Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are these dolls totally inappropriate?

284 replies

Itsbeen84yearss · 09/09/2021 08:00

Just seen the ad for these on channel 5 (in between peppa episodes). Marketed as ‘opposites’? I might be being bad minded but these look highly sexualised to me. I bought my dd an lol doll once but I think it had a school uniform on. Didn’t look like these at all. Why are they like this now?? Surely it’s sending all sorts of bad messages to kids

Are these dolls totally inappropriate?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
EngelbertsRumpispink · 09/09/2021 12:49

Red lace-up PVC, and spiked dog-collar type hair accesories.
Alrighty then.

camaleon · 09/09/2021 12:49

It is not that 'bleedin' obvious, you see? At least not for those among us who are not into fetishwear.

TatianaBis · 09/09/2021 12:46

@DoylyCarte

Yes because Googling “red pvc outfit” throws up so many fashionable lady choices… I actually can’t see any rubber male suggestions?

My ex used to run fetish nights at Torture Garden in the early noughties and I can confirm that a head to toe red pvc is indeed fetishwear 🤣. If you take off the t shirt underneath it ain’t nothing else. The t shirt is the only aspect that is not fetish in the whole outfit!!!

I linked a pic of a man wearing red latex leggings with black cross ties very similar to the doll.

Idk why anyone is bothering to dispute the red pvc look is inspired by fetishwear, it’s bleedin’ obvious.

SparrowNest · 09/09/2021 12:45

@User5490453456

I have inside knowledge on how the company markets these dolls. The whole image is based off "coolest girl in class" and the products are extremely expensive. It's primarily targeted to tweens/teens and the pester power they give their parents because having a doll is like being friends with the cool girl. The company spends enormous sums of money on influencer marketing (eg someone getting paid four figures to attend a single pr event, which is almost always unpaid in influencer marketing). They make sure the brand is associated with real life idols of these young girls which heightens pester power.

To be honest the outfits aren't really the issue. They're supposed to be edgy and a bit sexy and I wouldn't be surprised if they're based on fetish costumes. However at a glance, the doll on the left is inspired by "soft girl/fairy kei/gothic lolita" fashion which is very popular online, and the one on the right is a dupe for Kim Kardashian. Basically girls don't buy the dolls because of the sexiness factor even though it might look that way to adults. The selling point of those dolls are the surprise factor (there are tons of cheap plastic tat in each set to unpack) and the exclusivity and hype.

The outfits may appear inappropriate but no worse than what girls see on celebrities or a casual flip through Instagram. It'll also be a stretch to say the dolls are a bad influence since teen girls will eventually get exposed to slutty content all over social media anyway. The dolls are simply money making machines because of the huge markup and the fact that girls are pressured into wanting something that's reasonably well over any parent's budget. The prices range from £20 (blind boxes that cost £5 from other brands) to £200+ (dollhouses).

It feels like a gateway into irresponsible spending as an adult. The idea that something is priced just out of reach but you "have to have it". It's also introduces kids to status symbols and judging or being judged for no being able to afford something.

I can understand that they’d want to associate the dolls with teens in the minds of younger girls, but I’m pretty sceptical that they’re actually concentrating on marketing them to teens.

Have you met any teenagers?

Sootybear · 09/09/2021 12:44

I always thought Barbie was a teenager as she had a little sister and a boyfriend. You can get Barbies which are all different sizes now and colours and hairstyles. Some are marketed at younger girls while some are definitely collectables for older people. I used to have a Sindy ballerina doll who wore trendy clothes after her ballet classes. Notable was her gold pencil skirt and red blouse. We used to put on fashion shows with them at school.

Those LOL dolls do look a bit over the top and I probably wouldn't buy them for a child. Barbie is much more wholesome.

DoylyCarte · 09/09/2021 12:37

Yes because Googling “red pvc outfit” throws up so many fashionable lady choices… I actually can’t see any rubber male suggestions?

My ex used to run fetish nights at Torture Garden in the early noughties and I can confirm that a head to toe red pvc is indeed fetishwear 🤣. If you take off the t shirt underneath it ain’t nothing else. The t shirt is the only aspect that is not fetish in the whole outfit!!!

Are these dolls totally inappropriate?
Are these dolls totally inappropriate?
Caleva · 09/09/2021 12:32

Yuck.

Magenta82 · 09/09/2021 12:31
Hmm

Assumptions are interesting @rainbowmash

I'm pretty active in the local fet scene, I helped set up and run a successful and popular local munch. I go to a variety of clubs, events and parties where actual BDSM and fet play takes place and am friends with people who are heavily involved with the rubber/PVC fet scene including someone who runs PVC and vac bed events.

