Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about people who say ‘they worked hard to get to where they are’?

970 replies

MessyMissyMe · 07/09/2021 18:06

Generally these are highly paid people who were able to go to University (support from parents/inherited intellect/confidence and self belief built up by secure, happy childhood) or had the resources to start their own business and were lucky enough to get remunerated by employment that they enjoyed and were good at, didn’t have outside influences or stressors that made things harder/took up time they needed to study or build a career.

They basically are just LUCKY and don’t deserve their success anymore than a cleaner or a care worker living hand to mouth in social housing deserves their lack of.

AIBU to get annoyed at people who say this?

OP posts:
longue · 08/09/2021 19:38

The scholarship committee isn't flipping a coin or running a random lottery to decide; they're selecting the candidates whose experience and qualifications appeal the most. That's not luck securing the space.

How did the scholarship come about?

I know someone from a deprived background who left school without qualifications. One of the teachers at her dd's school pulled her aside & said your dd is incredibly bright. The teacher had worked at a private school & helped with bursary/scholarship forms & the child got a scholarship with 100% bursary. Her mum had no idea her ability was above average, she had no idea you could get bursaries & no idea how to go about finding out about one. Her dd was lucky the teacher recognised her ability.

threatmatrix · 08/09/2021 19:37

I’m sick of hearing this. I worked 80 hours a week with no holiday or time off for 5 years snd now I’m pretty well off. I worked decking hard for what I have.

Rozziie · 08/09/2021 19:35

*wasn't

Rozziie · 08/09/2021 19:34

@gwenneh and there's an element of luck in that. You might have gone to the same uni as one of the selection committee and they take a shine to you. You might be a bit more personable in the interview. It might happen that your research interest is something one of the panel is really into. These scholarships are ultra competitive. For every person that gets a scholarship, there are many more who miss out despite being extremely competent and deserving.

And I say this as someone who got one. Apparently 200 people applied and I was the only 'winner'. I worked bloody hard for it and put enormous amounts of effort in, but I'm not deluded enough to think I was also lucky.

Cornettoninja · 08/09/2021 19:32

Hmm… but taken to its logical conclusion, NOBODY should be given credit for achieving anything. It was all fated/preordained by DNA and patents and environment

@supermoonrising I don’t think that’s the logical conclusion to acknowledging luck, I think it’s an opportunity to examine the inequalities in society, and perhaps to examine what success is defined as.

I suppose it makes a difference whether you subscribe to the idea of privilege (as in white privilege, male privilege etc.) and the fact you can hold privilege even if you don’t necessarily immediately recognise it.

longue · 08/09/2021 19:28

Everyone gets the opportunity - it's up to everyone to apply them selves.

😆 The whole point is everyone doesn't get the same opportunity

gwenneh · 08/09/2021 19:27

@Cornettoninja

Yes *@InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest* but there will have been applicants whose hard work didn’t pay off. I obviously don’t know the ins and outs of your scholarship or the criteria but I’m confident that spaces would have been limited and people who worked just as hard as you and achieved the same grades won’t have been awarded the same scholarship. That’s the point, that is luck. It was hard work to get into a position to be in the running but luck that you secured a space.
Is it, though? The scholarship committee isn't flipping a coin or running a random lottery to decide; they're selecting the candidates whose experience and qualifications appeal the most. That's not luck securing the space.
SeasonFinale · 08/09/2021 19:25

The issue is that many people who have been brought up in a stable environment and who have well off parents may indeed have worked hard but you want to write them off as not having done so. there are also a whole group in the middle who have been to uni who have worked hard to get careers that are high earning ( but not handed to them on a plate) so of course your flippant comment will irk people.

People like that (including my husband and I (as a mature student)) do also appreciate that low earners often have jobs where they too work hard. People do deserve their holidays and material belongings if they have earned the money to buy them.

longue · 08/09/2021 19:24

Yes YABU. I’m pretty happy with where I’ve got to. I had a child at 18, worked full time since leaving school then decided to go back to uni, also worked a part time job in an area with no family help. Finished university whilst pregnant for the second time and now a full qualified medical professional and went back to work when my second was 6 weeks old. I believe I’ve worked pretty hard for it and now getting the reward.

How did you afford housing & childcare when you were at after your first dc & when you went to uni?

Cornettoninja · 08/09/2021 19:24

Yes @InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest but there will have been applicants whose hard work didn’t pay off. I obviously don’t know the ins and outs of your scholarship or the criteria but I’m confident that spaces would have been limited and people who worked just as hard as you and achieved the same grades won’t have been awarded the same scholarship. That’s the point, that is luck. It was hard work to get into a position to be in the running but luck that you secured a space.

