Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New NI tax. How are people meant to afford this?

540 replies

OnTheBrink1 · 08/09/2021 18:51

We bought our house just before covid, got a mortgage that pushed us quite a bit but worked it all out and it’s been doable since then. We needed to push the mortgage quite a bit because we were upsizing to get an extra bedroom for the kids and a downstairs loo and in our area and from what we had before it was a jump.
Been managing since then but no progression opportunities in DH job during the last 18 months due to covid it seems as recruitment was largely paused.
However, now we will now have to pay an extra almost £900 per year on this new tax. £73 I make it.
We don’t have any benefits of any kind.
It’s going to be quite a struggle to afford the mortgage and still maintain the car (which is old but we need for work and kids stuff) plus all the usual bills and food. Kids are between 8-12 and need bus passes, constant uniform and all manner of expenses of course.
I mean we will struggle by but it’s going to be tough to afford that extra £73 a month when we had all the mortgage planned.
Just don’t get how they can bring it in so soon when it’s such an increase. How are others in a more difficult position going to afford this? People will be loosing their houses surely?

OP posts:
Nosferatussidebit · 09/09/2021 15:20

[quote lllllllllll]There are about 600,000 people holding LGV cat C (rigid truck) or cat C+E (articulated lorry) licences in the UK who do not currently drive trucks for a living. Why would they want to return to the job? Facilities are poor, the hours brutal and the responsibilities onerous.

If this stat from the Guardian is correct though, we have a lot of people qualified to drive lorries already in the UK. What can we do to tempt them back?

www.theguardian.com/world/2021/sep/06/hgv-driver-shortage-was-inevitable[/quote]
Facilities are poor, the hours brutal and the responsibilities onerous.

Improve this. Which companies won't, because it's not cost effective and our already sky-rocketing supermarket prices would go up even more.

Plus not all hgv licensed drivers used to work as drivers- lots have them for leisure purposes (my BIL for example) or as part of a job which isn't solely being a hgv driver (my other BiL).

Porridgealert · 09/09/2021 15:20

@zenthoughtsonlythanks

Overnight we appear to have turned into a one party nation.

I don't any of us should feel comfortable with the dire state of politics in this country and what this means for our future. The very fact Boris had no qualms in overturning his manifesto, his own party policies and shove most of his future voters under a bus is quite alarming to say the least, and he expects to get away with it I assume after all where is the opposition - totally vacant.

The only thing this policy has done is bring the country together to unite against it.

Which voters has he shoved under a bus? And how?
Annoyedanddissapointed · 09/09/2021 15:19

@lllllllllll

Because that would be an admission that immigrants are needed even if they are not super highly educated.

That doesn't make sense though - there can't be anyone who would object to HGV drivers coming into this country for as long as they are needed to help solve the supply issues.

There are people who object to immigrants coming full stop no matter what.
lllllllllll · 09/09/2021 15:17

There are about 600,000 people holding LGV cat C (rigid truck) or cat C+E (articulated lorry) licences in the UK who do not currently drive trucks for a living. Why would they want to return to the job? Facilities are poor, the hours brutal and the responsibilities onerous.

If this stat from the Guardian is correct though, we have a lot of people qualified to drive lorries already in the UK. What can we do to tempt them back?

www.theguardian.com/world/2021/sep/06/hgv-driver-shortage-was-inevitable

Nosferatussidebit · 09/09/2021 15:16

@lllllllllll

Because that would be an admission that immigrants are needed even if they are not super highly educated.

That doesn't make sense though - there can't be anyone who would object to HGV drivers coming into this country for as long as they are needed to help solve the supply issues.

But there are. Same with care workers and all other understaffed roles migrants used to take. People claim "they're taking our jobs" no they aren't, they're plugging a skills gap. But some people are incapable of seeing that. I know people that are incapable of seeing it.
lllllllllll · 09/09/2021 15:14

Because that would be an admission that immigrants are needed even if they are not super highly educated.

That doesn't make sense though - there can't be anyone who would object to HGV drivers coming into this country for as long as they are needed to help solve the supply issues.

