Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about people who say ‘they worked hard to get to where they are’?

970 replies

MessyMissyMe · 07/09/2021 18:06

Generally these are highly paid people who were able to go to University (support from parents/inherited intellect/confidence and self belief built up by secure, happy childhood) or had the resources to start their own business and were lucky enough to get remunerated by employment that they enjoyed and were good at, didn’t have outside influences or stressors that made things harder/took up time they needed to study or build a career.

They basically are just LUCKY and don’t deserve their success anymore than a cleaner or a care worker living hand to mouth in social housing deserves their lack of.

AIBU to get annoyed at people who say this?

OP posts:
Rozziie · 08/09/2021 13:12

@JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil

I mentioned my friend who complained that I had been given more opportunities than her and was lucky earlier.

Another poor choice she made was turning down the opportunity to get a funded professional qualification at work. She declined it as they said that if she left within 1 year she’d have to repay it and as she wasn’t happy there she felt it was a risk. She’s still there 12 years later. She’s upset as they haven’t offered her any paid for training in recent years and her pay has stagnated.

Yes some of it is luck, some of it is hard work but some of it is also about the decisions you make.

Did she have any kind of a safety net if it hadn't worked out? That's another thing a lot of people don't think of when questioning why people haven't made a financial or career decision. I quit my job to do a full-time course leading to a career change and the stress was incredible knowing that if it didn't work out, I'd be up shit creek without a paddle. It took me 5 years to be able to take that plunge. Someone with a spouse or parents who could support them always has to consider that they could end up in an even worse situation than the one they're in.
FrauleinSchweiger · 08/09/2021 13:07

@Annoyedanddissapointed - I think it depends which side you're on Smile.

From my personal point of view, having had my physical limitations for most of my life, anyone who can do 'normal things' is v lucky. But I do appreciate that my view is subjective. I guess if you have not been limited by your health then to you it is normal and I'm the unlucky one.

I don't necessarily think it makes a difference whether people think they're lucky or I'm unlucky but the point is it's still "luck" that has played a part IFSWIM.

Rozziie · 08/09/2021 13:07

@Annoyedanddissapointed

Is it a luck to be in the majority of population being healthy or is it a bad luck not to be.

I personally don't think it's a luck to be healthy. It's unlucky to not be.

Saying it's lucky makes it sound like an usual thing imo.

This is exactly what a healthy person would say.

Almost 20% of the UK population has a disability of some kind. So no, not the majority, but it's a significant minority, isn't it? I wouldn't say it was particularly unlucky to be part of the 1 in 5 people.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 08/09/2021 13:01

I mentioned my friend who complained that I had been given more opportunities than her and was lucky earlier.

Another poor choice she made was turning down the opportunity to get a funded professional qualification at work. She declined it as they said that if she left within 1 year she’d have to repay it and as she wasn’t happy there she felt it was a risk. She’s still there 12 years later. She’s upset as they haven’t offered her any paid for training in recent years and her pay has stagnated.

Yes some of it is luck, some of it is hard work but some of it is also about the decisions you make.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 08/09/2021 12:59

Is it a luck to be in the majority of population being healthy or is it a bad luck not to be.

I personally don't think it's a luck to be healthy. It's unlucky to not be.

Saying it's lucky makes it sound like an usual thing imo.

FrauleinSchweiger · 08/09/2021 12:58

@Rozziie - yes I didn't see your post until after I had had my little rant Grin.

I completely agree with you about being extremely lucky not to be limited by your body or mind.

Rozziie · 08/09/2021 12:54

@FrauleinSchweiger I did make the point about physical and mental health just before you posted!

It is indeed so depressing how so many people say they haven't benefitted from luck and then go on to talk about how they 'grafted'. Just how hard do they think someone can graft if they're disabled or chronically ill? I'm fortunate enough to be able to work, but my earnings and job options have been hugely limited by my health. All this about 'get up at 5am and go for a run and get four hours' sleep a night and power on'...I'd end up in hospital after about a week of that.

If someone is healthy enough to be able to work very long hours and not become extremely sick, I'd say they're very lucky indeed.

Cornettoninja · 08/09/2021 12:53

Are rich conmen/grifters successful because they work hard and have other attributes mentioned here (risk takers, inquisitive, driven etc.) or because they’re lucky enough to have not been caught?

(As an aside I really struggled to think of a gender neutral alternative to the word conmen! Grin)

FrauleinSchweiger · 08/09/2021 12:48

@Maverickess - thank goodness for people like you Smile

I am astounded having RTFT that there has been so little mention of the importance and luck of being physically and mentally healthy.

Judging by this thread, and by successive governments and political parties pre election campaigns, those of us who are unable to work, however hard we would like to, really are totally worthless in a capitalist society. And don't we know it.

A few posters have mentioned about people with disabilities or chronic illness and how they have achieved great things. That is genuinely fantastic and they will have probably worked even harder to get where they have. However many of us with poor health will have tried to "work our arses off" but unfortunately our bodies have other ideas.