DonaPatrizia · 08/09/2021 19:21

Warren Buffett, one of the greatest investors in history, put his success down to winning the genetic lottery, by which he meant being born in a place and time where his talents are valued and where he has been largely safe from physical peril and hardship. I come from a pretty disadvantaged background, I have worked very hard for my success including going through uni and I continue to do so. However, I won the genetic lottery by being born in this country as opposed to, say, Afghanistan, and by being intelligent and healthy, at least so far. The vast majority of us in the UK won the lottery of life compared with the vast majority of other people on this planet. Yes, I worked hard and I don’t decry much more privileged people than me who have also worked hard. But none of us ‘deserves’ our success any more than a little girl in Kabul deserves to have her life curtailed by the Taliban.
So yes, OP, I agree with you, it’s irritating, I have a (very middle class) friend who ascribes anyone’s life that is less prosperous than her own, which is 99pc of the UK, to ‘choices’ as if others had the option to have rich parents, a rich husband and a 5 bed house in a nice village like she has, but for perverse reasons of their own deliberately chose not to avail themselves! She’s so lovely in other ways - and genuinely thinks she’s left wing - I can’t bring myself to challenge it. Hard work doesn’t entitle anyone to success and failure can’t automatically be attributed to lack of industry. Ignore people telling you that you’re being chippy, you’re not - you made an accurate observation.

nokidshere · 08/09/2021 19:19

some of us worked super hard all our lives but got nowhere

Depends what you mean by nowhere doesn't it? By who's rules? I'm probably nowhere by many peoples standards but I'm exactly where I want to be by my own.

catcatcatcat · 08/09/2021 19:19

It's one of my most hated privileged sayings ever. Pretty sure someone worrying about every penny they have working 2/3 jobs has worked harder tbh.

Bertiebiscuit · 08/09/2021 19:15

Totally agree - getting on in life is dependent upon birth, luck and our confidence - some of us worked super hard all our lives but got nowhere -

Ann30567 · 08/09/2021 19:14

I don’t normally jump on threads but I had to with this one. It is singularly the most irritating thing someone can say to me. Like many normal people I have worked since I was 14. After doing poss hundreds of min wage jobs I now earn an okay living as a domme (well I did before covid hit and then pregnancy) I have lost count of the rich clients who have said this to me. The last was born into a wealthy family that had largely accumulated their money through slaves. He spends his time on his land with his lake, swimming pool etc. People who say this have no idea of the real world. But F them. It means everything that we earn and then buy means far more to us.

Maverickess · 08/09/2021 19:11

I've said this on another thread and I think it applies here too, the opportunity to be successful (if you're counting success as material wealth) is open to anyone, but, it can't be open to everyone.
The opportunities aren't limitless, there are only so many highly paid, or even comfortably paid roles out there at any one time, in any sphere, to be filled. If someone leaves the top rung, and everyone moves up a rung, there's then a gap at the bottom, too many gaps at the bottom and the whole thing comes down.

And even if there were, who's going to do the lowly jobs that are needed to support these higher paid jobs? Who is a manager going to manage, if all their employees are also managers?
If I get a better paid job tomorrow, that is seen as me succeeding, my current job role doesn't become defunct because I no longer do it, someone else will need to be found to do it, with the same low pay, I'm out of the 'unsuccessful' bracket, and someone else enters into it.

On a group level, everyone being 'successful' doesn't work, those lower paid roles are needed to support the upper tiers, because without them there are no upper tiers.
Some people are either willfully or deliberately blind to this, I mean after all, who wants to think that their success is at the cost of someone else's? Of course these types of people are going to insist their hard work has got them there, and that anyone who isn't there doesn't have the work ethic or resilience they do - the alternative is to admit they're benefiting from others work.

Nomoreporridge · 08/09/2021 19:06

I think some of the people calling the OP chippy are being somewhat chippy themselves.

There is a massive correlation between coming from a stable, middle class and affluent background and doing well in life.

Of course there are people who do well despite coming from a poorer background, but they often benefitted from the ‘privilege’ of loving, supportive parents/ great teachers etc.

I say that as someone from a working class background who went to uni and has a well- paid, interesting job. Of course I worked hard, but I was also lucky!

I often meet people who worked just as hard as me, but circumstances meant it didn’t pay off for them…for all sorts of reasons!

