Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For viewing my H with contempt

217 replies

needsomeperspective · 06/09/2021 19:29

My H and I have now been married for almost 13 years. Two children. He has long term mental health issues stemming from an abusive childhood. Frankly I have known for a decade that he has BPD. He takes anti anxiety meds and anti psychotics (when he can be bothered to keep on top of them or as long as I police him like a child). He hasn’t had any job in over six years, no “real” job in ten. He spends much of his time sleeping in very late while I work my ass off to keep our family (and my mother) financially solid - fortunately I have a very good job - but along with that comes it’s own stresses for me as I am responsible for over 300 staff.

I’m lucky enough to have help with the kids and a cleaner. I’ve deliberately arranged my life so that I do not have to rely on my husband in any material way - because he isn’t dependable. He has cheated on me, he used to be emotionally volatile, now he is just an apathetic lump.

He is, all challenges considered, often a loving, kind and involved father and the children undoubtedly benefit from having him in their lives and in their home.

From my perspective we have an almost non existent sex life, and I frequently feel like I’m running a doss house for vagrants than participating in some kind of partnership. But it’s better than having no one. We’ve been very isolated during Covid.

I put in place (following his infidelity) a cast iron post nup which he agreed to sign so I’m not “trapped” in this marriage for financial reasons but I do feel that the children would be much better off if we stayed together and frankly I can’t see how I’d be happier as a single parent compared to this inadequate and pathetic marriage I’m in right now. Some sex is better than none - or one night stands with morons. At least I have someone to visit IKEA with.

How do I reconcile myself to the limitations of this situation and generate the compassion to view my husband as a victim of his mental health issues rather than a useless, feckless, contemptible burden surgically attached to the sofa and piggy backing on my years of relentless hard work - which frankly I often feel.

OP posts:
marly11 · 06/09/2021 23:05

I was in a situation akin to yours though my ex was not in quite such a bad place as yours sounds. I felt contempt for him - which I didn't feel great about, and had lost any respect and with that any sex drive. Personally I can't fancy sex with someone I have lost respect for. I actively agonised about the decision but now love my single life - free of the irritation and indignance of working my arse off while he moaned and groaned. The kids have been pretty fine and have a much happier mother and slightly more competent dad who had to actually step up and do something because I wasn't there to do it for him any more. At times I wish I had someone about who would do some jobs but to honest it is less burdensome than having someone around who I kept hoping might do something but only after 20 times of asking and reminding. I would recommend setting yourself free from this grind. The biggest worry I would see from your situation is him having access to the DC while having mental health episodes but otherwise I'm not sure what there is to lose from what you have described.

2andahalfpints · 06/09/2021 23:04

You are better than this

SpacePotato · 06/09/2021 22:55

How did he manage before you came along op? How did he support himself and hold down a job?

You are clearly successful and capable, did you know before you married him about his poor mental health?
Did he pick you on purpose knowing you could financially support him?

As others have said, you are doing your children no favours. All they will see is their mother being driven into the ground by a
manchild who refuses to help himself.
Why would you want them around him and his self destructive behaviours?

You are not showing them what a healthy, happy relationship is.

Why on earth would it be 50/50 with the children? Is their no protection from parents deemed too mentally ill to provide care where you live?

He might not choose to be this way but he is actively choosing not to do anything because you have made it so he doesn't have to.

Get rid. If he goes downhill or drinks himself to death, that's on him. Not you.
You can't fix him.

Protect yourself and your children. You deserve happiness. Enough is enough.

BreadInCaptivity · 06/09/2021 22:53

[quote needsomeperspective]@BreadInCaptivity - I think this neatly sums up everything from my perspective. It’s very good advice and I think I need to do exactly as you say. I put the legal and financial framework in place to facilitate this but I haven’t yet managed to move forward on the emotional side. I suspect that speaking semi-regularly to a therapist would absolutely help me to manage this situation much better.[/quote]

I think therapy for you would be a good idea to help you disconnect from your H and plan a better future for yourself as your children.

You might also want to consider family therapy (without H) for you and your children in the run up to your separation so they understand the situation.

It's a shitty situation for you and I send you much ❤️

Chocaholic9 · 06/09/2021 22:47

I've been single for the majority of my life, and what you have described sounds fucking terrible. No way is that better than being single.

As for what's best for the kids? I knew as a child that my parents were unhappy, and that poisoned the household I grew up in. They waited to get divorced until I was 21.

needsomeperspective · 06/09/2021 22:46

@BreadInCaptivity - I think this neatly sums up everything from my perspective. It’s very good advice and I think I need to do exactly as you say. I put the legal and financial framework in place to facilitate this but I haven’t yet managed to move forward on the emotional side. I suspect that speaking semi-regularly to a therapist would absolutely help me to manage this situation much better.

