Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For viewing my H with contempt

217 replies

needsomeperspective · 06/09/2021 19:29

My H and I have now been married for almost 13 years. Two children. He has long term mental health issues stemming from an abusive childhood. Frankly I have known for a decade that he has BPD. He takes anti anxiety meds and anti psychotics (when he can be bothered to keep on top of them or as long as I police him like a child). He hasn’t had any job in over six years, no “real” job in ten. He spends much of his time sleeping in very late while I work my ass off to keep our family (and my mother) financially solid - fortunately I have a very good job - but along with that comes it’s own stresses for me as I am responsible for over 300 staff.

I’m lucky enough to have help with the kids and a cleaner. I’ve deliberately arranged my life so that I do not have to rely on my husband in any material way - because he isn’t dependable. He has cheated on me, he used to be emotionally volatile, now he is just an apathetic lump.

He is, all challenges considered, often a loving, kind and involved father and the children undoubtedly benefit from having him in their lives and in their home.

From my perspective we have an almost non existent sex life, and I frequently feel like I’m running a doss house for vagrants than participating in some kind of partnership. But it’s better than having no one. We’ve been very isolated during Covid.

I put in place (following his infidelity) a cast iron post nup which he agreed to sign so I’m not “trapped” in this marriage for financial reasons but I do feel that the children would be much better off if we stayed together and frankly I can’t see how I’d be happier as a single parent compared to this inadequate and pathetic marriage I’m in right now. Some sex is better than none - or one night stands with morons. At least I have someone to visit IKEA with.

How do I reconcile myself to the limitations of this situation and generate the compassion to view my husband as a victim of his mental health issues rather than a useless, feckless, contemptible burden surgically attached to the sofa and piggy backing on my years of relentless hard work - which frankly I often feel.

OP posts:
Excelthetube · 07/09/2021 17:36

Short term misery or long term misery.

thepeopleversuswork · 07/09/2021 17:29

There isn’t a happy ending to this story. All paths lead to some level of hardship, pain and misery, for me at least. I just need to remind myself that I have tried to pick the path of least misery I suppose, and comfort myself with the fact that life could be worse - and for many it is.

I totally understand how you can have got to this mindset, but I think you are selling yourself short and deliberately holding yourself back from doing what you know you need to do.

You're lucky to be in a very strong financial position: that counts for a lot - a lot of women in your situation are trapped. You're not trapped.

I was in a similar position to you in that my husband depended on me financially for years after we separated: I paid his rent on and off for about five years. It's only been since the divorce (which I funded and which he benefited from) that I've actually been free of it. I have spent well over £100k, through a combination of divorce settlement and ongoing support, and not seen a penny myself.

But it was still worth it and I'd do it again if I had to. Because the feeling of being free of the millstone of someone else's endless, bottomless dependency is worth its weight in gold. And because ultimately I have taught my daughter that I won't spend the rest of my life being weighed down financially and emotionally by his needs.

needsomeperspective · 07/09/2021 17:19

It’s been incredibly helpful reading others stories and similar experiences. I suppose I feel sort paralysed. I am here because I feel the negatives of keeping him here are outweighed by the negatives of divorcing him. Sometimes I can feel almost happy for a few weeks at a time but it always cycles back to this.

My mother regrets staying with all her heart. She isn’t the forgiving type and held a deep seated contempt for my father for decades. And she chose to stay even after if grown up. My father died of cancer about 6 years ago and she regularly laments all the things she missed out on because of her choices - but they were HER choices - certainly after I’d left home. As a 1980s housewife she didn’t have the financial wherewithal to leave when I was a child. But certainly could have later. But she didn’t want to give up her cosy house, financial security, social circle etc.

At the end of the day we all have to live with the consequences of our decisions. And without a crystal ball we simply cannot project what would have been the correct path.

I don’t like my marriage how it is. I feel taken advantage of, unloved, emotionally unsupported, drained to the core a lot of the time. I don’t think however that i would be likely to feel any happier attempting to cope as a full time working single parent who would still have to financially fund my ex - if I wanted to facilitate any regular contact with the children (because if I didn’t he would have to leave this country) and co-parent with someone who would be extremely difficult to work with effectively whilst having to be parted, at least for some time, from my children. How is that better?!

There isn’t a happy ending to this story. All paths lead to some level of hardship, pain and misery, for me at least. I just need to remind myself that I have tried to pick the path of least misery I suppose, and comfort myself with the fact that life could be worse - and for many it is.

