Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If you worked in London

205 replies

LondonIsCalling · 08/09/2021 19:37

And live 40 minutes away from the job, would you drive or take the train?
Job is at a London hospital

OP posts:
NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 10/09/2021 08:25

Given that you're on a consultant's salary, and it takes the same to drive in or go by public transport I'd drive and pay the parking fees.

Did she say she's on a consultant's salary? How would anyone get paid a consultant's salary for working 9-5?

I was a van driver in London about 35 years ago. Even then, 40 minutes' drive from St Stephen's Hospital (as it was then) at peak times would have been no further than Knightsbridge or Hammersmith. OP, have you actually set Google Maps to show you the journey time to arrive at C&W at 08:45 on a weekday, rather than leaving home at 21:15, when you were looking it up?

Malin52 · 10/09/2021 08:19

If you are coming in via the M4 A40 then train. I used to commute in the opposite direction by car sometimes (Battersea to Feltham) and the queues coming in to London tailed all the way back to my off junction. Seriously. Train. Try both a couple of times though.

WhateverHappenedToMe · 10/09/2021 08:10

Train.

If you're lucky enough to have parking available it's likely to be very expensive.

SquirmOfEels · 10/09/2021 07:56

@LondonIsCalling

Obviously I don't want to give my exact location. By car it shows on Google that it takes 40 minutes from my house. I will work the standard hours 9-5.
That'll mean no further out that zone 4 to the S/W or zone 2 to the N/E based on the driving time

Which means there will be a plethora of options on public transport

Presumably OP means Tube or overground when she says train, as there aren't any railway stations near C&W. Even allowing for time to get to the station and then walk eg from Fulham Broadway or West Brompton to the hospital, you could be looking at 40 mins from roughly those areas, even if the actual time on the train is much less.

(Though if coming from the N or E then I think you could get in from much greater distances in 40 mins on tube/overground, but OP says it's similar time regardless of means)

SquirmOfEels · 10/09/2021 07:34

If it's 40 minutes regardless of which method, I'd choose train - no parking hassle, less congestion, it's a win for everyone.

You could use your car if there was disruption on the trains (but remember to leave more than the normal 40 mins in that case, as everyone will be doing it those days) Though because 40 mins means you're still pretty close in, if trains were all to cock, you could probably do the journey by bus or a combo of bus/tube/different rail line.

KittenKong · 10/09/2021 07:29

And the roads are getting narrower - so many lanes are being taken for bike lanes (Park Lane is a nightmare now as it’s gone from 2 open lanes to one car, one bike and one bus).

I have seen this happening a lot in London (to encourage us not drive) and last weekend drove along what was a 4 lane road - which is now a 1 and a half (the 2 car lanes aren’t really wide enough for 2 larger cars to pass).

DarlingFell · 10/09/2021 07:25

Train for a plethora of reasons. London traffic is awful as is the style of driving compared to outside of London. I used to live in Notting Hill, I love driving but can’t say I enjoyed it in central London. I now live rurally, which has its own challenges driving wise, but London driving is shit. Too much traffic, manic, crazy drivers who don’t indicate, pull out in front of you, take too many risks, aggressive cyclists everywhere with no road sense.

Train every time if travelling is to central London

JADS · 10/09/2021 06:27

I worked at CWH 10 years ago. My boss used to drive. The car park was great, but she wax always late. I took the tube to Fulham Broadway and was pretty much always on time. If you were starting early ie 7am I would consider driving, but otherwise no.

sheusesmagazines · 10/09/2021 03:49

I think I’m a minority here and I drive to work from east London zone 3 to NW London zone 1. But only because

  1. I have free parking
  2. Times are tight in the morning and I drop off my child to nursery on my way
  3. Car is quicker than public transport for my journey - usually
  4. No congestion charge
  5. I have a ULEZ compliant car

You have to do the journey in real life though. Google maps says my journey takes 35 minutes but it usually takes an hour most days. I also have a buffer where I can be up to 30 minutes late without it being an issue.

Most rat runs and shortcuts have been cut off since the pandemic to create low traffic neighbourhoods (fair enough!) so don’t bank on finding a secret back way to get there either (I used to be able to save 10-15 minutes this way).

Thomasina79 · 10/09/2021 03:33

I drive to my NHS non hospital job 30 minutes away, but I can park for free. If I could t I would get the bus. I used to work in a hospital in south london, but paid for a parking pass at £80 a month and that was nearly ten years ago. Nothing is cheap in London unfortunately.

bengalcat · 10/09/2021 03:26

Train . Even if you are able to get a staff parking permit finding a space with a 9am start might be a challenge .

NiceGerbil · 10/09/2021 02:38

No one would normally drive in London more central because the public transport is so good.

If it were sparse and unreliable people would drive.

Fewer cars in town is a good thing.

NiceGerbil · 10/09/2021 02:36

Buses
Delivery vans and lorries for all the food and retail outlets
Black cabs
Roadworks v common. Burst water mains. Collisions and criminal incidents.
Closures sometimes due to something suspicious or actual
Rich people getting chauffered about
That sort of thing

In general though the fact that the tube etc is v good and the charges leads to it not actually being too busy in town proper. At least the bits I know/ have worked in.

Where I work though the driving conditions would be tricky with scooters cyclists pedestrians motor bikes etc nipping in and out all over the place. I wouldn't fancy it.

When congestion in London is mentioned it's generally in the areas outside Central London. Where there isn't such good tube etc. And it's more residential. People doing school run or driving to more local job.

North circular for example. Shunt on there and it's screwed for ages. And the traffic is often extremely heavy.

Different ball games.

Animum2 · 10/09/2021 02:31

I worked in central London for 15 years, door to door was just under an hour using London transport, for most that's the normal thing

YukoandHiro · 10/09/2021 02:29

Depends on where you live ana where the workplace is

BarbaraofSeville · 10/09/2021 02:25

I'm now wondering, if no-one would normally drive in London, what's causing all the traffic?

NiceGerbil · 10/09/2021 01:10

Where does your train go into?

Is it a fairly reliable line?

Are there alternatives if strike or something?

I would never drive into a central London job and I've never met anyone who does!

KatherineJaneway · 09/09/2021 21:49

I wouldn't. Google says 40 minutes but I'd actually do a few trial runs, both morning and evening to check reality. As pp have said, where can you park? How much would that cost and is a space guaranteed.

KittenKong · 09/09/2021 10:44

It can take me that long to get not all that far across London!

puffyisgood · 09/09/2021 10:43

If 40 minutes is accurate OP must live close - managing to average as much as 10mph at 8-9am on a weekday would be pretty good going.

sophiiee · 09/09/2021 10:22

Train/ public transport every time - dont be so bloody selfish bringing pollution into our city!

TheRabbitStoleMyHat · 09/09/2021 08:59

Train, without a doubt!

I used to commute to a central London hospital to work and couldn’t imagine driving for one minute. Sit on the train or tube and read the Metro.

RampantIvy · 09/09/2021 07:24

I don't understand why anyone would consider driving to work in London. I used to commute to Oxford St from Croydon in the late 1970s, and the traffic was horrendous even then.

Public transport is plentiful and frequent. Leave the car at home.

hibbledibble · 09/09/2021 07:02

Don't drive to Chelsea and Westminster! I know the area well and traffic is horrific. It's often quicker to walk than drive, and I'm not exaggerating.

Public transport, or better yet, cycling, is the way to go.

sbhydrogen · 09/09/2021 06:25

Train 100%. Traffic around C&W is awful.