Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Boris Johnson should have to answer questions about the £350 million

136 replies

Poetrypatty · 07/09/2021 17:15

Basically he lied in order to get Brexit, saying we'd have £350 million A WEEK from Brexit for the NHS Angry When we are all getting tax rises instead.
Why is he just being allowed to get away with this lie, without even having to make an apology.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 19:28

[quote stuckdownahole]@Pumperthepumper I'll get stick for this, but:

  1. This isn't the Brexit I would have chosen
  2. In any case, I expected short-term disruption, especially when it became clear that we would get the Brexit preferred by the right wing of the Conservative party (see above)

The problem is that any other possibilities became moot when Labour refused to work with Theresa May even though she was in quicksand and would have grasped any helping hand, and then offered a second referendum as their policy when the election came around.

I don't care what the polls said, NO ONE WANTED a second referendum except for the politically engaged, who are a minority. Normal people just saw it as more argument and delay. The Tories were the biggest certainty of all time in 2019.

How do I feel? Not great at the moment but I think a future Labour govt might be able to mitigate a lot of the current damage. The point of being outside the EU is that we are flexible and can change course.[/quote]
No, fair enough. I think the main sticking point is nobody got what they wanted.

the80sweregreat · 09/09/2021 19:26

Jeremy Corbyn was a very reluctant remainer and refused to go on a platform with David Cameron to raise the profile of the remain campaigns.
I blame him as much as DC and Boris Johnson to be honest, the whole affair was shoddy and ill thought out from the get go. I believe that the tories thought remain would win and that would be that.
All history now, but the long term effects will ripple on for years still.

Justanotherlurker · 09/09/2021 19:21

To add, many Leave voters won't be upset that the bus promise hasn't come true because they ignored it anyway.

Yes, it is considered somewhat of a master stroke among political scientist as it made the remain campaign go on a defensive technicality route that didn't offer anything other than 'the bus figure is wrong'

The shortage of Lorry drivers is hitting EU and US, nothing to do with Brexit, the shortage of workers coming over and picking our fields (a good source of what is essentialy cheap slavery according to ardent remainers) is happening across western europe as the eastern side has now started to have base rate wages rising so there is less need to move for work to send money home.

The ardent remainers need to understand that they are not left wing, they are right wing globalists, there is a large cross over of people loudly procliaming on anonymous social media that they would be more than happy to pay extra tax to fund the NHS now complaining.

It's like the QT meme of the woman asking who will serve them coffee in Costa.

OhWhyNot · 09/09/2021 19:20

There was never going to be a second referendum

We often talk of leavers being duped those that believed (I include myself) that we had the possibility of a second referendum were also duped - why because we believe the narrative we want to. There was enough remain MPs

The biggest mistake was
to ever have a referendum- MP’s supported this by a huge majority without even debate which is utterly disgraceful. Such a momentous vote and so little discussion in parliament. We had more discussions over fox hunting

OhWhyNot · 09/09/2021 19:14

He could have put any figure in the side of the bus that wasn’t the point

Unfortunately it became a squabble about what the figure actually is with no one being able to agree because it’s very complex

Remain fell for this and while the Leave campaign went on their merry way making other statements that can’t quite be pinned down Remain got tangled up in this argument

It’s how Boris Johnson has always done politics create confusion and forge ahead onto the next project

stuckdownahole · 09/09/2021 19:11

@Pumperthepumper I'll get stick for this, but:

  1. This isn't the Brexit I would have chosen
  2. In any case, I expected short-term disruption, especially when it became clear that we would get the Brexit preferred by the right wing of the Conservative party (see above)

The problem is that any other possibilities became moot when Labour refused to work with Theresa May even though she was in quicksand and would have grasped any helping hand, and then offered a second referendum as their policy when the election came around.

I don't care what the polls said, NO ONE WANTED a second referendum except for the politically engaged, who are a minority. Normal people just saw it as more argument and delay. The Tories were the biggest certainty of all time in 2019.