Knittingupastorm · 09/09/2021 15:12

I agree hardly anyone pays IHT. However if you have been forced to move from NE England to London for work as I was most of the equity in a house is taxed at 40% (the balance over 500,000 for we single ones so our children are rendered homeless whereas the same house in NE England would not result in my children being homeless).

Why would your children be homeless if they inherit half a million, plus 60% of the rest?

Annoyedanddissapointed · 09/09/2021 15:10

@lllllllllll

And the government is refusing visas to EU lorry drivers who could come and relieve the situation.

Oh good lord - why?!

Because that would be an admission that immigrants are needed even if they are not super highly educated.. Not exactly on par with the Brexit message many were passing on
lllllllllll · 09/09/2021 15:08

And the government is refusing visas to EU lorry drivers who could come and relieve the situation.

Oh good lord - why?!

MatildaIThink · 09/09/2021 15:07

[quote BasicDad]@MatildaIThink I don't think you are bitter. You did say you thought the system was too generous though.

How would you have rolled out an almost overnight blanket policy to protect as many people as possible?[/quote]
I agree the initial deployment was always going to be flawed, speed trumped perfection, it had to, but on later rounds we should have learned by that stage.

For starters I would have fixed the obvious exclusions, new starters, the issues for those returning form maternity etc. but the government did sort of rectify those in the end. My husband was not eligible (employed through is own Ltd, paid mostly via dividend), despite getting nothing I totally understand the reasons for not covering dividend and as he said, he accepts the rough with the smooth, it is part of being self-employed or running your own business.

For CJRS the main issues with paying out were that it allowed companies to claim for holiday as well, we knew this would have been a problem, other countries schemes which were introduced before ours was even announced accounted for this, so it was a mistake that ours did not. There also needed to be some looking at the actual scheme, quite a few companies claimed when their claims were in breach, most will probably get away with it, yet many seemed up in arms when the supermarkets claimed, which were entirely legitimate to put shielding staff on CJRS. It also seems quite a few small businesses claimed whilst staff kept working for the business. With SEISS many people were still claiming whilst working pretty much full time, minor impacts at most, but still getting the payouts which meant their income vastly outstripped their previous years earnings (eg. 5-10% down, but getting 60-80% of a quarter's profit top up) so potentially 50-70% up. SEISS especially there should have been some kind of claw back. Looking at how the German Kurzarbeitergeld system operates would have been a good idea, if you get the chance have a read up on it, but it might actually be something worth keeping in the UK longer term, Germany has had it for over 100 years, but scaled it up for Covid.

lllllllllll · 09/09/2021 15:06

2 earners on 50k each are not earning massive amounts.

Is this a joke? Two earners on 50k each can easily afford this tax. In fact they should be paying more if anything!

OnTheBrink1 · 09/09/2021 15:06

@vivainsomnia

I think most people try to get the most they can afford if upsizing? No, most don't. Many factor in an emergency fund that would take I to account many circumstances. Poor health being one of them. One person losing their job, having to reduce hours to care for a relative.

You seem to want a number of luxuries as part of your normal life but not deemed them so. Having a toilet downstairs, a room for each child are luxuries.

You can afford the extra tax, you just don't want to cut into any of the luxuries you now take for granted. That's the same for the vast majority of people. You are no different.

No. It isn’t that at all. What I am saying is that these things were bought before covid. Yes we have a small contingency but this was largely used up during covid as my husbands wage was cut for 8 months. We don’t have loads of luxuries and the kids still don’t have a room each! Most houses anything bigger than a tiny starter home here have a downstairs loo
OP posts:
Xenia · 09/09/2021 15:05

" Blossomtoes Thu 09-Sep-21 14:01:21

given 40% of their homes goes to the state when they die anyway

Again untrue. A home owner’s estate is taxed only on anything above £500k. That’s £1 million for a couple which is why only only 5% of estates attract it."

