Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New NI tax. How are people meant to afford this?

540 replies

OnTheBrink1 · 08/09/2021 18:51

We bought our house just before covid, got a mortgage that pushed us quite a bit but worked it all out and it’s been doable since then. We needed to push the mortgage quite a bit because we were upsizing to get an extra bedroom for the kids and a downstairs loo and in our area and from what we had before it was a jump.
Been managing since then but no progression opportunities in DH job during the last 18 months due to covid it seems as recruitment was largely paused.
However, now we will now have to pay an extra almost £900 per year on this new tax. £73 I make it.
We don’t have any benefits of any kind.
It’s going to be quite a struggle to afford the mortgage and still maintain the car (which is old but we need for work and kids stuff) plus all the usual bills and food. Kids are between 8-12 and need bus passes, constant uniform and all manner of expenses of course.
I mean we will struggle by but it’s going to be tough to afford that extra £73 a month when we had all the mortgage planned.
Just don’t get how they can bring it in so soon when it’s such an increase. How are others in a more difficult position going to afford this? People will be loosing their houses surely?

OP posts:
MyPatronusIsACat · 09/09/2021 23:00

@lllllllllll

2 earners on 50k each are not earning massive amounts.

Is this a joke? Two earners on 50k each can easily afford this tax. In fact they should be paying more if anything!

This. ^ Saying a couple earning 50 grand a year each is 'not that much,' is an insult to people who don't earn a lot. (And that is WAAAAAY more than people who earn over 50 grand.)

Sick of this shit I am. Hmm

cadburyegg · 09/09/2021 22:53

I'm on 20k, single parent and the increase is only about £10 a month but it's a bit of a kick in the teeth along with the UC cut. I know we will manage but it's just a bit crap really. I work from home and so my heating/electricity is going to be used much of the day this winter. 🙁 I would be less concerned if I knew the money would be used appropriately. I've got experience of the social care system as my dad had dementia and the threshold for them to step in is very high- I had to file an adult safeguarding report for them to take me seriously (dad was violent).

I don't get the vitriol aimed at people who were furloughed either, being able to still work over the 18 months has saved my sanity.

thatonehasalittlecar · 09/09/2021 22:46

@Porridgealert

Your experience isn’t the same as mine. As I said, everyone i knew who was furloughed was not having the time of their lives, they were extremely worried and scraping by.

I didn’t know all that many people on furlough, though. Most people in my industry - 95% according to an industry survey - were out of work completely within days of lockdown. No furlough, potentially some SEISS, and a great deal of worry.

Bertoli · 09/09/2021 22:41

Agreed household income must be around 100K pa if the NI increase will cost you £73/month.
The advantage of using NI rather than increasing income tax is that both employers and employees will contribute to sharing the burden.
Other options would have been raising more from inheritance taxes say a 20% tax on estates worth more than 50,000 or reducing the huge cost of working tax credits as it seems ludicrous to be paying benefits to people working part time when there are record job vacancies and labour shortages.

ThistleTits · 09/09/2021 22:33

@Akire

Same with people lower end working with UC top up as wages low. Lose £20 week UC plus £20 month for extra NI so big drop of £100 for them
^ this will be the difference between eating and not eating for some people. Cut back on non essentials, I am pretty sure you will manage.
Iamthewombat · 09/09/2021 21:49

@Knittingupastorm

I suspect that one of the reasons for adding the extra to NI, rather than income tax, is that you can’t reduce NI by upping your pension contributions.

I think, although could be wrong because I’m far from an expert, that if you have a salary sacrifice arrangement for your pension then the employee and employer save on NI. It’s one of the pension options offered by my work.

That’s correct for workplace schemes operating on a salary sacrifice basis, but not for SIPPs, which are a popular vehicle for people who want something to run alongside a workplace scheme.

Workplace schemes often have a cap on contributions, or an unpalatable retirement date (one of my workplace schemes is tied to state retirement age, for example).

In any event, it would be easy for wealthier people to reduce income tax in this way.

