Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are these dolls totally inappropriate?

284 replies

Itsbeen84yearss · 09/09/2021 08:00

Just seen the ad for these on channel 5 (in between peppa episodes). Marketed as ‘opposites’? I might be being bad minded but these look highly sexualised to me. I bought my dd an lol doll once but I think it had a school uniform on. Didn’t look like these at all. Why are they like this now?? Surely it’s sending all sorts of bad messages to kids

Are these dolls totally inappropriate?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
TableFlowerss · 09/09/2021 11:17

@FlibbertyGiblets

I did laugh at tingly and clotted - and ducking bell has nearly finished me off Grin
I hate my phone 😂🤣
NewlyGranny · 09/09/2021 11:16

Gertrude, I think 'opposites' refers to the faux-innocent Lolita look of the doll on the left contrasted with the overtly available, rubber-fetish costume of the other one.

Can't ever recall or imagine a Ken doll all dressed up for pup-play in doggie mask and leash being marketed at boys. He'd have to be boxed on all fours...

This is marginally socially acceptable grooming of very young girls indeed to see their future selves in these dolls and aspire. I do think they are harmful. No wonder older girls feel pressured to conform or flee.

My DC had baby dolls first - DS and DDs; his was a Timmy with anatomically correct bits - and then there were soft Lilly dolls and DD2 had Madeleine dolls after she had her appendix out. We succumbed to Barbies eventually via gifts.

TableFlowerss · 09/09/2021 11:15

School uniform, on a doll that looked like Barbie who was clearly an adult woman? The problem with Barbie is not her outfit

The problem with Barbie is she was a beautiful woman that kids and women wanted to look like.

She was very obviously a woman so if she was flat chested and made to look more like a child it wouldn’t be an issue but of course a school uniform wouldn’t be appropriate- because she’s an adult

Hoppinggreen · 09/09/2021 11:15

They are bloody awful and make me glad my DD is too old for dolls now.
She was into Monsters High and while some of the outfits and bodily proportions were a bit dubious they were certainly diverse and embraced differences

FlibbertyGiblets · 09/09/2021 11:14

I did laugh at tingly and clotted - and ducking bell has nearly finished me off Grin

YouMeandtheSpew · 09/09/2021 11:14

Clearly I’m not a cool mum because I think the outfit on the right in particular is absolutely vile for a child’s toy.

I don’t have daughters so I’m not familiar with these dolls but I’m sure I’ve read that the makers of these LOL dolls have form for this - didn’t they create a range where you dipped the LOL doll in cold water and sexy lingerie appeared?

And they also manufactured Bratz dolls which came in for similar criticism.

Kales29 · 09/09/2021 11:13

Not much different to Bratz dolls that used to be around tbf. No one ever said anything about them... that I can remember.

Saying that, I've never encouraged the lol trend with Dd. She loves her barbies!

Anothermothernamegame · 09/09/2021 11:12

Vile!

TableFlowerss · 09/09/2021 11:11

@FuckingFlumps

Still can’t with cloths that were suitable for adults rather than children…..

But you're implying every outfit barbie dolls came with was sexy or skimpy or showing too much flesh. That's simply inaccurate. Some of her outfits were possibly a little more grown up but the vast majority were pretty normal clothes similar to those the children playing with her would have owned. Which is a distinct difference with the dolls the OP is talling about.

That was my typo, so I’m sorry it came across that I said you can’t get normal clothes. I know she did come with normal clothes as as a pp mentioned, she’s more tame now.

I meant as a whole, Barbie was based on a ‘beautiful woman’. In real life people wanted to look like her, with the boobs, the legs…

The whole concept of Barbie was a most definitely sexualised.

I suppose it skis depends what someone’s definition of sexualised means. Mini crisp tops are all the range for teenagers now, some would say they aren’t appropriate but others would agree and say of course they’re fine….

GUPIGUPI · 09/09/2021 11:10

Makes me think of the scene in Love Actually when Emma Thompson is wrapping the Christmas presents.

5128gap · 09/09/2021 11:07

@TableFlowerss

*I'll grant you her boobs were disproportionatly large but of course the swimming costumes she wore were figure hugging, all swimming costumes should be figure hugging whether for a doll or real person*

Why could she not have come with a school uniform on or clothes that don’t show off as much skin s possible.

It was always bikinis, tiny shirts, tingly belly tops and clotted that weren’t appropriate for the kids she was targeted at.

School uniform, on a doll that looked like Barbie who was clearly an adult woman? The problem with Barbie is not her outfits.
IvyTwines2 · 09/09/2021 11:06

Have some of the commenters actually looked closely at the image? The doll on the right is wearing a studded dog collar, studded pony tail bands, a skin-tight red PVC catsuit with printed thonging up the legs and crotch - the latter not a region normally highlighted on dolls! - and ultra high fetish boots. You don't even see this sort of gear at 'alternative' clubs (punk and goth dog collars are not usually combined with a red pvc cat suit - that combination sends a very different signal). It's fetish gear. And children do know that some clothes are 'adult' and 'sexy'. They pick up social cues easily from the media, but it's a very different order of things when those adult, sexy clothing styles are presented to them as something it's considered appropriate for them to engage in imaginative play with too.

dudsville · 09/09/2021 11:05

I wouldn't like it and wouldn't buy/allow it. It reminds me of the first time I saw someone wearing a neglige (sp?) As a dress with a tee shirt under it. She was about 13 years old and just thought it was a pretty dress. Times are changing.

