Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU about people who say ‘they worked hard to get to where they are’?

970 replies

MessyMissyMe · 07/09/2021 18:06

Generally these are highly paid people who were able to go to University (support from parents/inherited intellect/confidence and self belief built up by secure, happy childhood) or had the resources to start their own business and were lucky enough to get remunerated by employment that they enjoyed and were good at, didn’t have outside influences or stressors that made things harder/took up time they needed to study or build a career.

They basically are just LUCKY and don’t deserve their success anymore than a cleaner or a care worker living hand to mouth in social housing deserves their lack of.

AIBU to get annoyed at people who say this?

OP posts:
beigebrownblue · 08/09/2021 20:51

It would be something approaching humane if people didn't use the words 'hand-outs' on here.

Currently in Britain one in five children are living in poverty.

There are other uncertainties, not least for those who have caught Covid and battling longer term effects of this.

There is news that cuts are even worse now for special needs children.

The Universal Credit 'upllift' is being scrapped - sure that many are affected by that.

For people with long term illnesses and disabilties, and in receipt of Employment and Support allowance, in the news has only just emerged that this group, i.e. millions of people didn't get the twenty pounds a week in the first place.

Millions of people are waiting for operations right now...

The list goes on.

Such benefits and help for people such as free school meals, are not 'handouts'.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 08/09/2021 20:50

Yes you are BU.
My husband had a crappy abusive and unsupported childhood and built his business from scratch after leaving school at 14. He is very successful, we are very very comfortable financially and that’s down to him. I had a better upbringing but still working class in a London council estate with parents who worked long hours, sag drank and gambled, we didn’t have much. I wanted to teach so I went to the library and researched how to do it - I went to Uni at 22 and worked part time to support myself.
We both worked really really bloody hard to get what we wanted, no luck involved.

MeredithGreyishblue · 08/09/2021 20:46

[quote longue]@MeredithGreyishblue how would you redress the balance?[/quote]
How long you got?
(Start with making sure we we get an electable Labour party back together and ensuring this shitshow of a government is never allowed to make decisions for us again)

Education reforms, social care reforms, supporting child carers, more support for parents so they can be present, out of school provision that engages kids, more apprenticeships in professional services available at 16+, mentorship programs, curriculum overhaul, incentives, wellbeing & self esteem sessions, better careers advice.

There's literally endless things that could be done / better funded / tried again / improved. The gap could be bridged more than it is.

However, people who had a "standard" upbringing with "normal" opportunities and support shouldn't be lumped in with the uber privileged and made to feel less. That's not on.

Plus, you never really know what's going on in someone's life. Sometimes people overcome hurdles you never knew about.

bellewilson · 08/09/2021 20:44

I was brought up by a single mother we never had any money and lived on a council estate. I had my son at 16 (only just finished my GCSEs) and got zero help from government no benefits (26yrs ago) i applied for over 100 jobs before I got my first job in insurance. I worked full time and brought my first house at 21. I had my second son at 22 and was a single mother to my two boys and went back to work when my son was 8 weeks old as I had to pay my mortgage and paid for full time child care. I have worked hard and even upgraded my house twice. I meet my husband 13 years ago and got married and had 2 daughters and supported my husband while he started his own business while still working full time. I now own properties worth over £1m and have 2 rental properties plus have a successful career and my husband has a successful company, we have savings and drive nice cars. Neither of us have ever claimed benefits, both where brought up on council estates with no money and never had hand outs. Neither of us got an education apart from GCSEs. Yes we have worked hard and do deserve Everything we have. Not everyone who is well off had help or handouts or comes from money x

RachaelN · 08/09/2021 20:43

Sounds like jealousy tbh.

C152 · 08/09/2021 20:38

Yes, YABU. You're making a huge generalisation based on your personal experience only.

longue · 08/09/2021 20:36

But today in the UK probably a good 80% of people DO have that opportunity. They do live in a reasonably safe neighbourhood. They do have access to a library and the internet. They do go to a decent school with decent teachers.

Economic and social deprivation to the extent it exists in the UK is terrible, but the majority of people in the UK are very privileged, if not to the extent of B.Johnson and Rees Mogg and Rishi Sunak. (Ok half the Tory Party)

See I don't think it's just economic deprivation & obviously many in the West are "better off" than poorer countries.

There is a reason kids end up in gangs & drugs & that's not solved by going to the library more.

Whiskeywithwater · 08/09/2021 20:34

I worked hard to get where I am. My dad died when I was young. I grew up on a council estate. Went to state school, (a rubbish state school). Left school at 16. Then proceeded to work fucking hard. Left home at 17 and lived on fresh air for about 10 years. So from my perspective, yes YABU.

