Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young people are foolish for leading cars?

183 replies

Kitchendrama1 · 08/09/2021 13:19

£2k to get the car and 36 payments of £350 of which you get nothing at the end of 3 years. £14,600 with insurance included, for a car you won’t own for 3 years.

I can understand insurance is high for a young person, but it’s dumb?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SofiaMichelle · 10/09/2021 19:48

The depreciation of the car counterbalances the interest on the lease...

There is no interest on a lease???

Is this another post confusing leasing with PCP, which is completely and incomparably different, or have I misunderstood?

Leasing and PCP are as different as renting a house and buying a house (with a mortgage).

Kitchendrama1 · 10/09/2021 19:16

@whatthejiggeries

I always bought my cars outright. Now I lease. The depreciation of the car counterbalances the interest on the lease and honestly I prefer not paying out a lump sum. Most people I know lease - we could all buy outright if we wanted but it works for us. I will be leasing a car for my son when he is old Enough to drive
How much is it?
OP posts:
whatthejiggeries · 10/09/2021 06:47

I always bought my cars outright. Now I lease. The depreciation of the car counterbalances the interest on the lease and honestly I prefer not paying out a lump sum. Most people I know lease - we could all buy outright if we wanted but it works for us. I will be leasing a car for my son when he is old Enough to drive

SofiaMichelle · 09/09/2021 23:09

@NHSWoes

Again, mixing up leasing and PCP.

They are absolutely not the same thing.

NHSWoes · 09/09/2021 22:37

@InFiveMins

I always lease and have had monthly repayments of more than £350 for years. But I like having a nice new car every 3 years and never have any trouble with maintenance. Works for me!
I get that having no maintence would be good. However I have a loan for a (lovely car) at 150pm. If I saved the additional £200 per month that leasing would cost me this would easily cover all tax, maintenace and insurance with some to spare. And then once my loan is paid off then I'm only paying out basic amounts. Also have to bear in mind the car isn't yours as a PCP and then it's a nightmare if you unfortunately do have an accident.
BobMortimersPetOwl · 09/09/2021 20:45

Leasing isn't for me, but if its done with proper consideration for cost vs needs then I can't see why it's an issue generally.

What I see a lot of, and it is with younger people, is people leasing a high spec car which they could no way afford to have any other way, for in excess of £500 a month. Often they also complain about how they can't afford to save up.

MoonbeamSprinkles · 09/09/2021 19:47

^ So if 20 people buy a new car, then 20 will be produced. If the 20 people then get a new car after 3.. 6 ... 9 ... 12 years 80 more cars are produced...
If they don't get a new car and keep it for 12 years, only the original 20 cars are produced in that time period.
Same with 2nd hand, if you buy a 3/4 year old car and keep it for a further 10 years rather than replacing it after 5 years, 1 car less needs to be entered into the supply chain.^

But this isn’t what happens in reality.

As demonstrated on this thread there are many people who would prefer to buy second hand and wear it into the ground.
And there are many people only leasing because second hand car prices are so expensive.

So we don’t have 20 people all changing their car every year

We have ten people changing their car and then ten people buying those cars and continuing to use them.

If those ten people didn’t have access to second hand cars then they would need new cars as well so we’d still have to make the same number of cars.

Like I keep saying those lease cars don’t go in the bin, they get used usually right up until their parts are recycled.

MoonbeamSprinkles · 09/09/2021 19:38

If I had £350 spare a month as a young person I'd save it for a year and buy a car with it, it's what I did when I was young, eight year old VW polo £1650 in 2007

But the second hand car market is a completely different beast to what it was in 2007.

There’s very slim pickings for £3500

KingdomScrolls · 09/09/2021 19:11

If I had £350 spare a month as a young person I'd save it for a year and buy a car with it, it's what I did when I was young, eight year old VW polo £1650 in 2007, my brother had it after I was done with it, stayed in our family for eight years until someone crashed into it and wrote it off, never cost much other than basic servicing, tyres etc. You don't need a brand new car at that age, the insurance is too high, even now we tend to buy cars about five years old

FTEngineerM · 09/09/2021 19:01

I think everyone’s getting confused with that persons comment on insurance.

