Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are these dolls totally inappropriate?

284 replies

Itsbeen84yearss · 09/09/2021 08:00

Just seen the ad for these on channel 5 (in between peppa episodes). Marketed as ‘opposites’? I might be being bad minded but these look highly sexualised to me. I bought my dd an lol doll once but I think it had a school uniform on. Didn’t look like these at all. Why are they like this now?? Surely it’s sending all sorts of bad messages to kids

Are these dolls totally inappropriate?
OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
camaleon · 09/09/2021 15:53

@YouMeandtheSpew

The one of the left is wearing the full Lolita get-up. Pretty sexual if you ask me.

You’re right of course but I suspect lots of people haven’t read or seen Lolita so don’t see the reference.

10 years or so ago, a retailer (I think Woolworths?) sold a range of bedroom furniture for young girls under the brand name ‘Lolita’ and had to withdraw it after the inevitable backlash. Obviously not everyone is familiar with Russian literature but it was unbelievable that no one on their marketing or product or design teams thought to have a quick Google of the word first.

Dressing like a 'lolita' is a cultural reference, not one based on the book per se. If you had read you would know the doll does not match at all the description.

It is a bit much to treat everybody who is not seeing the dolls exactly the same way as not intellectually gifted enough.

TheMarzipanDildo · 09/09/2021 14:37

YouMeandtheSpew

Exactly.

YouMeandtheSpew · 09/09/2021 14:17

The one of the left is wearing the full Lolita get-up. Pretty sexual if you ask me.

You’re right of course but I suspect lots of people haven’t read or seen Lolita so don’t see the reference.

10 years or so ago, a retailer (I think Woolworths?) sold a range of bedroom furniture for young girls under the brand name ‘Lolita’ and had to withdraw it after the inevitable backlash. Obviously not everyone is familiar with Russian literature but it was unbelievable that no one on their marketing or product or design teams thought to have a quick Google of the word first.

SteppedOnBloodyLego · 09/09/2021 14:05

@Mummadeze

Lots of dolls look like this now. They don’t look sexualised to me. Just fun and fashionable.
They don’t look sexualised to you????!! Jesus wept Agree with PP, they look like littler hookers
FuckingFlumps · 09/09/2021 13:52

I promise you I don't think any of my opinions on these are 'cool' or 'clever'

The trouble is that's exactly how you and others are coming across. You don't see it as inappropriate so your argument is that the problem must be in the morals, views and minds of those who do see it as inappropriate.

It's perfectly reasonable to see these dolls as inappropriate toys for the children they were designed for without automatically having a mind that lives in the gutter. The 2 things are no synonymous.

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 09/09/2021 13:51

Luckily for me, by the time LOL turned up, DD had completely grown out of anything girly, and was never really into dolls except Monster High.

myheartskippedabeat · 09/09/2021 13:47

These are revolting
My daughter is 5
Safe to say santa won't be delivering one of those hear I can tell you that now!!!!!

DoylyCarte · 09/09/2021 13:46

The fact that you don’t see fetishwear on those dolls doesn’t mean that it’s not there. A bit like having your eyes closed during hide and seek.

camaleon · 09/09/2021 13:44

Let's leave it. I promise you I don't think any of my opinions on these are 'cool' or 'clever', nor do I feel contempt towards anybody else's. It may seem very naive (or 'faux' naive as you put it to add your little aggression there too) but it is how I saw it and I happened to write my view.

YOur explanation about your username is a perfect illustration on how to read too much into something for no reason.

CaptSkippy · 09/09/2021 13:44

@SquirryTheSquirrel

It's primarily targeted to tweens/teens

Really? I'm middle-aged but even in my long-ago youth, girls didn't really play with dolls beyond primary school age.

I remember that. No more barbies by the time you were actually a teen. At that point you're supposed to be the "barbie" so to speak. At that point you're suppsed to focus on your own appearance and be well versed in pop culture.
GreyhoundG1rl · 09/09/2021 13:43

(not sure at what age 'fucking' becomes 'appropriate' as username)
This is Mumsnet. It's not aimed at 5 year olds, unlike those abominations which are; despite the attempt to persuade us they're actually aimed at teenagers.
As if...

FuckingFlumps · 09/09/2021 13:39

But the dolls as presented in first photo do not seem to me sexualised per se and I very much doubt they do to a 5 years old.

Just because they wouldn't seem sexulised to a 5 year old doesn't mean that teh adults designing them should make them. Many things would pass over a child's head due to their innocence but that doesn't mean we shouldn't still have standards on what is and isn't acceptable. You might think it's cool and clever to say that you don't see them as sexulised but you're clearly in a minority and the intention of the designers was very obviously not innocent.

not sure at what age 'fucking' becomes 'appropriate' as username

Not at all sure what my username has to do with anything but if you must know it's because all my toddler wanted to eat whilst he was cutting his molars was flumps and I got sick of buying more fucking flumps. If you read something more into it then that's ok you. Hmm

camaleon · 09/09/2021 13:33

@PinkTonic

You don't need to be into fetishwear to know the outfit is inappropriate for a doll aimed at 5 year olds

Exactly. So much denial and faux naivety. The red doll is wearing a full pvc suit and a studded collar with a ring at the front. Cute and fashionable? Ay right. Anyone who doesn’t admit this is blatantly normalising the sexualisation of children is either extraordinarily gullible or part of the problem.