Cornettoninja · 08/09/2021 20:33

I like the description of that video @lazylinguist Smile

I also like simulator games that illustrate how much of your life is down to random luck (alter ego is a good old fashioned text based game if anyone’s got time to waste). Quite a few charities produce them to raise awareness of the concept that it isn’t enough just to make good choices/work hard.

longue · 08/09/2021 20:28

@MeredithGreyishblue how would you redress the balance?

MeredithGreyishblue · 08/09/2021 20:24

Turned into a predictable Competitive Hard Done By bun fight!

Statistically (and common sense, tbh) kids with parental support go on to achieve more than those who don't.

But you can't piss on everyone else's chips because of that.

Instead of being a dick about it, how's about we look at how to redress that balance for people who need it.

Snippy-snipping at people who work hard and happen to also have some privilege won't help. And frankly isn't very nice.

lazylinguist · 08/09/2021 20:19

The issue is that many people who have been brought up in a stable environment and who have well off parents may indeed have worked hard but you want to write them off as not having done so.

It's not that they haven't worked hard. It's that the statement "I worked hard to get where I am" ignores the contribution of their privileged upbringing to their success, implying that the only reason other people didn't do as well as them was because they obviously didn't work as hard. There are plenty of people who work hard all their lives and don't get great jobs and big houses!

There's a video somewhere, designed to highlight inequality, where a load of people get lined up for a short race with a cash prize. Before the race starts, the organiser says "Anyone belonging to an ethnic minority take one step back". "Anyone who was brought up in a poor area take a step back." "Anyone with a learning disability take a step back". "Anyone who...." etc etc etc. Quite a few people end up taking many steps back. Most people take at least a couple. Then the race starts. It's pretty obvious who's going to win, regardless of how hard anyone tries.

supermoonrising · 08/09/2021 20:18

@longue
But some people don't have the ability to stand still & think about opportunities & options
Totally agree. In the UK probably 10-20% of the population don’t have that ability/opportunity. It’s terrible. That’s why I vote Labour. And of course it’s easier for some than others.

But today in the UK probably a good 80% of people DO have that opportunity. They do live in a reasonably safe neighbourhood. They do have access to a library and the internet. They do go to a decent school with decent teachers.

Economic and social deprivation to the extent it exists in the UK is terrible, but the majority of people in the UK are very privileged, if not to the extent of B.Johnson and Rees Mogg and Rishi Sunak. (Ok half the Tory Party).

DancingQueen85 · 08/09/2021 20:14

I agree with you in the sense that we are all lucky living in the UK compared to being born in a third world country with no access to education or even basic necessities like clean water. Clearly this puts all of us at a huge advantage.
However anyone who has been state educated in the UK has the same opportunity to work hard and do well and progress to university. Family background doesn't have to be a barrier here, if you work hard there is no reason why you can't achieve it whatever you want in life.

Cheeseplantboots · 08/09/2021 20:11

Disagree. We had nothing in the early days of our marriage, lived hand to mouth but we sold a load of our stuff, bought a second hand van and started our own business. My husband worked bloody hard, took massive risks, 7 days a week for years to get our business where it is today. No family help, no university. He had a shit childhood too. Neither of us is highly educated. For some everything maybe handed to them but others do work hard to get what they have.

Wandafishcake · 08/09/2021 20:08

Oh totally agree. YANBU.
Always comes across as somewhat weak and defensive to me.

Like cleaners and roadsweepers don’t work hard? Like we don’t all know of loads of ‘managing director’ slackers.

longue · 08/09/2021 20:03

I believe in privilege but I also believe in free will. Many people spend significant parts if their lives in cruise control. Yes they might be working very hard day to day but they may have never sat down and evaluated the options - the opportunities and options for making As Much Money as Possible (if that is what you want to do).

But some people don't have the ability to stand still & think about opportunities & options.

Spaceshiphaslanded · 08/09/2021 20:02

I’m not quite sure it’s luck. Privilege - think that’s the word.

I’m well paid, privileged and don’t work hard. Sorry. But I don’t think you ABU, people need to recognize their privilege and support others better.

toconclude · 08/09/2021 19:54

@MessyMissyMe

I went to University RyanReynolds. Didn’t find it particularly hard tbh!
Sounds like you went to the wrong university.
Cornettoninja · 08/09/2021 19:53

@QueenoftheFarts it’s not about being humble (you absolutely should be proud) it’s about recognising that not everyone will have the same opportunities to make their hard work pay off in the same way. Attributing all your success to only your own cleverness/stamina is buying into the idea that unsuccessful and poor people only have themselves to blame when that’s largely untrue.

If you care about the bigger picture and wider society (and there’s no compulsion to) then it’s actually really important to recognise that for every success there is a failure despite doing things exactly the same.

Smithitchi · 08/09/2021 19:51

This!

I went uni, and I work my bloody socks off. We are just about comfortable but we can’t afford a holiday abroad every year, we are only just about to buy or first house and I’m 36. If we were fortunate to have a successful pregnancy I would not be able to afford to take a long maternity leave. We are not rich, we just aren’t on the poverty line.