OP posts:
Ohhelpmetoo · 07/09/2021 16:41

Been there . Done the hanging on until the children were grown up . But on little money. When I left I had years of feeling guilty because he was such a poor coper. The adult children rallied around him ( he was in good physical health and not old) whilst I was the “ baddie”
Then , he manipulated my DD into giving up an amazing ,never to be repeated opportunity as “ who will look after me”He was a healthy adult with a house , money and family and friends. I was blamed.” If you hadn’t left him I would have been able to go”But she still blamed me for leaving. I now think he had trapped her as well although she had her own home he was a useful childminder for her children at the time and I think she put up with him because of that .
I keep in contact but my annoyance turned to anger and my anger to hatred.

20 years on I’m old and alone . Still poor . 1 of my children speaks to me . The other regularly sends hateful messages about my morals , my appearance and my parenting skills. She has told relatives awful lies about me . In the way her father used to. I have never regretted leaving . I so regret staying . I could have saved myself and perhaps my unhappy adult child .
Please do not think that you will walk away at a specific time in the future . The damage has been done. If a friend ( or one of your children) was in your situation, what would you advise ? I also recognise that feeling of despair( perhaps how you were feeling at time of your original post) and then the back tracking “ oh it’s not so bad “ But you know it is . He has passed away . I’m living out my life as best I can .

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 07/09/2021 15:53

How do you reconcile yourself to the situation?
Well, by accepting that you are in this situation because you choose to be. You have and have always had several options and you are choosing this life. Tbh, if you're planning to stay in it then all you can do is take full responsibility for your decision and accept that you are getting exactly what you've decided to get. There's really no other way to come to terms with it is there? You could leave but you don't want to. For reasons that you feel are sound, this is the life you want. (Want as in prefer out of the options realistically available to you)

YouMeandtheSpew · 07/09/2021 15:40

I grew up in a similar environment to the one you’re describing OP. Not the same - my mum didn’t have things together in the way it sounds like you do. But similar, in the sense my father couldn’t really function as a parent or anything else because of mental health issues and alcoholism. And my mother enabled him - because of low self esteem I think.

It was REALLY toxic. I was very much aware of it even as a fairly young child. I’m not sure if it would have been better if they’d split up but that’s because my mother wasn’t a competent parent either really, whereas it sounds like you are.

People often talk about empathy for people with addiction but frankly I think there’s a fine line between empathy and enabling. And I do think from what you’ve said that you are enabling him. You provide him with an environment in which he doesn’t have to face up to the consequences of his behaviour. The very opposite in fact. His behaviour benefits him. He doesn’t have to work, parent his own children, and he has a lovely comfortable lifestyle. Why would he change? And that’s enabling.

I’m sorry, this probably isn’t helpful, but having some personal experience of this I would strongly advise against keeping an alcoholic around ‘for the sake of the children’ or ‘for the sake of not being alone’.

ladygindiva · 07/09/2021 15:05

Have you ever actually been single?My experience of it ( pretty much my entire 30s)is it's absolutely tonnes better than your marriage sounds. And I was poor.

hangrylady · 07/09/2021 14:59

@needsomeperspective

I don’t live in the U.K. I’m very happy with my legal position.

What I don’t fancy is swapping this unsatisfactory marriage (from my perspective - not my kids) for a worse situation where I’m just alone or dealing with a different kind of fuckwit.

By the sounds of it you're perfectly capable of managing on your own. You don't have to have a partner. let alone a fuckwit. If you meet someone in future then great but being single is better than what you've described.
LBirch02 · 07/09/2021 14:47

I’ve not RTFT but I honestly think if you split you wouldn’t be dealing with ‘another fuckwit’ cos you’d have learned from this relationship- you’d be with someone with a similar work ethic to you in all likelihood

LBirch02 · 07/09/2021 14:44

I totally agree with .HeadNorth on the first page of this thread. Easier said than done though

LBirch02 · 07/09/2021 14:41

It’s so difficult to respond to this post without saying the obvious OP but I sympathise how difficult it must be to work very hard and feeling like you’re getting nothing back

thepeopleversuswork · 07/09/2021 13:57

@AbstractEim

Why did you move him back in? Move him back out, he can probably pull himself together enough to be an occasional Disney dad which would be better for the dc than seeing him stuck to the sofa with no purpose in life every day. Do you want your dc to think this is a good way to live? He can have a relationship with the dc without living in the house with you, plenty of people do, it might give him a reason to make some effort as he definitely doesn’t have a reason at the moment.
This. In spades.

My ex, who had a lot of similar traits to yours (depression, alcoholism, total dependency), has actually sorted himself out to some degree since we split up -- it took a few years but he got there. He lives on his own, still drinks too much and his mental health is up and down but he is coping and financially independent and able to put on a good face for our daughter when he sees her.

He's a classic Disney Dad: sees my daughter about once a fortnight, no financial support whatsoever, almost no childcare, showers her with gifts and is generally pretty useless but makes her feel special.

It's not what I'd have wanted in a life partner but he is at least a benevolent and loving presence to her. And most importantly he's located out of my home where he can't continue to drain my finances and suck the life energy out of the family with his depressing behaviour. I thoroughly recommend it.

AbstractEim · 07/09/2021 13:51

Why did you move him back in? Move him back out, he can probably pull himself together enough to be an occasional Disney dad which would be better for the dc than seeing him stuck to the sofa with no purpose in life every day. Do you want your dc to think this is a good way to live? He can have a relationship with the dc without living in the house with you, plenty of people do, it might give him a reason to make some effort as he definitely doesn’t have a reason at the moment.

FlowerArranger · 07/09/2021 13:50

www.goodreads.com/book/show/720298.Codependent_No_More

A classic on codependency

mantlepiece · 07/09/2021 12:04

OP from what you say, you seem to justify all this due to your husbands supposedly terrible childhood. Do you think it was worse than yours?

Reading between the lines there seems to be a strange dynamic in your own birth family. Your father is spoken of in the same terms as your husband and you say you are now bankrolling your mother too.
What’s going on there? Is your relationship with your mother a healthy one?

It would seem you are living with a drug and alcohol addict. The behaviour you describe would stem from that more than from mental illness per se.

You sound like you could crash and burn due to the stress of suppressing your feelings on this traumatic life you are living.
If you go down it all falls apart, or does it?

thepeopleversuswork · 07/09/2021 11:19

OP I have some understanding of this as my ex-husband was not dissimilar (though not as bad, from what you've said here). This doesn't come from a position of judgement, but sympathy.

But you are enabling his behaviour and ultimately setting a terrible example to your children.

You have become very codependent and you have come to see yourself as almost a literal lifeline, supporting him financially, mentally, etc. You have trained yourself to think there is no alternative, probably through a combination of guilt and the fact that you have read up extensively on his mental health situation.

The reality is that your behaviour, while probably initially well-intentioned, is actually fuelling his dependency. I realise that leaving him will cause his health to spiral out of control and that this isn't something you can do lightly. But you simply can't maintain a situation indefinitely where you are basically acting as life support for one another.

It sets a terrible example to your children: that marriage and relationships are about morbid codependency, and that contempt is the natural state of affairs in relationships between adults.

I'm not minimising how difficult it will be to extricate yourself from this situation. You will have to prepare yourself for months of guilt and difficulty. But you have to do it. You can't inflict this on another generation of your family.

Pazuzu · 07/09/2021 10:51

Unlike quite a few threads on here where it can very well descend into a LTB pile on for the most marginal of reasons, in this case I do have to ask why are you still with this man?

Yes, he's had the bad childhood but he's not a child anymore and he's had children. You say he's involved but is he really or are you making excuses for him?

What example are your children getting? That's it ok for them to be absolute doormats? That it's ok for them to be useless wastes of space and let someone else do everything for them? A mutually agreed one parent stays at home to look after the house and kids is a completely different thing. This is one parent being a lazy self centred dick. If he was even trying to deal with it (e.g. taking the damned medication as per the prescription) maybe, but he's not.

As far as you're relationship, what exactly are you getting for your hard graft? A husband who cheats, doesn't want you and treats you like a bank?

My wife doesn't work. We agreed on this as it didn't make sense for her to do so financially. This is a mutually respectful decision. Him being an apathetic lump is not a respectful decision. It's you enabling his selfish behaviour.

It's ultimatum time. He either get's his shit together or he packs his shit up. Why should he be costing you your happiness?

As for the sex, buy a good vibrator. At least you won't have to clean up it's mess. The vibrator will also have FAR more respect for you than he does.

Do you have no friends who will go to IKEA with you? Take the kids. Fill them up with meatballs and Daim cake and they're so much more agreeable to ambling around and looking at unpronounceable furniture.

lazylinguist · 07/09/2021 10:22

I assume other women with husbands who are depressed or suffering from mental health issues also find themselves in this situation.

