Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I am a sahm - AIBU

438 replies

Mintchocchip35 · 08/09/2021 14:00

So dh and I have decided that I will not return to work after 2nd mat leave ends. I was previously a teacher. This is more my idea but dh is supportive either way. He runs his own business and works very long hours usually 6 days a week. He loves it and it is his passion.
So the arrangement will be my 3 year old will go to nursery 3 days a week and my 1 year old will go 1 day a week so I will have one day to myself a week. We also have a cleaner 2 hours a week. So in this instance would you consider all cooking, washing, tidying etc to fall to me even on weekends? Interested to hear your opinions.

OP posts:
KJaggard1 · 10/09/2021 09:35

Yes

gingerlime · 10/09/2021 09:20

Fair enough user. It just always strikes me in these threads that they can read like a stream of projection, interspersed with the odd bit of relevant advice.

Has anyone asked the OP what sort of house she even lives in? It could be a ten bed mansion for all anyone knows Grin.

When people say - “well I did everything,” what does that even mean?

BeenAroundTheWorldAndIII · 10/09/2021 09:19

@UserAtLargeAgain

But what I find odd in these threads is everyone just projects their own circumstances onto the OP - “well I have x children and manage to do such and such, but not this or that.”

I don't think "everyone" has done that at all. Sure, some posters have, as an example of what did or didn't work for them, but most posters have posted something like "OP should do everything", "DH should do everything when he's not working", "OP shouldn't pick up DH's pants", "It should be 50/50 when they are both at home", "DH should prioritise family time on his day off" etc - without any reference to what they do themselves.

I agree @UserAtLargeAgain I think for reference everyone should say how many kids they have and the ages. I bet half of these people don't even have kids and make assumptions on what raising a child is like (which we all thought would be a doddle pre kids 🙈🤣). I also find people's memories are incredibly short and forget how it really was or properly have a different view on how things were to DP/DH.
RobinPenguins · 10/09/2021 09:16

Also people’s concepts of housework vary massively - between someone who is OCD to someone who is just happy if the place is reasonably habitable. But nobody asks the OP what she means.

But tbh that wouldn’t really change people’s answers, would it? If the OP’s expectation is “reasonably hospitable” then it’s not a massive job on top of having a weekly cleaner, so she should do it. If the OP’s expectations are excessive and involve her exercising anxiety through extreme cleanliness…then she should do it in those circumstances too.

UserAtLargeAgain · 10/09/2021 09:13

But what I find odd in these threads is everyone just projects their own circumstances onto the OP - “well I have x children and manage to do such and such, but not this or that.”

I don't think "everyone" has done that at all. Sure, some posters have, as an example of what did or didn't work for them, but most posters have posted something like "OP should do everything", "DH should do everything when he's not working", "OP shouldn't pick up DH's pants", "It should be 50/50 when they are both at home", "DH should prioritise family time on his day off" etc - without any reference to what they do themselves.

gingerlime · 10/09/2021 09:02

“the vast majority of house stuff should fall to you”

Well yes if you’re the only one there 6 days a week Confused Kind of inevitable.

But what I find odd in these threads is everyone just projects their own circumstances onto the OP - “well I have x children and manage to do such and such, but not this or that.”

But nobody asks what “house stuff” even means for the OP. Eg. does she live in a modern three-bed semi where you can whizz round and get most stuff done in a couple of hours? Or does she live in a sprawling, older house which needs a lot more care and maintenance?

Also people’s concepts of housework vary massively - between someone who is OCD to someone who is just happy if the place is reasonably habitable. But nobody asks the OP what she means. They just talk about themselves and what they do Grin. Then they will talk about the reasons they stayed at work, or went part-time or used such and such childcare arrangement - as if all jobs and marriages are the same. It’s very odd.

SeriouslyISuppose · 10/09/2021 08:59

@gingerlime

As usual on MN, a thread with “SAHM” in the title means people who never want to SAH or who know full-well they don’t have the option in any case will have SOOO much to say. Any SAHM thread will always teach 1000 posts. Says it all really about the insecurity and general situation for women today.
In this case, it sounds uncannily as if the OP is giving up her career not because she wants to be a SAHM, but because her husband is a messy workaholic who doesn’t pull his weight with housework or childcare, and she’s burnt out and worried about increasing resentment, so she’s taking the hit. It’s a disaster waiting to happen.
UserAtLargeAgain · 10/09/2021 08:52

@gingerlime

As usual on MN, a thread with “SAHM” in the title means people who never want to SAH or who know full-well they don’t have the option in any case will have SOOO much to say. Any SAHM thread will always teach 1000 posts. Says it all really about the insecurity and general situation for women today.
Actually I think on MN it's the case that a lot of people will have done the SAH role at least temporarily - even if only during maternity leave - and certainly will have close friends or family members that are SAHPs so have quite a good insight into what it involves. So it's not surprising that many people feel they have a reasonable opinion.

