Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about people who say ‘they worked hard to get to where they are’?

970 replies

MessyMissyMe · 07/09/2021 18:06

Generally these are highly paid people who were able to go to University (support from parents/inherited intellect/confidence and self belief built up by secure, happy childhood) or had the resources to start their own business and were lucky enough to get remunerated by employment that they enjoyed and were good at, didn’t have outside influences or stressors that made things harder/took up time they needed to study or build a career.

They basically are just LUCKY and don’t deserve their success anymore than a cleaner or a care worker living hand to mouth in social housing deserves their lack of.

AIBU to get annoyed at people who say this?

OP posts:
Comedycook · 10/09/2021 18:25

I'm also sceptical as to how anyone could afford to buy a property straight out of uni by saving up. I know Loads of people who worked during uni...they made enough to get by, not but a property. Tell us more!

Rozziie · 10/09/2021 18:22

@LipstickLou

For once this is a serious debate. Nature or nature might be appropriate here. I have earned huge salaries in my career and then not been able to get a job above minimum wages. I have been a carer and have a mentally disabled child. We have owned a multi bedroom house and had to sell it in the crash. We have had a very difficult decade. However I never give up. I had a crap secondary school but went to Oxford. I wanted a last big job and I got it. I have a tricky family (compulsive gambler, bipolar mother) but I didn't want ordinary. I worked from 13. My son who spent ten years in rented accommodation with bastard landlords would never rent, he bought at 22 by saving through uni. He worked two Jobs. (He got a full loan as I was a carer) and now he works for the ggovernment! We all have a chance to help others. I support many charities, volunteer and would be delighted to help those at job clubs. Too posh to push, hell no!
I find it very hard to believe your son bought a house through saving through uni, to be honest. When was this? My loan didn't even cover my accommodation at uni and I had a part-time job and worked every summer, and that only just covered food, transport and other essentials. I wasn't destitute as a student but I couldn't have saved anything, and I graduated owing a lot of money on my student loan.
LipstickLou · 10/09/2021 18:17

For once this is a serious debate. Nature or nature might be appropriate here. I have earned huge salaries in my career and then not been able to get a job above minimum wages. I have been a carer and have a mentally disabled child. We have owned a multi bedroom house and had to sell it in the crash. We have had a very difficult decade. However I never give up. I had a crap secondary school but went to Oxford. I wanted a last big job and I got it. I have a tricky family (compulsive gambler, bipolar mother) but I didn't want ordinary. I worked from 13. My son who spent ten years in rented accommodation with bastard landlords would never rent, he bought at 22 by saving through uni. He worked two Jobs. (He got a full loan as I was a carer) and now he works for the ggovernment! We all have a chance to help others. I support many charities, volunteer and would be delighted to help those at job clubs. Too posh to push, hell no!

EspressoDoubleShot · 10/09/2021 17:53

@OldGeezer your post is spectacularly myopic and ill informed
You had parents who had the knowledge & drive to know about 11+ and what’s more you were tutored to pass. That’s lucky and advantageous.Tutoring secured you additional time & advantage. You’re clearly smart and have utilized your luck.

Plenty people work!work work and repeat to earn minimum wage and scrape by

Hard work is not the sole endeavour of the driven

Too many people have factors that hold them back and inhibit progress
poor socioeconomic backgrounds.
Absent or don’t care parents
Childhood experience of trauma and loss
Unstable accommodation

There is conscious and unconscious bias
Class
Nepotism
To over come as obstacles to progressing

lazylinguist · 10/09/2021 17:31

Does not mean that for one minute that those people did not work hard for their exam results though

No of course it doesn't. I've taught plenty of privileged, highly intelligent, very hard-working students. But the whole point of this thread is that however hard you work, your start in life (over which you had literally no influence) is highly relevant and was even partly responsible for your ability or motivation to work hard or not work hard. And that some people ignore or underestimate that when they appear to think that only hard work got them where they are.

HelloHummingbird · 10/09/2021 17:24

It's not just luck

HelloHummingbird · 10/09/2021 17:23

I'm a teacher, and I see this every day. The effects of a child's environment, upbringing and family attitudes are apparent from early primary age. It's easy to have the right attitude to education and to your future if that's what you've been fed from birth.

Does not mean that for one minute that those people did not work hard for their exam results though, as a teacher, like myself they work damn well hard apart from 1% who are lucky enough to have the IQs to not revise.

They're lucky in their upbringing but they still worked hard, and lots at the expense of their social life and mental health.

lazylinguist · 10/09/2021 17:21

And it doesn’t mean that others (who didnt. Have such. luck. Aren’t working hard either)

That's what I was saying Confused.

Easier @lazylinguist, not easy. Two very different things imo.

Fine, easier then. But a huge amount easier imo.

Yellowbowlbanana · 10/09/2021 17:11

OldGeezer is who the OP is about. Oblivious to the luck in their circumstances.

RacistAngst · 10/09/2021 16:52

And it doesn’t mean that others (who didnt. Have such. luck. Aren’t working hard either)

RacistAngst · 10/09/2021 16:50

Easier @lazylinguist, not easy.

Two very different things imo.

lazylinguist · 10/09/2021 16:39

I'm a teacher, and I see this every day. The effects of a child's environment, upbringing and family attitudes are apparent from early primary age. It's easy to have the right attitude to education and to your future if that's what you've been fed from birth.

lazylinguist · 10/09/2021 16:35

Wow, some people really are unbelievably oblivious. Do you not realise that even being in a position to be tutored for the 11+ and be entered for a scholarship at a public school already put you in a completely different ball-game from so many other children, OldGeezer?!

Children whose parents can't offer those things or don't give a shit, or don't even understand where to begin with seeking out those kinds of opportunity? Children with abusive parents, drug addict parents, children whose parents are barely able to feed their families? Would you tell them to 'make their own luck'? Nobody makes their own luck at age 11. You were given that luck to get you started, regardless how hard you might have worked later. Do you not understand that other people also work 'all the hours god sends' in the menial exhausting jobs they have no choice but to put up with, and without getting a vet's salary?

Your luck may have happened at the beginning of your life, but it affects all of it, including your character and ability to be motivated.

PalmarisLongus · 10/09/2021 16:33

"Two years pre/11+ tutoring = a good pass & scholarship to a local public school."

Lucky you had tutoring. Scholarships meant some one chose you, lucky that they picked you and not any of the others.

"Nose to grindstone throughout secondary education (including additional holiday studies + holiday jobs to supplement pocket money)"

Lucky you could study in holidays, lucky you got a summer job, lucky you got pocket money.

"Result - good ‘O’ & ‘A’ level passes.
Result - place at veterinary school."

Lucky you got a place at vet school and they didn't dismiss your application like they would have 100 others, but those 199nothers just didn't work as hard as you I guess.

"Work all the hours that God sends ( including 2 or 3 in 5 nights and weekends on duty )'
Lucky you got e ployed by someone and they didn't dismiss your CV like they would have other peoples. Or lucky that the business you set up worked out and ditn fail like 100ps of other businesses every year. Maybe they just didn't work hard enough?

"save, borrow invest in the business"

Lucky you could save and the recessions and pandemics didn't negatively affect that. Lucky you could borrow from people and banks and the people making that judgement said yes instead of no.

But yep. No luck at all.

Isn't it funny how often those that have been the luckiest deny it the most?

Comedycook · 10/09/2021 16:19

Oh and well done for working so hard at secondary school @oldgeezer

Can I presume one of your parents didn't die? Can I presume they weren't alcoholics? Can I presume you weren't a young carer? Can I presume you didn't live in cramped temporary accommodation?

Comedycook · 10/09/2021 16:17

@OldGeezer

You MAKE your own luck + work, work, work.

Two years pre/11+ tutoring = a good pass & scholarship to a local public school.

Nose to grindstone throughout secondary education (including additional holiday studies + holiday jobs to supplement pocket money). Result - good ‘O’ & ‘A’ level passes.
Result - place at veterinary school.
Work all the hours that God sends ( including 2 or 3 in 5 nights and weekends on duty ) save, borrow invest in the business - and repeat until retirement.

So yes - I’ve been lucky but I ( in fact We ) wouldn’t be where we are without me and SWMBO working bloody hard too!

Hilarious.

I presume your parents tutored you for the eleven plus or paid someone to. That's lucky you had parents who gave a shit

Rozziie · 10/09/2021 16:14

I'm sure a girl in Afghanistan or someone who was paralysed from being hit by a drunk driver would love to hear all about you 'make your own luck', @OldGeezer.

It's a horrid, ableist saying that implies everyone is starting on a level playing field, which couldn't be further from the truth.

Badbadbunny · 10/09/2021 16:10

Taking a "huge" risk can mean different things.

A lottery winner spunking all the winnings on red at a roulette wheel is taking a very different risk to someone investing their lottery winnings in a business with a properly prepared & researched business plan. The former being a 50:50, the latter could be more of a 90:10 risk of working due to the proper research etc., and the business plan may well include mitigations if the "risk" didn't work, i.e. recovering some of the money from asset sales etc.

OldGeezer · 10/09/2021 16:09

You MAKE your own luck + work, work, work.

Two years pre/11+ tutoring = a good pass & scholarship to a local public school.

Nose to grindstone throughout secondary education (including additional holiday studies + holiday jobs to supplement pocket money). Result - good ‘O’ & ‘A’ level passes.
Result - place at veterinary school.
Work all the hours that God sends ( including 2 or 3 in 5 nights and weekends on duty ) save, borrow invest in the business - and repeat until retirement.

So yes - I’ve been lucky but I ( in fact We ) wouldn’t be where we are without me and SWMBO working bloody hard too!

Testingprof · 10/09/2021 12:30

@BritInUS1

Wow, really !

I didn't have a wealthy upbringing, I didn't go to Uni, I got a full time job and studied in the evenings to learn more and get more qualifications to reach where I wanted to be (all self funded)

I have worked so hard to get where I am, I have taken huge risks, I have not be handed anything on a plate, I have worked hard for every single penny of what I have today

So have I been LUCKY, no !!!

Well actually… yes. You said it in your post, you took huge risks. If you were unlucky nothing would have gone your way and you’d have lost everything. Unless you didn’t really take huge risks… you were lucky but that doesn’t negate your hard work. Nor does it negate the hard work of those who have been less fortunate than you or those who were less able to take ‘huge risks’.
forinborin · 10/09/2021 12:26

On the luck topic, I don't think it is often down to being specifically "lucky". Sometimes it just suffices not to be unlucky.
I am not super successful, but doing OK overall.
So many people who started from the same position as I did (quite modest) and were smarter, more hardworking, passionate and more deserving overall. But then illnesses happened, elderly parents happened, disabled children happened to them, while I sailed through with no major setbacks.

WellLarDeDar · 10/09/2021 12:20

I think it's a combination of luck and hard work and a little bit of making good judgement calls at critical moments. The amount of each of those varies from person to person. I do think it's unreasonable to say all successful people are just lucky, some of them are but others have worked really hard. Calling it luck implies every successful person is just passive and doesnt try for things which I dont think is true. You sound a little bit bitter and I'm guessing luck hasnt favoured you. Things might not be great now but that might change.

8Sense8 · 10/09/2021 12:13

Some people have a lot of adversity in childhood and no-one to really support them through it. It's these children who will struggle with overwhelm, recognising an opportunity and managing emotions to enable them to reach for it. Plus a lack of all the social modelling that others have mentioned. Plus challenges that prevent them from making sense of what successful people do that is helpful. Re working hard- There's hard work that feels like pushing the hamster wheel as much as you're expected to (and more). There's also having resilience and self esteem to step beyond the hamster wheel (the work or way if living that you know). It's quite possible to take a resilient person add adversity and undermine their resilience. Then increase support and reduce adversity and they could spring back. It's not the same with someone who had the childhood that I described. They are far less likely to become resilient and able to grab 'lucky' opportunities. This isn't a simple thing.

EvilPea · 10/09/2021 11:26

Successful people tend to have successful children, they lead by example, that is not to say normal parents can not have successful children, many do, but not at the same rate as previously successful generations.

This is so so true and undervalued. It’s having an understanding of money, how to manage it and make it work. How to take risks knowing there’s a safety net of a roof over your head if it goes wrong. As well as the surrounding friends and family with additional links and advice. That support and advice is utterly invaluable in shaping a future.

mim321 · 10/09/2021 11:09

Successful people tend to have successful children, they lead by example, that is not to say normal parents can not have successful children, many do, but not at the same rate as previously successful generations.

I think this is true. Partly due to having opportunities that other children don't have but also the types of role models amongst our group of friends. We're fortunate to be well-off, as are most of our friends, and the kids see the type of jobs that fund those lifestyles and have made their target career choices accordingly. Not necessarily a good thing as my kids are aiming at professional services types jobs, rather than pursuing their passions. Money doesn't necessarily bring happiness and I worry that they might regret their choices down the line.