Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For viewing my H with contempt

217 replies

needsomeperspective · 06/09/2021 19:29

My H and I have now been married for almost 13 years. Two children. He has long term mental health issues stemming from an abusive childhood. Frankly I have known for a decade that he has BPD. He takes anti anxiety meds and anti psychotics (when he can be bothered to keep on top of them or as long as I police him like a child). He hasn’t had any job in over six years, no “real” job in ten. He spends much of his time sleeping in very late while I work my ass off to keep our family (and my mother) financially solid - fortunately I have a very good job - but along with that comes it’s own stresses for me as I am responsible for over 300 staff.

I’m lucky enough to have help with the kids and a cleaner. I’ve deliberately arranged my life so that I do not have to rely on my husband in any material way - because he isn’t dependable. He has cheated on me, he used to be emotionally volatile, now he is just an apathetic lump.

He is, all challenges considered, often a loving, kind and involved father and the children undoubtedly benefit from having him in their lives and in their home.

From my perspective we have an almost non existent sex life, and I frequently feel like I’m running a doss house for vagrants than participating in some kind of partnership. But it’s better than having no one. We’ve been very isolated during Covid.

I put in place (following his infidelity) a cast iron post nup which he agreed to sign so I’m not “trapped” in this marriage for financial reasons but I do feel that the children would be much better off if we stayed together and frankly I can’t see how I’d be happier as a single parent compared to this inadequate and pathetic marriage I’m in right now. Some sex is better than none - or one night stands with morons. At least I have someone to visit IKEA with.

How do I reconcile myself to the limitations of this situation and generate the compassion to view my husband as a victim of his mental health issues rather than a useless, feckless, contemptible burden surgically attached to the sofa and piggy backing on my years of relentless hard work - which frankly I often feel.

OP posts:
Walkaround · 07/09/2021 04:45

Well, you’re setting it up so that when you escape your dh because you feel the children no longer need him, your children will feel obliged to look after him, instead, while you “reclaim your freedom.”

LimeRedBanana · 07/09/2021 04:39

@needsomeperspective

Fortunately the drinking is occasional not constant, usual when I leave him on his own downstairs and go to bed alone. It’s not something the children are even aware of. Fortunately they are extremely happy children, have many friends, do well at school without being, as a pp put it ‘anxious overachievers’. They are tweens and very much pre-occupied with each other, their friendships, their zoom calls and raiding my fridge.

This thread makes it sound like I am in a constant morass of seething resentment all the time. I’m not. Most of the time I feel I have reconciled myself to the personal limitations of this marriage.

The children mostly see two parents who are very often physically affectionate, kind to each other and who spend a lot of time with them. Just sometimes - when he goes through low patches, drinks, is deeply moody etc. I feel at breaking point and that I just can’t bear it anymore. It’s me who suffers in this situation. Not because he abuses me or shouts at me or is an overtly bad person. But because I cannot help but imagine how my life could be if I had a husband who could actually carry half the load of life, who I could rely on, who was consistently loving, who was a true partner not an additional burden of responsibility to carry in an already overburdened life. But it IS my burden, not the children’s.

When we temporarily separated I spoke to the school, their teachers and the welfare team to have an eye kept on them in case they were suffering from stress or anxiety. I also had an educational psychologist spend time with them both. Clean bill of health on all fronts - at least consciously. No clue what they are “modelling” in terms of subliminal messaging for future relationships. If this theory was correct does that mean children of single parents will stay single?

My own parents did not provide a good relationship model for me and my mothers palpable disgust for my serial cheat father was certainly absorbed by me. That is perhaps why I am extremely careful not to in any way alienate them from their father, whose good qualities i point out, whilst allowing them to express any worries or concerns they may have if daddy is feeling “down”. They understand that he often doesn’t sleep well and that sometimes makes him irritable. If he ever is snappy with them he apologies and explains it wasn’t their fault. Ever since I made him move out and he spent most of a year living on his own, he has certainly materially improved his interaction with the kids. Pretty much the only thing he DOES put effort into is his relationship with them.

I’m not a stupid woman nor one who is living with a head in the sand about my kids welfare. I’m still here because my considered judgement having spent many months assessing all the alternatives, from a position of distance after effecting a separation where I paid for him to live in an apartment walking distance from the house, is that it’s a less damaging option for my children to remain together than not. It’s clearly a MORE damaging option for ME. But that has to take a backseat to their needs.

I dream of one day, when the children are independent, of finally getting my independence and starting a new life. I’m working and saving with a view to making that a possibility in the future, if my H never manages to deal with his problems. It might be slightly longer than a five year plan. But at least when I am finally in a position to prioritise myself I will try to have put all the infrastructure and finances in place to do so.

