Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have a polite word with neighbours about their DS screaming his head off in the garden every day?

612 replies

turndownthevolume · 08/09/2021 18:36

Regular on here, have NC for this.

Our garden backs on to another one belonging to a family with several children. The DC are out in it a lot playing football and making a fair bit of noise. That is all fine obvs, I have DC too (though they are older now) and I'd much rather kids were out and about in the garden than stuck in front of a screen. The dad (who I've exchanged a few friendly words with when lobbing balls back over the fence to them) seems a nice bloke.

But, one of the younger kids has really loud meltdowns more or less every day. He'll be arguing with siblings or whatever and he will just let out these bloodcurdling screams for prolonged periods. It makes it impossible to enjoy sitting out in the garden (they are small gardens and very close together) and in fact when he's properly screaming I have to shut the patio doors and windows. It's a bit frustrating during what'll probably last few days of decent weather not to be able to enjoy our garden or work anywhere near an open window on that side of the house. So I was thinking today that I might just go round and say something along the lines of. 'I totally understand young kids getting worked up is a fact of life and but is there any way, if he's very agitated in this way, you could sometimes encourage him to go inside until he's calmed down?' I appreciate that it won't always be possible but maybe if they have a sense of how its affecting the near neighbours they might consider it some of the time. Maybe this is just City life though and to bring it up would be unreasonable and v upsetting for them. Would appreciate some objective views.

YABU - you live in a city and you just have to suck it up
YANBU - and it would be ok to have a polite conversation with them about it

OP posts:
Kpo58 · 10/09/2021 15:36

So why does not taking a neurodiverse screaming child inside for 10 mins until they have calmed down trump making the entire neighbourhood miserable and stressed and potentially triggering other neurodiverse neighbours?

TwinsandTrifle · 10/09/2021 15:25

Might as well just keep any children locked away from public view as we don't want to cause any upset to the neighbours now, do we?

Yes that's the only alternative to letting them do as they please at the expense anyone else. Rule the roost, or put them in the cellar.

The suggestion that you take your shouting child somewhere he only disrupts your home as opposed to everyone in a 50m radius, means you're "locking your child away from public view"

I mean, I've heard it all now.

You're stopping your child being a nuisance for a short period of time, and showing consideration and respect for others. Not sending him to the tower. Seriously, get a grip.

5zeds · 10/09/2021 15:15

Please don’t swear at me just because I think disabled children shouldn’t be kept inside or taken inside when they are distressed (unless it helps THEM). I think your take on things is horrid, I think you have little understanding of what some people’s lives are like, or how many neurodiverse people behave despite your experience. I do confess to questioning (privately) how much real experience of disability you have and if perhaps you have extrapolated from a child who is fairly easily supported to thinking all are. I honestly don’t want to get into a toy for tat, I think we just hold very different views. That may make you feel I’m “lazy” or “lax” or me think you are “ignorant” or perhaps “unimaginative”, but little is to be gained from mud slinging. I personally am finding it quite hard to receive.

OP we don’t know what is causing this noise if you must, go round and talk to the parents please on the off chance that this is a child with additional needs don’t shout through the fence or blow fog horns or whatever. It would make me sad if you’d approached me but far better than if you’d scared my child or his siblings and made them anxious in their garden.

TwinsandTrifle · 10/09/2021 15:08

My focus is on my child and if anyone is so offended by a meltdown or certain noises then that is on them.

Yes this is more like it. This is finally acknowledging that you don't consider other people. Then pretending that if you had to take a shouting child indoors, it would somehow be alluding to "disabled children must be locked away"

Christing Christing Christ.

(And thank you to PP who also acknowledges this has been explained over and over. Some people know exactly what they're doing, they think they're so entitled and untouchable because they have a SEN card to wave, and bank on you being too intimidated to challenge anything to do with SEN)

toystoyseverywhere · 10/09/2021 15:05

@TwinsandTrifle again, why should the neighbours come before my child having fresh air? Or my child having a trip to the park or somewhere else? But wait let's just put the child last eh.

