Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have a polite word with neighbours about their DS screaming his head off in the garden every day?

612 replies

turndownthevolume · 08/09/2021 18:36

Regular on here, have NC for this.

Our garden backs on to another one belonging to a family with several children. The DC are out in it a lot playing football and making a fair bit of noise. That is all fine obvs, I have DC too (though they are older now) and I'd much rather kids were out and about in the garden than stuck in front of a screen. The dad (who I've exchanged a few friendly words with when lobbing balls back over the fence to them) seems a nice bloke.

But, one of the younger kids has really loud meltdowns more or less every day. He'll be arguing with siblings or whatever and he will just let out these bloodcurdling screams for prolonged periods. It makes it impossible to enjoy sitting out in the garden (they are small gardens and very close together) and in fact when he's properly screaming I have to shut the patio doors and windows. It's a bit frustrating during what'll probably last few days of decent weather not to be able to enjoy our garden or work anywhere near an open window on that side of the house. So I was thinking today that I might just go round and say something along the lines of. 'I totally understand young kids getting worked up is a fact of life and but is there any way, if he's very agitated in this way, you could sometimes encourage him to go inside until he's calmed down?' I appreciate that it won't always be possible but maybe if they have a sense of how its affecting the near neighbours they might consider it some of the time. Maybe this is just City life though and to bring it up would be unreasonable and v upsetting for them. Would appreciate some objective views.

YABU - you live in a city and you just have to suck it up
YANBU - and it would be ok to have a polite conversation with them about it

OP posts:
5zeds · 11/09/2021 09:58

I'm trying to raise my ASD child so that they can fit into the wider world, as such allowances, as some others seem to expect (not me), won't be made for them once they reach adulthood. the majority of autistic people will need reasonable adjustments to “fit into the wider world”. I’m glad you think your child has a chance of doing that but you must be aware that that isn’t an option for many even with exemplary parenting and support. People who are non-verbal and or have learning difficulties and communication deficits make up more than half the autistic population. We are an inclusive society in the uk and as such disabled people can and should expect to be not just tolerated but accommodated and welcomed.

wingingit987 · 11/09/2021 09:51

My kid screamed bloody murder at 6 this morning pretty sure they woke my neighbors this morning. If they say anything to me I'll be apologetic but If they feel they can parent better than me they can 😂🤣

whatthejiggeries · 11/09/2021 09:49

5zeds - I think you are being disingenuous. Blind people describe themselves as such. SEN and SN is usually used to describe mental disabilities such as autism and adhd when outside of a school environment. I think this how most people would understand if

Wonkydonkey44 · 11/09/2021 09:49

@Hhhh3345566

You should probably move to an isolated area with no neighbours if you want peace and quiet.
Confused
Hogwarts4Christmas · 11/09/2021 09:49

Why does (or should) a child's right to scream regularly in their garden supercede another person's right to quiet enjoyment of their house or garden?

Those saying move somewhere isolated if you don't like the noise.... you could equally say the same to the screaming child... that they should be the ones to move away?

I'd bet that the screaming child is negatively impacting far more people than the person who is frustrated listening to them scream, so do the rights of those 20 (or whatever) families now supercede the rights of 1 family/child??

People are understanding of special needs, but that's not an excuse to do fuck all about the behaviour of your dc. You should be considerate (like you want others to be of you/your dc), and try to mitigate the effect on others as much as possible. That's all people would ask.

Underamour · 11/09/2021 09:49

Difficult one. I wouldn’t confront them- they already know and aren’t doing anything about it. You have a few options:-

  1. stand in the garden loudly discussing how noisy their son is
  2. Attempt to calm him down unobtrusively- eg Oh my! Someone sounds upset? Does he need a drink?
  3. play loud music in the garden EVERY time he does it.

You cannot unsay the words you say to them so don’t say anything.

whatthejiggeries · 11/09/2021 09:43

Of course I don't know the exact needs of your autistic child But I'd know roughly what to expect, that it's possible that they are non verbal. That meltdowns may occur etc etc and that they unlikely need a menu in Braille or need a sign language interpreter or a wheel chair ramp. For me (and most people I would think) disabled is an umbrella term which gives me no indication of your child's needs at all. Perhaps this is because you feel you need to make the point that it is a disability where as with other conditions it is obvious You can choose whatever language you wish but I am not sure the rest of the world will understand what you mean.

Hogwarts4Christmas · 11/09/2021 09:40

@LittleGwyneth, thanks 😊

@TwinsandTrifle, @Annoyedanddissapointed, I agree with you both. I'm trying to raise my ASD child so that they can fit into the wider world, as such allowances, as some others seem to expect (not me), won't be made for them once they reach adulthood.