What I'm not into are dance clubs with a dress code like some of the more well known ones that make the papers.

TatianaBis · 09/09/2021 12:28

@TreeSmuggler

I could see both sides at first but pp has changed my mind with this post.

Why are these sexualised dolls never aimed at boys

So true. Imagine the right sided doll was supposed to represent a boy instead of a girl, and was dressed in men's fetish wear. Say a gimp suit, or maybe a pair of arse less chaps and some nipple clamps. Would that be considered normal and just a bit of fun?

Action man and Ken were pretty buff, but straight men don’t tend to sexualise their appearance as much as gay men, and neither does society so a sexualised male may not sell so well to boys. I suspect it would be regarded as looking ‘gay’.

Having said that boys do get pressure on their appearance from popular culture - one of my sons is preoccupied with diet and working out at 15.

TheMarzipanDildo · 09/09/2021 12:25

@Lweji

Not my cup of tea. But, sexualised? Hmm
The one of the left is wearing the full Lolita get-up. Pretty sexual if you ask me.

It’s just an odd choice by the designer.

CaptSkippy · 09/09/2021 12:25

@TreeSmuggler

I could see both sides at first but pp has changed my mind with this post.

Why are these sexualised dolls never aimed at boys

So true. Imagine the right sided doll was supposed to represent a boy instead of a girl, and was dressed in men's fetish wear. Say a gimp suit, or maybe a pair of arse less chaps and some nipple clamps. Would that be considered normal and just a bit of fun?

The dolls for boys is a whole other typed of f*cked up. It leads increasingly more often to steroid use and excessive work out routines.
MsFannySqueers · 09/09/2021 12:24

Those dolls are grim and inappropriate OP. Does anyone remember the Sheena doll? She sported a rather fetching lilac trouser suit. She had short auburn hair but had a miraculous contraption on her back that you could turn and she grew a long ponytail that could be styled. She must have been considerably cheaper than Barbie otherwise I wouldn’t have got one. My Nan made her a whole wardrobe of clothes none of which funnily enough included fetish wear!

TatianaBis · 09/09/2021 12:24

@InPraiseOfBacchus

Googling for (male!) latex adult fetishwear and claiming that it's analogous to a doll's vinyl-sprayed fabric outfit is utterly bizarre.

First of all it makes no odds if it’s pvc or latex - they’re shiny red rubber/plastic.

Utterly bizarre to deny that the doll’s red leggings are inspired by adult fetishware. Red, shiny leggings with criss cross black ties. Googled for a pic I’ve seen people wearing them. Linked a male as cba to find a female.

CaptSkippy · 09/09/2021 12:21

@RantyAunty

Mine are way too old for dolls so I had to look them up.

Absolutely disgusting. You have to wonder what will come out later about their creator issac larian

The fucked up lingerie and the bizarre looking genitals on these dolls.

OMG, at first I thought that dolls was smeared with blood.
camaleon · 09/09/2021 12:20

@Flyingantday

I’m not sure about this one… my dd had a few LOLs and it was mainly the bits and bobs, play sand etc in the packaging she enjoyed the most, plus anything that changes colour in the cold etc. I avoid them if possible because of the excessive plastic. In terms of the clothing - she liked swapping things around, putting skirts/shoes on, but wouldn’t aspire to dress or look that way and had many other toys which were played with more - from tractors to sylvanian families. I think in her mind they go I’m the same category as a build a bear cat in a tutu or a trolls figurine… cartoonish. I agree that as kids have no preconception about clothing etc, she would just see “cheerleader in sparkly pants” rather than “sexy cheerleader”

However I think as adults, there is a worry about the normalisation of certain looks and body types - particularly figures only possible with plastic surgery or extreme weight loss. Even down to Disney dolls with extreme thigh gaps and waists narrower than their foreheads. Also, the issue of sexualised images/dolls which would appeal to paedophiles as much as 5 year olds makes me feel uneasy, so I’m really not sure.

Those tree change dolls are so beautiful though.

I am no expert, but my guess is that paedophiles are attracted by the "innocent", non-sexual aspect of childhood much more than by this teen's look. The more innocent, the better..

We may not like the style or the promotion of certain body types directly or indirectly, but I see no sexualisation whatsoever there. And I very much doubt children do.