Might as well just keep any children locked away from public view as we don't want to cause any upset to the neighbours now, do we?

GreyhoundG1rl · 10/09/2021 15:02

@TwinsandTrifle

Do you think those things (meltdowns) are solvable by “taking someone inside”.

Fucketh me. For the twentieth time.... No!

But it solves the neighbours having to listen to it doesn't it!!!

Christing Christ.

Off for a gin.

I'll join you Grin
toystoyseverywhere · 10/09/2021 15:01

@TwinsandTrifle

Yet it continues! Every child is different. What works for one does not work on every child.

I am very entertained by the sad little wannabe insults you continue to try and add into your posts. Now it is making excuses for my child amongst other things! It only makes you look immature and another I know best type... not a good look to have.

Also now apparently the child is apparently now definitely without additional support needs! Another thing you have produced from thin air!

As for what you have stated it is perfectly clear that you believe your way is the only way and yes that is still disturbing. Extremely disturbing. Obviously you are now some type of superior additional needs parent who likes to claim she knows it all and anyone else who happens to say otherwise is immediately lazy amongst numerous other little insults.

Everyone has different requirements so shock horror different things work on different people... also as for the comment about the right organisation it is clear where that one is going!

You seem to think you know best and anyone else is this and that.... what a fall people with that attitide tend to have when it is realised that actually no they don't.

Also as for lazy and making excuses what about the actual safeguarding of an additional needs child in the house? I see you chose to ignore despite attempting to only quote certain parts....

TwinsandTrifle · 10/09/2021 15:00

Do you think those things (meltdowns) are solvable by “taking someone inside”.

Fucketh me. For the twentieth time.... No!

But it solves the neighbours having to listen to it doesn't it!!!

Christing Christ.

Off for a gin.

toystoyseverywhere · 10/09/2021 14:51

I have already mentioned in a post that no way am I hiding my child away. That was made very clear.

My focus is on my child and if anyone is so offended by a meltdown or certain noises then that is on them.

Not the old days where anyone with a disability is automatically hidden away so as not to upset anyone!

@GreyhoundG1rl hope you have finally grasped it this time around

5zeds · 10/09/2021 14:45

Sorry grasped not graded, it isn’t a phrase I’d usually use.

5zeds · 10/09/2021 14:44

The taking inside is to mitigate the effect it has on everybody around you, how have you still not grasped this?

How have you not graded that disabled people don’t have to hide themselves away least their disability impacts you???Confused. Did you miss the “this is my child” campaign by MN or the fairly hefty and rights disabled people have to protect them. Are you so blinkered that you really believe this shit?

GreyhoundG1rl · 10/09/2021 14:35

Do you think those things are solvable by “taking someone inside”.
The taking inside is to mitigate the effect it has on everybody around you, how have you still not grasped this?
TwinsandTrifle has tried hard enough to explain it, God knows.

5zeds · 10/09/2021 14:22

It isn’t an excuse it’s a disability. It would be an excuse if you said it wouldn’t work for your child as it obviously does. It’s like saying “my child can see if I bother to put her glasses on” and implying that the parents of blind children are lazy for not implementing your totally inappropriate intervention. I’m not sure why you keep bringing up your twins or comparing you older child to this one. Does your child have verbal tics or loud verbal stims? Does your child suffer from noisy overwhelming meltdowns? Do you think those things are solvable by “taking someone inside”.

TwinsandTrifle · 10/09/2021 14:08

Nobody knows what’s going on here but to assume it’s anything like your twins is ludicrous.

Sorry, at what point have I said the non SEN child OP is enduring the screams of, is anything like my twins? Or that my elder child with SEN is anything like my twins.

You're correct. That would be ludicrous. Hence no one has said it.