It really annoys me when politicians infer wealthy people ‘worked hard’ for it, as if a nurse or teacher just sits on their arse all day!! Especially when research shows most entrepreneurs come from wealthy backgrounds and had friends and relatives who could give them massive loans to kick start their businesses.

supermoonrising · 08/09/2021 19:06

@MarvellousMonsters
Luck or privilege plays a huge part in how successful you are in life

Sure it does. But neither is it “all luck”. A working class kid from a council estate (parents making 15k a year p) who ends up with a six figure salary was probably not “just lucky “. A typical middle class kid (parents making 50k a year) who ends up making a seven figure salary as boss of his own company probably isn’t “just lucky”.

Mynextname · 08/09/2021 19:02

@MummyMayo1988 but he is lucky that he could do that as you were there to take care of your child. You are both lucky you are well enough.

Many people take the opportunity to improve their lives, they get their qualifications, work hard and still life has other ideas.

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 08/09/2021 18:59

I know what you mean OP. Lots of people work extremely hard and will never earn massive money. It doesn't mean that people who have done well haven't worked hard, or that their success is undeserved.

I have worked hard to get where I am but I am not blinkered enough to recognise that there is an element of luck and privilege too. I'm not as lucky or as privileged as some of my colleagues/peers and you can't always make up for that just by working harder.

I also recognise that other people work for extremely hard, maybe harder than me but due to a number of factors won't earn as much.

InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest · 08/09/2021 18:56

@Cornettoninja

This. I came from a broken home but put myself through university by winning a scholarship and then working every minute I wasn't studying. Today I run my own business. No I don't think it's all down to luck. It's down to choosing to study when there was little to no encouragement, to not go out but stay in and study or work when others went out partying. To saving every penny when others went out drinking, eating or shopping. So no, I don't think it's down to luck

@InTheNameOfAllThatIsHonest I don’t think it’s all completely down to luck either but I do think luck can completely change the course of a persons life.

You literally say yourself you ‘won’ a scholarship. There will be someone who didn’t win who was likely every bit as hard working/clever/dedicated as you were to win that scholarship and in another year may of won the same opportunity but may have had the course of their life changed by not getting that scholarship.

Maybe won was the wrong word. I had to get top grades in all my A levels. It was the same for all applicants.
MummyMayo1988 · 08/09/2021 18:54

Yes! You are BU!
Everyone has the opportunity to go to uni!
My DH did - with no financial support from his family. He got a student loan.
He worked bloody hard for 3 years - leaving me and our DS back home - to get a good job when he finished. And he still managed to pay it back over 10 years.
Student loans shouldn't be called "student loans." When you finish uni; they take a small percentage of what you earn each month. If you can't pay it all back, it gets written off.
We sacrificed and worked hard to have the stable life we have.
Everyone gets the opportunity - it's up to everyone to apply them selves.

supermoonrising · 08/09/2021 18:51

Hmm… but taken to its logical conclusion, NOBODY should be given credit for achieving anything. It was all fated/preordained by DNA and patents and environment.

There’s a big middle ground between “it’s all luck” and “it’s all hard work”.

Particularly for people who end up making a lot of money in business, strangers don’t usually see the multiple failures, years of scraping by, years of risk taking, years living where they don’t really want to live but where they need to be based. They just see the end result.

I think people who make a lot of money haven’t worked harder
, but sometimes they’ve taken “risks” and short term “sacrifices” (in the broadest sense of the term) which many other people with similar intelligence and opportunity decided not to take. Obviously you can only compare people who started from a position of roughly similar privilege. But clearly privilege doesn’t explain it all, otherwise all working class people would be earning the same and all middle class would be earning the same etc. Putting down all differences within these similar groups to just “luck” doesn’t cut it.

Mynextname · 08/09/2021 18:49

@Geamhradh I also had free school meals. A combination of an abusive step parent then a single parent family. Homeless as a teenager. Encouraged not to get an education.

I worked every part time job under the sun whilst studying. I got good gcses and A levels. I did a degree whilst raising children and working and got a 1st.

I am still stuck in social housing claiming benefits with nothing to show for everything, why? No supportive family to help with childcare. A disabled partner. A disabled child. Bad decisions I made when I was a teenager and I had no one to guide me to a better place. These consequences still impact my life now. No financial support. The list goes on.

I see so many people who have had things so much easier and don't seem to have worked hard to deserve half of what they have got.

Yes, working hard helps. Most of it is luck.

SkinnyMirror · 08/09/2021 18:45

Oh and 'bad' luck is still luck!!!