I agree hardly anyone pays IHT. However if you have been forced to move from NE England to London for work as I was most of the equity in a house is taxed at 40% (the balance over 500,000 for we single ones so our children are rendered homeless whereas the same house in NE England would not result in my children being homeless). IHT is a wicked unfair and harsh tax to add to all the other tax that is around. For someone who is above 90 like 5 of my immediate neighbours and bought their house in about 1975 or earlier the £500k is not the bulk of the equity in their house, never mind any savings so most of their estate is indeed taxed at 40% on death.

beigebrownblue · 09/09/2021 15:00

@Islamorada

Worst bit is that more taxes may come our way. All those Covid jabs and now boosters, furlough, lockdowns, out of control borders. Hopefully people would stop calling for more welfare benefits and uncontrolled immigration because these expenses all come from our taxes.

The system make it very hard for workers to make decent money and save. It is very expensive and most things are a rip off as well. Salaries are low.

So what you are basically saying is, all those you deem sub-human i.e. people who are clinically vulnerable - elderly people (having had jabs), anyone who is unemployed (furloughed), anyone who gets Covid and has had to self-isolate and do the right thing, but has lost income as a result (plenty of people self employed and on zero contracts)...

Children (who don't do paid work)
Anyone who has to visit a food bank and will be struggling to pay for food when U.C. uplft ends....

Any refugees who have the audacity to flee a war torn country where they and their daughters are in danger of being raped, killed etc...
and when they get here, would dearly love to work and contribute but can't because they are not allowed to...

Where have we heard all that before...?

Perhaps if you lose your job or become ill or in any way vulnerable you might consider the following Niemoeller quote:

...First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out—because I was not a socialist.

Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out— because I was not a trade unionist.

Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew.

Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2021 14:35

@FanGirlFoof

Morrisons expects price hikes amid supply chain and HGV driver crisis mol.im/a/9972937

Just saw this on Facebook. We are definitely in for some belt tightening over the next year.

Indeed. And the government is refusing visas to EU lorry drivers who could come and relieve the situation. Funny how shy all those 2019 Tory voters have suddenly become.
FanGirlFoof · 09/09/2021 14:32

Morrisons expects price hikes amid supply chain and HGV driver crisis
mol.im/a/9972937

Just saw this on Facebook. We are definitely in for some belt tightening over the next year.

Sunflowers095 · 09/09/2021 14:21

@BlueFairiesinthesky

All the people who are questioning the budgeting skills of the OP. WHAT PLANET DO YOU LIVE ON?! Housing is incredibly expensive for those who have bought recently, it’s crippling. I bet you’re sitting on a nice load of equity. Often their is no choice. Renting is more than a mortgage and not secure.
Yeah but no one needs to have multiple kids or a bigger house. Those are extras not necessities.

Surely when you get a mortgage you consider:

  • current savings
  • what If one of you is out of work? Made redundant? Gets ill?

Seems like on mumsnet a 100% of pregnancies or somehow a total surprise and accident and so are the following ones. And no one realised kids cost money...?

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2021 14:01

given 40% of their homes goes to the state when they die anyway

Again untrue. A home owner’s estate is taxed only on anything above £500k. That’s £1 million for a couple which is why only only 5% of estates attract it.

BasicDad · 09/09/2021 13:42

@MatildaIThink I don't think you are bitter. You did say you thought the system was too generous though.

How would you have rolled out an almost overnight blanket policy to protect as many people as possible?

Xenia · 09/09/2021 13:39

The pandemic has divided people hugely as it was so unfair on all sorts of levels. Many of us on this thread however can probably agree tax is too high.

I don't think confiscation of people's homes which is basically Labour's alternative policy (as you do not raise that much from taxing more the very very small number of very high earners) (Rachel Reeves R4 yesterday was really implying as much) is better given 40% of their homes goes to the state when they die anyway.

MatildaIThink · 09/09/2021 13:25

[quote MyPatronusIsACat]@MatildaIThink

Your bitterness and resentment is showing.

Your post at 12.48 proves my point brilliantly ... You are jealous and bitter of people who were furloughed because YOU had to work through the pandemic...

Bizarrely, like portico, you saw them as living their best life, and living it large, purely because a couple of people on your facebook showed pics of themselves doing a bit of home decorating. You assumed they were happy as pigs in shit, and rolling in money, because they hung a few rolls of wallpaper, and tended to their garden!