OP posts:
CloseYourEyesAndSee · 06/09/2021 22:41

Maybe he would. Would that really 'break their hearts'? What kind of relationship do they have with him now - honestly? What does he do with them? How does he enrich their lives?
I thought my DS would be sad when his dad vanished for extended periods. Turns out he's fine. Occasional visits and short bursts of fun is enough to keep the relationship going and the rest of the time he enjoys his drama free, peaceful home. Think about it.

fiveminutebreak · 06/09/2021 22:41

It does sound incredibly challenging and you are shouldering an awful lot. Have you ever had any therapy for yourself? In terms of coming to terms with this. Your mental well being is really important too. And you might benefit from off loading with an experienced counsellor .

Many marriages have broken up under far less stress than this...

BreadInCaptivity · 06/09/2021 22:40

@Ilovetoddlerssaidnooneever

OP, I think your reasoning is based on flawed premises: 1) You believe it is your responsibility to keep your husband afloat. Whilst I understand you value the vows you made, your husband does have some responsibility for his own actions. If you divorce him, you are no longer responsible for him in any way, other than perhaps financially. 2) (in relation) you seem to think that you would be doing something bad if you left him. You are allowed to divorce him! This is no way to live!!! Referring back to my previous point, he is choosing (to some extent) to live like this. Hell, you've done everything you can to help him but he's not doing his part. I would argue that he is far more responsible for the breakdown of your relationship than you are. 3) your kids need a dad. What do people mean when they say this? I can guarantee you they do not have your husband in mind! It means kids need a good male role model. That he is most certainly not! If he beat you up, would you still be saying they needed a dad? 4) Having something (him) is better than nothing. I would argue though that sum total of his qualities is negative. In other words, he adds much more negativity to your life than that he contributes positively. Leaving him would therefore not be losing something, but bringing the balance back to 0 or above.

Please, please reconsider what you're doing. What is the benefit of waiting until the kids have gone to college?

I think what you are missing here is the fact that as miserable as it is, the OP has control over the situation especially regarding the impact on the children.

If they divorce she either has to accept her children spending time with a wholly unsatisfactory parent or go to court to prevent him from having access to them and live with the consequences of doing that including how her children will feel about that.

There's no easy answer here.

I agree with a pp that the least worst option is to emotionally withdraw from him and start working on a longer term plan that means that as soon as the children are at college and independent you can enact a swift exit.

Create a positive adult social circle around you and have zero expectations of him.

You've more than paid your dues on this marriage and given him every opportunity to help himself.

It's now time to plan your future without him in the picture even if that means a longer term strategy.

The sad fact is that MH issues do not exempt you from being a selfish, lazy bugger and your H seems perfectly content to maintain the status quo at the expense of his wife and children.

After a decade he won't change.

You simply need now to manage circumstances to yours and the children's best interests.

Good luck Thanks

Babdoc · 06/09/2021 22:40

OP, google codependency. And ask yourself whether you are emotionally invested in playing the martyred saviour role as your DH’s enabler in this toxic fiasco of a marriage.
I would urge you to seek counselling by yourself, as I think you need therapy every bit as much as your DH does. There is a reason why you took on this damaged person as a partner, and it isn’t healthy.
You cannot change your DH’s behaviour, but with skilled help from a professional therapist, you can change yourself, and begin to reclaim your life.

needsomeperspective · 06/09/2021 22:39

I’m not in the U.K. but either way I do feel strongly that the children have a right to see their father. My ultimate fear would be that he would lose the will / motivation to make the effort to see them at all in time if we separated. And that would break their hearts. I can totally see him mentally justifying it with “they are better off without me, what can I offer them, I’m nothing”. And that would be that. It’s what he did with his first child years ago.

It’s my fault. I should have picked a better dad for them.

OP posts:
MyPatronusIsACat · 06/09/2021 22:35

@Calvinlookingforhobbes

YABVU to live half a life like this. What a dreadful example to set your kids. Divorce him and find some happiness. This is your one and only life.
This in spades.

Also @needsomeperspective why oh WHY do women like you, with the most dreadful husbands, always ALWAYS say 'oh but he is such a good dad?' Confused

He really, REALLY isn't! He is NOT a good husband, and he is NOT a good dad. Please stop kidding yourself. You, AND your children will be better away from this man. He may have mental health issues, but I am very suspicious that he is, shall we say, taking advantage of them. You're a mug, and he is lapping it all up.

Please leave him, while your OWN mental health is still intact. This is not even a half life, it's a TENTH of a life. He's got it made, YOU are run ragged and wretched, and your children are NOT benefitting from this one bit. He is setting a terrible example to them.