Just as well some of us value people for more than their economic value. And before everyone piles on, I am well aware that a healthy economy is required in order to provide for those of us at the bottom of the heap.

However it is rather disingenuous for those who are able to work hard not to acknowledge that health is the greatest gift you have been given. So many people seem to take it for granted.

Many things in life can be determined by things within your control eg willingness to work to the best of your abilities, pride in your work and a healthy work ethic.

However, as the OP has mentioned, there are also a number of factors which are outside your control.

I fully admit that I have been lucky in being born into a stable family, in a western society that provided me with educational opportunities. I am lucky that because of my ethnicity background, I have not been subject to racism. I am lucky that I was born with a level of intelligence that enabled me to learn and develop my intellectual skills.

I can recognise all of these things as being lucky. Just as I can recognise my bad luck in having had a lifetime of a disabling and chronic illness which means I am unlikely to be able to carry out any paid employment, however "hard" I work (although I have done in the past).

It seems to me that if MN is reflective of society at large, it is quite a depressing picture.

AlexaShutUp · 08/09/2021 12:47

@TheStein

I wasn’t a great mum, my mental health is shit and I had no motivation myself. He was bullied throughout school and grew up knowing that his father didn’t give a shit about him. One of his friends committed suicide during his GCSE years which knackered up his own mental health (and his results!). But he wanted to be rich and he has worked since he was 13 constantly to achieve that.
OK, so a huge well done to him for getting their some challenging life circumstances.

But do you accept that someone else might have worked just as hard without necessarily achieving the same success? Through no fault of their own?

And do you agree that, if someone chooses to prioritise helping others over and above getting rich (eg by taking a role in the care sector or similar), then they might not enjoy the same level of "success" (as society defines it) but they may still have worked just as hard?

Rozziie · 08/09/2021 12:46

Yes, I can't stand people who say this stuff and are totally ignorant of their own privilege.

Even in cases where someone had a terrible start in life and built up their own business, there still will have been elements of luck in that. Being reasonably physically and mentally healthy is something a lot of people take completely for granted, for one thing.

Ultraopaque · 08/09/2021 12:43

I disagree with you op. My DH did have some advantages but his parents went bankrupt several times during his childhood and he had to pay off their debts, put himself through university, and keep his family afloat for the following 25 years. He still supports a family member now to a degree. He works really, really hard and rarely has time off.

TheStein · 08/09/2021 12:41

I wasn’t a great mum, my mental health is shit and I had no motivation myself. He was bullied throughout school and grew up knowing that his father didn’t give a shit about him. One of his friends committed suicide during his GCSE years which knackered up his own mental health (and his results!). But he wanted to be rich and he has worked since he was 13 constantly to achieve that.

SkinnyMirror · 08/09/2021 12:40

@TheStein

YABU My son was brought up in a single parent household on benefits on a rough conciliatory estate. He DID work hard to get where he is today.
I'm sure nobody would disagree but what we're saying is that luck/chance is also a contributing factor.
AlexaShutUp · 08/09/2021 12:37

@TheStein

YABU My son was brought up in a single parent household on benefits on a rough conciliatory estate. He DID work hard to get where he is today.
So were you a shit parent or was he lucky enough to grow up with a loving and supportive mum?

He might have worked very hard to overcome some disadvantages but he may also have been lucky enough to benefit from other advantages.

It isn't a simple equation of hard work = success.

Cornettoninja · 08/09/2021 12:35

I think this thread is entrenching my view that luck plays a large part in success.

For me, I think it’s apparent that generally working hard goes without saying especially when comparing general situations. Whether that hard work actually pays off or not is largely down to luck.

There are outliers at both ends of the scale but it seems to me that the majority work hard both professionally and personally to be self sufficient and secure.

Maverickess · 08/09/2021 12:35

How someone is financially successful also needs to be taken into consideration.
Are you successful because you've invested in creating and building a business yourself, but then employed people paying them low wages with no job benefits, meaning they need top ups from social benefits to live, while the work they do for you is increasing your profit?
Is that success or exploiting the situation for your own gain, telling yourself you deserve it?

TheStein · 08/09/2021 12:16

YABU
My son was brought up in a single parent household on benefits on a rough conciliatory estate. He DID work hard to get where he is today.

ClaryFairchild · 08/09/2021 11:59

It's a mixture of hard work, drive, resilience, willingness to take risks and luck.

A bit of everything goes into the mix to be successful against the odds. A lot of just one will rarely get you very far.

Maverickess · 08/09/2021 11:54

@AlexaShutUp

Don't have an issue with people saying they have worked hard to get what they have, I have an issue with the belief that hard work is the only denominator and it's only a lack of hard work that ensures people don't have whatever bar has been set.

Totally agree @Maverickess. Some of the hardest and most needed jobs in our society are very poorly paid.