Well, then. Everything’s fine.

You’ve got it all figured out, and the kids are - for all intents and purposes - the product of a healthy, mutually satisfying relationship.

Good thing you started this thread. You’ve gone from desperate, to nothing-to-see-here.

Situation resolved. Right?

Rangoon · 07/09/2021 04:25

In 12 years he has really stitched you up, hasn't he. In 12 short years you have taken all responsibility for everything, done all the work, earned all the money and he enjoys the five bedroom house, the sportscar, and the foreign holidays and having it off with the next door neighbour if not with you. He hasn't held any job for six years and hasn't held a decent job in 10 years. And he is the one with mental health issues. He's no dad of the year either abandoning his son from his first marriage. At the first sign that you need some support after working yourself to a frazzle, he is nowhere to be found.

If I were you my rage would be boundless. I would never have let him move back in. I wouldn't care if he had childhood trauma - I had childhood trauma. You have spent a lot of time on money on treatment which he never followed through with. Obviously he didn't care less if his son from his first marriage had childhood trauma because he wasn't there to even find out. He's not going to have the children half the time either - that would sound like hard work. I think the children will come to hold him in contempt sooner than you think. If they are not stupid, they will know that you do all the work and pay for everything while he is either sleeping, drinking or managing sex with other people.

If my maths is right, you're only early forties. Why are you settling for this? Given that there's no sex, you might as well take a friend to Ikea. I feel that if anything had happened to you that he would have soon found somebody else to latch onto.

You might be happy with the pre-nup and good on you for that but who gets guardianship of your children and control of your money if anything happens to you? I would make very sure that money is tied up tightly for your children's benefit and that your husband can't get his hands on it because he would just run through it.

Unless you want to spend your retirement years with this sad excuse of a husband, I'd get rid now. The older you are, the harder it is to start again (sad but true) so I wouldn't be waiting 8 years.

needsomeperspective · 07/09/2021 04:14

Fortunately the drinking is occasional not constant, usual when I leave him on his own downstairs and go to bed alone. It’s not something the children are even aware of. Fortunately they are extremely happy children, have many friends, do well at school without being, as a pp put it ‘anxious overachievers’. They are tweens and very much pre-occupied with each other, their friendships, their zoom calls and raiding my fridge.

This thread makes it sound like I am in a constant morass of seething resentment all the time. I’m not. Most of the time I feel I have reconciled myself to the personal limitations of this marriage.

The children mostly see two parents who are very often physically affectionate, kind to each other and who spend a lot of time with them. Just sometimes - when he goes through low patches, drinks, is deeply moody etc. I feel at breaking point and that I just can’t bear it anymore. It’s me who suffers in this situation. Not because he abuses me or shouts at me or is an overtly bad person. But because I cannot help but imagine how my life could be if I had a husband who could actually carry half the load of life, who I could rely on, who was consistently loving, who was a true partner not an additional burden of responsibility to carry in an already overburdened life. But it IS my burden, not the children’s.

When we temporarily separated I spoke to the school, their teachers and the welfare team to have an eye kept on them in case they were suffering from stress or anxiety. I also had an educational psychologist spend time with them both. Clean bill of health on all fronts - at least consciously. No clue what they are “modelling” in terms of subliminal messaging for future relationships. If this theory was correct does that mean children of single parents will stay single?

My own parents did not provide a good relationship model for me and my mothers palpable disgust for my serial cheat father was certainly absorbed by me. That is perhaps why I am extremely careful not to in any way alienate them from their father, whose good qualities i point out, whilst allowing them to express any worries or concerns they may have if daddy is feeling “down”. They understand that he often doesn’t sleep well and that sometimes makes him irritable. If he ever is snappy with them he apologies and explains it wasn’t their fault. Ever since I made him move out and he spent most of a year living on his own, he has certainly materially improved his interaction with the kids. Pretty much the only thing he DOES put effort into is his relationship with them.

I’m not a stupid woman nor one who is living with a head in the sand about my kids welfare. I’m still here because my considered judgement having spent many months assessing all the alternatives, from a position of distance after effecting a separation where I paid for him to live in an apartment walking distance from the house, is that it’s a less damaging option for my children to remain together than not. It’s clearly a MORE damaging option for ME. But that has to take a backseat to their needs.

I dream of one day, when the children are independent, of finally getting my independence and starting a new life. I’m working and saving with a view to making that a possibility in the future, if my H never manages to deal with his problems. It might be slightly longer than a five year plan. But at least when I am finally in a position to prioritise myself I will try to have put all the infrastructure and finances in place to do so.

OP posts:
DifferentHair · 07/09/2021 04:04

Gosh I think I'd be single.

There are benefits to being single as well.