How do I feel? Not great at the moment but I think a future Labour govt might be able to mitigate a lot of the current damage. The point of being outside the EU is that we are flexible and can change course.

stuckdownahole · 09/09/2021 19:03

To add, many Leave voters won't be upset that the bus promise hasn't come true because they ignored it anyway.

Lots of Remain voters profess to be upset about the bus promise and the low standards of integrity it represents, but I think they should be more honest and admit that what they are really upset about is that the country didn't vote Remain.

Pumperthepumper · 09/09/2021 19:03

@stuckdownahole

I voted Leave and the bus and £350m "promise" carefully worded for deniability had no impact whatsoever on my vote.

I was worried by the idea that our elected representatives no longer had control over issues of major public concern. I know we used to elect MEPs but they were less than 10% of the total in the European Parliament.

It wasn't that I wanted to reduce net immigration but that I wanted our government to have the power to reduce net immigration if that was the platform on which it was elected. Similarly, I work in an industry that would benefit from state aid, which wasn't allowed under EU rules. I'm not saying that I was expecting state aid post-Brexit, but I was happy that it was now a possibility.

That might point to the reason people aren't up in arms - many Leave voters won't feel that they were misled by the big red bus because they didn't take any notice of it in the first place.

How do you feel now?
stuckdownahole · 09/09/2021 18:59

I voted Leave and the bus and £350m "promise" carefully worded for deniability had no impact whatsoever on my vote.

I was worried by the idea that our elected representatives no longer had control over issues of major public concern. I know we used to elect MEPs but they were less than 10% of the total in the European Parliament.

It wasn't that I wanted to reduce net immigration but that I wanted our government to have the power to reduce net immigration if that was the platform on which it was elected. Similarly, I work in an industry that would benefit from state aid, which wasn't allowed under EU rules. I'm not saying that I was expecting state aid post-Brexit, but I was happy that it was now a possibility.

That might point to the reason people aren't up in arms - many Leave voters won't feel that they were misled by the big red bus because they didn't take any notice of it in the first place.

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2021 18:56

the majority of Tory Voters actually supported May's dementia tax

Did they? Is there any evidence of that?

Justanotherlurker · 09/09/2021 18:53

This thread is typical MN, full of people who loudly proffess they would happily pay more tax to fund the NHS when it's an attack on the Tories then get upset when said tax came in.

It is exactly the same response when St Jeremy Corbyn highlighted that 'taxing the rich' ended up being quite a wide margin.

Come the next election it will be a bad tory trait of not wanting to pay more taxes as the NHS still has 24 hours until it is privatised and a lot of posters under a name change will come out and parrot that they would be more than happy to pay more tax if it directly went to the NHS.

The cycle continues and everyone expects the 'other' to pay. Brexit doesn't even come into the overall argument, it's just a childish tantrum.

We shut down the country for the NHS, the majority of Tory Voters actually supported May's dementia tax. If there was real consitency in the arguments against the government people would be crying out for NHS reform instead of pretending that it's trying to be privatised.

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2021 18:33

A demographic notorious for not actually turning out to vote

Except that they did turn out to vote that year..

Turnout was at a 25-year high, boosted by young people and BME voters. More than half of those aged 18-24 turned out to vote, an increase of 16 percentage points on 2015. Turnout among BME voters also increased six points. Of those who went out to vote, but did not vote in the 2015 general election or the EU referendum, most voted for Labour

www.theguardian.com/politics/datablog/ng-interactive/2017/jun/20/young-voters-class-and-turnout-how-britain-voted-in-2017

DdraigGoch · 09/09/2021 18:23

@Blossomtoes

Did you see the first time voter kids around him that summer? They worshiped him. May’s campaign was no worse than Cameron’s in 2015 that handed him a majority.
A demographic notorious for not actually turning out to vote.

Cameron was a slick PR performer. He also went into it with a minority which many people expected to remain so. May went into 2017 with an expectation of "this is ours for the taking" which lead to overconfidence and the electorate giving her a bloody nose (the public don't like being taken for granted). The announcement of her social care policy was a PR disaster. Boris has probably got this one right - announce something as controversial, yet important as this sooner rather than later so that people forget about it come the election.

