Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New NI tax. How are people meant to afford this?

540 replies

OnTheBrink1 · 08/09/2021 18:51

We bought our house just before covid, got a mortgage that pushed us quite a bit but worked it all out and it’s been doable since then. We needed to push the mortgage quite a bit because we were upsizing to get an extra bedroom for the kids and a downstairs loo and in our area and from what we had before it was a jump.
Been managing since then but no progression opportunities in DH job during the last 18 months due to covid it seems as recruitment was largely paused.
However, now we will now have to pay an extra almost £900 per year on this new tax. £73 I make it.
We don’t have any benefits of any kind.
It’s going to be quite a struggle to afford the mortgage and still maintain the car (which is old but we need for work and kids stuff) plus all the usual bills and food. Kids are between 8-12 and need bus passes, constant uniform and all manner of expenses of course.
I mean we will struggle by but it’s going to be tough to afford that extra £73 a month when we had all the mortgage planned.
Just don’t get how they can bring it in so soon when it’s such an increase. How are others in a more difficult position going to afford this? People will be loosing their houses surely?

OP posts:
idontlikealdi · 09/09/2021 13:02

I'm going to come across as trite but we are high earners, we stay in a manageable mortgaged home, kids share a bedroom. I'm not getting caught up with the jones'.

My parents lost our house when I was a child in the 90s due to the recession and the impact on me was catastrophic at the time. We were on holiday and all they could do was watch tv to se how much the interest rates were going up.

All taxes can be hiked, im expecting an income tax one soon, mortgaging to the hilt is dangerous.

MatildaIThink · 09/09/2021 12:59

@MyPatronusIsACat

And you and @MatildaIThink can carry on with your jealousy and vitriol towards people who were furloughed, they will NEVER be told to pay it back. Mainly because it's ludicrous and insulting to suggest they should. As I said, it would be tantamount to asking everyone to pay back all the benefits they have ever received. Ludicrous, insulitng, and untenable.

You can carry on with your foaming at the mouth, there is no jealousy or vitriol. I have NEVER said that they should be told to pay it back, however it is obvious to anyone with two brain cells to rub together that we are all going to have to pay for it, that is the unfortunate consequences of the massive debt the country now has.

MatildaIThink · 09/09/2021 12:55

@StormzyinaTCup

When it comes to SEISS everyone who I know who was eligible to claim it is net better off that previous years because of it, yes their earnings were down, but not as much as the payments for SEISS. With CJRS, especially at the start it was abused by companies, holidays were claimed through it when nothing to do with Covid, people given extra holidays through Covid, many small business owners gamed the system with their staff still working whilst claiming on CJRS etc.

Interestingly though my work I am now starting to see HMRC begin investigating companies and asking questions of directors/individuals who they think may have over claimed/fraudulently claimed (mostly JRS related). There is a large team working on this at HMRC and they have been given an additional £100m by the government specifically to tackle COVID fraud. Also, now there is greater collaboration between HMRC and Companies House red flags will be a little easier to spot.

I really hope they do. I understand the reason for SEISS and CJRS, but the reality is it was also abused. So were the Bounceback Loans, a third have already been defaulted on, so many small Ltds took them out, withdrew the money and closed the company down, hoping that they would never be caught up with.

The latest estimates put the incorrect/fraudulent claims of SEISS at 20% for the early rounds, 50% for some of the later periods, that is a hell of a lot of money. The same with CJRS, some companies did not claim, some repaid, but there are many small businesses who completely gamed the system.

nanbread · 09/09/2021 12:55

@zenthoughtsonlythanks

I fully expected shit like this..which is why I didn't vote blue in 2019

Well the alternative was Jeremy Corbyn, so more policies just like this one in fact! It seems we now have two labour parties to choose from...

Where in any of Labour manifesto did it suggest doing this?

Stop making shit up.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 09/09/2021 12:54

@Bucanarab

People on £20k never going to be taking money out to pay for their care then?

Well they don't really need to, there's plenty of money to fund social care, it's just that it's hoarded by a select few.

The top 1% in the UK hold about 23% of the total wealth. If you want a monetary value on that it's between £3.3 and £3.6 Trillion depending on the figures you use. To put that into context it means 1% of the UK have enough wealth to completely wipe out the national debt and still have over £1,000,000,000,000 left.

Redistributing the wealth held be the elite should be the focus, not raising taxes for the masses. Taking 10% of the total wealth from the 1% would raise more money than the proposed NI increase will in 27 years. Take 50% and you could give social care £12billion a year until 2162!!

100% agree with you.
FanGirlFoof · 09/09/2021 12:53

@DucksFlyTogether

Food is more expensive
Utilities are more expensive
Petrol is more expensive.
I know my rent and council tax will go up in April like it always does.
Now an NI rise and tax rise the following year.