MarvellousMonsters · 09/09/2021 21:44

@nanbread

The money needs to come from somewhere.

Yeah it does. How about the top 5% instead of those on 20k.

Yep, pretty sure these guys could be doing a bit more
New NI tax. How are people meant to afford this?
IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 09/09/2021 21:38

You have three children, a large mortgage and work part time. Banking on nothing ever going up was a huge risk. If you had to pay for medical care for the five of you it would cost way more than the increase you will have in NI.

Nosferatussidebit · 09/09/2021 21:38

@CookL

I find that hard to believe. At the worst they will have medical insurance but I believe most high earners use private medical services.
DH and I are in top 12% as a household. Most of our friends are top 10%. I don't know anyone who routinely uses private health care. IVF, occasional medical appointment, sure but routine GP appointments, surgery etc. All NHS.
DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 09/09/2021 21:37

@jamdonut

I’m just annoyed it will completely negate the similar amount pay ‘rise’ that I will get as a council employee .
At least you get one. Dh and are police, no pay rise for us, not even 1% that everyone sneered at.
jamdonut · 09/09/2021 21:32

I’m just annoyed it will completely negate the similar amount pay ‘rise’ that I will get as a council employee .

Knittingupastorm · 09/09/2021 21:29

I suspect that one of the reasons for adding the extra to NI, rather than income tax, is that you can’t reduce NI by upping your pension contributions.

I think, although could be wrong because I’m far from an expert, that if you have a salary sacrifice arrangement for your pension then the employee and employer save on NI. It’s one of the pension options offered by my work.

Iamthewombat · 09/09/2021 21:24

@ilovecardigans

What about limiting tax relief on pension contributions for higher rate taxpayers? Or cap tax relief at 10% on all pension contributions?
The first suggestion is likely to happen, and rightly so. I say that as a higher rate taxpayer who stands to lose from such a change, but come on! Higher rate taxpayers hoover up a huge proportion of the pension tax relief.

I suspect that one of the reasons for adding the extra to NI, rather than income tax, is that you can’t reduce NI by upping your pension contributions.

Porridgealert · 09/09/2021 21:17

@Knittingupastorm. I was responding to a postr who implied people didn't want to be on furlough. You're just reinforcing what I said. People enjoyed being on furlough. I never said they should be miserable. Personally I loved receiving money for no work. I'd be happy to be on furlough to retirement.

Knittingupastorm · 09/09/2021 21:08

[quote Porridgealert]@thatonehasalittlecar
"Everyone I know who was furloughed would have much rather been working / earning instead of cowering at home worrying about their loved ones"

Do I think that most people would rather have worked than have covid exist? Yes.

Do I think that those people who were sat at home in the garden ordering paddling pools and outdoor furniture online were cut up about being on furlough? No.[/quote]
So? Does it matter if every single one of them had the time of their lives? Was the money only worth it if they were miserable?
What did you want them to do? Turn up at a closed workplace and demand to do something? What possible difference can it make if some people on furlough enjoyed some of it.
And if companies put people on furlough when they shouldn’t have, that’s on them, not the employees.

Porridgealert · 09/09/2021 21:03

@thatonehasalittlecar
"Everyone I know who was furloughed would have much rather been working / earning instead of cowering at home worrying about their loved ones"

Do I think that most people would rather have worked than have covid exist? Yes.

Do I think that those people who were sat at home in the garden ordering paddling pools and outdoor furniture online were cut up about being on furlough? No.

LadyWithLapdog · 09/09/2021 20:58

@CookL

I find that hard to believe. At the worst they will have medical insurance but I believe most high earners use private medical services.
You’d be very, very surprised then about some of the pettiness.
CookL · 09/09/2021 20:48

I find that hard to believe. At the worst they will have medical insurance but I believe most high earners use private medical services.

cherubtastic · 09/09/2021 20:47

It will be a struggle. I’m also losing the UC covid up-payment this month too. I’m a single mum nurse, don’t take from me to pay for me but yet not pay for me. (Unions arguing over 3% pay rise but with the NI contributions Boris will effectively have won on the 1%)

thatonehasalittlecar · 09/09/2021 20:41

@portico

You do understand that the furlough payments weren’t given to the workers, they were given to the companies?

