Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have a polite word with neighbours about their DS screaming his head off in the garden every day?

612 replies

turndownthevolume · 08/09/2021 18:36

Regular on here, have NC for this.

Our garden backs on to another one belonging to a family with several children. The DC are out in it a lot playing football and making a fair bit of noise. That is all fine obvs, I have DC too (though they are older now) and I'd much rather kids were out and about in the garden than stuck in front of a screen. The dad (who I've exchanged a few friendly words with when lobbing balls back over the fence to them) seems a nice bloke.

But, one of the younger kids has really loud meltdowns more or less every day. He'll be arguing with siblings or whatever and he will just let out these bloodcurdling screams for prolonged periods. It makes it impossible to enjoy sitting out in the garden (they are small gardens and very close together) and in fact when he's properly screaming I have to shut the patio doors and windows. It's a bit frustrating during what'll probably last few days of decent weather not to be able to enjoy our garden or work anywhere near an open window on that side of the house. So I was thinking today that I might just go round and say something along the lines of. 'I totally understand young kids getting worked up is a fact of life and but is there any way, if he's very agitated in this way, you could sometimes encourage him to go inside until he's calmed down?' I appreciate that it won't always be possible but maybe if they have a sense of how its affecting the near neighbours they might consider it some of the time. Maybe this is just City life though and to bring it up would be unreasonable and v upsetting for them. Would appreciate some objective views.

YABU - you live in a city and you just have to suck it up
YANBU - and it would be ok to have a polite conversation with them about it

OP posts:
turndownthevolume · 08/09/2021 20:02

Wifi has died so typing on phone with thumbs!

@CantBeAssed I’d hate for that to be the impact, honestly. I’m sorry you are currently having a hard time with your DS at the mo and wish you all the best.

I really appreciate each of you taking the time to post. It is helpful. I won’t say anything to the neighbours because I’m sure those of you who said it won’t be helpful and has the potential to really offend are right.

A couple of potentially relevant points.

  • this isn’t new, goes back 15 months to when we first moved in, no idea why it’s particularly got to me today probably just a bit hormonal and overwhelmed. I guess I don’t understand why the parents don’t intervene more. If DS has SEN, wouldn’t no attempt at intervention most of the time be unusual?
  • when I say 5 mins, I don’t mean 5 mins a day and that’s it, just intermittent screaming bouts of around that length in response to, say, not getting the ball.

Anyway, I’m reading all your posts and taking them on board, particularly those from posters who have DC with SEN and are haven’t to deal with seriously distressed children on a regular basis

OP posts:
ChristinaXYZ · 08/09/2021 19:55

@Sparklfairy

This will be an unpopular opinion but I don't think kids should be impacting on neighbours just because "they can't help it". Bring them inside.
Totally agree. It is over the top behaviour for the age of the child. If the child has behavioural issues or special needs then the parents need to be with the child more often rather than just leave the poor kid to be genuinely distressed by his or her siblings. If there are no special issues then they need to act to stop the behaviour. Any kid of any age can have the odd OTT behaviour moment but it should not be happening regularly in a 'bloodcurdling scream' kind of way! That is ridiculous! It is anti-social and poor parenting. I'd have the quiet and polite word and if that does not work or they 'laugh in your face' as someone else said, then I'd record and date a few episodes and talk to the council environmental health re the noise. You should not have to put up with it.
Frogsandsheep · 08/09/2021 19:49

I am now paranoid that you’re my neighbour……
I probably am a bit immune to the noise of my dc but they argue a lot over football although I do bring them in when they shout loudly.
One of mine has SEN but my neighbours don’t know that.

Sparklfairy · 08/09/2021 19:46

They know he's noisy. They hear it too

So you admit they're lazy then?

I know some parents don't like to admit their sen kids are hard work, but it is laziness.

Nottheduchess · 08/09/2021 19:41

If you were to call over and ask if the child is ok, would he respond and calm down? If there is no Sen and the child is just a little spoiled knob dramatic, I would definitely have to say something. No way would I allow my children to scream and tantrum in the back garden, it’s just good manners to not inflict your misbehaved children on the neighbours.

esloquehay · 08/09/2021 19:41

@flawedperfection

My hard hat is being donned as we speak, but even if it’s a child with autism or something, wtaf should the neighbours have to put up with its noise? I sympathize with people with difficult kids but I don’t know why others should put up with it.

You sound delightful, referring to a child with Autism as "it" and "difficult".

thinkbiglittleone · 08/09/2021 19:39

I agree that, in the interest of neighbourly relations I probably wouldn't highlight something they are probably already aware of, and possibly trying hard to rectify for what could be a phase which will pass come next summer when you are back sitting on your garden.

converseandjeans · 08/09/2021 19:37

That would drive me mad & YANBU.

I do feel sorry for the child & wonder if the other siblings are winding them up.

You're allowed to want to enjoy your own garden. The parents should intervene & try to at least encourage him indoors. Unfortunately it's their responsibility - even if it is a tough one for them to deal with.

Mindyourbusiness22 · 08/09/2021 19:36

Just don’t do it. The child may well have a disability, just because you can’t see it doesn’t mean it doesn’t exist.

We all need to learn to block out the noise, unless you live in the middle of nowhere noise is going to be all around you. It’s up to the individual how they manage noise. And before anyone says it, i am not including anti social behaviour in this obviously.

DontBuyANewMumCashmere · 08/09/2021 19:36

I don't think you're being particularly unreasonable, but we all know it's a short phase and for the sake of your long term neighbourly relationship I wouldn't say anything.
They know he's noisy. They hear it too.

