Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that he should just take his key with him, and that him being locked out is not my fault?

182 replies

PODSNAPPERER · 06/09/2021 21:03

I have a lodger.

Said lodger is a bit odd about taking things with him when he leaves the house, such as his phone, his keys, a shopping list, anything.

I work nights (from home) and as such am often asleep at odd times during the day when most people are up.

Some time ago I was asleep, lodger went out, I got up and also went out. When I got back he said he had to walk to my Mum's to get her spare key because I'd locked him out, and that he didn't know I was going out so hadn't taken his key. I said 'But you didn't know I was staying in either, so why wouldn't you have your key with you?'

If he goes shopping he often comes back without things as he couldn't find them. We do our own shopping separately as a rule but now and again will offer to pick up things for the other. In the past he's brought me sweet chilli sauce instead of hot chilli sauce, and a bag of lettuce instead of a bag of stir fry because he didn't take his glasses with him so couldn't see what the label said.

When I asked why he wouldn't take his glasses shopping he said because he knows where all his own things are and what they look like so it isn't usually a problem. He says things as to why he doesn't take his phone and keys like 'no pockets in summer' (!).

I've often rang him when he's gone out, for whatever reason and he's not got his 'phone. Odd, but fair enough, up to him however he will then complain if I've tried to ring/message him to say 'I'm going x do you want anything' or 'I'm going to the pub/event/whatever do you want to come?' and he's missed the message.

Anyway today I start work at 20:15.
I woke at 1900 from my nap and decided to go for a quick run, having not been able to earlier because It's so hot.

Lodger is out with the dog (she's my dog but he walks her often just because he likes to, fine).

I get back at about 19:40, and lock the door behind me as I am going in the shower. Lodger still not back.

When I go back downstairs he's in and he's LIVID with me. I also have a message on my phone to the lines of 'Why the fuck did I lock the door, he's had to go all the way to my Mum's for her spare key and he was already hot and bothered and had been out longer than he wanted and I shouldn't have locked the door etc etc'

I ignored the msg and said 'Lodger, if you go out, you take your key with you, it is not my fault if you choose not to.' I also reminded him that if we're both in and I go out for a run, I always ask do I need my key-It's nicer to not have to carry my key, sure but if I need it, if he may go out, I'll take it, we have to be responsible for these things.

'You only think of yourself! You don't think of anyone else! You knew I was out so you should have waited until I get back!'

'I didn't know you didn't have your key. You're a grown man, I am not responsible for your locking yourself out.'

'You're selfish! I never take my key!'

'You should! Adults have house keys for a reason! I couldn't have waited, I had limited time before starting work. You need to take your key with you if you're going out'.

'Well I never will!'
'Stop whinging then!'

AIBU?

Happy to be told so, honestly I just cannot get my head around him thinking it is a good idea to go out without one?

And he absolutely had his pockets in his trousers. He should have locked the door while leaving the house anyway, IMO as I was in bed and anyone could have walked in.

Let me have it MN. :)

OP posts:
takehomepay · 07/09/2021 11:11

That's too longwinded, OP. Just tell him he must always ensure he has his key with him and not rely on your mum's spare or you staying home and you will do the same.

PODSNAPPERER · 07/09/2021 11:09

He is still on this this morning.

Last night I told him that he must not leave the house insecure if I'm in but asleep and he must take his key when he goes out. He said he overheard me telling my mum that it was too hot to go for a run yesterday, and that by the time I woke up it would be too late and I'd not have any time before work.

This is true however,
1)He wasn't meant to be earwigging that conversation
2)I'm entitled to change my mind if i wish and as it happened I did wake early enough to go for my run.

Ive told him this and that I'm entitled to change my mind 20 times if I want to. He's told me that yes I am but it is selfish of me to not inform him of my change of plan, and that I could have left him a key somewhere.

This is my proposed reply (he's out). What do you think?

"Take your key when you go out Dave. Go out meaning whenever you go out, regardless of what for.

Exceptions do exist, if you don't want to take a key and I'm in (& not sleeping!) And you ask me if you need a key and I say no(like I do when I'm running, it is awkward carrying a key so I'll ask and sometimes not take one).