Relentless is a good word to describe how it feels at times too.
My DD is artistic, clever, kind, but struggles socially.
Due to how we've raised her, she has learnt to manage her triggers as well as trying to be considerate of others, but it was a really difficult journey to get to where we are now and it may have felt easier for us as parents (in the short term) to ignore her behaviour, but it wouldn't have helped her, us or anyone else in the long term, and actually, it would've made our lives much harder now.

sue20 · 11/09/2021 09:30

I live in the city and know there’s not a lot can be done re noise round my way it’s constant bloody DIY with noisy power tools. I had same reaction thinking child may have some issues. I Think it’s perfectly reasonable to let them know in a friendly way that it impacts you. We all live in this life together and you are as entitled to enjoy your garden as they are to put a screaming child into their garden. Also child needs to learn there are people to consider around them. Every day is a lot! If children don’t get some checking as they grow up they turn into people who just”laugh in your face” when asked to consider others.

5zeds · 11/09/2021 09:26

But SEN isn’t shorthand for autism Shock and a blind person would have SEN because they would need adaptations to access their education (Eg Braille books?).

What more focused information do you think you are conveying with the term SEN?

Spikeyball · 11/09/2021 08:36

So if you know what autism is, describe what my son is like.

TwinsandTrifle · 11/09/2021 08:29

She can't describe his needs. Just like I wouldn't be able to describe the needs of a diabetic. But I know what diabetes is.

You know what she means.

Spikeyball · 11/09/2021 08:26

Sen only applies to under 25 and sn only applies to children.

Spikeyball · 11/09/2021 08:24

"if you told me your son had autism or SEN or SN I would know what you meant immediately"

My son has sen and autism. Describe his needs.

Disability is important because that is what gives the right to reasonable adjustment.
None of the descriptors would tell you what his needs actually are.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 11/09/2021 08:15

@Hhhh3345566

You should probably move to an isolated area with no neighbours if you want peace and quiet.
5* so original. Amazing. Absolutely right. Bowing to your intelligent remark there. applaus
whatthejiggeries · 11/09/2021 08:05

So everyone in the street should move to a more isolated area because of one family. Why don't they move to a more isolated are so their kid can scream as much as it wants without disturbing everyone else? The OP isn't complaining about a normal level of noise

Hhhh3345566 · 11/09/2021 08:01

You should probably move to an isolated area with no neighbours if you want peace and quiet.

whatthejiggeries · 11/09/2021 07:53

@Spikeyball if you told me your son had autism or SEN or SN I would know what you meant immediately. If you said he was disabled it could be a number of things. It's obviously your call to describe your son how you wish but if you are explaining to others disabled is not necessarily the quickest route to explain your sons condition. I guess it's similar to someone blind describing themselves as disabled. If you let a restaurant know you were disabled how would they cater for that unless you give further description of your condition ie I am blind. Therefore why not just describe as such in the first instance? When the whole point of a disability is that they have additional needs surely the description of the condition is better than the umbrella description that fits anyone from a dyslexic to a paraplegic ?

Spikeyball · 11/09/2021 06:55

SEN relates only to education. Outside of education it is has additional needs or has special needs or has a disability. Ds who has autism has a disability because for him it is disabling.

BobISMyUncle · 11/09/2021 02:48

I've had the very same thing. An older boy, 10 years or so, having what appeared to be a screaming, aggressive meltdown. It transpired that the boy had been diagnosed with Autism. The family, who I got to know really well, fostered several profoundly disabled children. I can only say, that I have huge respect for this couple, who have helped so many children - not to mention the families. I remember the smell. The whole family smelled so gorgeous! There may be a reason, that you are not aware of, why this child is behaving like this. I just know, that I don't know what battles people have to face in their daily lives. Just ask.

5zeds · 10/09/2021 23:40

Well the two descriptors overlap but I’m not sure why you’re more likely to have SEN than be disabled if you have behavioural problems of the kind described. But I really wasn’t looking for a terminology row, I’m in the SW and here we recognise invisible disability rather than describing it as SEN, because we would use SEN more when describing issues in school, or at least in my circle, though I’m beginning to wonder how normal that is if the rest of the country use “SEN” to describe invisible disability.

TwinsandTrifle · 10/09/2021 23:23

I’ve never heard a child with autism or adhd called a disabled child before.

Me neither. Not in real life. MN is the only place I've encountered this. Personally I don't care about, or feel the need to judge, which one people use. But yes, disabled could mean absolutely anything. Whereas SEN is far more specific.

5zeds · 10/09/2021 23:11

I don’t think anyone here would suggest autism wasn’t a disability. In fact they’d probably be a bit cross if you minimised their experience like that.

Smileyaxolotl1 · 10/09/2021 22:59

I’ve never heard a child with autism or adhd called a disabled child before.
In fact I thought particularly with autism the idea that it was a disability rather than a unique way of thinking (i appreciate that for many autism is incredibly ‘disabling’)
would be frowned upon.

TwinsandTrifle · 10/09/2021 22:55

Disabled is a very wide spectrum of things. SEN narrows it down somewhat.

This