Do you think you could co-parent well?

perrierplease · 07/09/2021 03:46

@needsomeperspective

I don’t live in the U.K. I’m very happy with my legal position.

What I don’t fancy is swapping this unsatisfactory marriage (from my perspective - not my kids) for a worse situation where I’m just alone or dealing with a different kind of fuckwit.

I think you actually would be happier on your own, you've just got used to this cock lodger.
chaosmaker · 07/09/2021 03:06

Do the meds have a huge effect on him working on top of his condition. BPD is horrendous to live with. Could you divorce but let him still live with you/separate bedrooms if you think it's better for your kids that he stays? Another one here that things single would be better than the situation you've described

LopsidedWombat · 07/09/2021 02:41

God I think maybe this man has drained you so much that you have lost perspective and the ability to imagine a different life for yourself. Being single does not have to mean alone (if no friends or family then at least time and space to remember who you are without this shit in your life). Get a vibrator rather than settle for occasional sex with someone you cannot stand, when the dust has settled from separating go on dates, have fun, meet someone that you enjoy being with.

The effects of an abusive childhood are awful of course but there comes a time when you have to seek support. He has children so he needs to take his meds, have therapy, do whatever he needs to do or he just repeats the cycle and hands down mental health issues to his children as well.

It's really hard to see it when you are in it but you don't owe him the sacrifice of a good life for yourself because he got dealt a shit hand in childhood. If he will not help himself then what can you do? This will go on forever if you allow it to.

Joystir59 · 07/09/2021 02:33

You are not loving yourself much at all OP. Get therapy. Being single is infinitely preferable to the awful dynamic being lived out in your household.

Joystir59 · 07/09/2021 02:31

Your kids are immersed in the toxicity of your awful disdain and martyrdom.

Joystir59 · 07/09/2021 02:29

Have you ever thought that you are enabling his inertia? If you stop basically parenting him perhaps he will gain some sense of self and motivation.

Joystir59 · 07/09/2021 02:24

You are spilling out your life on the arid ground for this loveless marriage? What on earth for? Gather up your strength and leave. Set a good example to your children!!!

TheGrassIsGreenerish · 07/09/2021 02:16

Your kids are going to mirror their own relationships on what they see at home. Why would you want that life for them?

BreadInCaptivity · 07/09/2021 02:12

ATP

I'd thought about the "granny flat" scenario but discounted it.

It means there is no clean break.

He still gets his cake and eat it with no inventive to seek help.

Meanwhile the OP when they divorce has him literally on the doorstep.

She'll end up ( for the children) carrying him again.

It's the worst case scenario - divorced but still "responsible".

Summerdayshaze · 07/09/2021 02:11

I’m single. I’m not dating fuckwits. And I certainly wouldn’t prefer your life.

BreadInCaptivity · 07/09/2021 01:59

I'm a she adult female and proud ATP Grin

Been around a long time but have just done my regular 2 year name change.

AcrossthePond55 · 07/09/2021 01:33

Bread is spot on with everything s/he said. If you've made up your mind to stay in the marriage then you need to 'emotionally divorce' yourself from him and get therapy for yourself. I'd do weekly sessions if only to have a regular place to blow off steam.

Just don't shut the door completely on separating before the kids are grown. Leave that option open. There's no failure in exiting a bad or destructive relationship no matter what the reason. And keep a close eye on the kids. Children are very perceptive creatures, sometimes unnaturally so, and they see more than we realize. It may happen that you must leave for them, despite what you want.

If you were able to get an iron clad post-nup then do you think you could get him to sign an iron clad 'supervised visits only' agreement and move him back to the bed-sit and allow the visits in your home?

Also, it appears that you are, shall we say, fairly comfortable financially. If you don't think he'd agree to moving out is there any way to 'section off' part of the house and create some sort of separate quarters for him so you don't have to have him continually in your line of vision? Or possibly create a separate lockable 'retreat' for you where he is not allowed so you can 'decompress' from time to time?

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 07/09/2021 01:24

What an utterly ridiculous way to live your one precious life! And you are deluded if you think your poor bloody kids aren't affected by living like this. Seriously, just leave him, and make a new and better life for you and your kids. God, I wouldn't let a dog live like this!

Justilou1 · 07/09/2021 01:14

This is going to be quite long and I’m going to be blunt. Please understand that this is coming to you with so much empathy but…..You are using him (and your work) as an excuse for not taking responsibility for the physical, emotional and psychological well-being of your children or yourself.
You sound so emotionally exhausted and lonely. I really feel for you, but I think you need to attack this like you would work tasks and break it all down into priorities and assign responsibility.