Flyingantday · 09/09/2021 12:16

I’m not sure about this one… my dd had a few LOLs and it was mainly the bits and bobs, play sand etc in the packaging she enjoyed the most, plus anything that changes colour in the cold etc. I avoid them if possible because of the excessive plastic. In terms of the clothing - she liked swapping things around, putting skirts/shoes on, but wouldn’t aspire to dress or look that way and had many other toys which were played with more - from tractors to sylvanian families. I think in her mind they go I’m the same category as a build a bear cat in a tutu or a trolls figurine… cartoonish. I agree that as kids have no preconception about clothing etc, she would just see “cheerleader in sparkly pants” rather than “sexy cheerleader”

However I think as adults, there is a worry about the normalisation of certain looks and body types - particularly figures only possible with plastic surgery or extreme weight loss. Even down to Disney dolls with extreme thigh gaps and waists narrower than their foreheads. Also, the issue of sexualised images/dolls which would appeal to paedophiles as much as 5 year olds makes me feel uneasy, so I’m really not sure.

Those tree change dolls are so beautiful though.

camaleon · 09/09/2021 12:08

@TreeSmuggler

I could see both sides at first but pp has changed my mind with this post.

Why are these sexualised dolls never aimed at boys

So true. Imagine the right sided doll was supposed to represent a boy instead of a girl, and was dressed in men's fetish wear. Say a gimp suit, or maybe a pair of arse less chaps and some nipple clamps. Would that be considered normal and just a bit of fun?

Plenty of dolls for boys are full of mucles/naked torsos/etc.

And from where I watch, what you are considering sexualised really depends on your perception. I see nothing sexual in those dolls. I may not like them and I would not buy them unless requested explicitly.

I still fail to see the sexualised bit (unless you can see pretty much on every thing).

tickledtiger · 09/09/2021 12:07

To the innocent eye they probably look fashionable but there’s such a thing as fashion based on fetish gear. The one on the rights trousers are suspect.

I think they’re ugly and they make Barbie look like a good role model in comparison.

TreeSmuggler · 09/09/2021 12:05

I could see both sides at first but pp has changed my mind with this post.

Why are these sexualised dolls never aimed at boys

So true. Imagine the right sided doll was supposed to represent a boy instead of a girl, and was dressed in men's fetish wear. Say a gimp suit, or maybe a pair of arse less chaps and some nipple clamps. Would that be considered normal and just a bit of fun?

InPraiseOfBacchus · 09/09/2021 12:05

@Itsbeen84yearss

I admit Barbie wasn’t a great role model in many ways but I do think this is in another stratosphere of inappropriate and yes I do think some clothes are more sexual than others. I mean you don’t see jogging bottoms and oversized woolly jumpers in sex shops do you?
Don't google "knitwear fetish"!!! (it's actually quite a big scene!)

There's a serious point here though - you're likely to find literally anything replicated in adult kink products/scenes. Most likely a lot of stuff many posters have in their own wardrobes, too.

The red PVC (not latex! very different in fact!) doll is covered neck-to-ankles and is wearing a full-length cotton t shirt under her jacket. Googling for (male!) latex adult fetishwear and claiming that it's analogous to a doll's vinyl-sprayed fabric outfit is utterly bizarre.

If you're scrolling through gay male rubber couture to make a point about a doll who's wearing something in a vague similar colour and texture... maybe you ought to have a look at yourself.

GreyhoundG1rl · 09/09/2021 12:01

@Potteringshed

Where do you live that red latex or tutus are fashionable?

Looks like the kind of clothes I'd see young people wearing to go clubbing in Glasgow or London. Not necessarily fetish wear - trendy but a bit alt I'd say. No more sexualised than Bratz or Barbie.

But they're aimed at 5 year olds, not people of clubbing age 😬 They're bloody awful.
RantyAunty · 09/09/2021 12:01

Mine are way too old for dolls so I had to look them up.

Absolutely disgusting. You have to wonder what will come out later about their creator issac larian

The fucked up lingerie and the bizarre looking genitals on these dolls.

Are these dolls totally inappropriate?
TatianaBis · 09/09/2021 11:57

@Lweji

Not my cup of tea. But, sexualised? Hmm
red latex fetish leggings
RevolvingPivot · 09/09/2021 11:55

My dd has 7 of the big ones and 100s of the small ones. She wouldn't wear what they wear.

JaninaDuszejko · 09/09/2021 11:55

They are dreadful. My DDs are far too old for dolls now (and stopped playing with them around 9 or 10) but we were exclusively a Lottie house (boxed Barbies went straight to the charity shop). Love Lottie dolls and all their outfits.

Swipe left for the next trending thread