FuckingFlumps · 09/09/2021 11:04

Still can’t with cloths that were suitable for adults rather than children…..

But you're implying every outfit barbie dolls came with was sexy or skimpy or showing too much flesh. That's simply inaccurate. Some of her outfits were possibly a little more grown up but the vast majority were pretty normal clothes similar to those the children playing with her would have owned. Which is a distinct difference with the dolls the OP is talling about.

TableFlowerss · 09/09/2021 11:03

@Whinge

Why could she not have come with a school uniform on or clothes that don’t show off as much skin s possible.

It was always bikinis, tiny shirts, tingly belly tops and clotted that weren’t appropriate for the kids she was targeted at.

It really wasn't. I had plenty of Barbies who wore clothes I would wear today. Dresses, jackets, jeans etc. I'm not saying those outfits didn't exist, but to say she always wore outfits like you describe isn't true.

Yeah she had other clothes but there we’re definitely clothes that could be considered sexualised.

The whole concept of her was based on an adult, not a child…. She wasn’t meant to be a child…

LittleMysSister · 09/09/2021 11:02

@EmeraldShamrock

I also don't think i've seen a sexy Barbie. I'm sure there have been some over the years, but my Barbies as a child were vets, horseriders, babysitters etc. Barbie was sexy no matter how she dressed Hugh Hefner type Most white adult movie stars looked like barbie in the 80's, big breasts, tiny waist, blonde hair. Young girls couldn't wait to grow to be like barbie in her tiny bikinis.
Yes I agree with this. By design, Barbie was a 'sexy' doll, regardless of what she was wearing. The breasts, the legs, the pointed feel for heels, the hair, the tiny waist.

Also you have to remember the time when Barbie was made and how sexual she actually was likely seen as then, which is more of an accurate comparison with these dolls...obviously she is seen as fairly tame for today but I bet she wasn't back when she first came out.

Lorw · 09/09/2021 11:01

How do you tell a 13-14 year old that clothing is not appropriate when their favourite pop stars wear it and their dolls all wore it

Surely we should be teaching teenage girls that it is okay to dress however they like?

TableFlowerss · 09/09/2021 11:00

@FuckingFlumps

Why could she not have come with a school uniform on or clothes that don’t show off as much skin s possible.

It was always bikinis, tiny shirts, tingly belly tops and clotted that weren’t appropriate for the kids she was targeted at.

Barbie came with loads of outfits that were not swimming costumes, skimpy shirts or belly tops... Confused

And????

Still can’t with cloths that were suitable for adults rather than children…..

Lifeisaminestrone · 09/09/2021 11:00

These dolls are hideous.

I don’t like Barbie but she seems to have more ‘substance’ than these!

No way would I buy for my child.

Whinge · 09/09/2021 11:00

Why could she not have come with a school uniform on or clothes that don’t show off as much skin s possible.

It was always bikinis, tiny shirts, tingly belly tops and clotted that weren’t appropriate for the kids she was targeted at.

It really wasn't. I had plenty of Barbies who wore clothes I would wear today. Dresses, jackets, jeans etc. I'm not saying those outfits didn't exist, but to say she always wore outfits like you describe isn't true.

TableFlowerss · 09/09/2021 10:59

Oh ducking bell it says clotted, I meant clothes 😆

FuckingFlumps · 09/09/2021 10:59

Why could she not have come with a school uniform on or clothes that don’t show off as much skin s possible.

It was always bikinis, tiny shirts, tingly belly tops and clotted that weren’t appropriate for the kids she was targeted at.

Barbie came with loads of outfits that were not swimming costumes, skimpy shirts or belly tops... Confused

TableFlowerss · 09/09/2021 10:58

We’ll I made a mess if that 😂

I mean tiny shorts tiny belly tops 🤣🤣

TableFlowerss · 09/09/2021 10:57

I'll grant you her boobs were disproportionatly large but of course the swimming costumes she wore were figure hugging, all swimming costumes should be figure hugging whether for a doll or real person

Why could she not have come with a school uniform on or clothes that don’t show off as much skin s possible.

It was always bikinis, tiny shirts, tingly belly tops and clotted that weren’t appropriate for the kids she was targeted at.

FuckingFlumps · 09/09/2021 10:54

@TableFlowerss

No worse than barbie and her mates with figure hugging swimming costumes and massive boobs!
I'll grant you her boobs were disproportionatly large but of course the swimming costumes she wore were figure hugging, all swimming costumes should be figure hugging whether for a doll or real person.