Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

New NI tax. How are people meant to afford this?

540 replies

OnTheBrink1 · 08/09/2021 18:51

We bought our house just before covid, got a mortgage that pushed us quite a bit but worked it all out and it’s been doable since then. We needed to push the mortgage quite a bit because we were upsizing to get an extra bedroom for the kids and a downstairs loo and in our area and from what we had before it was a jump.
Been managing since then but no progression opportunities in DH job during the last 18 months due to covid it seems as recruitment was largely paused.
However, now we will now have to pay an extra almost £900 per year on this new tax. £73 I make it.
We don’t have any benefits of any kind.
It’s going to be quite a struggle to afford the mortgage and still maintain the car (which is old but we need for work and kids stuff) plus all the usual bills and food. Kids are between 8-12 and need bus passes, constant uniform and all manner of expenses of course.
I mean we will struggle by but it’s going to be tough to afford that extra £73 a month when we had all the mortgage planned.
Just don’t get how they can bring it in so soon when it’s such an increase. How are others in a more difficult position going to afford this? People will be loosing their houses surely?

OP posts:
Porridgealert · 08/09/2021 20:27

@Maverickess

You know what *@Cocomarine* although it's going to have an impact on me financially in an essential kind of way, I wouldn't begrudge paying it if it meant that we had more staff to provide better care, that I didn't walk out of each shift feeling like I've run a marathon and still haven't managed to meet everyone's needs in the person centred and dignified way I am supposed to and want to. Less stress and better outcomes for the residents would be worth it to me, I just can't see it happening, so I'm going to be paying for my employers profits to go up, direct from my wages now, talk about in one hand and out the other!
No one minds paying more until they have to pay it. And then people start scrambling round looking for reasons why it shouldn't be paid.
maddening · 08/09/2021 20:25

Op regardless of the right and wrongs of the argument can you look to sell items etc or earn some extra cash eg get some hours at the pub?

StressedAF · 08/09/2021 20:22

Sorry I might have this wrong but the comment about people losing homes doesn’t quite ring true. When we bought 7 ish years ago mortgage interest rates were around 5% an awful lot more than they are now.

Did the bank stress test your income when you applied?

I agree it’s not great but I would prefer to pay extra in NI so everyone can access healthcare through the NHS. If we moved to an American style private health care system with insurance, we’d likely pay more in NI to insure the family and even then insurance doesn’t cover everything. In the US some people end up going bankrupt and losing their homes to pay for health care. My friend who used to live in Texas told me she begged her sons nursery not to call an ambulance because she couldn’t afford it, that contributed to her reasons for moving back here.

cookingisoverrated · 08/09/2021 20:20

The money needs to come from somewhere.

Yes, it does. but not from hard working people who are scraping by and aren't able to save much so rich people can pass on their wealth to their children.

vivainsomnia · 08/09/2021 20:08

Sorry OP but if you worked out your budget and the mortgage you could afford not taking into account a safety net of at least £100 a month, then the error is how you budgeted.

An increase in tax was always a possibility with many other things you might need to start factoring in. No-one likes to pay more tax, but to stretch your budget to the max and then say you can't afford it is an error on your behalf.

mobear · 08/09/2021 20:05

@longue The cap only includes care costs, not accommodation and other costs. For example, my grandmother’s care home is £8,000 a month (privately funded) but I think only 1/2 of that is ‘care costs’ so it would take her nearly 2 years to hit the cap even though by then she’d have paid in excess of £180,000 to the care home.

longue · 08/09/2021 20:05

No only care cost so not cost of room, food or cleaning

So the bill will be higher?

Sobeyondthehills · 08/09/2021 20:03

I figured it to be roughly a week's worth of electric for us, we are already struggling, so have no idea how we are going to pick between electric or food for one week.

I feel for those already using food banks and just don't have anymore to give

caringcarer · 08/09/2021 20:02

No only care cost so not cost of room, food or cleaning.

longue · 08/09/2021 20:00

Yes the cap should be a % & I think I heard on the radio that the 86k cap doesn't include all costs.

Tbh it's not even covids fault, this has been coming ore pandemic.

caringcarer · 08/09/2021 19:59

All the people who received handouts during the pandemic through grants and furlough, it was inevitable taxes would have to be raised to pay the debt back down. I am more upset about £86k cap. That means some people with low value houses such as £75k will need to sell their home for care.

longue · 08/09/2021 19:57

@Maverickess exactly

longue · 08/09/2021 19:57

It doesn't even make sense because on one hand it's to fund much needed pay rises in the NHS & social care but then it will just get taken off them by this levy.

