Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young people are foolish for leading cars?

183 replies

Kitchendrama1 · 08/09/2021 13:19

£2k to get the car and 36 payments of £350 of which you get nothing at the end of 3 years. £14,600 with insurance included, for a car you won’t own for 3 years.

I can understand insurance is high for a young person, but it’s dumb?

OP posts:
Myusernameisnotmyusernameno · 09/09/2021 12:06

We lease our car. It's brilliant. We know how much it will cost us a month and don't have to worry about a payment at the end of it. I did have a car on PCP in 2010 and that was a total money pit. I don't recommend that at all.

Passmeamenuatthetottenham · 09/09/2021 12:03

I agree with you about phones but cars are a different matter. Cars are getting more and more environmentally friendly with every passing year so there is a big difference between cars being produced now and even three years ago

Emissions rules in this country and Europe have been really strict for years. And even with hybrid/electric vehicles there is no way that producing/shipping new cars for everyone constantly is more environmentally friendly than keeping the same car for 10 years or so.

It makes me laugh when people try to be 'environmentally friendly' by buying a new hybrid car every couple of years!

MoonbeamSprinkles · 09/09/2021 10:44

If we all bought a new car and kept it the average lifespan of a car which is 10 years, we’d still need the same number of cars being made than if we did what happens now.

Which is that some people buy new and some people buy those cars second hand in a few years time.

It’s the same number of cars on the road except the 4 new cars are being sold to the same person rather than 4 different people.

Some people are always going to want to buy second hand as in normal times it can work out cheaper.

If they weren’t able to sell the 3 year old lease cars off the garages wouldn’t do it.

canigooutyet · 09/09/2021 10:37

It's worked well for one of my dd's. New driver under 25.

She shopped around and got a newer model Kia on lease paying around £170 a month compared to roughly 350 a month insurance. Paid around £600 deposit and has it for 2 years.

Had she bought an older Kia it was around 9k for the car, 350 pm for insurance plus an up front cost of nearly a grand.

The lower cost has allowed her to put more money into an ISA. When the lease ends she might go down the route of ownership depending on the insurance cost as she wants more than the standard theft and fire. Plus she has the peace of mind knowing if something goes wrong, she hasn't got a potential hefty repair bill, it's not two cars knocked together etc. Plus if she loses her job and cannot quickly find another one, the car cost can easily be covered whereas the insurance would be an issue as although it could be cancelled, many companies charge a hefty fee for this.

When I talk to her later will let her know she is foolish and should have gone for the expensive option of having a car. And instead of shopping around, she should have just got the first deal she saw.

MoonbeamSprinkles · 09/09/2021 10:22

The point Im trying to make is, if we kept our cars longer, what would the impact on our climate be? What is the difference of 4 new cars v 1 that is already produced over a (say) 12 year period?

But the cars ARE being kept, they’re just changing ownership.
There’s still a good trade to be had in second hand cars and even really old bangers can be stripped for parts and those parts recycled. None of those 4 cars will be put in the bin.

It’s not new cars driving up demand, it’s people having multi car households and people having cars that they don’t need and taking trips in a car that could be walked or cycled.

It’s not like phones that become obsolete and end up in landfill, cars stay on the road or in the system until they are of no use anymore.

Ylvamoon · 09/09/2021 10:13

@MoonbeamSprinkles that is your personal opinion. As you said yourself, the 2nd hand car is already available.
You didn't buy it, because you didn't want to pay the price and believe it will be unreliable. Or did you buy it because you didn't want to wait for a new one?
These are pure economic decisions.
The point I try to make is, if we kept our cars longer, what would the impact on our climate be? What is the difference of 4 new cars v 1 that is already produced over a (say) 12 year period?

FTEngineerM · 09/09/2021 10:06

Cars may be the most reliable they’ve ever been but that doesn’t guarantee a four year old car won’t need work doing to it.

Just because a car needs maintenance it doesn’t make it unreliable. It only becomes unreliable when parts aren’t changed preemptively. I don’t actually know anyone who changes big parts preemptively though so it’s certainly more common to wait for a failure before replacing. Big jobs like clutch, flywheel, drive shaft, timing belt etc do you actually read the manual and change according to mileage or do you just wait for it to die and take the risk.

MauveMavis · 09/09/2021 09:45

I think this is a generational gap and bizarrely also an income thing.

I've always been financially comfortable. I buy a new (or newish) car and keep it until it gets expensive. Therefore you may meet me driving something very new or a 10yo tatty car.

Most of my friends/ family do the same.

Worked out over the years we keep the car it is cheaper than PCP but you have to be able to afford the car in the first place and manage any unexpected big bills.

So it's actually an economy that is only available to those who have money. In addition you have to be secure enough socially to not care that people may judge you on your car.

MoonbeamSprinkles · 09/09/2021 09:43

Unreliable cars? Cars are the most reliable they’ve ever been

Yes unreliable.
Cars may be the most reliable they’ve ever been but that doesn’t guarantee a four year old car won’t need work doing to it.
That’s why you have to have a yearly MOT after three years.

Kitchendrama1 · 09/09/2021 09:39

@MoonbeamSprinkles

See, I am not sure about this at all. Why is it better to produce something new when you can actually use what is already there?

Because there aren’t enough reliable cars to supply demand.
Hence why second hand car prices are insane at the moment.

I just tried to buy a second hand car and no matter how I looked at it it didn’t make sense.
The second hand version of the car I wanted was 12k and the brand new version was 14k and I would only have to pay off the depreciation.
The second hand version went in a shot because new cars are taking ages to come off the factory lines and also lots of people prefer owning outright.