So count me in. Does it make you feel any better to go around knowing that much about other people based on the fact they don't see fetishwear and sex on those dolls.
camaleon · 09/09/2021 13:31

@FuckingFlumps, my point is that not everybody sees as you do and not 'appropriate', whatever appropriate for a doll means, is not the same as sexualised.

The showing underwear thing under water, if true, is a cut above and I would consider that very sexualised. But the dolls as presented in first photo do not seem to me sexualised per se and I very much doubt they do to a 5 years old.

(not sure at what age 'fucking' becomes 'appropriate' as username)

PinkTonic · 09/09/2021 13:28

You don't need to be into fetishwear to know the outfit is inappropriate for a doll aimed at 5 year olds

Exactly. So much denial and faux naivety. The red doll is wearing a full pvc suit and a studded collar with a ring at the front. Cute and fashionable? Ay right. Anyone who doesn’t admit this is blatantly normalising the sexualisation of children is either extraordinarily gullible or part of the problem.

TreeSmuggler · 09/09/2021 13:18

Having said that boys do get pressure on their appearance from popular culture - one of my sons is preoccupied with diet and working out at 15.

Yes this is a big issue but a different one imo. Yes Ken might be muscled but would you see him on the shelf wearing a leather fetish outfit and carrying a cat o nine tails, no you wouldn't. It's impossible to even imagine.

User5490453456 · 09/09/2021 13:04

Going on a tangent, the company plagiarised the entire image of a blogger and turned it into a doll: www.thefashionlaw.com/last-year-mga-introduced-a-new-l-o-l-surprise-doll-and-it-looks-a-whole-lot-like-this-artist/
The CEO was extremely rude to the blogger on Twitter when asked about it and not sure how the story ended. I think she wanted to sue but obviously lacked funds and would probably not win anyway.

A lot of the LOL dolls are based on grossly exaggerated street fashion, celebrities, pop stars, influencers etc. It's simply whatever is trendy and edgy right now. If you look at the concert outfits of Cardi B or Meghan Thee Stallion, they are virtually identical to fetishwear and nobody cares (nor should they). Many of the dolls are actually more tame in design and focus on cute styles but it's basically whatever appeals to girls.

Yes, I agree with PP that although they seem to be marketed to tweens, a huge demographic is between 5 and 10. The cheap products inside never match the price and there's a MASSIVE amount of plastic packaging waste. I'm not even a typical eco-warrior/Fridays for Future person but the wastage in a LOL ball is insane. I personally don't allow DD to have them. She can complain all she wants but she'll be getting a lecture in capitalism and marketing from me Grin

Ajl46 · 09/09/2021 13:03

@Mummadeze

Lots of dolls look like this now. They don’t look sexualised to me. Just fun and fashionable.
The eyes are far too large surely?!
GreyhoundG1rl · 09/09/2021 13:02

It's primarily targeted to tweens/teens
Wtf? Of course they're not 🤦‍♀️

Evesgarden · 09/09/2021 13:01

YANBU

I HATE the LOL dolls. Why the fuck do dolls need to be in fishnet tights and knickers.

And the names - fucking spicy babe?

SquirryTheSquirrel · 09/09/2021 12:58

It's primarily targeted to tweens/teens

Really? I'm middle-aged but even in my long-ago youth, girls didn't really play with dolls beyond primary school age.

TakeMeBackTo1980 · 09/09/2021 12:54

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8732677/One-Britains-best-selling-dolls-reveal-secret-adult-style-lingerie-plunged-water.html

Yeah, and when you put them in water it reveals the lingerie they have on. Fucking gross.

Are these dolls totally inappropriate?
FuckingFlumps · 09/09/2021 12:51

@camaleon

It is not that 'bleedin' obvious, you see? At least not for those among us who are not into fetishwear.
You don't need to be into fetishwear to know the outfit is inappropriate for a doll aimed at 5 year olds. Hmm
EngelbertsRumpispink · 09/09/2021 12:50

*accessories

EmeraldShamrock · 09/09/2021 12:50

Having said that boys do get pressure on their appearance from popular culture - one of my sons is preoccupied with diet and working out at 15.
Young men/teenage boys are definitely under pressure now, watching love Island and viewing Instagram.
Lots of them body shave, eyebrows shaped, sun bed, some of the teenage boys my niece's hang out with are chiselled and sculptured with muscles.
My nephew 14 was suicidal after some counselling his slim body was the main focus of his despair.

Swipe left for the next trending thread