Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about people who say ‘they worked hard to get to where they are’?

970 replies

MessyMissyMe · 07/09/2021 18:06

Generally these are highly paid people who were able to go to University (support from parents/inherited intellect/confidence and self belief built up by secure, happy childhood) or had the resources to start their own business and were lucky enough to get remunerated by employment that they enjoyed and were good at, didn’t have outside influences or stressors that made things harder/took up time they needed to study or build a career.

They basically are just LUCKY and don’t deserve their success anymore than a cleaner or a care worker living hand to mouth in social housing deserves their lack of.

AIBU to get annoyed at people who say this?

OP posts:
AccidentallyOnPurpose · 08/09/2021 17:44

What about all the people that start at the bottom and work hard to be successful?

Not everyone that goes to uni comes from a safe,stable and needs met home.

peaceanddove · 08/09/2021 17:36

what if you don’t have the time or resources to put in 80 hour weeks or the confidence to take risks or grab opportunities?

Well, then basically that's tough. Life is never, ever going to be fair and it's as simple as that.

You sound very bitter. Be careful what you wish for though. DH lost his Mum, very unexpectedly, last month, they were extremely close. He couldn't take a single day off the whole week after she passed, even though his grieving was so raw. He just couldn't. All the shiny new Range Rovers (yes, he has one) in the world can't cushion you from that.

Margerine78 · 08/09/2021 17:34

I got booted out of home at 15, and worked hard to get my 'A' Levels so I could get the hell out of my hometown and go to Uni (which I did and lived on grants, credit cards and income of three crap jobs (I'm not from a rich family at all), and managed to then get my dream job in London.

That said, I don't have material things, like my own house like many of my middle-class mates do. Being poorer puts you on a back-foot. regardless of how hard you work. I've only at 44 paid off my debts and saved enough for a mortgage. Mates of mine never had debts as parents helped them, and they got a massive hand out to cover deposit and get on property ladder years ago.

Although to say "I got where I am as I worked hard" is something someone who's being defensive would say so probably something from those that got help!

SkinnyMirror · 08/09/2021 17:27

@gwenneh

Question for those of you who think it's down to luck -- are you very risk averse by nature?
Research shows us that 'lucky' people are more likely to take risks ( I'm talking career development research here) and that people view lucky people as more likely to take risks - there are a whole load of other attributes which lucky people have in common too.

What has already been alluded to and needs more research is the relationship between what we describe luck or chance and privilege.

SkinnyMirror · 08/09/2021 17:21

I can only speak for myself but it irritates me because it downplays the inequalities in society that have perfectly easy fixes if we choose to pay attention.

What I often see as examples of luck can be traced back to fundamental social inequalities and to deny the element of luck implies that situations can be recreated by anyone in any situation.

Should we accept that women are generally paid less than their counterparts in similar roles because some women have worked ‘hard enough’ to achieve parity of pay or should we question why there is a difference?

Yes to all of this!

vivainsomnia · 08/09/2021 17:06

You're confusing the fact that many people don't do as well financially despite working very hard with the idea that no-one who has done well can put it down to the fact they have worked especially hard.

Pinkandwhitewafer · 08/09/2021 17:03

My SIL lived in a rented apartment and lived paycheck to paycheck before meeting my rich BIL. She married him within 2 years of meeting him, they sold his large mortgage free house and bought another, larger, mortgage free house. 100% his money. He has a very nice leased car that he changes every few years (as he always has done). When they first bought the new house they invited us, PIL & other family round for a lunch. She showed us round and continuously said things like "we worked so hard to get here, it just feels so nice" etc. Grin Absolutely bizarre. She also now talks about "their" money and cutting down on holidays as they have just got a new car etc. I don't think she knows we know the house was fully paid with BILs money and the cars are leased through his business. Shes most bizarre and loves to bring up how well THEY have done and humble bragging. Surely she should now be £££ up each month as she no longer pays rent, yet she likes to say how she's now got less money as they are paying things off together that we know they aren't.

(Definitely BILs money as he and DH work together in their business where they see one another's finances openly and DH was advising on the house etc)

FaceForRadio1973 · 08/09/2021 16:31

This is interesting. I didn't go to university, and all I got was a six GCSEs.