Same here. I'm really noticing it now. Second hike in gas and electricity due next month - about a 25% increase in monthly payments in a year. Will be doing an overhaul of voluntary expenses this month - as someone else said, charitable giving will be going, along with some treats. This isn't going to help small businesses like hairdressers, coffee shops etc as a lot of people will cut expenses that way.

I've already switched mobile supplier and got £5 off, changed TV subscriptions and got £12 off and am about to change broadband supplier for a £4 reduction. That just about covers the increase in gas and electricity. Considering going mostly veggie to reduce food bill.

MatildaIThink · 09/09/2021 12:48

[quote MyPatronusIsACat]@MatildaIThink

You are clearly another person who was not furloughed, and are woefully clueless about what being furloughed was like for many, and the fact that PEOPLE HAD NO CHOICE. FFS, you make it sound like people were on holiday for a year, being paid 80% of their salary and living it large.

Utterly clueless[/quote]
I was not furloughed, I worked full time through the pandemic. My husband was not furloughed or eligible for SEISS, but faced a drop in income of more than 70% over the whole year and for Apr20-Jul20 he earned nothing. I know many people who were, for most it was a holiday, indeed many were posting on social media about enjoying their paid holiday. Three of my closest friends husbands were furloughed last year, their entire houses were decorated, the gardens are now amazing and they did not have to take a pay cut.

You seem to think the majority took a 20% pay cut, most did not, you also seem to think that for most a 20% pay cut would be devastating , for higher earners it would not and for lower earners benefits kicked in. Also with so many costs reduced (no childcare, no eating out, no holidays, no commuting) even those facing a 20% cut will not have faced a full 20% cut in reality.

You can keep saying "Utterly clueless" to everyone who does not agree with you, but the reality is most people had a very different experience of furlough to what you had, or at least what you perceive happened.

StormzyinaTCup · 09/09/2021 12:36

When it comes to SEISS everyone who I know who was eligible to claim it is net better off that previous years because of it, yes their earnings were down, but not as much as the payments for SEISS. With CJRS, especially at the start it was abused by companies, holidays were claimed through it when nothing to do with Covid, people given extra holidays through Covid, many small business owners gamed the system with their staff still working whilst claiming on CJRS etc.

Interestingly though my work I am now starting to see HMRC begin investigating companies and asking questions of directors/individuals who they think may have over claimed/fraudulently claimed (mostly JRS related). There is a large team working on this at HMRC and they have been given an additional £100m by the government specifically to tackle COVID fraud. Also, now there is greater collaboration between HMRC and Companies House red flags will be a little easier to spot.

Bucanarab · 09/09/2021 12:35

People on £20k never going to be taking money out to pay for their care then?

Well they don't really need to, there's plenty of money to fund social care, it's just that it's hoarded by a select few.

The top 1% in the UK hold about 23% of the total wealth. If you want a monetary value on that it's between £3.3 and £3.6 Trillion depending on the figures you use. To put that into context it means 1% of the UK have enough wealth to completely wipe out the national debt and still have over £1,000,000,000,000 left.

Redistributing the wealth held be the elite should be the focus, not raising taxes for the masses. Taking 10% of the total wealth from the 1% would raise more money than the proposed NI increase will in 27 years. Take 50% and you could give social care £12billion a year until 2162!!

GenderApostatemk2 · 09/09/2021 12:18

Graduates now have a 42%+ tax burden once you include student loans.
My DD has worked damn hard for the last 10 years as a Teacher, she’s made it to HoD and is thanked now by a massive tax burden, she and her partner will pay an extra £100 monthly between them, they have a huge mortgage and nursery fees too. Yes they both earn decent money but 42% tax (in real terms)?

Older workers who can salary sacrifice up to £40k into a pension (down to minimum wage if they so choose) can avoid both income tax and NI 😡

MatildaIThink · 09/09/2021 12:12

@SquirryTheSquirrel
Hawkins001
To also help save, people can look at e.g. Sky packages, virgin, their costas, look at substituting different food brands, minimizing takeaway food, ect, all adds up in expenditure.

I tire of hearing this sort of thing.

Newsflash - many people can't afford those things now. Not everyone has a raft of small luxuries they can cut back on.

Many people do not pay for those things, but many people do. Statistically the lower your income level the more likely you are to smoke for example. Most of the high earners I know do not have Sky/Virgin, they do tend to have Netflix, but Netflix is £12 pcm vs Sky at £70+ pcm. Most of the lower earners I know all have Sky, plus sports packages etc. I do not know why that difference exists but it does.

When it comes to takeaways the evidence shows that these, as well as ready meals which cost more, are much more likely to be consumed by low earners. As well as branded food items which they perceive as "better".