Theythinkitsalloveritisnow · 06/09/2021 22:35

@CloseYourEyesAndSee

Why would your children go to him half the time?? Why would they even be staying with him at all? They would get just as much from a weekly visit/hang out with him at home as they do from living with him and they would be protected from the toxicity that they are currently living in.
I don't think the OP is in the UK
CloseYourEyesAndSee · 06/09/2021 22:32

Why would your children go to him half the time??
Why would they even be staying with him at all? They would get just as much from a weekly visit/hang out with him at home as they do from living with him and they would be protected from the toxicity that they are currently living in.

Ilovetoddlerssaidnooneever · 06/09/2021 22:31

@needsomeperspective

“I completely disagree with this. He currently doesn't have a lot of reasons to access therapy. He gets to drink himself into a stupor and stay in bed until 6pm, doesn't need to work, gets everything done for him. He has every reason to not seek help. EUPD I'm sure can be hellish to live with, but therapy is scary. If it does improve his mental state, he'll be expected to start acting like an adult and parent. Easier to do nothing and keep drinking and doing whatever he feels like, with the eternal excuse of " I'm ill, it's not my fault"“

This.

I’m quite certain this is why he hasn’t managed to help himself in all the years we’ve been together. Despite every opportunity. Where is the incentive? He gets to drive a sports car, live in a five bedroom house with a pool, and go on fancy holidays with his family without having to raise a finger. And when he is asked to get a job he has all the excuses in the work because he has mental health issues so cannot be expected to cope with that. Alright for some people eh?! Bitter again much?!

Just ditch him OP!!!! You're so angry!!! And I don't blame you, but the only solution is divorce! Nothing short of withdrawing all support is going to get him to take some responsibility, history has shown that. I'm sorry to point this out, but even you having a crisis wasn't important enough for him to step up.

I don't know anything about divorce and family courts, but I can't imagine he'd have them half the time. And if your kids will be in college in 8 years' time, aren't they almost old enough to decide for themselves if they want to visit their dad? I'm afraid there's another flawed premises here: you think he'd make their life 100% hell for 50% of the time if you left him, whereas he is currently probably making their life miserable (but not quite hell) 100% of the time. Moreover, I doubt he'd have them 50% and unsupervised, as your entire marriage demonstrates he is not capable of looking after them with all the support he could wish for (short of actually having it done for him), let alone independently.

justasking111 · 06/09/2021 22:29

Well if you won't divorce him then ban the booze pour it away. Take the car keys too.

I am baffled that your children are better off with a father who drinks and sleeps it off. They really aren't you know ask any adult who grew up in a home like this

You're so far down a rabbit hole enabling his behaviour

needsomeperspective · 06/09/2021 22:22

“I completely disagree with this. He currently doesn't have a lot of reasons to access therapy. He gets to drink himself into a stupor and stay in bed until 6pm, doesn't need to work, gets everything done for him. He has every reason to not seek help. EUPD I'm sure can be hellish to live with, but therapy is scary. If it does improve his mental state, he'll be expected to start acting like an adult and parent. Easier to do nothing and keep drinking and doing whatever he feels like, with the eternal excuse of " I'm ill, it's not my fault"“

This.

I’m quite certain this is why he hasn’t managed to help himself in all the years we’ve been together. Despite every opportunity. Where is the incentive? He gets to drive a sports car, live in a five bedroom house with a pool, and go on fancy holidays with his family without having to raise a finger. And when he is asked to get a job he has all the excuses in the work because he has mental health issues so cannot be expected to cope with that. Alright for some people eh?! Bitter again much?!

OP posts:
Ilovetoddlerssaidnooneever · 06/09/2021 22:19

OP, I think your reasoning is based on flawed premises:

  1. You believe it is your responsibility to keep your husband afloat. Whilst I understand you value the vows you made, your husband does have some responsibility for his own actions. If you divorce him, you are no longer responsible for him in any way, other than perhaps financially.
  2. (in relation) you seem to think that you would be doing something bad if you left him. You are allowed to divorce him! This is no way to live!!! Referring back to my previous point, he is choosing (to some extent) to live like this. Hell, you've done everything you can to help him but he's not doing his part. I would argue that he is far more responsible for the breakdown of your relationship than you are.
  3. your kids need a dad. What do people mean when they say this? I can guarantee you they do not have your husband in mind! It means kids need a good male role model. That he is most certainly not! If he beat you up, would you still be saying they needed a dad?
  4. Having something (him) is better than nothing. I would argue though that sum total of his qualities is negative. In other words, he adds much more negativity to your life than that he contributes positively. Leaving him would therefore not be losing something, but bringing the balance back to 0 or above.