If there was loads of reliable second hand cars just lying around I would agree with you but it’s a sellers market at the moment.

Unreliable cars? Cars are the most reliable they’ve ever been
OP posts:
MoonbeamSprinkles · 09/09/2021 09:37

See, I am not sure about this at all. Why is it better to produce something new when you can actually use what is already there?

Because there aren’t enough reliable cars to supply demand.
Hence why second hand car prices are insane at the moment.

I just tried to buy a second hand car and no matter how I looked at it it didn’t make sense.
The second hand version of the car I wanted was 12k and the brand new version was 14k and I would only have to pay off the depreciation.
The second hand version went in a shot because new cars are taking ages to come off the factory lines and also lots of people prefer owning outright.

If there was loads of reliable second hand cars just lying around I would agree with you but it’s a sellers market at the moment.

Ylvamoon · 09/09/2021 09:16

I agree with you about phones but cars are a different matter. Cars are getting more and more environmentally friendly with every passing year so there is a big difference between cars being produced now and even three years ago

See, I am not sure about this at all. Why is it better to produce something new when you can actually use what is already there?
I think if you buy a new car and have it for 12 years, that is better than having 4 new ones built in that time.
Yes, fuel consumption safety ect. will improve ... but what else actually does improve? What is the environmental impact of 4 new build cars v running an older car during this time?
Fact is, we need consume less.

MoonbeamSprinkles · 09/09/2021 08:59

Where do people think their steady supply of reliable cars that are a couple of years old that they are buying with their loans are coming from?
They are ex lease cars.

MoonbeamSprinkles · 09/09/2021 08:58

There is quite a lot wrong with it actually when our planet is completely fucked and people are ripping through its resources because the phone they got last year is now 'old' and they want the latest one.

I agree with you about phones but cars are a different matter. Cars are getting more and more environmentally friendly with every passing year so there is a big difference between cars being produced now and even three years ago.
Also after your lease is up the dealers don’t put the car in the bin they sell them on, most cars get driven into the ground even if they change ownership.
The demand for second hand cars is through the roof at the moment it’s insane.

Themostwonderfultimeoftheyear · 09/09/2021 07:56

We lease. We did buy but it was an absolute money pit and so stressful. Never again.

We don't pay £350 though.

Charlieiscool · 09/09/2021 07:52

It was my priority to work and save towards buying my first home. A car was something that had to wait.

SofiaMichelle · 09/09/2021 07:28

There are a few posts in this thread which seem to be confusing 'leasing' with 'PCP'.

They are very different in all respects, other than there being a monthly payment.

Oh also, it's a bit of a myth that you can't buy the car at the end. When they take them back off you they are going to see them anyway

Many lease contracts are specifically written to exclude you ever being given the option to buy the car when the contract ends because there are VAT implications and other HMRC issues for the lease company.

Sometimes a friend or relative might be able to but the car but not the person with the original lease contract.

Not just a myth.

Passmeamenuatthetottenham · 09/09/2021 07:16

You’d trade in a working car for the same reason you’d buy a new tv, phone or IPad if yours is working. People like to upgrade things and there’s nothing wrong with that.

There is quite a lot wrong with it actually when our planet is completely fucked and people are ripping through its resources because the phone they got last year is now 'old' and they want the latest one.

Passmeamenuatthetottenham · 09/09/2021 07:14

Urgh, the whole PCP thing is just another consumerist thing, where car companies have convinced people that you must have a new or nearly new car every 3 years and then go onto the next new shiny thing?

What's wrong with taking out a loan for a perfectly decent car that you can then drive for 10 years or so? I don't mean an old banger that has terrible emissions or is really unsafe but there are tonnes of really decent cars out there that aren't brand new.

The whole new car all the time thing is just so unsustainable.

londonrach · 09/09/2021 07:05

I've a friend who leased her car ..it's cheaper than buying a car and her job needs her to drive alot. Your figure s are totally wrong. She careful ly worked it out. She's in her early 50s so not young

DwangelaForever · 09/09/2021 06:13

Depreciation. I have only ever owned one car outright and it was an old banger, I am on my 3rd purchase hire car. It just makes more sense to me, I can get a new one every 3/4 years without worrying too much.

slightlyworriedthissunday · 09/09/2021 06:04

You’d trade in a working car for the same reason you’d buy a new tv, phone or IPad if yours is working. People like to upgrade things and there’s nothing wrong with that.

You sound like such a snob OP!

I am no better with my (now) owned outright 6 year old car than the next person with their £350 lease. I’m no worse either. It’s just a choice.

BlaiseAnais · 08/09/2021 22:23

@Kitchendrama1 forgot to say. I meant those figures are expensive. There are cheaper ways to lease cars that make it got value rather than implying you were lying.

BlaiseAnais · 08/09/2021 22:19

@Kitchendrama1

No deposit.

I negotiated hard, I bought in March. It was already in the forecourt as the person who had specd its finance fell through. They registered it with the new years plate so got a great car for minimal cost.

funnelfanjo · 08/09/2021 21:35

@linerforlife

Because why would I want to own a rapidly depreciating asset? You know the old saying - if it drives, flies or fucks, lease it!
No, I’ve never heard that saying. It’s charming. Confused

But excepting property and antiques, you can’t expect anything you buy to appreciate in value. You buy something, you use it. When you don’t want it any more then you sell it if it’s worth something to someone else, whether that’s a car or phone or a boat or designer shoes. You’ll never get all your money back, but you had the use of it while you owned it.