I didn't inform you of my plans in the first place to then inform you I had changed them anyway.

You didn't have your 'phone on you either so when I woke up and decided to go for a run, informing you would have made no difference.

I wouldn't have left the key because I did not expect you to leave the house insecure with me asleep upstairs, nor do I expect a grown man to leave the house without his key regardless."

OP posts:
SeriouslyISuppose · 07/09/2021 10:30

If you're not actually giving him his notice, and I suspect you aren't (mystifyingly), then the very least I would do is get a new lock on the front door, the automatic deadlatch type that you can't leave unlocked, because it locks when you shut the door.

That way at least he can't go out leaving the house unlocked. Unless he thinks it's OK to leave the front door wide open to the street because it's better than the bother of remembering to take his key with him.

OccultGnuAsWell · 07/09/2021 10:11

If you get a key safe I think it'll work well. But only once. Then he'll forget to put the key back in the safe and back to square one.

Plus it won't resolve the problem of him leaving the door unlocked when he leaves the property.

If he "can't" remember to take his key with him and lock up behind him then surely he won't go through the extra steps of opening the key safe/locking door/returning key to safe.

I really dislike people who expect others to accommodate their quirks and foibles rather than behaving like a functioning adult and taking the bloody key. So this may be colouring my response.

Is he so good a lodger that you would want to work round this behaviour? Or is it time to suggest he move on?

I know which way I'd be leaning.

LookItsMeAgain · 07/09/2021 09:53

Give him notice that he has to leave.
If you got 'broken in to' while he is out and you're out (and he neglected to lock doors) wouldn't this invalidate your home insurance? You'd get nothing.

He is being very irresponsible.

Disneycharacter · 07/09/2021 09:32

Would a code operated key safe outside your house be an option?

takehomepay · 07/09/2021 09:24

Contactless innit.

Jemand · 07/09/2021 09:24

If his sight is so bad that he can't read labels on shopping, how does he manage with payment?

Scoobydoobywho · 07/09/2021 09:17

At least when you hopefully kick him out, you won't have to ask for the key back.Grin

takehomepay · 07/09/2021 08:52

I also reminded him that if we're both in and I go out for a run, I always ask do I need my key-It's nicer to not have to carry my key, sure but if I need it, if he may go out, I'll take it, we have to be responsible for these things.

YANBU, tell him he needs to start carrying his key. And take the spare key from your mum so he doesn't have that back up option anymore.

I think you should also start carrying your key (on an armband, waist bag etc) so that he can't point to your leaving the house without your key as justification for him doing that. I get that you ask but he seems incapable of making that distinction.

noonetoblamebutmyselfandpizza · 07/09/2021 08:50

Smart door lock! Will solve the key problem.

BruceAndNosh · 07/09/2021 08:14

The alternative is replace the lock with a code lock, not a key safe.
If he wants to access the house, he should pay for this lock in full, as he is the only 9ne who can't manage a key

MuddlingThrough1724 · 07/09/2021 08:13

I'd a) get a new lodger because who needs the stress of him in their lives and b) get a key safe for a spare key in the meantime.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 07/09/2021 08:01

@saraclara

"There is a new rule for this house. The door must always be locked. For my security and for the security of my and your belongings. This means that when you leave for any reason, you must take your key and lock the door behind you. This is my home, and if your unhappy with those rule, then you are at liberty to find somewhere else to live"
Deffo this
saraclara · 07/09/2021 07:59

"There is a new rule for this house. The door must always be locked. For my security and for the security of my and your belongings.
This means that when you leave for any reason, you must take your key and lock the door behind you.
This is my home, and if your unhappy with those rule, then you are at liberty to find somewhere else to live"

rwalker · 07/09/2021 07:43

You know his quirks way up if the good outweighs the bad.

TBH this isn't just about the key for what ever reason he won't take anything with him thats just him.

The alternative is a new lodger that take there key but they could be a complete arseshole and nightmare .As they say better the devil you know as you said you get along fine.