The common factor if you're trying to find one, is that I don't make excuses for my twins, or my DS.

TwinsandTrifle · 10/09/2021 14:04

If someone has only just experienced additional needs recently this could really affect how they feel and could make them doubt their parenting abilities

Well, frankly, good! Because parenting a SEN child is very very different from a NT child. I hope it does make people doubt what they've been doing, question why it's not working, look for the right organisation to help them parent their SEN effectively.

Rather than just declaring "well that doesn't work with my child" and leaving it there. If you can't see that's inconsiderate, lazy and doing the child a massive disservice, I literally can't think of a more simplified way to put it...

TwinsandTrifle · 10/09/2021 13:59

what I’m not is oblivious to the vast difference in ability and degree of disability particularly among the neurodiverse

Hence me mentioning the fact that I've been part of SEN groups for a decade and encountered hundreds of children with all sorts of abilities. With plenty of parents who got on with their lot, however hard it was. And those who claimed it was impossible for them, when we could all see it wasn't. Every child is different. But not so unbelievable rare and unique that they are the only one genuinely unable to be parented. Hope that's less "disturbing" Grin for you now you realise the relevance of me saying I have a long term (13yr) and broad life experience of SEN children, outside of my own SEN child. Did you think I was scoring SEN points per year? Top trumps at 13. Good grief.

how lovely to encounter a special needs parent who believes her way is the best

My "way" is to stop making excuses, don't be self absorbed and inconsiderate, and parent your child. SEN or not. I think you'll find that "way" is not mine, more that of parents who value the needs of others as well as their own.

toystoyseverywhere · 10/09/2021 13:57

As for the claim about removing a child who has had a meltdown from where they are that is also not great advice. Some cannot be.

Also that also teaches others that something that the child cannot control is something to hide away.

Meltdowns happen for many different reasons. Does not mean the child should be removed simply to not disturb anyone else. It is part of how they express themselves. It is what it is.

Obviously in some cases, yes removal is the best option if the meltdown is down to where the child is. That's a given. But not every single time.

toystoyseverywhere · 10/09/2021 13:54

Also there will be other people reading this thread who could very easily have a child or children with additional needs. Who is reading numerous posts stating lazy parenting and discipline is all that is needed and then the follow on school speech which is not helpful.

If someone has only just experienced additional needs recently this could really affect how they feel and could make them doubt their parenting abilities particularly when numerous other members of the ever so lovely public constantly stare and make comments loudly in earshot.

For example, a young mum for example reading some of these who could easily have already experienced people judging regarding being a young mother and constantly "offering" advice and whatnot would already be feeling somewhat vulnerable.

Children all require different things. Not just additional needs children. It isn't right that someone could be made to feel absolutely rubbish through reading some of the ignorant posts on here.

No doubt this post will be cherry picked again but I'm glad I have posted this as people do turn to this site and read plenty of posts without commenting. A lot of times due to low confidence etc. Unless actual evidence of lazy parenting then leaving insults out of it is the responsible thing to do.

toystoyseverywhere · 10/09/2021 13:48

Precisely this. As I've already posted numerous times every child is different. They do not all respond to the same techniques/tactics and they also need to come out of some meltdowns when they are ready to. Whereas some others can be distracted enough to come out of one.

The same as how some require PIC cards whereas some others don't. Same with visual timetables.

It is actually quite depressing to see how many actually don't understand that every child is different. Particularly when someone states they have a child/ren who has support needs.

To label anyone who says otherwise as being lazy and not parenting etc is actually quite vile given the fact that all it is that their child responds differently from your child/ren.

Perfectly used to other views of a certain type but how lovely to encounter a special needs parent who believes her way is the best and is happy to claim all others are lazy and don't bother.