I'm in an office based engineering / design role, sat on my arse in a comfortable chair, earning a lot more than my step-son as a farmer.

I don't even need to comment on how hard he has to work...

IntermittentParps · 08/09/2021 16:09

what if you don’t have the time or resources to put in 80 hour weeks or the confidence to take risks or grab opportunities?
My DP had both. He still ended up with his GP saying he had to leave his job or he'd end up with a stomach ulcer.
Everyone has problems and pretty much everything in life that looks good has its downside.
You seem to have a chip on your shoulder.

WhyOhWhyOhWhyyyy · 08/09/2021 15:58

Lots of people have shared their stories about how hard work and determination set them up but what if you don’t have the time or resources to put in 80 hour weeks or the confidence to take risks or grab opportunities?

Also overcoming adversity to be successful takes luck. being blessed with robust mental health for example, having the intelligence to make the right choices or the self awareness to decide to improve yourself.

OP - I think it’s a massive cop out to say that it’s just luck that people have self-awareness, determination and confidence and this is why they have been successful. These are all personal attributes that can be developed, it’s the fact that people have honed and used these skills, plus the effort taken to get training or an education, that has made them successful.

I understand that people in low paid jobs work hard on a day to day basis (I have done many low paid jobs myself earlier in my life) , but I find I have little sympathy with people who complain about their lack of success without taking any tangible steps to change things. You are responsible for your own life.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/09/2021 15:55

"She keeps telling me I'm so lucky to have the career I do, but won't make any moves to build her own even when they're presented. She comes off as very risk-adverse, which is why I ask the question."

Confidence is a big thing, yes, but there's not that much you can do to change your personality. Therapy, I suppose, but then that's expensive and you have to be lucky to find the right therapist for you. I think a lot of our personality is laid down in early childhood.

Cornettoninja · 08/09/2021 15:47

@nokidshere

And yes, it is irritating when people show no appreciation for the privileges that helped them along, and claim its all down to their own hard work.

It's only irritating if you let it be. It has no impact on my life if Jenny down the road thinks she only got where she is because of hard work. I'm unlikely to change her mind and I know it's not true.

I can only speak for myself but it irritates me because it downplays the inequalities in society that have perfectly easy fixes if we choose to pay attention.

What I often see as examples of luck can be traced back to fundamental social inequalities and to deny the element of luck implies that situations can be recreated by anyone in any situation.

Should we accept that women are generally paid less than their counterparts in similar roles because some women have worked ‘hard enough’ to achieve parity of pay or should we question why there is a difference?

BackAgain5thAccount · 08/09/2021 15:46

If someone says he got rich through hard work, ask him whose work.

Who was born in a log cabin that he built himself?

HollysBush · 08/09/2021 15:41

I just can’t understand the people who can’t see this! Yes, you have worked hard to get where you are. BUT you have also been ‘lucky’ or circumstances (not all of them of course) have been in your favour.
And other people less ‘successful’ than you aren’t necessarily lazy!

5128gap · 08/09/2021 15:41

I also find the ones most likely to spout this tend to be middle aged men. Who completely ignore the advantages that alone gave them. Going to school in an era where education opportunities were often very much geared towards boys, building careers in male biased environments, and frequently benefitting from a partner who shouldered most of the domestic and childcare duties to facilitate their ability to 'work their arse off'.

gwenneh · 08/09/2021 15:39

What kind of small risks are we talking?

We talk a lot about her employment situation; she's terribly unhappy at her job (zero hours, only providing part time employment, taking on a labour-intensive second job requiring lots of driving and it's caused her to run several cars into the ground in the time I've known her) but yet won't take a new, full-time position elsewhere for more pay. Nor will she build out the labour-intensive second job into a proper business, though I admit that would be WAY more risky even with her reputation and book of clients.

She's been through the interview process for roles and landed at least three offers that I'm aware of but always turns them down at the last second. She has support from her friends, family, and DH; no DC and even if everything went tits up their situation means they'd never be out on the street.