To solve this issue you could get one of those combination outside key safe there about £25 you can get them from screw fix .
The bonus is you could use it as well and never have to take your key when you go running .

LagunaBubbles · 07/09/2021 07:33

Why on earth are you putting up with this?

CCSA · 07/09/2021 07:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

SeriouslyISuppose · 07/09/2021 07:24

@NoNoThankYou

OP, I know you've posted in a fairly light-hearted manner but please ask yourself why you're allowing yourself to be treated like this and then wondering whether you might be being unreasonable to boot.

Why do you think it's OK for a man to treat you (and your mother) in this way? Who has trained you into thinking this sort of thing it's just something you might have to put up with? Would you put up with it from a woman? Would you put up with it from a woman you were in a romantic relationship with?

This behaviour is so entitled, controlling and abusive that I would be seriously considering leaving a marriage over it given what it says about his opinion of you and how is acceptable to treat you, never mind chucking out a fucking lodger.

I completely agree, and also with @EmpressWitchDoesntBurn’s point that he may be going out and leaving your house unlocked on a regular basis, because you being burgled is far less of a faff than him remembering his keys.
Jemand · 07/09/2021 07:23

Does he work? Does he manage to remember to take his glasses to work, and cope with entry codes etc there? I really wouldn't believe the shopping excuses - my sight is terrible but even I could read the label on a bag if I bring it up close to my eyes, and I could certainly tell the difference between lettuce and bean shoots.

Jemand · 07/09/2021 07:20

@AttaGirrrrl

100% YANBU! This has got to be a first?
No, it's happened countless times.
IamtheDevilsAvocado · 07/09/2021 07:20

@GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing

Can’t believe the cheek of him!

It’s your house and he is your lodger. He doesn’t get to make rules for you, or have a go at you. You set the house rules for him.

He needs to be told in no uncertain terms to take his key with him every single time. Next time he fails to do so, he’s out on his ear (i probably wouldn’t give him that one chance tbh!)

Leaving the house unlocked is dangerous . And having a go at you is bizarre.

This, with knobs on

I remember being bloody annoyed when I just SHARED a house with a couple of blokes who NEVER took their keys with them, who confused me with their butler/mothers (I was 19 at the timeHmm)....

I told them I was no longer opening the door to them... Interrupting what I was doing, on ocassion waking me up as I was working nights. ....it was a large house and my room was up 3 flights and at the back of the house.... I turned my music up and ignored the bell ringing and shouting...

Someone else came home about 2 hours later...oh dear it had been raining Grin.
The chief idiot went mad at me... Barged into my room, effing and blinding and how I was a stupid bitch for not answering the door. I loathed him. I just kept saying I'd given him fiar warning and it wasn't my responsibility to let him in and out as he was an adult. This guy was in his late 20s...

I wonder OP, is he a whole generation older? I wonder if he's one of these arse blokes who are congenitally incapable of 'taking orders' from a younger female...despite you have every right both legally and morally.

It's YOUR bloody house, you set the rules... If he doesn't like locking the door every time he leaves, he can rent somejwee on his own and leave it insecure to his hearts content.

Just about leaving the house insecure all the time would be enough for me to give him a 'final' warning... It MUST be locked every time you're out...

As others have said... It voids your insurance and horrible thought of waking and finding a burglar (or worse) has just walked into your place.

He doesn't seem to understand this... Which for me, would over ride any other consideration... As he's putting you at risk

caravanman · 07/09/2021 07:00

Apart from the angry and abusive way the lodger has spoken to/texted OP, it does sound like he has some issues with his memory/organisational skills. The lanyard could help. However, my husband, who has similar issues, often forgets to put his lanyard on, so the problem with forgetting keys or even losing keys still persists. Perhaps a prompting note on the door might help as well.
My husband's problems relate to executive dysfunction . Does the lodger have dyslexia, autism or ADHD?

Anon135798642 · 07/09/2021 06:52

Son of a nutcracker, he sounds like a fucking nightmare OP!!

YANBU - get rid of him!!

Swipe left for the next trending thread