It's a shame they aren't proactively getting him inside to quiet down, but it's a bit tough really isn't it.

I personally wouldn't rock the boat. Next summer it will be different. Hopefully.

GreyhoundG1rl · 08/09/2021 19:35

[quote RussianSpy101]@Flawedperfection when my autistic son is having a meltdown, which is severe distress at something and completely out of his control, the last thing on my mind is what my neighbours are “having to put up with”
My concern is my son.[/quote]
Understandably. But you'd hardly leave him screaming in the garden multiple times a day?

noprofessional · 08/09/2021 19:34

My children would not be allowed to behave this way, my SEN 9 year old included. It's unacceptable for neighbours not to be allowed quiet enjoyment of their property.
I'm not sure if they would be very receptive if you did talk to them OP. If they aren't bothering to intervene already, it seems they don't care.

RussianSpy101 · 08/09/2021 19:33

@Flawedperfection when my autistic son is having a meltdown, which is severe distress at something and completely out of his control, the last thing on my mind is what my neighbours are “having to put up with”
My concern is my son.

JudgeJ · 08/09/2021 19:32

@Theworldspinsonmyhead

He sounds like he has SEN or the parents are just used to it. Really though... summers almost over and you might ruin the relationship. Hopefully next year he'll be better at controlling his emotions.
Being used to the excessive noise and ignoring its detrimental effect on the neighbours are very different things.
GreyhoundG1rl · 08/09/2021 19:27

Why is it instantly assumed that a child screaming without any input from the parents has sen and is having a meltdown?
Some kids scream. They don't have to be left to do it in the garden so the whole street can get the full benefit of the noise.
So whatever the reason, the parents could mitigate the nuisance factor if they had a mind to.

Littlegemlettuce · 08/09/2021 19:26

I have 2 Sen kids.

I wouldn’t be able to move mine in the middle of a meltdown-it’d make it worse & probably last longer, so bringing the child inside might not be possible as once the meltdown starts it’s already too late. I just have to let it run its course.

We do keep an eye on ours though if they’re in the garden & they are brought in if they don’t play nicely together.

LimeRedBanana · 08/09/2021 19:25

I think it’s a catch 22 OP, no good can probably come of speaking with the neighbour.

The child could very likely be NT (just as likely to be NT as not), but so far, the parents don’t seem to care in the slightest bit that their child is disturbing the neighbours.

I’d be mortified if that were my child, and would (have) told them to keep it down off my own bat.

If you have a parent who’s not doing that, then they’re not suddenly going to start doing it because someone has asked them to. It’s not in their head to care.

Sorry - it sounds really annoying. Wine

DGFB · 08/09/2021 19:24

Of course you can’t say anything. They are children - in their garden!
If you don’t like it then move somewhere away from other people’s gardens?
Before you know it they will be older and more able to handle their emotions. Please don’t expect parents to somehow stop their children having a meltdown

PeachMelba78 · 08/09/2021 19:22

Both my kids are SEN and have meltdowns, we make them go to their respective room to cool down. Meltdowns are no fun for anyone and children need a safe space to get their anger out without impacting others where possible. It’s not always easy to get them to their rooms but they do calm quicker if they have a space to do so.

elizabethdraper · 08/09/2021 19:21

5 mins?

My 7 year old has 2 hour screaming meltdowns

If it happens in the garden, that's where it happens.

He is too big for me to lift and bring inside

Buy some noise cancelling headphones, they are great

drpaddington · 08/09/2021 19:21

I can completely sympathise but as a parent of a child with SEN I think potentially there's not much they can do.

DS has incredibly loud meltdowns. When inside the house with all windows and doors closed he can be heard from inside the house over the road. I don't remember it happening in the garden- although he is generally very loud anyway even when happy- I think I'd probably bring him inside if he did meltdown outside, but everyone would still be able to hear him anyway! I'm constantly on edge, worried about disturbing people, wondering if someone will call the police etc. It's really not fun.

SamMil · 08/09/2021 19:20

I voted YABU. I don't actually think you are being unreasonable, as this does sound like a lot of screaming! However, for the sake of good neighbourly relations, I don't think it would be beneficial to mention it. Your neighbours will know about the noise already and raising it runs the risk of souring an otherwise good relationship between you. I think living next to other people is going to be annoying sometimes, so choosing your battles is probably a good idea. It won't last forever and, having read some of the posts on here, your neighbours could be far worse, so I'd probably try my best to let it go.

Artichokeleaves · 08/09/2021 19:19

I've got an insane dog that barks its head off at anything and nothing. It's not allowed to stand in the garden and drive the neighbours nuts, if it starts being antisocial I go and bring it in. I don't see the difference between a dog making an antisocial amount of disturbing noise (and doubt anyone would say no, let the dog crack on) and a child.

Theworldspinsonmyhead · 08/09/2021 19:19

He sounds like he has SEN or the parents are just used to it. Really though... summers almost over and you might ruin the relationship. Hopefully next year he'll be better at controlling his emotions.

Darkchocolateandcoffee · 08/09/2021 19:17

@Flawedperfection

If they’re reasonable, no harm in mentioning it. If they’re not, then an anonymous note might be an idea. My hard hat is being donned as we speak, but even if it’s a child with autism or something, wtaf should the neighbours have to put up with its noise? I sympathize with people with difficult kids but I don’t know why others should put up with it.
You don't sound at all sympathetic to SEN parents to me. If you had any knowledge of coping with a child with SEN you would know that it's near impossible to stop eg an autistic child in the middle of a meltdown.

Good god.

Swipe left for the next trending thread