She keeps telling me I'm so lucky to have the career I do, but won't make any moves to build her own even when they're presented. She comes off as very risk-adverse, which is why I ask the question.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/09/2021 15:36

" It has no impact on my life if Jenny down the road thinks she only got where she is because of hard work. "

It impacts your life if she thinks you're lazy because you're less successful.
A friend's relative is a landlord and he believes all his tenants are feckless because he thinks everyone who doesn't own a house is feckless.

5128gap · 08/09/2021 15:31

@nokidshere

And yes, it is irritating when people show no appreciation for the privileges that helped them along, and claim its all down to their own hard work.

It's only irritating if you let it be. It has no impact on my life if Jenny down the road thinks she only got where she is because of hard work. I'm unlikely to change her mind and I know it's not true.

No, but perpetuating the myth that hard work (alone) equals success has an impact on people who are not successful as it suggests its their own fault, exacerbating all sorts of harmful stereotypes. If Jenny down the road is racist or homophobic and perpetuates myths linked to these views it has no impact on my life, but I wouldn't like that either.
H1ppyHa1r · 08/09/2021 15:24

Decades ago, I was in FT employment

My friend offered me a job with training in a completely different industry ( I sometimes worked with him at weekends for extra money)

I stayed I'm my original job & I have enjoyed my work. I often wonder, how my life would have worked out, if I had chosen to move & work with my friend.

We remain friends today

Nobody can predict the future

Resilience · 08/09/2021 15:24

I think there are a huge amount of variables affecting how successful someone becomes (not to mention that defining success by status/wealth is also open to question).

I wouldn't estimate the impact of hard work when it comes to capitalising on opportunity, but I've been round long enough to see that an absence of luck can override a huge amount of hard work. Life isn't fair.

Personally, I like to define success by personal happiness in which relationships with others feature very highly. I love my best friend and she me not because of jobs, houses, salaries or achievements but because we genuinely enjoy being together, never feel judged, and know we've hot each others backs. That friendship was forged at a point we both had nothing and frequently made choices between topping up electricity or eating. The fact I now earn a good salary and my life is totally transformed has undoubtedly been influenced by luck probably more than anything, but even with all that luck I still had to work hard. Conversely, even with the hard work, without that luck I'd have probably failed.

Rozziie · 08/09/2021 15:23

@gwenneh

I've already covered the point that it's much harder to take risks if the outcome of them not going your way would be devastating.

That's perfectly understandable. I'm more curious about situations where the risk isn't life-or-death.

I have an acquaintance who subscribes to the luck school of thought. Yet I've noticed that she's unwilling to take even small risks even though the benefit would be enormous and the penalty for failure low. She is extremely risk adverse, and I'm curious if this is a common trait among those who feel luck is the larger part.

What kind of small risks are we talking?

I've recently started investing a little bit here in there, including high risk things like crypto. The rewards could potentially be great, but so are the risks. I'm comfortable enough now that I can afford to gamble a few hundred quid here and there without it potentially devastating my finances and leaving me hungry but there were times that a gamble or a risk not going my way would have absolutely wiped me out.

singingsoprano · 08/09/2021 15:22

@smokeyjoes

Resilience and optimism play a huge part in making yourself get up again and again and refusing to give up

To me those two things are the secret. And usually a large drive (often not that obvious) to succeed. Only some people have this, maybe 20% or the population?

I agree smokeyjoes having been brought up in care and facing many hurdles to being lucky. I was in a children's home from a month old, faced several deaths before the age of 13 of key people in my life and worked very hard at school to change what were potentially limited opportunities. I also studied part-time whilst holding down a full-time job, with 3 children under the age of 9. That is more than luck.
Rozziie · 08/09/2021 15:20

@ILoveYoga

YABU. Sounds like sour grapes actually or a big chip on your shoulder.