So if what you are suggesting is that the companies should pay it back, in some sort of student loan scenario, then I think we’ll have an awful lot of companies winding up in the next few years.

The point of furlough pay was to keep the companies afloat when they weren’t allowed to trade at all / to their fullest, so not everyone ended up unemployed and a massive burden on the state.

Everyone I know who was furloughed would have much rather been working / earning instead of cowering at home worrying about their loved ones and watching their safety nets disintegrate. And they were the lucky ones with safety nets.

Nosferatussidebit · 09/09/2021 20:41

It would be more economically viable for her to pay fir a live in carer

Depends where in the country and whether she has anyone will to legally act as the employer and all responsibility that entails. There's also legal ramifications with regards to deprivation of liberty and how that can only be achieved in a care home (currently, law for change imminent). It does happen but isn't simple and often isn't legal (deprivation of liberty and also human trafficking, modern slavery concerns!). Elderly care is a minefield of legal and emotional issues.

scarpa · 09/09/2021 20:40

@sillylittleprincesspants

We have a high income but live to our means. There isnt much we can cut back on that we haven't already as nearly all of our income is on school fees. We have two years left and we're done but it's tight right now.

Very worried about the NI raise. Due to everything else except our salaries going up, including dh who's actually went down last year we are really stuffed now. I'm shocked the government want to do this now.
I did have to hand notice into our school last year and it really upset our dc but then dh managed to find a new job but lower paid and we managed to keep the dc in school but after selling everything we had, so I just don't want to have to go through it all again and schools in our area have waiting lists so it isn't even as simple as pull them out come what may. Really down about it. I think I'll be taking on a weekend job worst case to make up the short fall.

Downsize your house? Move to a cheaper area/one where schools don't have a waiting list? Surely if you had given notice your children's school last year, you had a plan where you were going to send them - did you not think at the time that having to sell 'everything you had' to ensure you could keep spending 'nearly all' your income on a luxury might leave you in a precarious position should anything else change?

Seems remarkably shortsighted of you. And forgive me if I don't feel too sorry for you managing to afford the luxury of having more than one child in private education and a 'high income' and yet complaining about having to get a second job to pay higher NI. That'd be like complaining you had to get a second job to run your Ferrari.

And yes, I'm sure all parents would do their best to keep their children happy. But private schooling isn't even by the longest stretch essential. Not even close. Dry your tears on an expensive blazer and maybe consider for a second that people like my mum, who with the NI raise and UC reduction, has sold her car so that she can afford heating this winter.

DaphneDeloresMoorhead · 09/09/2021 20:34

[quote mobear]@longue The cap only includes care costs, not accommodation and other costs. For example, my grandmother’s care home is £8,000 a month (privately funded) but I think only 1/2 of that is ‘care costs’ so it would take her nearly 2 years to hit the cap even though by then she’d have paid in excess of £180,000 to the care home.[/quote]
It would be more economically viable for her to pay fir a live in carer

Nosferatussidebit · 09/09/2021 20:30

70k is not the same 70k North as it is in the south

And it depends where 'north'. What a house will buy you in a 'naice' area of greater Manchester is very different to the best area of Preston for example.

LadyWithLapdog · 09/09/2021 20:27

@CookL

50% of the money raised by this increase (1.25% of income) will be raised from the too 14% of taxpayers. People who will never need to use state social care and probably don’t use the nhs either
Private hospital doctors, nurses, teachers in private schools are still educated in the state sector, the rich eat in places served by ordinary people, the streets are cleaned etc etc. They don’t live in a total bubble where they can pay for complete exclusivity.

And I bet you everything you want they’ll get all their medication free on the NHS, their catheters and incontinence pads. We’re not all that different regarding needs and behaviour.