Being able to buy the house is mostly the luck of having inherited a chunk of our deposit from my grandparents. I’ve been saving for 8 years for the rest of it and would need another 8 years without the inheritance by which time many lenders would not offer me enough years to pay it off without a high mortgage. Prior to that I was working hard to pay the debt of uni because I don’t come from a well off family and uni was financially difficult for me. If I came from a family who could have helped with rent for uni, or paid my fees for teacher training something, I’d have been able to have saved for a deposit straight out of uni.

If I came from a well off family, I wouldn’t have had to put off starting to try for a family for so long because of finances. Now I’m facing the prospect of infertility and I wish I’d been able to try sooner.

So yeah, it is partly down to luck, partly down to your family background and partly down to hard work. But hard work alone doesn’t always make it happen. People who come from more well-off backgrounds, or have a better run of luck get things in a more timely fashion and don’t have to make nearly as many compromises in their lives.

supermoonrising · 08/09/2021 19:50

*supermoonrising I don’t think that’s the logical conclusion to acknowledging luck, I think it’s an opportunity to examine the inequalities in society, and perhaps to examine what success is defined as.

I suppose it makes a difference whether you subscribe to the idea of privilege (as in white privilege, male privilege etc.) and the fact you can hold privilege even if you don’t necessarily immediately recognise it*

I believe in privilege but I also believe in free will. Many people spend significant parts if their lives in cruise control. Yes they might be working very hard day to day but they may have never sat down and evaluated the options - the opportunities and options for making As Much Money as Possible (if that is what you want to do). The options and opportunities that they have open to them thanks to being born in one of the very wealthiest countries in the world. It sounds an easy question to ask (how can I make as much money as I possibly can?) but the answers to it are often not to our liking. Many people prefer to to stay in cruise control. Or to do a career they enjoy - rather than evaluate their skills within a mindset of “how can I utilise my skills and opportunities to make as much money as I possibly can?”…. the answer may be you need to retrain. Or you need to leave your friends and family and relocate away. Or you need to do something mundane and boring for several years while earning a pittance. Or you need to risk total failure and being back at square one again 5/10 years down the road. Sound like fun? To many people it doesn’t, so instead they stay in a kind of comfort zone. Some do it happily while acknowledging and applauding those who are (currently) living outside it. While others don’t acknowledge the risks the successful people who stepped outside it took, and instead focus only on “luck” and “privilege” to explain away disparities with “successful people” who had more or less exactly the same opportunities as they themselves enjoyed.

QueenoftheFarts · 08/09/2021 19:47

I say I worked hard to get where I am because I did.

We were a very poor family and the first time I had a modest amount of money was when I earned it and got my student grant.

My "father" fucked off when I was three months old because he couldn't handle the pressure of being a parent. He claimed poverty at court so never gave a penny towards keep. He has holidayed several times a year all of his life.

My first holiday was when my mum got very sick and John Lewis (who she worked part time for while trying to get some exams under her own belt) paid for us ALL to stay in a hotel by the sea for a week while she convalesced.... we felt like millionnaires...

Cut to today and I've worked fucking hard to earn good money and be able to make it to a few cheeky center parcs breaks per year...(steady on!), my kids now have privilege no doubt.... but I can see that at work... some people don't realise the journey.

People assume that I went to private school, probably had a pool and a pony and always had money in my pocket...

I lived in a council house and our neighbours used to post dog shit through the letter box because they didn't like a single parent family living in their street.... so yeh.. I think YABU in saying this.

My only gift was being able to work hard. And I did. I'm disabled now, so I won't be able to work hard much longer... but I deserve every achievement... I refuse to be humble about that graft...

Cornettoninja · 08/09/2021 19:40

Is it, though? The scholarship committee isn't flipping a coin or running a random lottery to decide; they're selecting the candidates whose experience and qualifications appeal the most. That's not luck securing the space

No, but it’s luck that in year you’ve applied that no one has the edge over you. If spaces are limited it’s likely it will be decided on factors that you couldn’t have had any effect on with hard work alone Maybe you won a silver in the 100m and there’s someone who won bronze (if you want to take the scenario further these two people could have exactly the same running times but other competitors on the day itself resulted in second and third place).

It’s all hypothetical without knowing the criteria but it’s perfectly possible one scholarship candidate could lose out to another simply because they were at a worse school but achieved exactly the same A level results and had a similarly impressive extra curricular cv.

longue · 08/09/2021 19:39

I suppose it makes a difference whether you subscribe to the idea of privilege (as in white privilege, male privilege etc.) and the fact you can hold privilege even if you don’t necessarily immediately recognise it.

This it's about recognising your privilege but people struggle with the concept.

Swipe left for the next trending thread