There is a reason behind this, lower income people feel that they derive "status" from these items, where as in higher income groups expensive items, even cars to not increase status, which generally comes from being able to demonstrate property wealth, which is almost unfakeable (where as cars, household items etc. can all be leased, on credit etc.).

I know when things are tight it is difficult, when I was studying for my PhD and my husband was starting his own business at the same time things were incredibly tight, we even got rid of our TV license to save money and we both worked in a bar and restaurant in evenings, firstly for extra money and also because they often fed you on shift (although I know that might not be possible with small children).

HungryHippo11 · 09/09/2021 12:11

Interest rates are really low currently. It was a bit short sighted to buy a house which you can only just afford at current rates, what would you have done if interest rates went up?

vivainsomnia · 09/09/2021 12:09

I think most people try to get the most they can afford if upsizing?
No, most don't. Many factor in an emergency fund that would take I to account many circumstances. Poor health being one of them. One person losing their job, having to reduce hours to care for a relative.

You seem to want a number of luxuries as part of your normal life but not deemed them so. Having a toilet downstairs, a room for each child are luxuries.

You can afford the extra tax, you just don't want to cut into any of the luxuries you now take for granted. That's the same for the vast majority of people. You are no different.

themidnighttrain · 09/09/2021 12:09

@BasicDad

It's absolutely bonkers to even suggest those on furlough would pay it back though.

They were mandated by government to not work. It was not a choice. They owe nothing.

How in the world can you not see that? It was not a voluntary leave of absence!!

I don't agree with individuals having to pay it back.

However, some companies - notably those not providing key services - claimed furlough when they didn't need to. They've suffered no loss in profits. Those are the companies who should have to pay it back.

MyPatronusIsACat · 09/09/2021 12:07

[quote portico]@MyPatronusIsACat

Pls read my early posts - that triggered your ire. I did not say for furlough to be repaid in one go. I used the sane analogy as graduates repaying student loans. Furloughs (80% of salary) are considerably mmuch more than income support/unemployment benefits. Now, I have no choice in paying my taxes. I find egregious that I will be paying for those who received furlough and that there are no means to clawback (over the long term) from furlough recipients.[/quote]
Seriously, WTAF are you going on about? Confused

Why on EARTH should people pay back their furlough? Confused As has been said, everyone who was furloughed had NO CHOICE in the matter, and they lost 20% of their salary, some for virtually a YEAR, and many struggled terribly with their basic living costs, and will be suffering financially for YEARS because of this. How the hell are they meant to pay back some £18K to £25K back? Even 'in instalments?'

And as I (and many others have said,) there is not a single reason WHY they should 'pay it back!' There is so much wrong with your suggestion, and yes it is 'triggering my IRE' because your dreadful and ill-informed suggestion is insulting!

The furlough money people had was their ONLY income. You go on like it was in addition to their salary! Your posts are so ill-informed that it wouldn't surprise me if you thought people were paid furlough in addition to their salary. I bet you think people in social housing get it for free too... Hmm

Do you ALSO suggest that when people go back to work after say 2-3 years of being unemployed and on benefits, or ten years as a single stay-at-home-mum on benefits, that they pay back all the benefits they claimed/received the whole time ? Because suggesting people pay back their furlough is exactly the same as suggesting people pay back ALL the benefits they received when they weren't working.

Your posts are making me furious, and I won't be engaging with you any further.

And you and @MatildaIThink can carry on with your jealousy and vitriol towards people who were furloughed, they will NEVER be told to pay it back. Mainly because it's ludicrous and insulting to suggest they should. As I said, it would be tantamount to asking everyone to pay back all the benefits they have ever received. Ludicrous, insulitng, and untenable.

MyPatronusIsACat · 09/09/2021 12:04

@BasicDad

It's absolutely bonkers to even suggest those on furlough would pay it back though.

They were mandated by government to not work. It was not a choice. They owe nothing.

How in the world can you not see that? It was not a voluntary leave of absence!!

Exactly. Most ridiculous post on the thread. Utterly ludicrous.
Nosferatussidebit · 09/09/2021 12:04

[quote MyPatronusIsACat]@MatildaIThink

You are clearly another person who was not furloughed, and are woefully clueless about what being furloughed was like for many, and the fact that PEOPLE HAD NO CHOICE. FFS, you make it sound like people were on holiday for a year, being paid 80% of their salary and living it large.

Utterly clueless[/quote]
I wasn't furloughed (NHS) but I can imagine even for people being paid 100% of their wages it must have been worrying - risk of redundancy increased etc. Yes, you didn't have to worry about child care but worrying about finances and job security is no joke.

BasicDad · 09/09/2021 12:01

Above message was addressed to @portico

BasicDad · 09/09/2021 12:01

It's absolutely bonkers to even suggest those on furlough would pay it back though.