Please, please reconsider what you're doing. What is the benefit of waiting until the kids have gone to college?

needsomeperspective · 06/09/2021 22:18

@jgjgjgjgjg

You know that you can go to IKEA together and even have sex if you both want to even when you're divorced?
HA! Done get to have sex now let alone if we were divorced 🤣
OP posts:
SeoultoSeoul · 06/09/2021 22:16

I think its very admirable of you to put your DC first in all of this but TBH, illness or not, I think infidelity would be a deal breaker for me.

needsomeperspective · 06/09/2021 22:16

“What would happen if the exhaustion made you ill, who would take on your responsibilities and look after you?“

I already knowing the answer to this question. Two years ago exactly this happened. I was cracking at the seams even beforehand but when I found out about his affair I literally fell to bits after years and years of having to carry everything. I was fined off work for a month, lost 15 pounds in two weeks and took myself off to the doctor for a cocktail of anti anxiety medication because I had panic attacks which were insupportable.

Of course my husband was nowhere. As soon as I show any weakness or appear to need support he is gone. I was extremely fortunately that my mother was staying with me and made sure I ate and washed. I pulled my socks up after a few weeks and got on with things because - well who else was going to provide for everyone and everything if I didn’t?

I’m fully, painfully, aware that I would have no support from my H because he simply isn’t capable of providing it. I’m sure he wishes he was but that’s just the bare fact of the situation. If I didn’t work, we would be bankrupt. If I didn’t get up with the children every morning they would spend all day on their iPads and wouldn’t go to school. If I didn’t shop we would starve. If I relied on him for emotional comfort I would be bereft.

OP posts:
jgjgjgjgjg · 06/09/2021 22:10

You know that you can go to IKEA together and even have sex if you both want to even when you're divorced?

MrsHuntGeneNotJeremyObviously · 06/09/2021 22:05

OP, anyone judging you negatively has no idea of how mentally exhausting it can be for the partner of someone like your husband. Especially when you have to hold down a job and look after DC as well. I think you've done brilliantly, but I do agree with almost everyone else when they say that separation is the best way to go. You can't help someone who won't help themselves!

Theythinkitsalloveritisnow · 06/09/2021 22:04

@Lotusmonster

DBT is quite different to CBT. The participant is not able to progress through the therapy until the therapist is totally happy that the participant has made the changes. This therapy is trying to achieve serious re-wiring and it is clinically proven ….NICE approve it in the UK. But the commitment OP is huge. It’s a full time job actually with daily exercises for 1-2 years. Repeating the course is not uncommon. Given BPD carries a high suicidal risk, he has a lot of reasons to get his shit together OP. It doesn’t bear thinking about the slide BPD can take. But whilst I feel your pain, shaming him and talking to him in a shaming way won’t work. Validation is a key part of understanding BPD. The person with BPD feels that their feelings aren’t validated. It to me, you are feeling the same….so I’m not sure where to begin with this!
I completely disagree with this. He currently doesn't have a lot of reasons to access therapy. He gets to drink himself into a stupor and stay in bed until 6pm, doesn't need to work, gets everything done for him. He has every reason to not seek help. EUPD I'm sure can be hellish to live with, but therapy is scary. If it does improve his mental state, he'll be expected to start acting like an adult and parent. Easier to do nothing and keep drinking and doing whatever he feels like, with the eternal excuse of " I'm ill, it's not my fault"
needsomeperspective · 06/09/2021 22:03

What I don’t want is to be in a position where my children spend half their time with someone who is not mentally well. I also have no illusions that my H can be trusted to only bring healthy and positive people into their lives - it’s incredibly likely that he will either disappear completely (he has done this with his son from a previous relationship who he hasn’t seen since he was 3 years old - he is now 22) or get involved with another nutcase woman in short order given his incredibly poor judgement.

At least if we are all together under one roof I can ensure that even if my children are not seeing the picture perfect model of the Walton’s marriage they aren’t shuffled off for half their lives to whatever god awful situation my husband would inevitably end up getting himself into if he wasn’t safely ensconced here.

If I cannot fully trust him to take responsibility for the children’s welfare in our own home then I’m hardly likely to think it sensible to give him carte blanche to fully fuck them up without me there to protect and support them.

This was a key deciding factor in my decision to allow him to move back in after his “affair” / breakdown.

Whilst you may not believe it from reading my venting on here I do not always feel this resentment and bitterness towards my husband. I would say 30% of the time I feeling extremely loving, 30% compassionate / understanding, 30% generally tolerant and resigned and 10% raging with contempt and disgust.

Rationally I KNOW it’s not his CHOICE to be this way. He wouldn’t choose to lie in bed all day in the dark because he can’t bear to get out of it. He wouldn’t choose to have zero motivation to do anything with his life, or feel suspicious if everyone, or feel like he is a worthless human being, or be stupidly vulnerable to manipulative people pressing his buttons, or feel paralysed with fear of being alone causing catastrophic errors of judgement or emotional outbursts. No one would choose that.

But if he is here I can keep him as stable as possible, make sure he takes his pills, manage his extremes and moderate the impact of his illness on our kids in a way I couldn’t if he was cast adrift unsupported and had them on his own half the week.

OP posts: