10/09/2021 08:00

Muscle weighs more than fat. "In simple terms, a pound of muscle weighs the same as a pound of fat," Heimburger tells WebMD. "The difference is that muscle is much more dense than body fat. Therefore, a pound of muscle will take up much less room in your body than a pound of fat
What on earth are you blathering on about? Saying fat takes up more space than muscle, is the same thing as saying muscle weighs more than fat.
And yes when someone girst starts weight training they build up muscle noticeably very quickly. Having little musculature could tell the difference in how my biceps and calf muscles felt after one session let alone 9!

Bluntness100 · 10/09/2021 07:55

@Tempusfudgeit

There was a study out this week that counterintuitively showed that overweight people who exercise lose less weight at rest.

I've always seen diet and fitness as separate. Lose the weight first, with very accurate calorie counting, then get fit through exercise. Your joints will thank you too!

Don’t do this, the poster has completely misunderstood the study which in no way is recommending that people don’t exercise during a weight loss phase.
Tempusfudgeit · 09/09/2021 19:04

Here it is:

www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0960982221011209

Tempusfudgeit · 09/09/2021 19:02

There was a study out this week that counterintuitively showed that overweight people who exercise lose less weight at rest.

I've always seen diet and fitness as separate. Lose the weight first, with very accurate calorie counting, then get fit through exercise. Your joints will thank you too!

Mercurial123 · 09/09/2021 18:55

Muscle does not weigh more than fat

Muscle weighs more than fat. "In simple terms, a pound of muscle weighs the same as a pound of fat," Heimburger tells WebMD. "The difference is that muscle is much more dense than body fat. Therefore, a pound of muscle will take up much less room in your body than a pound of fat. Another benefit of muscle, it is significantly more vascular [better blood supply] than body fat and will cause you to burn more calories at rest than body fat."

user1471442488 · 09/09/2021 18:46

Also, to actually add something useful…I’ve found keto amazing for weight loss. I never felt hungry at all as eating lots of fat kept me full all day. You won’t quite believe the numbers you’ll see on the scales when you’ve been eating like a queen all week!

user1471442488 · 09/09/2021 18:44

@a8mint

I think you will have built loads of muscle doing weights 3 x a week for three weeks especially in the first 3 weeks.
No she won’t. It is very difficult for women to put on muscle, and there is no way that 3 sessions in 3 weeks is going to add anything significant.
Leftbutcameback · 09/09/2021 18:38

I would definitely say keep going, and see if you start to look more toned. I’m the other way around - gained no weight but have gained inches and at least half a dress size. Weight really isn’t everything esp as you get a bit older.

StrikeItLuckyShuffle · 09/09/2021 18:30

@MintyGreenDream
My pleasure :) and by not weighing yourself you will soon notice the difference when your clothes start to get looser that’s how I knew it was working
I gave up weighing myself as I have two sets of scales and both say a different weight when I stand on them and was never lower than when I first started Confused I was so annoyed by it I even kept moving it around the kitchen floor and standing on them at a funny angle just to see if a different area of the room would make me weigh less after all the effort and healthy food I had been eating made no bloody difference lol

Definitely stick to the 1200 calories and yes cut out carbs that’s what I’ve done
no bread or potatoes just put extra veg on your plate :)

MintyGreenDream · 09/09/2021 15:40

@StrikeItLuckyShuffle thanks I really needed to hear this

OP posts:
MissConductUS · 09/09/2021 14:36

Move more. Briskly walk 2-3 miles on the days that you don't work out in the gym.

One problem with cutting your caloric intake is that your metabolism slows down in response. Exercise will reduce that effect.

StrikeItLuckyShuffle · 09/09/2021 14:26

Firstly
Stop weighing yourself .

Stick to what your doing and don’t give up

I was in exactly the same position ( same weight / clothes size same daily calories and going gym 3-4 times a week)
I’m 3 months in and now sticking to it seeing the results
I’ve not lost a mega amount (7lbs ) but I’ve gained muscle and tone in my arms
lockdown flapping clapping bingo wings are almost all gone
I’ve gone down to a size 10-12 and gained so much confidence.

But my strong advise is do not bother with weighing yourself
It just makes you feel like your not doing enough when you see no difference or worst of all it says you have gained !!
but it does work if you stick to the 1200 calories and go gym minimum 3 times a week it will come off
Don’t give up :)

Cocomarine · 09/09/2021 13:58

@a8mint

I think you will have built loads of muscle doing weights 3 x a week for three weeks especially in the first 3 weeks.
That’s just wrong.
MintyGreenDream · 09/09/2021 13:56

@Latinarapida thanks I think im definitely going to give keto a go

OP posts: