Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be reluctant to drive this journey without a mirror?

61 replies

nomirror · 08/09/2021 11:08

A couple of weeks ago, the nearside wing mirror (just the glass part) fell off my car whilst driving. I did pull up as soon as I could and walk back to look for it but couldn't see it, it's possible it had smashed and shattered when it fell off. The mirror was one that had apparently been stuck on by previous owner and had come loose. These things happen.

I went online to order one - due to the age of my car it wasn't available from any local retailer unless I bought another stick on one (my car actually has heated mirrors, so it makes sense to buy a proper replacement with the backing plate so the heat sensor will work - it doesn't work on the current one as the backing plate is covered in double sided tape and adhesive). Annoyingly delivery for the mirror and plate was either unspecified, or 21-28 days. So I put in the order for the one with the delivery date.

In the meantime I've been driving my usual local journeys to shops etc, as there are perfectly manageable with just rearview and offside mirror.

However next week I am due to do a 4 hour motorway journey, and I am reluctant to do this without my nearside mirror. I'll be on the M1 and M25, lots of changing lanes etc and I completely rely on both wing mirrors. DP rather scoffed at this and said (as he often does in driving, having had a licence for 20 years longer than me) oh you'll be fine. But I simply don't feel confident to do it.

Is that being wimpy of me? OR am I right to be cautious? The earliest date for the mirror to be delivered is Monday, and I'm due to travel on Weds so I'm hoping it should be here, but it's possible it might not. My back up plan - which will be annoying if I have to do it - is to spend another £10-12 (in addition to the £20 for the one on order) for a stick on one from Halfords but I am slightly annoyed at the double expense! Which again DP says is not needed as I can drive without it - whereas I think yes I can drive without it, but I can't confidently drive without it on a motorway!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EIIa · 12/09/2021 04:18

It’s a tenner op

Probably less than what you’ll spend in food on your journey 🙄

Stick your hand in your pocket and stop being so stingy

KnobJockey · 12/09/2021 04:16

I dont get why you just haven't bought it for £10 already.

It's £10, it would make the total cost of a mirror £30 (still reasonable), it would have made your life easier for the month, and you would be safer for you and everyone around you. It's an absolute no brainer. And, I'm sorry to say, if people say you might not be able to afford £10, then you can't afford to be running a car safely. It's a maintenance cost.

I personally wouldn't dream of driving a car on a motorway without both wing mirrors. I have lost the front mirror before and had to manage the rest of the journey without it, but I think side mirrors are essential.

daisychain01 · 12/09/2021 04:08

I agree with the point upthread that local driving is more dangerous than motorway driving.

The thing about motorway driving is that percentage-wise, you get fewer accidents than on local roads, so in that sense they are safer. However, due to speeds and stopping distances, when an accident occurs it is always worse and invariably involves more vehicles. Local journeys are inherently more risky due to the unpredictability and often random way people drive. Plus people are far more complacent and take more risks because they think they know the road well as they do the journey most days.

Your DH is being unreasonable telling you to "man up" (hello mysoginism, how ya doing!), equating the desire to drive safely has nothing to do with manning up and everything to do with being a good safe and considerate driver, and recognising cars are killer machines in the hands of a complacent person.

KihoBebiluPute · 12/09/2021 04:05

Yanbu - you need both mirrors to safely change lanes on a motorway. Unless you resolve to do the whole journey in the leftmost lane, as slow as the vehicle in front the whole way.

PrincessNutella · 12/09/2021 03:11

The idea that even one person would think that driving without these mirrors is reasonable is jaw-dropping to me.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 08/09/2021 15:52

Pay the £10 and stop worrying. If your DH kicks up tell him that your safety and peace of mind is worth more than £10

cinnabarmoth · 08/09/2021 15:47

Both my wing mirrors have had to be replaced with stick on ones from Halfords, I can't get the exact ones due to weird anomaly with my car model. I traced round the bit where the mirror goes and was able to get close approximations from a different make and model of car from Halfords - they have now lasted several years.
You don't have to have a nearside mirror (my car passed an MOT without one) but for the sake of £10 just get a stick on one for now and replace properly as and when, if you really need to.

Heyha · 08/09/2021 15:32

Oh 🤦 that will teach me to skim read 😂

I'd be slightly less worried then in that case but yes I'd still pay out the £10 for peace of mind. And still not care what DH thought!

Off to have a word with myself about proofreading now....

saraclara · 08/09/2021 15:21

@Heyha

Not having a driver's side mirror will fail an MOT so that would suggest they're pretty bloody essential (I'm almost certain as well that is the only mirror required by law as long as you've got that plus one other but I can't find a good source).

I'd definitely not be on the motorway without a full compliment of mirrors and I wouldn't be bothered one bit who knew it! It's hard enough towing stall trailer with just the side mirrors but I will do that as of course you can. I couldn't entertain not having the use of the driver's side one especially for the sake of £10.

It's the passenger side that's broken. Not the driver's
Heyha · 08/09/2021 15:09

Not having a driver's side mirror will fail an MOT so that would suggest they're pretty bloody essential (I'm almost certain as well that is the only mirror required by law as long as you've got that plus one other but I can't find a good source).

I'd definitely not be on the motorway without a full compliment of mirrors and I wouldn't be bothered one bit who knew it! It's hard enough towing stall trailer with just the side mirrors but I will do that as of course you can. I couldn't entertain not having the use of the driver's side one especially for the sake of £10.

Excited101 · 08/09/2021 14:56

I’ve been driving well over 15 years, so a lot more than some and a less than others. I drive all over quite happily, all different cars etc. Get the intermediate mirror. If you’re a decent and confident driver it’ll just make you more so, and safer too.

LakieLady · 08/09/2021 14:47

YANBU, OP.

I wouldn't want to do any significant amount of motorway driving without a full set of mirrors, they're so important when you're changing lanes.

RincewindsHat · 08/09/2021 14:44

No way would I drive on the motorway without both mirrors. You'd be putting yourself and everyone around you at risk.

I had to buy a stick on replacement mirror for my car once after the mirror glass flew off randomly while driving one day, it was super cheap and Halfords ordered it in for me very quickly. It lasted fine for over a year before I sold the car on.

DynamoKev · 08/09/2021 14:40

Off topic but why are we still calling them wing mirrors when they have been fixed to the door for about the last 40 years at least?

saraclara · 08/09/2021 14:29

I had the same issue. It was almost impossible to get hold of the right mirror for my specific model of car, even via the scrap dealers consolidation websites.

It's absolutely legal to drive without a nearside wing mirror, as long as the offside and rear view are available, but I postponed a meetup that would have required a motorway journey of an hour. I just wasn't comfortable with it, and I'm not a nervous driver. I just know that I do use it a lot on the motorway, especially when moving to a lane on my left.

I'd definitely get the stick on. It's £10 for peace of mind. It wasn't an option for me, unfortunately.

nomirror · 08/09/2021 14:14

I do care if I'm over cautious, I don't want to be one of 'those' drivers - the ones who won't use a motorway, or drive in a city, or in an unfamiliar area, that kind of thing. I've only been driving for a few years and although I think I'm a good, safe driver, my experience is vastly less than my DP. Sometimes he will basically tell me to man up about things and I realise I am being too risk averse (I never used to like driving in heavy rain or snow for example but have done it many times now and whilst I don't enjoy it am not thrown by it any more) but others I feel that my concerns are valid - as here, and I just want to calibrate my views with others. Isn't that the purpose of AIBU to be a sounding board to get other opinions? (some of which may be dissenting).

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 08/09/2021 13:49

@nomirror

It's not causing angst and drama - I simply wanted to understand if I was being over cautious about driving without a mirror, as my DP was so matter of fact about it.

Seems like most people would prefer to have a mirror as well, so it's not me being a wimp.

Who cares if you’re over cautious. There’s a solution to the problem and it’s a pretty low stakes one. Just buy the stick on mirror and move on with life.

Or don’t because your DH doesn’t think you need one, but quite frankly that would be bizarre. Do you normally second guess such mundane things in life when someone has a different opinion than you?

nomirror · 08/09/2021 13:19

It's not causing angst and drama - I simply wanted to understand if I was being over cautious about driving without a mirror, as my DP was so matter of fact about it.

Seems like most people would prefer to have a mirror as well, so it's not me being a wimp.

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 08/09/2021 13:16

I feel like the obvious answer is to buy the stick on mirror, wait and see if the other one arrives, if it does install the real one and return the stick on one, if it doesn’t then use the stick on on one and then install the real one when you get home (or wait until the stick on one falls off then install the real one)

I’m so curious how this is causing angst and drama.

pickingdaisies · 08/09/2021 12:49

On a motorway I wouldn't drive without one, because so many people do crazy undertaking manoeuvres. Seems like they aren't prepared to wait for cars to pull back in after overtaking. Or they can't bring themselves to pull out?

BobbinThreadbare123 · 08/09/2021 12:44

Those looking to the past for wing mirror-less cars - the legislation that requires them is for all vehicles first used after 1st Aug 1978, so it's been a thing for quite some time! Driver + rear is a legal requirement. Any lost/unusable mirror is a MOT fail anyway.

Shade17 · 08/09/2021 12:43

It's also not rocket science to realise it's safer with both.

Of course, but it doesn’t mean you will die without a NS mirror. Perspective is needed.

This seems like an incredibly dangerous idea.

Get a grip. Two would be preferable but it’s not the end of the world.

OhRene · 08/09/2021 12:41

A few phone calls to local scrap yards will find you one and it'll be just a few quid. If not, stick one on temporarily. You really shouldn't take the risk not having one.

Toottooot · 08/09/2021 12:38

You are being unreasonable to quibble at the thought of spending an extra £10-12 for both the safety you and other road users. Even if it’s not legally required the peace of mind it would give you is surely worth the tenner alone.

PrincessNutella · 08/09/2021 12:36

This seems like an incredibly dangerous idea.