Maverickess · 08/09/2021 19:57

You know what @Cocomarine although it's going to have an impact on me financially in an essential kind of way, I wouldn't begrudge paying it if it meant that we had more staff to provide better care, that I didn't walk out of each shift feeling like I've run a marathon and still haven't managed to meet everyone's needs in the person centred and dignified way I am supposed to and want to.
Less stress and better outcomes for the residents would be worth it to me, I just can't see it happening, so I'm going to be paying for my employers profits to go up, direct from my wages now, talk about in one hand and out the other!

jenkel · 08/09/2021 19:56

We worked all through covid, no furlough for us, I thought all the way along we are going to be paying for this for years to come, a little bit sickening when we worked so hard, no benefits for us, no 1 year paid holiday for us, in fact dh is a contractor, has no paid holiday, no sickness entitlement and pays both parts of the ni, employer and employee, ir35 to thank for that. I have no doubt that the nhs and social care needs a massive injection of cash and rethink, but the nhs is a juggernaut, it is too big to be controlled, it is just going to be swallowed up and I honestly think it will make no difference in the long term. 3 years, 6 years, 9 years down the line we will be in the same situation, just paying more tax for the privilege. A cash injection and possible a total overhaul of the management of the nhs and social care will work but that won’t happen as it’s too difficult.

LexMitior · 08/09/2021 19:56

[quote Cocomarine]@Maverickess I think that’s one of my biggest issues! I don’t mind (well, I mind but see the need) to pay more - if it was going to fix or even improve things. I have no faith that it will go into anything other than a Tory crony’s pocket in consulting fees.[/quote]
There has never been ringfenced tax rises in the UK. This is just the line by design so that people don't complain. In practice, it all goes to the Treasury, and they allocate it.

Come the next election the Government won't even have to say this - it can just drop this line and it will. Money reallocated to... wherever they feel like it.

And this tax applies to the low waged by design. It has to. It won't stop houses being sold.

And btw, if you tolerate this, this new lower earner tax take will come again and again. Because its too good a lever not to pull; so its a test.

Still, if you vote Tory, you can either benefit from their policies or pay to aspire to their values.

Anyone who thinks they will reform the housing market or "level up" after this is on glue. Mind you, you would have had to be a bit dim to believe that given all that they have ever done. The clue is in the name.

longue · 08/09/2021 19:55

When you are earning massive amounts, then you should be able to absorb £73pm without it worrying you

2 earners on 50k each are not earning massive amounts. The issue is many or the actual 1% aren't on PAYE.

longue · 08/09/2021 19:53

What I do begrudge is when i'm eligible free prescriptions won't exist or free tfl & my state pension will move out again i'm sure.

Kite22 · 08/09/2021 19:53

Hardly "middle earners" RVN123 if they are paying higher rate tax. You have a skewed idea of what the population as a whole, earns.

If you are going to be paying another £900 pa that means you have a household income of around £100k pa. If you are in a situation where your household income is £100k pa, but a cost increase of £75 pcm is devastating there is something seriously wrong with your finances.

If this calculation is correct, then I agree with this poster. When you are earning massive amounts, then you should be able to absorb £73pm without it worrying you. What are you going to do when interest rates start to rise again ?

Is anyone able to link to a table, indicating how much more people in different income brackets will be paying, please?

KingdomScrolls · 08/09/2021 19:51

Some industries didn't get furlough, and haven't had payrises for a decade, salaries are already low for the responsibility held and this is the thanks

longue · 08/09/2021 19:51

@Cocomarine I agree that those lower down the scale are disproportionately impacted & actually if this does improve things it's worth it. I have little faith the money will go to where it's needed & that we will see more tax grabs.

MatildaIThink · 08/09/2021 19:49

@SeasonFinale
So when you vote in Labour next time and income tax goes up by 3% you're fine with that then?
It usually depends where you are on the scale. Labour will almost certainly only put taxes up on high earners. As usual with most people they say that they want taxes to rise, but what they actually mean is that they want other people's taxes to rise, not their own.

I am prepared to pay more tax for a better society, but from the tantrums on here it seems only a tiny fraction of mumsnetters are.

Cocomarine · 08/09/2021 19:49

@Maverickess I think that’s one of my biggest issues! I don’t mind (well, I mind but see the need) to pay more - if it was going to fix or even improve things. I have no faith that it will go into anything other than a Tory crony’s pocket in consulting fees.

longue · 08/09/2021 19:49

The problem is not high earners paying tax, it is everyone else.

I would argue against that as the real higher earners ie not those on 100k often pay a lot less tax.

"Using anonymised data from personal tax returns, we show that in 2015-16 the average rate of tax paid by people who received one million pounds in taxable income and gains was just 35 per cent: the same as someone earning £100,000. But one in four of these paid 45 per cent – close to the top rate – whilst another quarter paid less than 30 per cent overall. One in ten paid just 11 per cent—the same as someone earning £15,000. The rich, it seems, are not all in it together."

Ariela · 08/09/2021 19:49

@Baystard

matilda you're right about tax but what grates with me is that in Scotland higher earners pay more NI than those elsewhere in the UK already.
To counteract that though, Scottish people don't have to pay Uni fees, or prescriptions. It's really only the healthy childless Scottish that are affected.