Posts about parking often reach 1000 posts as well. What does that say?

LST · 10/09/2021 08:47

@gingerlime

As usual on MN, a thread with “SAHM” in the title means people who never want to SAH or who know full-well they don’t have the option in any case will have SOOO much to say. Any SAHM thread will always teach 1000 posts. Says it all really about the insecurity and general situation for women today.
Technically I have been SAH for the past 18 months. I still think if you can be SAH and not work and have a cleaner and afford nursery then the vast majority of house stuff should fall to you.
gingerlime · 10/09/2021 08:44

As usual on MN, a thread with “SAHM” in the title means people who never want to SAH or who know full-well they don’t have the option in any case will have SOOO much to say. Any SAHM thread will always teach 1000 posts. Says it all really about the insecurity and general situation for women today.

BeenAroundTheWorldAndIII · 10/09/2021 08:38

@holidaynearlyover

Some of these justification responses are hilarious! Yes both parents have a role in bringing up the children but if you are sending your children to nursery and getting a cleaner than what are you doing? I can see it breeding resentment in a few years when your eldest is at school and your youngest has more hours at nursery.

Bring a SAHM with two very young children at home all the time is very different to your set up. That is a hard job but you can't say it's full time when so many woman manage to work and still do all the chores etc that you don't do.

Do what you want and be happy about if but I'm a bit fed up of people peddling the argument that you have a tough ride!

Totally disagree with everything you have said here! I have two children (2 1/2 and 10 months) the oldest we kept in nursery 2 days a week for a few reasons, but actually I get very little done in the day time when I have them both, or even just the baby. I actually feel like I get more done when I have them both as the baby will entertain himself better in his sisters company. All children are not the same, it would be impractical (and impossible) for me to do a deep clean of any room/bathroom, ironing etc with them here. I know OP has a cleaner for 2 hours a week but im constantly picking up/washing up/sweeping etc but it's still a mess when hubby comes home from work and I'm mid tea prep and the kids have every toy possible all over the place, so although 2 hours would be great for bigger jobs it's hardly like she doesn't need to lift a finger the rest of the week. It's very much a full time job looking after kids, if you found it easy then great, but that's not everyone's experience. My kids have both been very clingy and held very much. Breastfeeding to sleep/contact napping etc. Even come bed time if falls to me (due to bfing) to see to the baby hourly in the night. I suspect I'll enjoy my return to work and indeed felt more energised for the housework/childcare like I did after my first. It's an absolute pleasure being a mum but it can be emotionally, physically and mind numbingly draining 🤷🏼‍♀️ my husband fully admits his days at work are easier and more predictable than my days at home and he is more than happy to muck in. After all he gets his 30 mins dinner in peace, to pee in peace, to enjoy a hot drink and gets his two hands to complete the task at hand with a wriggling baby and a I'm gonna climb on every single thing toddler 🤷🏼‍♀️ I'm beginning to wonder if my reality is completely different from others. I think this thread should come with a disclaimer of how many kids each person has and ages for reference 🤷🏼‍♀️
Ellie474747 · 10/09/2021 08:27

Id also think about the reason for wanting to be a SAHM, As this sounds like more hard work this and partly why I’ve stayed in work, I have full respect for SAHM I don’t think people realise how exhausting it can be. Really do think about this before you give up a career.

Feelingoktoday · 10/09/2021 08:26

I would hate to live with a partner that chooses to work 6 days a week. Entirely different if they have to in order to bring a wage into the house but this is t the case here. What kind of life have you both got? It’s not a relationship it’s a housekeeper/childcare relationship. I would rather have less money and spent time with my husband. And I would rather he spent time with his kids too. We have choices in life. He chooses to work rather than be with his family. Lovely.

Mintchocchip35 · 10/09/2021 08:22

Dd not dad!

OP posts:
Mintchocchip35 · 10/09/2021 08:21

I've been teaching for 12 years and I'm quite confident I could get another job in a few years time. In fact the lady that is currently covering my maternity leave has just returned herself from a 4 year career break as her dad has now started school.

OP posts:
TatianaBis · 10/09/2021 07:57

You’re just arguing for the sake of it now. Additional training is not necessarily required as I have said. Depends on the field, the length of time out of the workplace etc.

‘Career break’ refers to anything from paid sabbaticals, to voluntary work, to further study, to taking time out for kids, to travel.

If you want to catastrophise that women have “lost” their careers that’s up to you, I really cba to argue further.