Yes, and it's the lack of acknowledgement to that that I find frustrating and unfair, and the belief that only those who are financially successful 'deserve' certain things, and unless what you do with your life results in financial success, you are undeserving - when in reality it's society's lack of acknowledgement of any non financial results that mean there's this viewpoint that money = success and nothing else matters, and that hard work automatically = money. Neither really is true, but a lot of people like to subscribe to that view, imo, because actually it's a really unlevel playing field, and they like to think that everyone started from the same point, with the same opportunities and it's lack of aspirations or hard work that results in lack of 'success' when that couldn't be further from the truth, no one likes to think that they're thought of as having it easy, and so go to lengths to prove they didn't, and that they're deserving of what they have, and the only possible way another would not have it is because they didn't work as hard and therefore don't deserve it.
Crikeyalmighty · 08/09/2021 11:43

As someone said above luck will get you so far as will connections — however other aspects come into play and at the ripe old age of 59 I will use my H as an example. He doesn’t have a degree or A levels but is a complete expert in his niche area. He takes calls and makes them at 10pm, answers emails and queries on holiday, constantly networks and has done ok through sheer perseverance — we’ve never had parental handouts etc.on the other hand im originally from a midlands mining town and the amount of people who wanted and expected a high paying job on the doorstep 9 to 5 with minimum of effort, nothing that inconvenienced them or meant they had to gain further qualifications or god forbid to move away was high. There are indeed some entitled people who say they worked hard who did nothing of the sort but plenty who have indeed worked hard to get where they have at sometimes a significant cost to domestic or social life

todaysdilemma · 08/09/2021 11:32

Read your update. Why are you comparing yourself to her in the first place?? How is your experience in any way minimised because she has the finances to afford an expensive holiday. This is obviously jealousy/bitterness and actually maybe you shouldn't be friends with someone when you're judging sentences they make about their own life.

Compared to majority of the world, you're in a better position just by being born/living in the first world. Do you compare yourself to the poor immigrants in this country or the unfortunate elsewhere? So why compare yourself to someone better off?

And if privilege was all it took to have a good life, there wouldn't be any people who grew up in good circumstances but still struggle. Hard work is hard work. There are people who go to the same unis and do the same jobs who don't do well. The same way some able bodied people do less with life than a Paralympian.

CarrotSticks23 · 08/09/2021 11:30

I think that the majority of people who are truelly successful have worked hard. They have had circumstances that have facilitated this that were out of their control, but it is not sheer luck. That's not to say people who aren't in the same position are lazy, or that they haven't worked hard too but that shouldnt detract from people's achievements. OP you come across as very jealous.

I have a good job and I have worked hard for it. I have worked harder than a lot of people I know. Again that's not to say they are lazy or not successful in their own fields and I don't think I'm any more deserving of success than them, I don't think they have any desire to do what I've done tbh we are not in competition, but I have worked hard and it's not sheer luck. I've made decisions that others haven't that have enabled me to get to where I am and I'm not going to downplay that

People in my area who are really successful have worked incredibly hard. They've put in more work, time and taken risks that I never would. That is why they are more successful than me in my field. Some of the things my peers have done I think are incredible and I really admire them for it. Again circumstances have probably enabled them to do this, and they have a personality that encourages their work ethic. But they have worked hard, made good decisions and I don't see why they shouldn't be proud of it. I'd rather they were proud of their hard work than bragging about being rich or intelligent or lucky, and I think this is actually why most people say they worked hard. Not to say others are lazy but so it doesn't seem like they are bragging about being rich

There's also an element of smart working, some people are ruthless and will only work where it benefits them and are quite happy to fuck others over. Some people are the complete opposite and burn themselves out trying to help others. Had I been person A I probably would be more successful but I'm more in the middle and I'm comfortable with this, but I could have chosen differently or acted differently

AlexaShutUp · 08/09/2021 11:20

Don't have an issue with people saying they have worked hard to get what they have, I have an issue with the belief that hard work is the only denominator and it's only a lack of hard work that ensures people don't have whatever bar has been set.

Totally agree @Maverickess. Some of the hardest and most needed jobs in our society are very poorly paid.

Maverickess · 08/09/2021 11:18

Don't have an issue with people saying they have worked hard to get what they have, I have an issue with the belief that hard work is the only denominator and it's only a lack of hard work that ensures people don't have whatever bar has been set.
The issue is that financial contribution is deemed by many the only success worth anything and lack of financial success is somehow linked to lack of hard work, morality, laziness and lack of aspirations, and when only certain avenues are rewarded financially and materialistically, anyone not reaching a certain level is written off.

As a care worker, I work hard, though my hard work is not valued at all, if it were I'd be a lot financially better off, so my financial success is not there, but my role benefits society greatly - as I get satisfaction from helping others, and I'm doing that, then personally I view myself as successful, but the majority disagree because of the contents of my bank account, and some actively mock and belittle because of it, insisting that I could reach their level of success - if only I worked harder.

Swipe left for the next trending thread