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2021 18:20

You only have to read all the people on higher (and lower) incomes moaning about "all the tax" they pay to see that a lot of people want tiny taxes but State-Funded everything

Not only that but they complain bitterly about substandard public services starved of funding by Tory austerity.

DynamoKev · 09/09/2021 18:17

@Bambam2019

Isn’t this why we can never have a true democracy- because politicians are not held accountable for the lies they tell, they continue to do so. Nobody can say that what is on a manifesto is going to actually happen so people don’t truly know what they are voting for. I wish people wouldn’t vote for the tories, only the very rich ever benefit.
Actually, it's partly our fault - as a nation we are in denial about a number of issues. You only have to read all the people on higher (and lower) incomes moaning about "all the tax" they pay to see that a lot of people want tiny taxes but State-Funded everything - and both major parties usually promise that - The relative honesty of the Corbyn manifesto was a change and look what happened to that.
Bambam2019 · 09/09/2021 18:07

Isn’t this why we can never have a true democracy- because politicians are not held accountable for the lies they tell, they continue to do so. Nobody can say that what is on a manifesto is going to actually happen so people don’t truly know what they are voting for.
I wish people wouldn’t vote for the tories, only the very rich ever benefit.

Blossomtoes · 09/09/2021 18:04

Did you see the first time voter kids around him that summer? They worshiped him. May’s campaign was no worse than Cameron’s in 2015 that handed him a majority.

DdraigGoch · 09/09/2021 18:00

He had plenty of charisma in 2017, he cost May her majority. Remember “Ooooohhhhh Jeremy Corbyn” at Glastonbury of all places?

May lost her own majority with an inept campaign.

Journeyofthedragons · 09/09/2021 14:11

@Jaysmith71

Where is Farage these days?

On GB News morning, noon and night.

Unlike the mysterious disappearing Andrew Neil, still nowhere to be seen.

In between that he's shilling his money making scheme on SM.
To think Boris Johnson should have to answer questions about the £350 million
Bollindger · 09/09/2021 13:49

We need an opposition.
If there is one then the things people want might happen, but they are not doing the job, they are coasting along and doing very little because Covid is an unknown we can't really fight.
Also in times of troubles people vote for Tory not Labour, this won't change for a while, till someone with balls steps up and takes charge.

Blossomtoes · 08/09/2021 18:32

@Poetrypatty

Jeremy Corbyn was useless in my eyes. A terrible public speaker, didn't oppose Brexit, far too left wing. People just want normal centrist leaders not some kind of lefty revolution. He had zero charisma and didn't seem to me like someone you could put your faith in. Just not a natural leader.

I would prefer Keir Starmer as PM, he's a bit boring but seems trustworthy and sensible and that is what I want.

He had plenty of charisma in 2017, he cost May her majority. Remember “Ooooohhhhh Jeremy Corbyn” at Glastonbury of all places? I’m quietly delighted that all the Tory voters who bleated on about Labour bankrupting the country and raising taxes are well and truly getting their comeuppance now. Highest taxes for 70 years. 🤣
Demelza82 · 08/09/2021 18:04

While I don't disagree with you, I really wish people would stop bringing up that bloody bus. It was obvious to many of us at the time from the wording that it couldn't happen - it wasn't a promise and it was proposed by people campaigning who had no will or power to actually make it even happen.

dmifflin · 08/09/2021 17:54

Let's dooo the timewarp againnnnnn

Porridgealert · 08/09/2021 15:36

@DynamoKev

I remember people resigning in Thatchers cabinet for stuff MPs wouldn't even think twice about now. Oh aye? Like Cecil Parkinson perhaps? Or Lord Archer and Jonathan Aitken who both ended up in the clink? Fortunately we don't seem to have had so many criminals in high profile jobs these days.
Not since Blair resigned, no.
MistySkiesAfterRain · 08/09/2021 15:26

What would he say? "I wanted power through any means necessary". Admitted Boris, never.