Give you my own experience. Had a child very young. Abandoned by their father who also never paid child support. Would change jobs often so hard to track down to get court ordered support garnished from his pay. Had no money, no job and lived in a different country that has no social medicine, so no medical care for my child. I could have gone on the equivalent of the dole, but understood I’d have to declare bankruptcy for the small amount of debt I had and then it’s very hard to come off the dole. If I’d done the bankruptcy, I would not have been able to eventually have the career I wanted (financial service). So I got a job at night that paid well because of unsociable hours and depressing environment, transcribing medical records in a state hospital. My childcare was a teenage girl and she looked after my child in her home (so help from her mum). I had no social life. I spent no money on myself. I used cloth nappies, so after the initial outlay, the costs were minimal. I used baby oil and cloths to clean my baby to avoid costs of wipes, made my own baby food and I’d the “canning” myself from pick your own veg and farmers markets. I eventually found a nursery on a university campus that had reduced fees for single mothers and also took some classes there while working full time at night, operating on very little sleep until I had my degree whereupon I changed jobs but also had to pick up project work related to my field on weekends (evenings) to help ends meet. Did not even have time to think about dating let alone any “me” time or outings with friends - until my child was 5 years old (school age for my country). Even then I continued my further education with a masters and then professional qualifications (very intense study plus hours long series of exams). Took me to 30 to qualify. Years of high stress, lots of tears, very little sleep, no nights out etc. So yes, worked bloody hard for what I achieved but I could have chosen the easy option and gone on the dole and the occasional unskilled jobs. BUT My child is now in their 30s, happy, healthy, great relationship and he’s followed the same profession. I own my own home and have a I’d retirement fund, friends and a lovely husband plus additional DC born after I qualified.

Alternatively, you could write it another way.

"Had a child very young, which was not a great decision in hindsight. Abandoned by their father who also never paid child support. Would change jobs often so hard to track down to get court ordered support garnished from his pay. Had no money, no job and lived in a different country that has no social medicine, so no medical care for my child. I did luckily have the option to go on the dole so we wouldn't starve to death or have to live on the street, but understood I’d have to declare bankruptcy for the small amount of debt I had and then it’s very hard to come off the dole, so obviously I wasn't that desperate. If I’d done the bankruptcy, I would not have been able to eventually have the exact career I wanted (financial service), so I made the educated choice not to go down that route. I was then fortunate enough to get a job at night that paid well because of unsociable hours and depressing environment, transcribing medical records in a state hospital. Thank God I had that option! I was also lucky enough to be able to use a teenage girl for cheap childcare and she looked after my child in her home (so help from her mum) - two childminders for the price of one! I had no social life. I spent no money on myself. I used cloth nappies, so after the initial outlay, the costs were minimal. I used baby oil and cloths to clean my baby to avoid costs of wipes, made my own baby food and I’d the “canning” myself from pick your own veg and farmers markets - just as well those were around to provide a budget food option for us. I eventually was fortunate enough to find a nursery on a university campus that had reduced fees for single mothers (so lucky!!) and also took some classes there while working full time at night, operating on very little sleep until I had my degree. Luckily I was healthy enough to be able to do that! I then changed jobs but also had to pick up project work related to my field on weekends (evenings) to help ends meet. Did not even have time to think about dating let alone any “me” time or outings with friends - until my child was 5 years old (school age for my country). Even then I was fortunate to have the opportunity to continue my further education with a masters and then professional qualifications (very intense study plus hours long series of exams). It only took me until I was 30 to qualify in a very well-paid profession and after just a decade or so of hardship in my very early adulthood, I now have a great and comfortable life."

There you go. See how different it looks when you acknowledge your good fortune, luck and support from others?

gwenneh · 08/09/2021 15:18

I've already covered the point that it's much harder to take risks if the outcome of them not going your way would be devastating.

That's perfectly understandable. I'm more curious about situations where the risk isn't life-or-death.

I have an acquaintance who subscribes to the luck school of thought. Yet I've noticed that she's unwilling to take even small risks even though the benefit would be enormous and the penalty for failure low. She is extremely risk adverse, and I'm curious if this is a common trait among those who feel luck is the larger part.

Gwenhwyfar · 08/09/2021 15:18

"if I hadn't got a place at that one I'd have gone to another. Or college, or somewhere. There were places for anyone who applied basically. If my friend wanted to go to the same 6th form as me, or any other, she would have got in."

Yes, but not if she wasn't academic at all. That's where the luck comes in.