I read it as £170/m for the car insurance for the lease car. When it would have been £350/m for a purchased car.

Leased is just a long term rent, probably why the insurance is less. When he daughter goes to buy her own car one day she wants it to be fully comp and not have to oh £350/m just for insurance.

Shade17 · 09/09/2021 18:58

I'd imagine in the contract is some such disclaimer demanding fully comprehensive insurance as well.

I suspect it’s one of these deals which includes insurance

Kitchendrama1 · 09/09/2021 18:31

@Ylvamoon

If we all bought a new car and kept it the average lifespan of a car which is 10 years, we’d still need the same number of cars being made than if we did what happens now

So if 20 people buy a new car, then 20 will be produced. If the 20 people then get a new car after 3.. 6 ... 9 ... 12 years 80 more cars are produced...
If they don't get a new car and keep it for 12 years, only the original 20 cars are produced in that time period.
Same with 2nd hand, if you buy a 3/4 year old car and keep it for a further 10 years rather than replacing it after 5 years, 1 car less needs to be entered into the supply chain.

This is how we should be thinking. Look at the goods that are already there and replace when absolutely necessary. And stop falling for all all the clever marketing that is tapping into our future earnings.

Yes exactly!

How long would you say a car lasts?

OP posts:
AdobeWanKenobi · 09/09/2021 17:57

She's driving a PCP car without fully comp insurance?? Have I read that right?
That sounds extremely risky!!

I'd imagine in the contract is some such disclaimer demanding fully comprehensive insurance as well.

Shade17 · 09/09/2021 17:32

When people talk about depreciation just for driving a new car off the forecourt, have they not heard of ex-demos with little more than delivery mileage for 20-25% off new prices? Do they not haggle with the dealer if they want a brand new one that's not even been registered?

Both our cars were bought new, one is a few years older than the other. They were brand new, not even demos, and we haggled over 20% off the list price, in fact the latest one was 25% off list - we paid £15k and the list price was just under £20k.

Surely no one just pays the list price at a dealership without haggling?

That’s not a thing at the moment due to the supply situation.

Shitfuckcommaetc · 09/09/2021 16:51

@canigooutyet

It's worked well for one of my dd's. New driver under 25.

She shopped around and got a newer model Kia on lease paying around £170 a month compared to roughly 350 a month insurance. Paid around £600 deposit and has it for 2 years.

Had she bought an older Kia it was around 9k for the car, 350 pm for insurance plus an up front cost of nearly a grand.

The lower cost has allowed her to put more money into an ISA. When the lease ends she might go down the route of ownership depending on the insurance cost as she wants more than the standard theft and fire. Plus she has the peace of mind knowing if something goes wrong, she hasn't got a potential hefty repair bill, it's not two cars knocked together etc. Plus if she loses her job and cannot quickly find another one, the car cost can easily be covered whereas the insurance would be an issue as although it could be cancelled, many companies charge a hefty fee for this.

When I talk to her later will let her know she is foolish and should have gone for the expensive option of having a car. And instead of shopping around, she should have just got the first deal she saw.

She's driving a PCP car without fully comp insurance?? Have I read that right? That sounds extremely risky!!
Badbadbunny · 09/09/2021 16:44

When people talk about depreciation just for driving a new car off the forecourt, have they not heard of ex-demos with little more than delivery mileage for 20-25% off new prices? Do they not haggle with the dealer if they want a brand new one that's not even been registered?

Both our cars were bought new, one is a few years older than the other. They were brand new, not even demos, and we haggled over 20% off the list price, in fact the latest one was 25% off list - we paid £15k and the list price was just under £20k.

Surely no one just pays the list price at a dealership without haggling?

MoonbeamSprinkles · 09/09/2021 16:33

Yes and the number of people who 'prefer new cars' has gone up massively. Think about how many people leased new cars 20 or even 10 years

This is because there are so many more cars on the road.
So many more people have more cars in their households.

Because the general demand for cars have gone up they haven’t been able to keep up with supply.
So they’ve incentived buying a new car with very good lease deals where you only have to pay the depreciation. This helps with the supply of new cars AND second hand cars.

Instead of calling people buying the new cars foolish, we should be buying less cars full stop.
Then the supply would be more in line with demand and they wouldn’t incentivise new cars and it would go back to what it was 7 years ago when it made sense to buy a second hand car and drive it into the ground.

Passmeamenuatthetottenham · 09/09/2021 14:22

But they aren’t doing it for everyone. They’re doing it for the people who prefer new cars.

Yes and the number of people who 'prefer new cars' has gone up massively. Think about how many people leased new cars 20 or even 10 years ago. No one needs a new car. It's just another form of rampant consumerism that is probably only going to get worse as everyone continues to desperately try and keep up with the latest thing.

SofiaMichelle · 09/09/2021 13:28

@MauveMavis

Worked out over the years we keep the car it is cheaper than PCP but you have to be able to afford the car in the first place and manage any unexpected big bills.

PCP isn't leasing, if that's what you mean.

ThreeLittleDots · 09/09/2021 13:13

I've always bought lowish mileage economic 8-10yo little cars for around £2.5 - 3K and expected to pay several £££s per year in MOT, servicing and repairs. I pay an independent mechanic to give them the once over before I buy, and keep them going for years and years.

Leasing a Corsa at £150 per month with £1,400 deposit, over 48 months is £8600, which is much more than I've ever spent buying and keeping a 2nd hand car on the road over the same period.

But of course understand that some prefer to spend their money in different ways. Each to their own.

Shade17 · 09/09/2021 12:48

She shopped around and got a newer model Kia on lease paying around £170 a month compared to roughly 350 a month insurance. Paid around £600 deposit and has it for 2 years.

Sounds like a great deal if it includes insurance. Is it like the Peugeot just add fuel scheme?

Ylvamoon · 09/09/2021 12:41

If we all bought a new car and kept it the average lifespan of a car which is 10 years, we’d still need the same number of cars being made than if we did what happens now

So if 20 people buy a new car, then 20 will be produced. If the 20 people then get a new car after 3.. 6 ... 9 ... 12 years 80 more cars are produced...
If they don't get a new car and keep it for 12 years, only the original 20 cars are produced in that time period.
Same with 2nd hand, if you buy a 3/4 year old car and keep it for a further 10 years rather than replacing it after 5 years, 1 car less needs to be entered into the supply chain.

This is how we should be thinking. Look at the goods that are already there and replace when absolutely necessary. And stop falling for all all the clever marketing that is tapping into our future earnings.

MoonbeamSprinkles · 09/09/2021 12:17

My friends with PCP Range Rovers are constantly at the garage getting issues fixed

That’s because range rovers are notorious for having issues.
That’s got more to do with it being a Range Rover than it’s age.

MoonbeamSprinkles · 09/09/2021 12:15

And even with hybrid/electric vehicles there is no way that producing/shipping new cars for everyone constantly is more environmentally friendly than keeping the same car for 10 years or so.

But they aren’t doing it for everyone. They’re doing it for the people who prefer new cars.
If they did it for everyone then the supply of second hand cars in three years would be astronomical, therefore the price would come down and it would be more attractive to buy second hand and the market would reset itself with more people buying second hand again.

At the moment we have a shortage of second hand cars so if you’re looking to buy a car then a new car on lease makes financial sense. Then in three years time those cars will go back into the system and the price of second hand cars will go down and leasing won’t be as attractive anymore.

Passmeamenuatthetottenham · 09/09/2021 12:11

Also makes me laugh the idea that 4 year old cars aren't reliable! My friends with PCP Range Rovers are constantly at the garage getting issues fixed!