I doubt it tbh. Not all people who have depression are also cheaters and completely useless. There is no way on earth I could stay married to someone like that. I'd rather be single for 100 years. Your dc may not see animosity, but they must certainly see a very unequal relationship where you do everything and tolerate your husband doing nothing. And they probably do sense the underlying resentment and contempt, even if you don't realise it. Is this the kind of relationship you want to be modelling to them?

Worldgonecrazy · 07/09/2021 10:21

Yabu staying in a miserable relationship and teaching your children this behaviour.

Get out, get happy and gain enough self respect to say no to the fuckwits.

Do you really believe the myth that any relationship is better than no relationship?

Learn to love and respect yourself because right now, you don’t come across as someone with any self respect.

dayslikethese1 · 07/09/2021 10:15

It sounds like you're bad for each other. If you don't care enough about your own happiness can you turn it around? If you left maybe your OH would be forced to seek treatment/sort himself out? So then you could both live happier lives. Plus I don't see how this can not affect your kids, they're prob walking on eggshells round him.

BigGreen · 07/09/2021 10:08

What stood out in your posts was a real need for control (and an assumption that you can control the family dynamic over the next 8 years). I wonder if you've really had to control everything because your partner has been totally destabilising, but maybe that's not the most helpful dynamic right now? Perhaps you feel that he has been controlling you by being unreliable and having crises, and you've felt the need to control him to stem emotional damage that he's been doing to you?

Also anger can often carry other emptions inside it - like deep rejection from not having your needs met for so long. Can you get some therapy to unpick and process these emotional complexities? Getting therapy for myself was the best thing I ever did. The therapist actually met my emotional needs which was very healing and I actually enjoyed having a grown up space to vent and deal with my anger and frustration.

From what you've written it seems like you really need to make a co-parenting relationship with your H and split with him. Ultimately it might be helpful to see him in the same light as an alcoholic - you cannot change him, and actully you can't control him, you need to free him with kindness now.

Lotusmonster · 07/09/2021 09:47

Hope you get things sorted OP. Lots of views on this thread…many saying you’re a hero and some saying you’re an enabler. I know stuffs rarely black and white and people that think this kind of situation is can lack experience. I’m glad you’re kids are mercifully self absorbed. From experience, as they grow up the real ‘watch point’ is as they enter early adulthood …aged 17 onwards. There’s a lot of brain changes going on then. My DD’s BPD presentation was literally like an overnight switch. It was quite scary. I’ve asked myself endlessly if there was stuff we could have done to prevent BPD from happening. Having read up, there’s a predisposition sadly. However I do think that we could have validated her more at certain points. Trauma and bereavement was a feature of her teen life sadly. I guess for you, think about the best environment that you can give your kids whereby they can talk, be listened to, validated and not be subjected to domestic trauma. The impact is huge.

RazorSharp · 07/09/2021 09:44

@georgarina

Continued reading this thread and it's clear there are major codependency issues at play here.

Hating your husband so much but enabling his behavior, not splitting 'for the kids' but really because as you've said 'it's better than having no one.'

This dynamic is so, so unhealthy and to be brutally honest you're hurting your kids by continuing it. It just can't be a good environment to be around a passed out addict father and resentful, angry mother. The bravest, healthiest thing would be to leave, not to be a martyr.

Excellent analogy, all so true.
georgarina · 07/09/2021 09:39

Continued reading this thread and it's clear there are major codependency issues at play here.

Hating your husband so much but enabling his behavior, not splitting 'for the kids' but really because as you've said 'it's better than having no one.'

This dynamic is so, so unhealthy and to be brutally honest you're hurting your kids by continuing it. It just can't be a good environment to be around a passed out addict father and resentful, angry mother. The bravest, healthiest thing would be to leave, not to be a martyr.

Mulletsaremisunderstood · 07/09/2021 09:39

I echo the sentiments that you are staying in this marriage for your own emotional reasons, not for the benefit of your children - no matter what you keep telling yourself. This is not any healthy example of a relationship to set for them.

You said that if you split up, they would have to spend half their time in an unpleasant environment with their father, but they would also spend half their time in a calm and happy household with you. And they will notice and understand the difference.
But now, they don’t have any alternative, the only family life they know is this fucked up version. You think you are hiding it from them, but your children will sense your contempt and unhappiness.

Is this the kind of relationship you want for them when they grow up? This is all they know, it is not unreasonable to think they will seek out something similar, if only that it’s familiar.

Will you take responsibility for the fact that one of your children could end up in this type of relationship, given that you have set the template for them.

And the fact that you could break the cycle, by leaving (you have the financial means) but you stay for your own needs, not theirs.