They were mandated by government to not work. It was not a choice. They owe nothing.

How in the world can you not see that? It was not a voluntary leave of absence!!

MyPatronusIsACat · 09/09/2021 11:57

@MatildaIThink

You are clearly another person who was not furloughed, and are woefully clueless about what being furloughed was like for many, and the fact that PEOPLE HAD NO CHOICE. FFS, you make it sound like people were on holiday for a year, being paid 80% of their salary and living it large.

Utterly clueless

MatildaIThink · 09/09/2021 11:37

@MyPatronusIsACat
Whilst I do not agree that people should have to pay back "furlough" CJRS, I do think that it was too generous as a system, the same with SEISS.

When it comes to SEISS everyone who I know who was eligible to claim it is net better off that previous years because of it, yes their earnings were down, but not as much as the payments for SEISS. With CJRS, especially at the start it was abused by companies, holidays were claimed through it when nothing to do with Covid, people given extra holidays through Covid, many small business owners gamed the system with their staff still working whilst claiming on CJRS etc.

I know plenty of people who were put on furlough, from shielding people who worked for supermarkets to people in industries that were entirely shut down by the government, none of them had the 20% drop and all were on full pay, the company covered the difference (as well as the NI, pensions etc.). The estimate on the news was that something like 75% of people on furlough got full pay rather than reduced pay.

The fact that the latest figures released today, for the period ending 31st July show that 1.6 million people are still on furlough shows that CJRS has gone on too long, nearly all of those people will not be returning to work and will be made redundant as the scheme winds down, because if there was not a job for them in July then there is one one in October (unless you count the 6,000 people who work in nightclubs), either that or their employer was gaming the system. CJRS makes sense if the aim is to avoid redundancies, it makes no sense if it is only used to delay redundancy.

Titsywoo · 09/09/2021 11:30

The top 5% of earners already pay half of all income tax and 96% of all CGT paid by private individuals. The top third of earners in the UK have the sixth highest effective rate of income taxation in the EU, the bottom two thirds have the lowest effective rate of income taxation in the EU. The problem is not high earners paying tax, it is everyone else.

Agreed. We paid £42000 in tax last year and although it can be argued we earn a lot we live in SE and we are not rich by any means (no new cars, holidays and private schools here).

The super rich and big companies should be paying their full taxes (they never will which is part of the reason they are so rich!) but people earning say £100k a year are getting taxed a lot already so I don't think it is fair to burden the top 5% with everything.

It is a tricky situation - somehow this needs to be paid for, but I know for many it will push them from just surviving into poverty.

SquirryTheSquirrel · 09/09/2021 11:29

@Hawkins001

To also help save, people can look at e.g. Sky packages, virgin, their costas, look at substituting different food brands, minimizing takeaway food, ect, all adds up in expenditure.
I tire of hearing this sort of thing.

Newsflash - many people can't afford those things now. Not everyone has a raft of small luxuries they can cut back on.

portico · 09/09/2021 11:27

@MyPatronusIsACat

Pls read my early posts - that triggered your ire. I did not say for furlough to be repaid in one go. I used the sane analogy as graduates repaying student loans. Furloughs (80% of salary) are considerably mmuch more than income support/unemployment benefits. Now, I have no choice in paying my taxes. I find egregious that I will be paying for those who received furlough and that there are no means to clawback (over the long term) from furlough recipients.

jcyclops · 09/09/2021 11:27

kite22: Once you earn more than £4189 per month your NI drops from 12% to a measly 2%.
I didn't know this. Can anyone explain why this is ?

Remember it is the part of your earnings OVER £4189 on which you pay 2%, not your whole earnings. You will still pay 12% on the earnings between £797 and £4189. The reason for this is down to the history of NI.

From 1911 to 1975 the contributions were not income related at all - they were flat rate - and everyone paid the same amount. You literally bought a stamp that was affixed to a card as a record of your contributions (hence getting your cards when you left a job). This was partly because the benefits from your stamps were not income related either - everyone received the same state pension and unemployment benefit. (Flat rate payments to government still persist with things like passports, driving licences etc.)

When paying NI at a percentage was introduced in 1975, it was thought fair for those on low incomes to pay less, but if there was no upper earnings limit then higher earners would suddenly be paying double, triple or even more than before and this was deemed unreasonable (imagine if the £3650 NI you pay on your £40000 salary suddenly went up to £6000). The solution was an upper earnings limit so that nobody would may more than a fixed maximum. This maximum lasted until 2003 when earnings over the upper limit started paying 1%, and this was increased in 2011 to 2%.

Many other "taxes" have maximum payments irrespective of your earnings. Council tax has a maximum amount payable (ie. the highest band). With student loans you do not pay back more than the loan + interest, so there is a maximum amount you will ever pay irrespective of your income.