Are you actually serious?! I have never read so much rot! As I said, you are clueless. (Which was NOT the case for the vast, VAST majority of furloughed people.)

And I seriously doubt that they were showing off oodles of holiday snaps whilst on furlough. We were all in lockdown FFS.

If you're going to spout such tripe, at least make it credible FGS.

Like with @portico I am not engaging with you any further. Can't be arsed with engaging with with people spouting such ill-informed tripe.[/quote]
Again, you seem to think anyone who does not agree with you is "bitter", full of "resentment", "clueless" etc.

I did not "see them as living their best life, and living it large, purely because a couple of people posted on facebook", I know quite a few people who went on furlough, all are quite happy saying they enjoyed it and it meant last summer off on full pay. My husband also did loads in the garden, but was on zero pay, for everyone concerned it makes sense, it was time well spent, being productive, whether off of work entirely or on furlough.

No one was showing off "oodles of holiday snaps" because everyone I know was not stupid enough to go away, but again, you are deliberately misrepresenting what people have said to try and twist to your own misrepresentation.

There is someone on this thread not being credible as you seem to disagree with facts that do not fit your world view, and this post is a reply to them.

the80sweregreat · 09/09/2021 13:21

I do know someone who took out a bounce back loan, then made themselves bankrupt.
Not sure if they have to pay it back ? Wasn't a big business to start with etc. very small. They wound up the business.
I thought at the time was this ethical , but lockdown was an odd time and many were up against it . It was offered to them and they took it thinking it could work for them starting a new project , but it didn't work out.
It's going to take HMRC ages to trawl through all the various claims and so on but I'm sure a few will have to pay things back ?
How will that work ?

vivainsomnia · 09/09/2021 13:18

Redistributing the wealth held be the elite should be the focus, not raising taxes for the masses
Until the next crisis, and then you hit them again? How many times should they be deemed sole saviours of the whole nation, to support a society need they will never use, before they have enough to be hold the fort for all, with little appreciation back, and decide to go somewhere else?

DobbleDobble · 09/09/2021 13:18

@simitra- your quote
“Lots of boomer bashing as usual. Its not the boomers who were sitting on their asses at home getting 80% of their pay for doing sweet fanny adams! Someone has to pay for all that time that folks spend doing up their houses and gardens.”

Big sweeping generalisations about people on furlough too, no?some of those on furlough probably had many sleepless nights worrying over feeding their kids etc
As I recall the boomers have also made hay whilst sun shone and enjoyed buying their council houses, the best of the labour market and best of NHS services too.I’d happily take those things over covid, shite jobs market and long waiting lists on the NHS and no dentists around.
No one generation really gets off better

I’ve worked all the way through on frontline services.What I can tell you is we won’t see a drop of this money into those services, they’re already mentioning in the press this morning they’re going to employ nhs directors on big wages to deploy this money Shock
I think people will happily pay for services if they are getting value for money and transparency which within the NHS is laughable.
The whole thing needs reforming from the top down.That’s what people want, they don’t want pharmaceutical companies charging £90 for paracetamol to the NHS and the NHS paying that.Everyone will put money into something fit for purpose and value.

MyPatronusIsACat · 09/09/2021 13:13

@MatildaIThink

Your bitterness and resentment is showing.

Your post at 12.48 proves my point brilliantly ... You are jealous and bitter of people who were furloughed because YOU had to work through the pandemic...

Bizarrely, like portico, you saw them as living their best life, and living it large, purely because a couple of people on your facebook showed pics of themselves doing a bit of home decorating. You assumed they were happy as pigs in shit, and rolling in money, because they hung a few rolls of wallpaper, and tended to their garden!

Are you actually serious?! I have never read so much rot! As I said, you are clueless. (Which was NOT the case for the vast, VAST majority of furloughed people.)

And I seriously doubt that they were showing off oodles of holiday snaps whilst on furlough. We were all in lockdown FFS.

If you're going to spout such tripe, at least make it credible FGS.

Like with @portico I am not engaging with you any further. Can't be arsed with engaging with with people spouting such ill-informed tripe.