5zeds · 10/09/2021 13:42

@TwinsandTrifle
Like I do you mean? With twin toddlers as well.
I’m sure you are an expert in your own children but frankly your understanding of disability in the wider community does seem limited. Despite how it may seem on this thread I am actually an incredibly strict parent (and I too have twins and disability to contend with), what I’m not is oblivious to the vast difference in ability and degree of disability particularly among the neurodiverse. No, not all children benefit from or can be helped by the intervention suggested, some are not safe to move, some regulate faster with less direction (think PDA presentations), some cannot control their noise levels at all and some sounds are utterly involuntary. Some parents are feckless and some lazy and some at the end of their strength. Nobody knows what’s going on here but to assume it’s anything like your twins is ludicrous.

Those who don’t get it will either listen, learn the hard way when their child develops less endearing behaviour, or carry on thinking they are brilliant parents never pausing to notice their extreme good fortune.

toystoyseverywhere · 10/09/2021 13:42

@TwinsandTrifle I haven't actually called anyone disablist actually.... I haven't resorted to that one however it usually appears when people with certain attitudes and believes appear!

As for twin toddlers is it yet again someone must know best regarding how many children they have/how many have a disability etc? As what was that to do it with?? The thirteen years means nothing. Not all are the same so somewhat disturbing you seem to be so fixed on that...

So apparently it is bang on every single five minutes constantly throughout the afternoon? Hmmm. As I've already stated does this child that so many are going on about coming out with he needs discipline otherwise he will have issues at school and end up with heaven forbid, a label? And also be known as that child also!

Also this little boy must have an inbuilt alarm for it to be happening every single five minutes.... quite some spectacular timing right there to be honest.

Realistically, I suspect there is some noise at times however every five minutes is somewhat exaggerated. Easy enough for someone to do as when someone becomes aware of a noise they do tend to focus and actually listen out for it more than various other sounds. Human nature. All part and parcel of being a human is our brains doing that.

The same as when an annoying buzzing noise occurs in a house at times. It ends up seeming louder and then becomes more and more irritating. A fly buzzing around. A wasp. Those types of things.

To actually claim that anyone who has dared to say the opposite on this thread is a lazy parent etc is ridiculous.

Does that also mean that they therefore don't safeguard their child also? As why would so called lazy parents bother doing that! I'm on about ensuring doors are locked, no switches also nothing left out at all that the child could potentially eat... nothing to climb on.... I could list all day.

Parenting a child who has additional needs is not for lazy parents as the child would be removed. Lazy parents don't tend to make sure all potential hazards are away etc so child would then end up with numerous injuries. They would be noticed before it is met with nobody would realise from outside the family home! Vast majority of additional needs children have various appts so it would be noted and therefore reported

TwinsandTrifle · 10/09/2021 13:28

Imagine if some of these self congratulatory “good parents” actually had to parent anyone with less rudimentary needs

Like I do you mean? With twin toddlers as well.

Pack the excuses in.

TwinsandTrifle · 10/09/2021 13:27

well why would you chose to behave in such a dickish way as to complain to parents about a child making noise for maybe five minutes here and there???

I love how people try and minimize poor behaviour then act offended.

This kid is screaming, in 5 minute bursts, regularly, all afternoon. No parental intervention. Not a jolly hockey sticks little sweetheart, laughing loudly. It's not "noise here and there" it's ear piercing screaming all afternoon, with some relief between each outburst.

The lazy parents on here are something else. And so are some of the SEN parents. Who are rightly being called out on their excuses, and have to revert to the same old same old trying to make out anyone calling them out is disablist, or doesn't get it.

Oh, they do get it. Believe me.

toystoyseverywhere · 10/09/2021 13:23

@5zeds that is one very scary thought indeed!! Wouldn't be so judgemental then, would they? But then again, they would likely cause more issues/damage by pretending everything was just absolutely perfect! Seem the type to!

toystoyseverywhere · 10/09/2021 13:21

All children must respond in the exact same way to multiple sensory experiences. Therefore they must all settle down and work through the meltdown in exactly the same way as others.

A dream world.