EspressoDoubleShot · 10/09/2021 07:39

If she is not working she doesn’t have her career
QTS is retained yes however as I said a break on practice requires additional training to demonstrate competence. So whilst yes one retains QTS one doesn’t retain career if not working. Career is active and participatory, which so why returning to practice is required. Career break is the phrase used to describe the pause in one career during a period of inactivity.

TatianaBis · 10/09/2021 07:34

I have never disputed that additional work may be required, I have made that point myself. Depends on the job and the length of time out of the workplace.,However, this doesn’t mean OP ‘has no career’ as you claim. She will not lose her QTS on a break from work.

EspressoDoubleShot · 10/09/2021 07:00

In fact the DoE has a scheme to encourage teachers to return yes as I said a break from working requires return to practice training. You don’t just rock up after an absence you need to undertake additional training,show your understanding contemporary practice etc

EspressoDoubleShot · 10/09/2021 06:56

Bingo! ‘Ardest job in the world has been trotted out
Don’t be so daft. Multiple jobs are more arduous than watching your own kids

IWannaGoToTheSpa · 10/09/2021 06:44

I apologise as i haven’t read all the comments. I think my opinion might be different to others though. And an aside opinion, which you haven’t asked for but I think is more an important point tbh!!

Firstly, you have two children, and your one year will be with you most of the time apart from one day a week when they’ll be in child care and and you’ll have your three year old two days a week, and three days in child care. Right? It’s great you have some help here even though it’s paid for help. And good for you on the cleaner, I have one too in a similar situation to you. I don’t have the one day to myself though. Otherwise similar - I’ve had my two children with me all the time while I’m on mat leave, my 7 month old with me and my 4 year old about to starts school next week. It’s been bloody hard work.

Hope I’ve got all the facts right. I’m sorry, but I absolutely don’t think all the rest at home falls to you in any way!!! Your job is the kids during the day. Your husband’s is his business. The rest is shared! End of! I’ve done both working and children and by far working is the easier job by far!!!! That day to yourself should be your day to rest, for your sanity!!! It’s really hard to have a one year old pretty much full time (bar onr day) a three year old as well two if those days and get much else done. I’m soooooo much more tired looking after my kids than going to work and kids send you crazy. You need that break, OP. As for picking up his shit - you’re not his maid! He should be keeping himself and you don’t pick up ha clothes off the floor. He’s not your third child. From what you said, he sounds like a good guy and not a tyrant. But I’d not fall into the trap of you having to do everything else round the house. IMO cleaning is a small chore, there’s still a million other house keeping things to do. Everything else should be shared between you and your husband I think.

My second point, which you’ve not asked for!!! Is that are you sure you want to give up work entirely? I know a lot of women to do this. I’m talking purely in the situation where they can because their husband earns enough money and the wife doesn’t have to wrk. I think it’s really unwise. Even if you think, “that would never happen to me” (and I pray it doesn’t) what happens if in 10 years time you guys split up? I know so many women who bragged about not having to work and now are getting divorced and their husbands are shafting them as they haven’t worked im years, now are unemployable and can’t get a job. I think for sensible reasons it’s good to keep your hand in. Just my advice out of kindness x

holidaynearlyover · 10/09/2021 06:37

Some of these justification responses are hilarious! Yes both parents have a role in bringing up the children but if you are sending your children to nursery and getting a cleaner than what are you doing? I can see it breeding resentment in a few years when your eldest is at school and your youngest has more hours at nursery.

Bring a SAHM with two very young children at home all the time is very different to your set up. That is a hard job but you can't say it's full time when so many woman manage to work and still do all the chores etc that you don't do.

Do what you want and be happy about if but I'm a bit fed up of people peddling the argument that you have a tough ride!

VictoriaB07 · 10/09/2021 06:09

Exactly,why are so many commenting about her DH weekends off when OP clearly stated her DP works long hours for 6 days?
Read the post people!

SD1978 · 10/09/2021 02:04

Given the 'main' cleaning is outsourced, and you have one 'free' day, then yes- I would expect that parent to do the majority of the household tasks. He has one day off- as do you, however your one day off is child free, and his isn't. I would expect him to be involved with the family in that day, but wouldn't expect all household tasks to fall on him, given there is two of you there. Is he home early enough to do bedtime with the kids when he's there? If not, id expect that to be shared on the Sunday, no just him every week, as the fast he's not involved is due to work, not because he can't be arsed.

Mamanyt · 10/09/2021 01:46

Yep. I'd expect to do between 75-85% of the household duties, with DH pitching in on small stuff...help with clearing away after meals, putting kids to bed (although NOT every night, but fathers should be doing that if for no other reason than the kids are accustomed to it if Mum is ill), such as that. But yes, the vast majority should be your responsibility. That has now become your "career." It is unpaid, but critically important.