Kids first.
You are both responsible for the physical, mental and emotional health and safety of your children and you are BOTH failing in this task.
*You have accepted that DH will never take responsibility for his MH and yet you are facilitating a lifestyle for him where he has continual access to your children while drunk and under the influence of contraindicated medication. This is dangerous and willfully neglectful.

While I believe you work very hard to provide for your family, (and recognize the emotional and physical exhaustion) I also believe that you are hiding behind this work to avoid accepting responsibility and doing what really needs to be done here. Kids are not stupid. They are very sensitive to their environment and they will have already developed their own coping mechanisms. I very much doubt that you have the right impression of what they see and think. They will have grown up with the “volatility” and learned appeasing behaviours - as have you - to avoid “triggering” him. No matter how little they are, they will all be carrying the burden of responsibility for their DF’s MH, and that’s not fair. You say he is an involved father, yet you also mention that he sleeps through every morning and frequently wakes in the evening, drinking through the night. Do they bring kids home for to play, or are they worried it will “trigger” him? Do they have problems making or maintaining friends at school? Do they suffer from anxiety? Do they require a lot of attention? Cry a lot? Are they high-achievers who can’t handle the thought of failure?

You need to stop facilitating him. He is his own responsibility. Once he is no longer in your home he will make a token attempt to sort his shit out, then revert to form and disappear. Realistically, he will be a temporary inconvenience.

You and your kids need counselling. You would benefit from CBT (it works quickly). Your identity is split between confident, capable career woman and fake home life. Your kids need long-term counselling to ensure that they don’t repeat their father’s patterning. Once he is out of the house, you need to start treating them like they are intelligent humans and be honest with them. Don’t whitewash his behaviour any more. They need to learn that it is not acceptable and that they don’t need to avoid “triggering” the people they love any more.

I would also take a really good look at how your kids are around you and be brutally honest…. Are they afraid of triggering you because you’re “so tired because of work?”

There… I know I was hard, but I can see through the eyes of your kids. I grew up just like them. I am 49 and have CPTSD.

MMMarmite · 07/09/2021 00:18

I think you should divorce. It can't be good for any of you in living in that atmosphere.

OneMoreForExtra · 07/09/2021 00:15

What a ghastly situation OP.

Lots of good advice about first and foremost exploring with a therapist why you're here in the first place. I suspect progress here will make your options and choices much clearer.

You defend the status quo vehemently and I recognise the intense focus on a pragmatic compromise at the expense of all personal hopes and preferences - because I'm doing it too on a much, much less extreme scale. You're weighing up how to minimise impact on your kids and husband and secure whatever benefits can be gained from this, and your own wellbeing is completely unrecognised in this approach. I really hope your next step is to go and find out why you're so fiercely defending the set-up you have at the same time as hating it so much.

In the meantime, might a pragmatic step be a separation arrangement which puts him in an annex on your property, possibly with some kind of carer/support? You gain the freedoms of a single person, run your life and your family home as you wish to, but he's available to the kids and safer than he might be otherwise. Could be a halfway house to the divorce you can't contemplate yet.

bettyboodecia · 07/09/2021 00:14

"From my perspective we have an almost non existent sex life, and I frequently feel like I’m running a doss house for vagrants than participating in some kind of partnership. But it’s better than having no one."

Sorry but 😂... how is it better? Even if it is better for you (which I wholly fail to see), having a mentally disturbed parent living with their kids drinking all night and sleeping all day is much worse than an absent parent. Kick him out!

villanova · 06/09/2021 23:12

Hi OP I appreciate I know very little about MH issues, and I realise this article is referring to PTSD from abuse, but I've been interested to see MDMA having almost miraculous (and relatively quick) effects in controlled trials for several intractible MH issues. Could you see if there's a trial near you? www.technologyreview.com/2021/08/25/1032117/mdma-ecstasy-ptsd-therapy-mental-health/

Vitallyli · 06/09/2021 23:08

Oh gosh OP, I'm so sorry you are in this situation. I completely understand your reasoning for staying. However I think if you emotionally distance yourself from him your situation may become absolutely unbearable. It sounds like you are in a real crisis at the moment. Do you have friends or family you can talk to about it? having emotional support helps. If not maybe groups for people who live with partners with MH? I would definitely do counseling for yourself as well to unload some of your emotions and possibly find a solution to keep going like this. You know sometimes some things resolve themselves in a way we can't control or predict, you feel like you are in total control of your life but some outside factors may change your situation too, so time will show? What did you see in him when you met and decided to get married? What do you see in him now that 30% of the time you like him?

ViciousJackdaw · 06/09/2021 23:06

You mention barbiturates and heavy drinking. Together.

He'll snuff it eventually with that combination. It isn't fair to put the DC in the position where it could be them who find him dead.