Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New NI tax. How are people meant to afford this?

540 replies

OnTheBrink1 · 08/09/2021 18:51

We bought our house just before covid, got a mortgage that pushed us quite a bit but worked it all out and it’s been doable since then. We needed to push the mortgage quite a bit because we were upsizing to get an extra bedroom for the kids and a downstairs loo and in our area and from what we had before it was a jump.
Been managing since then but no progression opportunities in DH job during the last 18 months due to covid it seems as recruitment was largely paused.
However, now we will now have to pay an extra almost £900 per year on this new tax. £73 I make it.
We don’t have any benefits of any kind.
It’s going to be quite a struggle to afford the mortgage and still maintain the car (which is old but we need for work and kids stuff) plus all the usual bills and food. Kids are between 8-12 and need bus passes, constant uniform and all manner of expenses of course.
I mean we will struggle by but it’s going to be tough to afford that extra £73 a month when we had all the mortgage planned.
Just don’t get how they can bring it in so soon when it’s such an increase. How are others in a more difficult position going to afford this? People will be loosing their houses surely?

OP posts:
MyPatronusIsACat · 09/09/2021 11:18

@portico

Of course I looked at my post before posting it.

Then surely you must have seen what a supremely ridiculous and pathetic suggestion it was, saying people should pay back their furlough money.

When people are whingeing about the 1.25% rise in N.I. how the fuck do you think people are going to pay back so much furlough money (running into 20 grand or more,) when they had a 20% drop in income for about a year.

Although, from the stupidity of your suggestion, you probably think people on furlough got the furlough money, in addition to their wages!!! Probably think they're rolling around in a bed of 50 pound notes...

Just when I think this site can't get more batshit.

MyPatronusIsACat · 09/09/2021 11:17

@portico

Of course I looked at my post before posting it.

Then surely you must have seen what a supremely ridiculous and pathetic suggestion it was, saying people should pay back their furlough money.

When people are whingeing about the 1.25% rise in N.I. how the fuck do you think people are going to pay back so much furlough money (running into 20 grand or more,) when they had a 20% drop in income for about a year.

Although, from the stupidity of your suggestion, you probably think people on furlough got the furlough money, in addition to their wages!!! Probably think they're rolling around in a bed of 50 fifty pound notes...

Just when I think this site can't get more batshit.

Peregrina · 09/09/2021 11:04

Much depends on what our taxes pay for. For many of us now, we don't expect the Government to spend it wisely on our behalf - it will be money for chums and for vanity projects.

portico · 09/09/2021 11:02

Typos listed in upper case:

Well, I will make sure fellow voters and myself will give a drubbing to the local Tory MP in our marginal constituency - AT THE NEXT ELECTION. Sadly, Labour WILL do well. Still more taxes.

A rise in NI is the main starter in an expensive meal out. The main meal will be paying for the cost of pandemic. Pudding will be paying for housing and maintaining refugees fleeing their home countries - with more knock on impacts to state services.

portico · 09/09/2021 11:00

Well, I will make sure fellow voters and myself will give a drubbing to the local Tory MP in our marginal constituency. Sadly, Labour to do well. Still more taxes.

A rise in NI is the main starter in an expensive meal out. The main meal will be paying for the cost of pandemic. Pudding will be paying for housing and maintaining refugees fleeing their home countries - with more knock on impacts to state services.

OnTheBrink1 · 09/09/2021 10:46

@Clavinova

OnTheBrink1 However obviously couldn’t have prepared for a pandemic and my DH (main earner) and the entire staff of his workplace had his salary slashed by 15% for 8 months in 2020.That took up quite a bit of savings and safety net ... Well, it’s all relative. DH works in a city. The commute alone is over 4K per year.

Was he able to work from home during the pandemic and save money on his commute?

For some of it yes, but the trouble is it hasnt really saved much money because he still has to go in for park of the week - it’s no longer better to buy a season ticket but going in for 2 or 3 days per week actually costs so much more. Also the station car park is very dear and hasnt brought back weekly or monthly parking tickets yet - it’s just day to day which is £9 per day on top. There is talk of 3 day per week season tickets but nothing has materialised yet
OP posts:
themidnighttrain · 09/09/2021 10:25

@Nanananani

As a high earner I want to pay more tax to help others. If I felt for a second that it wouldn’t be swallowed up by red tape and middle management in the NHS which desperately needs a complete overhaul then I’d be all for it. I’m also sad that it hits the working but not the affluent pensioners, doesn’t touch the asset rich and allows families to pass vast wealth.

I’m a high earner in Scotland. £130,000 a year. Massively lucky- I had working class parents, started my professional career with substantial debt.

No parental help for house buying so big mortgage buying for first time in 2015. We will inherit nothing.

I pay private healthcare for whole family.
Provide financial support for parents who are still working low paid jobs in 60s
Pay £46,933 pa income tax
Pay £6465 NI

  • £1,625 new NI

I know high earners are meant to take it all on the chin and accept it without complaining because there’s always someone worse off but not all of us top 1% are tories awaiting land and a country pile. For some of us it’s still quite hard to handover another £1600 a year to see it disappear into a mismanaged abyss.

I don't earn as much as you, but I can relate to all of your points.

No help for buying my (tiny) home, no expectation of inheritance, propping up family financially, and willing to support the NHS if there was any chances my taxes would actually reach the NHS.

I think it's quite something that the gut reaction to the news is 'if the money would actually be used properly, it wouldn't hurt as much'.

We clearly all don't trust our politicians. What a vote of confidence...

themidnighttrain · 09/09/2021 10:18

@forinborin

I feel for you, OP. Similar drop here, but a single parent. I cannot quite understand the gloating about rich fat cats like us having to pay for this. I won't benefit from the improvement in public services, not being entitled to public funds, and I have two of my own parents to fully fund in another country where there's zero social support. On a budget like everyone else.

Of course I won't starve, but that's my usual charity money gone, genuinely hope it makes everyone happier.

I completely sympathise with sending money to your parents.

A lot people can't fathom that when you're a higher earner, it doesn't mean the money is all for you. Some of us already live quite frugally, because we're financially supporting relatives who wouldn't be able to stand on their own two feet without us.

Like you, I'm also going have to cut back on giving to charity. It's that, or cut back on money to my family, and I can't do that. I'm all they have.

Gothichouse40 · 09/09/2021 10:17

I think I commented months ago that I knew this Pandemic would need to be paid for. We are in for hard times and my advice is , if you can, save your money, do without as many luxuries that you can. I know for young families it's very difficult. My own family will be hit quite hard. If I had one piece of advice to give, don't mortgage yourself up to the wire. We are not even at normal interest rates, if these start to rise you will be in difficulty. I experienced this way back in the 80s, as a young mum with a family. It was hell and we knew people who were repossessed etc. It's the main reason I believe everyone should have a savings buffer and Ive never been a mad spender. Buy what you need. Martin Lewis website has really good advice for anyone struggling financially. I very much feel for the younger generation and the low paid, the Pandemic was nobody's fault. As an older person I would also like to say I don't and will never,ever vote Conservative. This has really shown that all they care about is lining their old school tie pals pockets. For ordinary working people, they care not a jot. For any of you struggling please do visit Citizen's Advice, sometimes your library will know locally where you can go for help.

Clavinova · 09/09/2021 10:13

OnTheBrink1
However obviously couldn’t have prepared for a pandemic and my DH (main earner) and the entire staff of his workplace had his salary slashed by 15% for 8 months in 2020.That took up quite a bit of savings and safety net ...
Well, it’s all relative. DH works in a city. The commute alone is over 4K per year.

Was he able to work from home during the pandemic and save money on his commute?

zenthoughtsonlythanks · 09/09/2021 10:03

Overnight we appear to have turned into a one party nation.

I don't any of us should feel comfortable with the dire state of politics in this country and what this means for our future. The very fact Boris had no qualms in overturning his manifesto, his own party policies and shove most of his future voters under a bus is quite alarming to say the least, and he expects to get away with it I assume after all where is the opposition - totally vacant.

The only thing this policy has done is bring the country together to unite against it.

Nanananani · 09/09/2021 09:58

As a high earner I want to pay more tax to help others. If I felt for a second that it wouldn’t be swallowed up by red tape and middle management in the NHS which desperately needs a complete overhaul then I’d be all for it. I’m also sad that it hits the working but not the affluent pensioners, doesn’t touch the asset rich and allows families to pass vast wealth.

I’m a high earner in Scotland. £130,000 a year. Massively lucky- I had working class parents, started my professional career with substantial debt.

No parental help for house buying so big mortgage buying for first time in 2015. We will inherit nothing.

I pay private healthcare for whole family.
Provide financial support for parents who are still working low paid jobs in 60s
Pay £46,933 pa income tax
Pay £6465 NI

  • £1,625 new NI

I know high earners are meant to take it all on the chin and accept it without complaining because there’s always someone worse off but not all of us top 1% are tories awaiting land and a country pile. For some of us it’s still quite hard to handover another £1600 a year to see it disappear into a mismanaged abyss.

Xenia · 09/09/2021 09:54

Tax is far too high, full stop, on everyone and neither main political party is low tax now, sadly.So voters don't get an effective choice. The only hope is if enough Tory voters make enough complaints to their MPs etc that the low tax wing of the Tory party might ultimately prevail. I won't hold my breath.

OnTheBrink1 · 09/09/2021 09:48

Thanks for your comments. I know I am not by any means the worst off, of course there are so many more people in worse positions, but this is true for all of us, in all aspects of life.
In answer to a few- yes we do earn a above average - around the 70k mark (not 100k as some have suggested) It’s not fallen into our lap by any means, we have had times of not being able to afford to eat properly earlier in our lives and getting a job that pays well has been 20 years plus of slog in terms of passing exams and 12 hour working days, stress and illness due to stress.
We got out mortgage on a fixed deal and budgeted for the repayments. It was a new mortgage before covid. I think most people try to get the most they can afford if upsizing? It’s hard at first but as the years roll on, salary goes up and mortgage payments stay generally the same (if on a fixed) so it’s becomes easier and easier to afford.
However obviously couldn’t have prepared for a pandemic and my DH (main earner) and the entire staff of his workplace had his salary slashed by 15% for 8 months in 2020. That took up quite a bit of savings and safety net.
For those who say ‘op you are on 70k sorry that’s a huge amount why can’t you afford an extra £70-£80 per month.
Well, it’s all relative. DH works in a city. The commute alone is over 4K per year. But the salary is twice what he would earn locally doing the same job.
We live in a fairly expensive area in the South - this is partly due to family connections but mainly due to transport links for work. We are stuck here for now because of the kids schools. We had saved and waited ages- years and years to move to where we are now and moving again would be very costly not to mention the housing market is barren round here at the moment anyway. Houses are really expensive ( rental or to buy) so lots of money goes on that. We are not frivolous, we have an old 18 year old car, haven’t spent any money on the house and everything in here is from the previous occupants, we don’t eat out or go on fancy holidays. Pretty much all of that money goes on things the kids need for school, food and bills. We are most certainly not rolling around in cash wondering what next treat to spend it on as some people seem to think.
What I’m saying is yes we will find it from somewhere but it just seems like an awful lot per month all at once and so soon. Even if I was in a position to no longer be able to afford my mortgage payments, 6 months isn’t really enough time to sell and buy somewhere cheaper - it took us over a year last time!
By no means do I want any sympathy. My OP was also asking how others in different circumstances will afford to keep their houses, it’s just seems like such a lot at once

OP posts:
BlueFairiesinthesky · 09/09/2021 09:34

Comparing salaries without knowing housing costs is a fruitless exercise. It’s comparing apples and pears.

If I lived where my colleagues live, I would live like a king. They earn the same and housing costs are easily 25% of what I pay. All other bills are cheaper too (water, etc). They frequently talk about days out/ holidays/ restaurant trips that I can’t afford. They could have the same lifestyle I do, on half my salary.

Whereas I live in an area with high housing costs which stretches far geographically - so no option for me to move as I don’t want to be far from my friends and family.

forinborin · 09/09/2021 09:28

My income as a single parent including working tax credit is less than £20k and I pay a mortgage and bills. If I can manage so can someone on £50k.
How much is your childcare out of that £20K? I am also a single parent on a fat paycheck, and mine was £30K net until very recently. Not a Norland nanny, just two full time places in an ofsted "good" nursery chain.

BlueFairiesinthesky · 09/09/2021 09:27

Just to enlighten people who may not realise the mortgage burden on people who have bought houses more recently....

We live in small ex council, 3 bed semi. All original - no extension. Not in London but in the South. It is not fancy, the area still has lots of council tenants. We were lucky in that we purchased over 5 years ago, had a 30% deposit and remortgaged recently so got a much better rate.

We still pay £1050 mortgage per month. My friend is renting a very similar property and it costs £1700-1900. We’re one of the lucky ones.

Now do you see what strain people are under? The reality is people have been forced to stretch themselves. I have some sympathy with posters saying the OP should not have stretched for a downstairs toilet and extra bedroom. I do agree- id love these too but can’t stretch to afford it without putting us at risk in the face of rising living costs/ interest rates.

Rising prices does mean cutting charity giving, removing child from after school club and drama - hurting the people who run these clubs. We’re also looking at reducing our ISA savings, which is ironically for our retirement!

forinborin · 09/09/2021 09:24

Nah. Still a budgeting issue overall. Seriously. If someone is on 50k plus and £50+ a month (depending on the wage) means they can't afford some bills, it's ridiculous
This is a very narrow minded statement. Everything depends on circumstances, and when you are living on £1.1K month after childcare - for rent, bills, food - yes, £50/month is a material amount that can push you over the line.

wedwewerpink · 09/09/2021 09:24

@Annoyedanddissapointed

Nah. Still a budgeting issue overall. Seriously. If someone is on 50k plus and £50+ a month (depending on the wage) means they can't afford some bills, it's ridiculous

But the same could be said for someone on 16-17k...that they should be able to afford 15quid!? It's all relative no??

Annoyedanddissapointed · 09/09/2021 09:22

[quote portico]@Annoyedanddissapointed
When you chant about £50K earners, you may want to consider net pay. Once you consider mortgages, abs otter usual bills then that does not leave a lot. An extra taxation is always going to hurt![/quote]
While extra 50 a month is obviously annoying and would logically mean something like 50 less into savings, it shouldn't put earners at that level into a position they claim they will have to cancel x and y... Which I've seen on MN and online sonce the news came out. How can people not find that weird, I will never know

Waxonwaxoff0 · 09/09/2021 09:22

[quote portico]@Annoyedanddissapointed
When you chant about £50K earners, you may want to consider net pay. Once you consider mortgages, abs otter usual bills then that does not leave a lot. An extra taxation is always going to hurt![/quote]
My income as a single parent including working tax credit is less than £20k and I pay a mortgage and bills. If I can manage so can someone on £50k.

zenthoughtsonlythanks · 09/09/2021 09:20

Also Boris is probably hedging that many of his younger voters will be happy to still receive the much anticipated inheritance in tact, with mother safely squirrelled away in a paid for state funded nursing home. It will be a win win for some. Sadly on the backs of the young, poor and many over stretched middle class families, they have been thrown under the bus for the boomers once again.

BlueFairiesinthesky · 09/09/2021 09:18

@the80sweregreat

So the vast majority of the senior manager “pen pushers” in NHS England will be on 8C (£63k-73k). Below them are many more project managers, administration staff/ PMO roles on varying salaries below this. At the top of these teams is maybe 1 or 2 staff on Band 9 (from £93k).

I haven’t come into contact with any non-clinical managers who would be higher than Band 9. You can easily tell what salary range people are on by job title as it’s hierarchical.

The leaders in the upper echelons of the NHS will be earning £200k plus but great responsibility and huge budgets/risks to manage. You need to appreciate that the NHS is one of the world 10 largest employers! It needs to be lead by competent people with the salary to match.

The only people I’ve come into contact with who probably earn £200k plus are national clinical leaders, such as the lead for obesity and diabetes. But they’re qualified doctors with a lot of experience, often have academic professorships, and could earn far more in private sector- or by going to the US/ Middle East. So their salary is very justified given the expertise and need for their skills.

portico · 09/09/2021 09:18

@Annoyedanddissapointed
When you chant about £50K earners, you may want to consider net pay. Once you consider mortgages, abs otter usual bills then that does not leave a lot. An extra taxation is always going to hurt!

zenthoughtsonlythanks · 09/09/2021 09:17

porridge I don't think Boris has done this to make his fat cat friends richer per se, I think he has done this to consolidate his main voting base - baby boomers.
He has done this to plug a gaping hole after the pandemic, and he has done this to park his tanks on the labour lawn by investing so heavily in the NHS (leaving Starmer nowhere to hide) The consequences however to the party and its principles, values and policies are in tatters.